Page 1 of 1

Diplomacy skill broken?

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 11:03 am
by alhoon
Here some examples of why I believe the diplomacy skill isn't working as it should in 3rd edition and I'm anxious to see the "social combat" system in 4th.

My players used to allow themselves to get captured by enemies if they saw the battle was difficult. A special gnome in particular had a couple of diplomacy feats and diplomacy as a class skill:
5th level: 8 ranks + 3 charisma modifier + 3 skill focus +2 from a feat that gives +2/+2 = +16. Add to this eagle splendor and it's a +18 at 5th level :shock: A roll of 14 and Whoooops. The ruthless bandits that have captured the party and was going to ransom them agreed to:
1. release the PCs immediately. 2. If the Lord would pardon them, they will join his army... for free. 3. Put the gnome as their leader.
And with a +18 to diplomacy you can bet castle Ravenloft that the lord would agree.

Another case: They found a +1 weapon they didn't want. They went to another noble and the gnome said: "I have this magical weapon for sale. Just 2000 gold pieces." I told him there is no way a minor noble could agree to give them about 1/4th of his fortune for a weapon that would probably gather dust over the fireplace for the rest of his life.
The gnome player said "My character tries to convince him that a magic weapon is a symbol except of a weapon and that every wealthy and powerful lord should have one. Also he may not use it but what of his sons? One of them may become a warrior and need the best of the best. It could become his legacy to his line from that time of prosperity" He added some more crap... I told him "You're not talking to a king. He's not that wealthy. He can't afford to give so much money just for a weapon! A dozen of professional bodyguards payed for a year could cost him less and he knows it."
The player said "What's the DC?" I thought a moment and told him. "OK since you only said crap to him, sucking him up, stroking his ego and not a single real argument I'll make it next to impossible: 27 DC"
He just smiled and rolled. I didn't remember at the time what his bonus was... he got a 32. :?

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 12:02 pm
by NeoTiamat
Yes... I recall that Diplomacy was generally considered one of the most broken mechanics. Especially since there are so many ways to raise the skill (oodles of synergies, Circlet of Persuasion, plus the usual skill focuses and charisma buffs).

Something I tend to do in my campaign is scale the DCs to the abilities of my PCs. Otherwise there's one fellow who'd have charmed the archvillain by now.

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 1:57 pm
by HuManBing
I dunno, I think Diplomacy should definitely be a useful skill, but the DM shouldn't feel bound by the rigid rules in a book, at the expense of his own campaign's smoothness.

Even 2nd ed. (which had very barebones diplomacy rules) had this to say about Morale - when a group of 1st level PCs offer surrender terms to an ancient red dragon, perhaps hoping for a lucky break on the dice - remember what common sense is saying... "There ain't no way!"

In the bandits situation, the DM shouldn't feel he has to allow the Diplomacy roll to dictate the pace of the plot development. That sort of turnabout in fortunes is by no means impossible, but it's very difficult and would take time and familiarity to do. The sort of trust that comes from being a bound-and-gagged obedient captive for a few nights, then telling stories at the fire and making one's captors laugh over a few weeks, and then proving that one will not take chances to escape or otherwise harm the bandits. The gang's not stupid - they won't offer the PCs their entire stashed hoarded gold just because somebody broke lucky on the dice.

This reminds me very strongly of the sword with "True Strike" permanently enchanted on it for a permanent +20 to hit. Sure, the rules pedantically read allow this to happen, but the DM and common sense must have jointly taken a leave of absence first.

If your PCs are going to try that, then it's your duty to alter the rules and make it clear that fantasy gaming still has some grounding in fact, as is the case with most fiction.


Edit: removed an unintentionally harsh-sounding first line.

Which is rather ironic, given that the post is about Diplomacy. (Irony unplanned, unfortunately. I'm not that clever.)

