Page 1 of 3
Hallowed Witch PrC
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 9:07 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Is it just me, or is this class a little bit of a lightweight? As far as I can tell, the best powers are reserved for covens, but unless your entire party is hallowed witches, you can't use these in an adventure. Then they set the requirements so high that you making an entire party of witches is prohibitively difficult.
I've been pondering the possibility of making a "coven-member" feat. If you have the feat, you qualify as a coven member, but gain no other spellcasting powers. At least one member of a coven must actually have the prestige class in order to use the abilities. That way, a Hallowed Witch PC with the Leadership feat could be master of her own coven, and use the coven spellcasting for the benefit of the group. What do you think?
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 12:30 pm
by Sorti
The hallowed witch increases by one each of your caster level classes, to it's better than mystic theurge and many others... try a cleric1/druid1/wizard1/HW10....
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 12:42 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Sorti wrote:The hallowed witch increases by one each of your caster level classes, to it's better than mystic theurge and many others... try a cleric1/druid1/wizard1/HW10....
You have to be able to cast 2nd level divine and arcane spells, so one level in each isn't enough to qualify. You have to be at least 6th level total to qualify.
Moreover, increasing Hallowed Witch levels doesn't give you more spells, just higher caster level, so even if your proposed character was possible, (s)he wouldn't be able to cast 2nd level spells.
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 2:29 pm
by Isabella
I've been looking through the Ravenloft books a lot lately and I've found that a lot of the prestige classes have some problems with them. Here's what I do with the 3e Ravenloft prestige classes to fix them:
1) Remove any seemingly unreasonable restrictions on the class that don't make any sense or seem to add anything to the game.
2) Compare the class to other published prestige classes, or even base classes, to make sure it is not underpowered.
3) Puzzle over all of the poorly worded and ill defined abilities. Try to add action types to all the abilities they forgot to add those to.
4) Put the book back on your self.
5) Go play a druid or something.
Perhaps I am too harsh, but the Ravenloft PrCs always stuck me as more "interesting" than "play balanced" or "useful". I bear a particular grudge against Knight of the Shadows after having had to build one - the so called Prestige Class class looks like a Paladin with less abilities and a different spell list. He would have been better off as a Shadowdancer, or even just continuing in his base classes.
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 2:49 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Isabella wrote:5) Go play a druid or something.
*lol*
Perhaps I am too harsh, but the Ravenloft PrCs always stuck me as more "interesting" than "play balanced" or "useful". I bear a particular grudge against Knight of the Shadows after having had to build one - the so called Prestige Class class looks like a Paladin with less abilities and a different spell list. He would have been better off as a Shadowdancer, or even just continuing in his base classes.
I often find them very nice for NPCs, too weak or specialized for PCs.
Joël
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 7:29 pm
by Sorti
DeepShadow wrote:Sorti wrote:The hallowed witch increases by one each of your caster level classes, to it's better than mystic theurge and many others... try a cleric1/druid1/wizard1/HW10....
Increasing Hallowed Witch levels doesn't give you more spells, just higher caster level, so even if your proposed character was possible, (s)he wouldn't be able to cast 2nd level spells.
I stand corrected.
Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 11:28 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, here's the first attempt at a "coven" feat:
Coven
You are in tune with the weave and trained to assist Hala's
Requirements: Int 10, Wis 10
Effects: Pick one 0-level spell from the druid or sorcerer spell lists. You can cast this spell once per day as a spell-like ability. Alternatively, you may participate in a coven casting, which must be led by a Hallowed Witch. If you participate in such a casting, this counts as your use of this feat for the day.
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 10:05 pm
by Dimitri Mazieres
DeepShadow wrote:[...] Moreover, increasing Hallowed Witch levels doesn't give you more spells, just higher caster level [...]
After checking the book, it doesn't even do that. I didn't see anywhere in the description anything about the PrC levels stacking with other spellcasting classes' levels.
Isabella wrote:Perhaps I am too harsh, but the Ravenloft PrCs always stuck me as more "interesting" than "play balanced" or "useful". I bear a particular grudge against Knight of the Shadows after having had to build one - the so called Prestige Class class looks like a Paladin with less abilities and a different spell list. He would have been better off as a Shadowdancer, or even just continuing in his base classes.
