Page 1 of 3
Comments on Scientist (LotB)?
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 12:30 am
by NeoTiamat
I've been attempting to make a Scientist NPC, (Human Expert 6 / Scientist (Biologist) 9), and I've been scratching my head from time to time.
Basically, my general question is has anyone used this PrC before, and if so, what were the results?
More specifically, I am questioning how many uses of the abilities do scientists actually get, and whether I'm quite right in my reading of the Metaphysical Resistance, which appears to be dreadfully overpowered (Above character, at CR 12 and with 18 int, has the equivalent of SR 27).
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 8:24 am
by DocBeard
I haven't, though it seems like, yeah, they get a lot of protection, considering that Arcane Magic's supposed to be the "scientific" powerset in D&D.
Personally, if you're doing Scientist, I'd make it a core class. It's a new power type, and deserves one.
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 1:07 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
You're right, it's way stronger than it ought to be. I have to wonder if whoever wrote the PrC made the Scientist overpowered on purpose, under the assumption that it'd be a class for NPC experts only: they're weak enough that they'd need such perks to hold their own against or alongside PCs. Opening it up to PHB classes could've been a change of plans, that didn't get taken into account in the class's stats.
If you're writing this for the sea-monster book, NeoT, I don't mind if you apply a house-rule fix to the character's abilities, so long as you include a sidebar explaining exactly what you changed.
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 3:04 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Anytime something calls for something very non-standard, like this using an ability score instead of modifier, it always sets off warning bells to me.
Since the spell "Spell Resistance" grants SR12+caster level, perhaps a more reasonable and more "d20" version of this ability would be 10+IntMod+scientist level.
Scientist level should always be well less than caster level of a straight Clr, though most scientists will have a high enough int to compensate a bit. Since the ability is active all the time, it should be lower than a 1min/level spell.
That would put your NPC at SR 23. If he fights a caster at his CR, the caster needs an 11 to penetrate. 50/50 chance. Not too outlandish, I think.
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 4:08 pm
by Georg Kristianokov
If you need a base class scientist, what about the class I proposed for the Har A'Kir campaign?
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 6:53 pm
by NeoTiamat
Yes, this is for the Marine Book.... hmm.... I think I'll do just that, use class and apply a few fixes to the more strangely applied abilities.
Gonzoron, consider your Metaphysical Resistance fix swiped. Georg, Doc, while I see your argument, I'd rather keep as close to canon as I can.
Hmm... anyone have thoughts/suggestions regarding the Applied Science?
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 6:58 pm
by DocBeard
Totally understandable, especially for a 'netbook.
Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 9:04 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Sounds good!
BTW, given that this NPC's a
marine biologist, you might want to have the character use a custom version of a power source: one that draws energy from fish. Electric eels, rays, and catfish would all be likely candidates for this, and the idea of plugging a gadget into an aquarium to charge it up, then tossing the living "power source" some yummy minnows so it'll unleash a
zzzap! is pretty amusing.

Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2008 10:44 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
As I read it, the "Science" abilities and "Applied Science" abilities are mostly separate.
You get as many "at will" Science abilities as you want. You just make the knowledge check for each one.
You get (Scientist level+IntMod) "limited" Science abilities per day in any combination from your list . Again, you make the knowledge check for each one, and these draw 1 charge from your power source each. It's unclear if you burn the charge even if you fail the check, but I'd be inclined to say yes.
If you selected your Applied Science trick from your specialty:
You get (1 + IntMod) Applied Science tricks day, each of which requires a knowledge check and a charge. (Each time you choose the same trick again, add 3 uses)
If you selected your Applied Science trick from outside your specialty:
You get 1 Applied Science trick per day, which requires a knowledge check and a charge. (Each time you choose the same trick again, add 1 use)
Clear as mud?
ETA: The only one that seems to be completely broken is the biologist's cure minor wounds at will. Any decent Int Scientist with max ranks in his field should almost always pass the check. that means he can dish out 600hp an hour. with enough downtime, the party will never stay hurt long.
Posted: Wed Feb 27, 2008 10:31 am
by NeoTiamat
Mmmm.... mostly clear, although when you look at the example listed it does seem to make things even more confused.
I'm also a touch dubious on the high number of uses per-day for the final abilities, since at level 14, (Say, a Wizard 5 / Scientist 9), any decent Int 18 Scientist who grabbed Int-stat boosts at levelups and the +2 Mental Attribute to Int (resulting in an Int of 22) can cast, say, Energy Drain seven times a day. Twentieth level wizards should have it so good.
Posted: Sun Mar 02, 2008 2:00 pm
by The Giamarga
About the SR: A 13th level monk gains SR =10 +level. Some prestige classes grant SR X + class level.
I asked at Dicefreaks about it and
according to them :
...the formula to SR
"...varies from monster to monster, PrC to PrC. Most demons, for instance, have SR = 8+CR, devils, 12+CR, angels 14+CR.
[...]
