Page 1 of 1
Sherlock Holmes and the Gothic
Posted: Mon Mar 24, 2008 7:38 am
by Ail
Hi all,
I've read Sherlock Holmes numerous times, and now I'm rewatching that old Granada-TV series with Jeremy Brett, and one thing I noticed is that the episodes are so very Gothic in terms of ambiance, locations and even the actors they choose. There are episodes where the authors seem to have genuinely hunted for ugly people for almost unimportanto roles.
However, besides this superficial evaluation, I've noticed that some of the villains in the story fit some Gothic archetypes. There are those fathers who keep their daughters imprisoned because they want their fortune; a baron that is scarred with vitriol after he himself used it on several women; the man who is poisoned with the same poison he used on his siblings, and by lover of his murdered sister, no less...
Of course, it is not a surprise that Conan Doyle would write with Gothic sensibility, as he's a product of that era and I think he did write some supernatural tales. But being Sherlock Holmes a totally not-supernatural fiction, it is, at first, non-Gothic too. So, has anyone cared to even analyse how Gothic traits appear in these tales?
Thanks all.
Alex
Posted: Mon Mar 24, 2008 8:52 am
by Joël of the FoS
I've read the Hounds of Baskerville, and that's a mystery novel well tainted with gothic fears. First, until the end, the possibility of a supernatural monster is high. Then, the most interesting is the way people react to this possibility in the novel, and how Conan Doyle describe the gloomy ambiance.
I wish I had read it before DMing Howls in the Night!
Joël
Posted: Mon Mar 24, 2008 9:37 am
by Ail
Yes, I understand you well, especially since that module was based on that tale. Just for curiosity, I think there is one other tale that purposefully tried to goad the reader into thinking there might be a supernatural explanation. The title in the Portuguese version I read translates to "The Vampire of the Sussex." Unfortunately, it must have been rather uninteresting compared to other tales, because I haven't kept a good memory of its plot. I just think it's a south-american woman that is accused of drinking the blood of her own child, and in the end it becomes apparent she is instead trying to save her.
Alex
Posted: Wed Mar 26, 2008 1:03 pm
by Band2
Yes, alot of the Holmes stories are gothic. I have always found A Study in Scarlet to have lots of gothic atmosphere. Especially the murderer.
A couple of other stories come to mind involving potential supernatural explanations that turn out to be false - The Yellow Face and The Adventure of Wisteria Lodge.
I have not read it, but a couple of years ago a new book was published by the heirs of Doyle's estate called Ghosts of Bakerstreet, I believe. It is suppose to be filled with similar stories that either appear to be supernatural or are supernatural occurances. It was written by various authors.
Also do not forget Joe Bardales's articles about Holmes in Gothic Earth in the Book of S series from the Kargatane. He addes some supernatural explanations to a few of the tales. There are only 2 articles, though more were promised they were never published.
Posted: Thu Mar 27, 2008 12:03 pm
by JamesLowder
You might also want to check out the anthology Shadows Over Baker Street, which mixes the Holmes and Cthulhu cycles. How the various writers juxtapose the focus on reason in the Holmes mythos and the essential irrationality at the heart of the Cthulhu tales is interesting. Authors include Neil Gaiman and several other fine writers. I have something in there, too.
The book's also been released in translation in Germany, Spain, and, I believe, Poland.
Cheers,
Jim Lowder
Posted: Sat Mar 29, 2008 2:41 pm
by William Blackmoor
Neil Gaiman's story from 'Shadows over Bakerstreet' is titeld 'AStudy in Emerald' and can be found here as a free e-audio mp3 download:
http://www.harpercollinsebooks.com/A190 ... wnload.htm
I think it's one of the better stories of the book, which is titeled 'Schatten über Baker Street' in german. I also quite liked Mr. Lowder's 'Die Weinenden Masken' (nice take on Watson's time in Afghanistan)
Best wishes
William Blackmoor
Posted: Sat Mar 29, 2008 2:45 pm
by JamesLowder
William Blackmoor wrote:Neil Gaiman's story from 'Shadows over Bakerstreet' is titeld 'AStudy in Emerald' and can be found here as a free e-audio mp3 download:
http://www.harpercollinsebooks.com/A190 ... wnload.htm
I think it's one of the better stories of the book, which is titeled 'Schatten über Baker Street' in german. I also quite liked Mr. Lowder's 'Die Weinenden Masken' (nice take on Watson's time in Afghanistan)
Best wishes
William Blackmoor
Thanks, William. I really enjoyed writing that story and was very pleased to get an invitation to the anthology.
Cheers,
Jim Lowder
Posted: Tue Apr 01, 2008 1:24 am
by Lord_Pruitt
Well, consider the time period that Doyle wrote the Holmes stories in and the underlying element of dispelling old wives tales with the emerging scientific knowledge. I immensely enjoy the Sherlock Holmes stories and have found that they can grant a wealth of ideas for Ravenloft campaign ideas and arcs.
If anyone enjoys the movies, I recommend the old black & whites staring Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce.
Posted: Tue Apr 01, 2008 2:36 pm
by Brandi
Rathbone's a great Holmes but (and it may not be entirely Nigel Bruce's fault) they make Watson too much of an imbecile.
Look for the ITV series with Jeremy Brett as Holmes and (in the first two) David Burke or (after that) Edward Hardwicke as Watson instead; they're really excellent.
Posted: Tue Apr 01, 2008 3:07 pm
by The Giamarga
I´m a big fan of
Without a Clue myself, where Watson is the brain and Holmes an alcoholic unemployed actor.
Posted: Tue Apr 01, 2008 4:08 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Personally, I rather enjoy the Lord Darcy stories. Setting a Holmes-esque mystery in a world where magic does exist, yet the "inexplicible" crime may only seem to require its use, has got to be quite a challenge for a writer. The period-piece elements are pretty similar to Ravenloft, too.
Posted: Wed Apr 02, 2008 9:30 am
by Band2
Thanks for the recommendation James, I will have to try and find Shadows over Bakerstreet.
Joël of the FoS wrote:
I wish I had read it before DMing Howls in the Night!
Joël
When I ran Howls in the Night set in Gothic Earth, I combined the adventure with The Hounds of the Baskervilles to change the adventure up. Worked out well.