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 4:36 pm
by A G Thing
HuManBing is right and also you don't have to give them the DC of a check unless they have a feat like Judge Difficulty or such so you can reward them based more on what you feel is appropriate and not what some book lets your PC's attempt to exploit. Say that the skill is usefull if used in the right circumstances or you could compare it against the NPC'S roll. 32 minus say the NPC roll of sense motive of perhaps 12 unmodified still knocks the characters roll down to a 20 not to mention that the character has to beat all the NPC's in the room and if even one see's past the ruse could quickly reign in the talk against the weaseling PC's negotiator. Heck have the NPC's use the aid another action in that and they can have a staggering bonus as well if you need to teach them a lesson.
Heck if he uses it to nudge the rules in his favor all the time, his character may develop a reputation for it and then every time he tries it he will be under higher and higher penalties.

I had the same problem and it took me near 5 games to think of a fair way to defeat that method without it being a complete "Behind the screen" sort of thing...

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 4:55 pm
by Hazgarn
The Giant in the Playground site had an interesting article reworking Diplomacy DCs. http://www.giantitp.com/articles/jFppYw ... hONNF.html

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 6:44 pm
by alhoon
Most of the time I used a skill check against diplomacy. But let's face it: Scaling the DC as the PCs increasing level is cheap and stealing them of the gratification of going up in level.
To me it's the same as telling everyone: "Now that you're 5th level, every orc warrior you encounter or any village guard or every bandit will be 3rd level." And then later "Now that you're 10th level, everyone is at least 5th level"

Also a DC 27 is waaay to much. The player wasn't abusing the rules. He had feats and ranks all for this reason. If I told them that the DC would be 40 for tasks like selling a magic sword then they would ask me what the average commoner or expert 1st level trader has for diplomacy.

What I'm looking forward to is a social combat system that it changes the attitudes gradualy, like combat.
I.e instead of saying to them "DC 27 do or do not" I would prefer a system like: "He has diplomacy +11. Each success on your part increases the price of the sword by 300 gold. Each success on his part reduces the price by 300 gold. You have a total of 4 tries both of you."
Why I didn't do that back then?

I haven't thought about it. :)

Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 8:24 pm
by NeoTiamat
Well, I wasn't implying doing it to everyone. Rather, I'd probably treat it like Intimidate, where the DC is a modified level-check.

So against villagers? Sure, charm the socks off of them. Against the high-level archmage........ good luck.

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 3:47 am
by A G Thing
Well any game mechanic can be exploited and If you let him have the skill feats and such and knew the possible events then you as the DM have to arbitrate. I guess if you wanted to build up a verbal combat system then you could make opposed rolls but the players will try things that are absurd sometimes and must not happen or they will run with it if it is done too often.

Still maybe this will get the threads juices flowing...

Diplomacy vs Diplomacy or Bluff or Intimidate, could all be opposed rolls that the loser may lose the amount from his next roll equal to the amount the winner beat it by.
Slowly one side of the arguement would win more while the other would lose more.
As they are reasoned down further and further others could still aid by shouting in to give temporary boosts but only as many times as thier Charisma modifier per opposed check, and only one per turn of course this is optional.

Example: Guy with 5 Diplomacy is trying to keep him and his friend convinced to attack, and the guy with 10 Diplomacy is trying to get him and his friend out of danger by convincing them to let them go.

Theoretically the guy with 5 total Diplomacy could take on the guy with 10 and with good rolls and maybe some friendly support win or the other guy could win easy or it could lead to a draw of sorts.

On the final check the scores would each have lowered but the one that has enough to totally eliminate the other is the winner.

Our above example places 5 vs 10 and if 5 rolled 15 totaling 20 but the guy with 10 rolls only 8 totaling 18, then next check the guy with 5 would be the same but the guy with 10 would now have 8 on his next roll since he lost by 2.

That next roll could have the guy with 5 roll a 17 totaling 22 while the guy with 8 and his friend with 12 Cha who aids with his one +2 bonus roll a 12 totaling thanks to his friend 22, this round is a tie and neither suffers a penalty but the guy with 8 is still back to eight the next round.

Third round could be when the guy with 5 rolls a 10 and has a friend chime in to boost the total to 17, but unfortunately for him the guy with eight just rolled an 11 totaling 19, so now in his next round he has only a 3 left to use for the Diplomacy face off.