I agree. Ever since 2e Champions of the Mists I loved the KoS concept, but the 3e version, while fitting in that it changed the focus from a heavy-armor clad warrior to a more stealthy one, somehow seemed lacking to me. The spell list seems appropriate, but the abilities are weak when compared to other PrC.
The same goes for the Avenger. Lots of flavor, but weaker than a base class.
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:23 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Dimitri Mazieres wrote: I didn't see anywhere in the description anything about the PrC levels stacking with other spellcasting classes' levels.
From Van Richten's Arsenal page 97 left column at the bottom
Primal Magic: Hallowed witch levels stack with other arcane or divine spellcasting classes for the purposes of determining caster level. For example...
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:26 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Dimitri Mazieres wrote:I agree. Ever since 2e Champions of the Mists I loved the KoS concept, but the 3e version, while fitting in that it changed the focus from a heavy-armor clad warrior to a more stealthy one, somehow seemed lacking to me. The spell list seems appropriate, but the abilities are weak when compared to other PrC.
The same goes for the Avenger. Lots of flavor, but weaker than a base class.
Sounds like a job for our friendly neighborhood Frat-fans! Let's start a collection of suggested beef-ups and whip these classes into shape!
I think the simplest way to beef them up is to grant bonus feats every so often. For the Avenger, granting the use of the Back to the Wall, Dead Man Walking etc might compensate for the narrow focus. Hallowed Witches might get metamagic feats that they can apply to their otherwise stunted spellcasting. Some of these might be conditional, like the ranger's use of TWF when lightly armored.
I agree with you all about the KoS, Hallowed Witch and Avenger, but the LotB classes all seem much better balanced. Perhaps it's just VRA classes that are the problem?
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:33 pm
by Isabella
DeepShadow wrote:
I agree with you all about the KoS, Hallowed Witch and Avenger, but the LotB classes all seem much better balanced. Perhaps it's just VRA classes that are the problem?
Well, and Heroes of Light and Champions of Darkness.
But we don't talk about them.
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:42 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Isabella wrote:Well, and Heroes of Light and Champions of Darkness.
Well, but those aren't "balance problems" so much as "What the !@#% does this
mean?" problems. Any time a prestige class ability says, "You will have to work out how this ability works in-game with your DM"...
*splutters*
I can't even finish that sentence. That's how ridiculous it is. Some of them are OK, at least as ideas for prestige classes to be re-jiggered, but--
Well, as Isabella said, we just don't talk about those books.
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 12:32 am
by Dimitri Mazieres
DeepShadow wrote:Dimitri Mazieres wrote: I didn't see anywhere in the description anything about the PrC levels stacking with other spellcasting classes' levels.
From Van Richten's Arsenal page 97 left column at the bottom
Primal Magic: Hallowed witch levels stack with other arcane or divine spellcasting classes for the purposes of determining caster level. For example...
*slaps forehead* That's what I get for trying to read faster than I should...

Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 7:30 am
by The Giamarga
DeepShadow wrote:Okay, here's the first attempt at a "coven" feat:
Coven
You are in tune with the weave and trained to assist Hala's
Requirements: Int 10, Wis 10
Effects: Pick one 0-level spell from the druid or sorcerer spell lists. You can cast this spell once per day as a spell-like ability. Alternatively, you may participate in a coven casting, which must be led by a Hallowed Witch. If you participate in such a casting, this counts as your use of this feat for the day.
Have you taken a look at the 2E Van Richten's Guide to Witches? How does it work there? Can non-spellcasters form a coven there?
I recently stumbled over the Fates Three NPCs in the Carnival. They are a Ftr2, Rog2, Rog4, who when together can cast a special version of
read thoughts (or perhaps mind probe) that draws out the victim's dark secret which they then pantomime to his horror. None of the three has any other magical abilities aside from being female vistani.
So:
- they cannot cast any spells alone
- they can cast a minor spell when together
- and neither of them is a spellcaster
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 1:48 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Good point about the Three Fates! These are actually listed in VRGtW as a coven of spellcasters within Carnival, but I missed the fact that none of them were spellcasters. In light of that, I think I need to revise my "Coven" feat. It shouldn't allow any spellcasting alone, only as part of a group. I don't want to render the prestige class redundant, so I'll have to come up with some way to make the actual witches count more in the casting.
Still, it ought to allow some kind of benefit to an individual, shouldn't it? How about a +1 to Cha-based skill checks with Witches of Hala?