In general, SR = CR +0 or less is meant to stop less than 25% of spells, SR = CR +5 is meant to stop about 25% of spells, SR = CR +10 is meant to stop about 50% of spells, SR = CR +15 is meant to stop about 75% of spells, and SR = CR +20 is meant to stop about more than 75% of spells.
So while the Scientists formula is a bit weird the results it gives are more or less ok. It is the crowning ability of the PrC and only gained at 11th character level. My Mordenheim Exp5/Scientist10 for example has a whopping SR30, but then again he also had got the Godless feat before hitting Scientist 6.
If you want to lessen the impact of the ability you could rule that similar to the Godless feat´s SR, the Scientist cannot voluntarily supress his SR. That´s a nice drawback right there.
Posted: Sun Mar 02, 2008 2:10 pm
by The Giamarga
NeoTiamat wrote:Mmmm.... mostly clear, although when you look at the example listed it does seem to make things even more confused.
I'm also a touch dubious on the high number of uses per-day for the final abilities, since at level 14, (Say, a Wizard 5 / Scientist 9), any decent Int 18 Scientist who grabbed Int-stat boosts at levelups and the +2 Mental Attribute to Int (resulting in an Int of 22) can cast, say, Energy Drain seven times a day. Twentieth level wizards should have it so good.
Soul-draining machine for the win! The scientist still needs to pass a Scientific Knowledge Check DC 19 every time and he needs a
power source on hand to power the tricks. Each casting costs charges and
power sources don´t come cheap.
Also the caster level for Applied Science tricks is only half the scientist level, which is a bit strange. And while the text says that it is usable 1+ intmod times per day, the example says scientist level + intmod times per day which is even more! This should probably be errataed in the sidebar too.
I´m also very much in favor of expanding the list of tricks to include more spells (also from other sources). Mordenheim clearly needs
clone, as he cloned his manservant several times.
Posted: Thu May 22, 2008 9:32 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
gonzoron wrote:The only one that seems to be completely broken is the biologist's cure minor wounds at will. Any decent Int Scientist with max ranks in his field should almost always pass the check. that means he can dish out 600hp an hour. with enough downtime, the party will never stay hurt long.
Just skimmed through Paizo's Pathfinder RPG, a.k.a 3.75th edition. In it, they make 0-level spells castable at will for everyone. This required removing
cure minor wounds from the game. To replace it, they made
stablize, which simply stabilizes a dying character, but doesn't heal any hp. (And the reverse,
bleed, which causes a stabilized character to start dying again.)
stablize would make a good replacement for
cure minor on the biologist at-will trick list, IMHO.
Posted: Thu May 22, 2008 10:57 am
by cure
Is it just me, or is there something profoundly unsatisfying about the LoB Scientist. I believe that I can accurately describe the thinking behind it as the following: Arcane and Divine casters do the same thing, just use different power sources, so we will extend that to scientists.
While true, as far as it goes, seeing Arcane and Divine casters as seperated principally by a question of spicing is to do profound injustice to their respective originality. And that is no less the case with this 'scientist.'
Mordenheim was interesting not because he was a spell user knock off, but because he was a thoroughly modern scientist ideologically in denial and deluded about the supernatural underpinnings of his 'natural' world and his 'natural' science. Mordenheim doesn't cast Clone, he harvests necessary parts from the dead, adds electricity and by the fiat of the Dark Powers, Igor is reborn as good as new. Mordenheim doesn't think that he is rationalising magic and building a character class for him that does just that is profoundly ungothic. Whereas a golem of desire, that is GOTHIC.
Recall the chiurgeon 2ed character class from the Kargatan Book of Secrets p 187 by Wyatt. That was a brilliant gothic take on a modern profession. The transplants weren't empowered by power sources in place of the will of the gods. They were simply modern medicine with an excellent chance of failure given the very immodern conditions, which describes perfectly surgery almost within living memory.
The chiurgeon did not cast knock off cure light wound spells any more than our doctors do today. Any more than our scientists do today. A scientist or a chirugeon should look like our own, and when they transgress - and transgress is the word and is what Frankenstein is all about - the bonds of our science, then the Dark Powers step in, to help them along, with twisting, horrid corruption, in body and spirit, as their ultimate goal. The trepanning ability doesn't even need the intervention of the Dark Powers. Cure madness, or at least attempt to, by drilling holes in the patient's/victim's head. It might work, it might work at a terrible price, or it might not work at all. Horrifying and gothic in all cases. A scientist character class without so much as a reference to golems of desire has lost the plot.
Posted: Thu May 22, 2008 2:57 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
I agree with Cure. I don't have LoB, but from reading this thread it seems like the class has applications to several different games, but Ravenloft is not one of them. Chiurgeon is the perfect example of the "virgin field" of medicine and its applications in the Ravenloft setting. And a great example of things that might be beyond the ability of a scientist being augmented by the setting!
Please help me out. The LoB Scientist can replicate ANY spell with science?