Diplomacy skill broken?
Posted: Fri Apr 04, 2008 11:03 am
Here some examples of why I believe the diplomacy skill isn't working as it should in 3rd edition and I'm anxious to see the "social combat" system in 4th.
My players used to allow themselves to get captured by enemies if they saw the battle was difficult. A special gnome in particular had a couple of diplomacy feats and diplomacy as a class skill:
5th level: 8 ranks + 3 charisma modifier + 3 skill focus +2 from a feat that gives +2/+2 = +16. Add to this eagle splendor and it's a +18 at 5th level
A roll of 14 and Whoooops. The ruthless bandits that have captured the party and was going to ransom them agreed to:
1. release the PCs immediately. 2. If the Lord would pardon them, they will join his army... for free. 3. Put the gnome as their leader.
And with a +18 to diplomacy you can bet castle Ravenloft that the lord would agree.
Another case: They found a +1 weapon they didn't want. They went to another noble and the gnome said: "I have this magical weapon for sale. Just 2000 gold pieces." I told him there is no way a minor noble could agree to give them about 1/4th of his fortune for a weapon that would probably gather dust over the fireplace for the rest of his life.
The gnome player said "My character tries to convince him that a magic weapon is a symbol except of a weapon and that every wealthy and powerful lord should have one. Also he may not use it but what of his sons? One of them may become a warrior and need the best of the best. It could become his legacy to his line from that time of prosperity" He added some more crap... I told him "You're not talking to a king. He's not that wealthy. He can't afford to give so much money just for a weapon! A dozen of professional bodyguards payed for a year could cost him less and he knows it."
The player said "What's the DC?" I thought a moment and told him. "OK since you only said crap to him, sucking him up, stroking his ego and not a single real argument I'll make it next to impossible: 27 DC"
He just smiled and rolled. I didn't remember at the time what his bonus was... he got a 32.
My players used to allow themselves to get captured by enemies if they saw the battle was difficult. A special gnome in particular had a couple of diplomacy feats and diplomacy as a class skill:
5th level: 8 ranks + 3 charisma modifier + 3 skill focus +2 from a feat that gives +2/+2 = +16. Add to this eagle splendor and it's a +18 at 5th level
1. release the PCs immediately. 2. If the Lord would pardon them, they will join his army... for free. 3. Put the gnome as their leader.
And with a +18 to diplomacy you can bet castle Ravenloft that the lord would agree.
Another case: They found a +1 weapon they didn't want. They went to another noble and the gnome said: "I have this magical weapon for sale. Just 2000 gold pieces." I told him there is no way a minor noble could agree to give them about 1/4th of his fortune for a weapon that would probably gather dust over the fireplace for the rest of his life.
The gnome player said "My character tries to convince him that a magic weapon is a symbol except of a weapon and that every wealthy and powerful lord should have one. Also he may not use it but what of his sons? One of them may become a warrior and need the best of the best. It could become his legacy to his line from that time of prosperity" He added some more crap... I told him "You're not talking to a king. He's not that wealthy. He can't afford to give so much money just for a weapon! A dozen of professional bodyguards payed for a year could cost him less and he knows it."
The player said "What's the DC?" I thought a moment and told him. "OK since you only said crap to him, sucking him up, stroking his ego and not a single real argument I'll make it next to impossible: 27 DC"
He just smiled and rolled. I didn't remember at the time what his bonus was... he got a 32.