This final round the guy with 3 rolls a 19 for 22 but the guy with 8 rolls a 17 for 25. This reduced the guy with 3 finally to 0 Diplomacy and by reducing the final check of the guy with 8 who got 25 by 3 for the amount his defeated opponent lost to get him to 0, his new total is a 22 Diplomacy check. Enough to make them unfriendly but not indifferent by the DC chart. At this point say that it is as far as diplomacy can take the situation.

Victory and not the insane modifier or check result but perhaps enough for a comprimise or such. Some times it may go quicker or slower but the guy with the higher modifier still starts out in power but is not absolutely going to win by just a lucky roll and may have to settle for a lesser result. If the guy with 8 had rolled 24 the match would have continued and he could have ended up with some bad rolls with a lower score for a check of perhaps 19 and failed to do anything.

If from the start we had gone with just straight rolls the guy with 5 compared to the guy with 10 at the start would have won on the first roll by luck.
With this system we had to have him wittle away his opponents arguement and he lost to someone with superior skill when his own luck ran out.

This is just a suggestion and I guess you don't need to have the others in thier aiding but I just thought of it and I hope it might inspire you and others if nothing else.

Hope I was at least aiming in the right direction?!?! :wink:

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 7:24 am
by Chris
Just another thing to remember ist, that diplomacy isn´t dominate person. That means you can´t let someone do something that ist extremely against his interests.

This is how i threat diplomacy.

The noble wouldn´t buy the sword, but he maybe if he can affort it.

The bandits will threat you well and maybe if your have a good die roll they let you go.

Think of Hannibal Lector. He will help you if you in your hunt if you could convince him due your diplomacy skill, but he will eat up one of your party members as soon he gets a good cianti :D

Another imprtant thin: Diplomacy only works if the "victim" wants to talk or listent to the "Faceman"

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 8:23 am
by DocBeard
"Wow, I really like you."

"I'm still going to kill you, but I thought I should say that."

The problem with parleying is that sometimes, the bastards just want you dead, y'know?

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 9:17 am
by HuManBing
DocBeard wrote:"Wow, I really like you."

"I'm still going to kill you, but I thought I should say that."

The problem with parleying is that sometimes, the bastards just want you dead, y'know?
Have you seen Three Amigos?

El Guapo: I like these guys! They're funny!

[Thinks for a while]

El Guapo: Just kill one.

[Jefe draws his pistol and shoots Lucky Day in the arm]

Lucky Day: Ow! What the hell!

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 2:19 pm
by JinnTolser
There's a discussion pretty similar to this going on at the WotC forums as well. Some people there have raised a few good points, in particular a poster named Metafictional on the second page. Here's the link to his post

A brief summary of what some people there said about this subject:

1. Apply circumstance modifiers. It won't be enough to make things impossible, but it can at least make it a little harder for the skill to be abused.

2. Diplomacy against enemies isn't always that viable of an option. It takes a minute of uninterrupted talking to make a Diplomacy check. Nowhere does it say the other party has to listen, though. Or wait until he's finished talking.

3. If the player has been abusing his diplomatic skills, word of his smooth tongue will get around, and people might decide not to listen to him, or at least be more predisposed not to believe him.

4. Diplomacy does not exist in a vacuum. You cannot convince people to do what you want just because you rolled well, and offer them nothing in return. Diplomacy is the art of the deal, after all.

I think the best point raised in that topic, though was "a dice roll never overrides common sense." :)

Posted: Sat Apr 05, 2008 3:32 pm
by A G Thing
Well heres a system I came up with just for you and I guess it is okay but it may need some fine tuneing.

Okay as an example of two guys using the skill of Diplomacy in a contested system I will now give you how I see that it could go in a combat encounter.

Here are our competitors...

Guy 1 has 7 ranks total with all modifiers to Diplomacy and is trying to resist Guy 2 and fight.

Guy 2 has 10 ranks total with all modifiers to Diplomacy and is trying to convince Guy 1 to be Indifferent from Hostile which is the highest result possible with his current ranks.

Here are standard rules in effect in 3 examples.

Example 1 standard: Now in a standard roll if both Guy 1 & 2 rolled, the higher would win automatically. Guy 1 rolls a 20 while Guy 2 rolls a 14. Guy 1 has won by luck and Guy 2 has failed and nothing is left but to fight.

Example 2 standard: In the reverse if guy 1 gets the 14 and Guy 2 rolls the 20 then Guy 2 according to the chart has made Guy 1 go to Indifferent. Even if Guy 2 rolled 6 less he would still make Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.

Example 3 standard: Now if Guy 1 rolls a 15 and Guy 2 rolls a 15 then Guy 2 will win and will according to the chart make Guy 1 go to Indifferent. Even if guy 2 rolled 1 less he would still make Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.

By standard rules though they would have to take 1 minute (10 rounds total) to do such. If they do it in one round then Guy 2 the one initiating the roll must take a -10 penalty to his roll. With this he still has a 20 due to his extremely lucky roll. and that still makes Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.

Now lets say we make them go head to head and the loser loses to his future rolls the amount the winner has beaten him by. This goes on till one reaches 0 ranks to roll total. Then the final total of the last check of the victor, is the total that determines the result.

Using the above examples results lets compare the conflict examples.

Example 1 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a 27 total and is clearly ahead of Guy 2 who has rolled 24 total. Guy 1 has beaten Guy 2 in this first round by 3 and thus Guy 2 must decrease all future checks in this opposed contest by 3 giving Guy 2, 7 ranks left to use. This will go back and forth till one is reduced to zero and the outcome is now tied in it's chances as both Guy 1 and Guy 2 have the same total from the 2nd round on until one loses another amount.

Example 2 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a total 21 and is now behind Guy 2 who through a lucky roll has gotten a total of 30. Guy 2 has beaten Guy 1 in this first round by 9 and since Guy 1 only had 7 ranks to begin with he is reduced to 0 ranks and has lost. Guy 2 has the winning result of 30 which is enough to get Guy 1 to Indifferent.

Example 3 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a total 22 and is now behind Guy 2 who rolled a 25 total. Guy 2 has beaten Guy 1 in this first round by 3 and since Guy 1 only had 7 ranks to begin with they are now reduced by 3 giving Guy 1, 4 ranks left to use. This will go back and forth till one is reduced to zero and the outcome is now more in favor of Guy 2 but still not absolutely determined to be for one or the other.

Now how is this different you say.

In Example 1 standard the results we see are that Guy 1 automatically wins with no real contest through sheer luck Guy 1 with that 20 rolled a total 27 but Guy 2 would have gotten a total of 30 with the 20.

In Example 1 conflicting Guy 1 has earned equal footing and thus the next round is not in his opponents favor. Now no matter what in the next round both Guy 1 and Guy 2 roll 20 neither can roll higher than 27 total.
------------------------------
In Example 2 standard the results we see are that Guy 2 automatically wins with no real contest through sheer luck, Guy 2 with that 20 rolled a total 30 but Guy 1 would have gotten a total of 27 with the 20.

In Example 2 conflicting Guy 2 has still won and reduced Guy 1 to 0 and by doing such Guy 2 has succede because the final result of 30 is enough to change Guy 1 from Hostile to Indifferent. Still can't beat overwealming luck.
----------------------------
Example 3 standard the results we see are that Guy 2 automatically wins with with no real contest through sheer luck, Guy 2 that 15 rolled a total 25 but Guy 1 with the same result only could get 22.

In Example 3 conflicting Guy 2 has still won the round but has only reduced Guy 1's starting ranks of 7 by 3 to a new total of 4 ranks in future rounds. Now Guy 2 may still roll a maximum of 30 while Guy 1 may only roll a maximum of 24. This places the odds in Guy 2's favor even more than before but he could still lose future rounds. If however in those future rounds he continued to dwindle Guy 1's reserves then Guy 2 may roll high enough to still get Guy 1 to either Unfriendly or Indifferent or he may still roll too low to succede at either.

Now in these it is up to you if either side gets circumstance modifiers for thier arguements.

Just something I came up with in about an hour so maybe you will like it maybe not. I can help further in developing it if you want. Maybe it will inspire you. Either way hope it helps! :)