Page 1 of 1
Fixing the Avenger
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:43 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, so people think the Avenger class is a lightweight. Here's my fix: the Avenger's intuition ability is perhaps the weakest point (hey, every other level, I increase my ability to dominate the plotline or derail the current adventure with my obsession!) so at those levels, I'd add the following ability:
Bonus Feat: Every odd-numbered level, the avenger may select one of the following feats: Back to the Wall, Courage, Dead Man Walking, Diehard, Improved Supernatural Resilience, Indomitable, Open Mind, Sworn Enemy, Warding Gesture. These feats work regardless of the avenger's current mission, as they represent the hardening effect of the ceaseless struggle against his/her nemesis.
There, whatcha think? Anything I should add to the list?
Posted: Sun Apr 06, 2008 11:52 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I dunno, I've always felt like the weakest point for the Avenger is what happens after you stop being an Avenger. I mean, unless the Avenger's story arc syncs up perfectly with the campaign's arc, then either you run out of campaign with the Avenger unavenged, or you're lumbered with a bunch of levels in a class whose abilities are now mostly useless.
Personally, I think I'd make it a 5 level class, more accessible and useful to spellcasters, and with some kind of "Congratulations!" ability after you successfully avenge yourself against your foe...
Unless the whole point is that an obsession with vengeance leaves you empty when you achieve it, which is very Gothic and cool but kinda a wet blanket in terms of game play.
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 12:09 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Well, I'd like to think that these feats are at least a small consolation prize. For a bigger prize, how about some kind of "inner peace" ability, that you have fulfilled your life's mission and can face the future with a heart unburdened?
I'd put this ability at 2nd level at least, so that nobody is tempted to take one level of the class for some wimpy nemesis they kill the next adventure, just so they can have the congratulatory power.
Hey, in previous editions, the avenger was related to the Knight of the Shadows. Perhaps there's still that kind of connection: if you have killed your nemesis (without becoming a monster yourself), you are invited to join the Circle, and can qualify for the KoS prestige class with fewer requirements. Some of the purpose of the KoS might be to redirect that otherwise wasted potential into a healthy life of helping others, kinda like a self-help group. After all, no one knows how empty such a victory can be like another successful avenger.
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 7:47 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
The easy entry into KoS sounds neat. It shouldn't be the only perk you can trade in for, though, because avengers aren't necessarily good guys like the Circle.
Perhaps the avenger could choose between two post-nemesis options: one for those who find peace once their retribution is accomplished, and another for those who've gotten so deep into their vendetta that they can't function without one? For the former, they'd get an "inner peace" perk of some kind and the option of entering the KoS if they're good guys. For the latter, they'd get to choose a new nemesis to pursue (and another one after that, etc), but at a price of forever forfeiting access to the "inner peace" path ... and they might even get a chance to become a dread revenant after they die.
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 9:23 am
by Sorti
We could say when you avenge yourself you can trade Avenger levels for some other combat-oriented classes (fighter, ranger, KoS...), it's not unprecedented (see Blackguard), and eventually keep some free ability from your Avenger past...
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 9:50 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
I like the choice between good and evil, and I also like trading in levels. Perhaps blackguard vs KoS? We'd have to have an option available for someone who chose neither, though.
What about a Horror/Madness check upon realizing your life no longer has meaning? Succeess or failure would help determine your path.
Of course, this means we also need to fix the KoS prestige class. I'll make that next on my list.
Posted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 5:09 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Interestingly enough, the above bonus feats list includes the feat requirements for a KoS--Courage and Dead Man Walking. Avengers are already skilled in Gather Info, so perhaps the best one to waive for an ex-avenger is Knowledge (local). Other than that, a 3rd level avenger should have no trouble qualifying for Knight of the Shadows.
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 1:36 am
by The Giamarga
An Avenger who has defeated his nemesis, still has bonuses against the minions. So unless he roots out all creatures of that tyoe, he still has some nice powers left to use.
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 11:43 am
by Jester of the FoS
Avenger: Possible fixes
Problems:
* Focused on a single foe. Class abilities are diminished (if non-existent) when fighting unrelated foes
* Built-in end. Kill the enemy and the class vanishes.
* Alternate stats. A minor problem but it hurts that you essentially need 3 versions of your character sheet (regular, nemesis, and nemesis-related) to keep track of hp, skills, saves, etc.
* 1/2 the bonus are related to tracking down a single quarry. The use is vague. If you beat the DC by 5 you can pin-point the city they’re in. But what do you learn if you hit the base DC? What if you already know what city they’re in? As abilities go it’s ass.
Intent:
* Track down a sworn enemy
* Avenge a grievous wrong
* Transfer enmity to similar foes
I’d recommend a complete rebuild from 3.0 to 3.5 for this class.
First, I’d make it more focused on tracking down similar foes, much like VanRichten was focused on vampires; set the base class and abilities around that then have them increase against the nemesis (aka the reverse of it currently).
This would also work really, really well as a ranger prestige class so I’m leaning to dropping the HD to d8 (especially since it might also be a rogue class). Additional HD provided by the class would help keep it up to fighters.
This might mean alternate abilities, something not really handled in existing classes.
Level 1 – Favoured Enemy
L2 – Resolve +1
L3 – Sneak Attack +1d6, Familiar Target
L4 – Resolve +2
L5 – Improved Favoured Enemy, Sneak Attack +1d6,
L6 – Resolve +3
L7 – Sneak Attack +1d6
L8 – Resolve +4
L9 – Mastered Favoured Enemy, Sneak Attack +1d6
L10 – Resolve +5
Favoured Enemy. As per the ranger ability for the same type as the nemesis. If the character already has the nemesis’ type as a favoured enemy the bonuses increase by 2. Against the enemy themself the bonuses increase by an additional 2. At the game master's discretion, an avenger may select an organization instead of a creature type as his favoured enemy. For example, a character might select a particular thieves' guild, merchant house, or even the city guard. The favoured enemy bonuses would apply to all members of the chosen organization, regardless of their creature type or subtype.
Resolve. When facing the favoured enemy the avenger gains temporary hp equal to 1/level, and a +1 bonus to fortitude and will saving throws. When facing the nemesis these bonuses are doubled. Avengers are relentless when facing their chosen opponents. (with favoured enemy boosting wisdom skills already the wisdom bonus is less needed). This bonus increases by 1 at levels 4, 6, 8, and 10.
Sneak Attack. As the rogue ability.
Familiar Target. An Avenger is so skilled at combating their quarry they know all the weak spots of their prey. This ability has one of two effects. If the favoured enemy is normally immune to sneak attack damage (such as undead or constructs) then the avenger is now able to apply this damage. If the subject is not immune to sneak attacks then the avenger receives a +4 competence bonus to confirm critical hits.
Improved Favoured Enemy. Bonuses against the favoured enemy increase by 2. Bonuses against the nemesis still only increase by 2 for a total of 6 (in addition to any ranger benefits).
Mastered Favoured Enemy. Bonuses against the favoured enemy increase by 2. Bonuses against the nemesis still only increase by 2 for a total of 8 (in addition to any ranger benefits).
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 11:48 am
by Jester of the FoS
That's my fix. The favoured enemy essentially replaces intuition with the related bonuses to sense motive in survival paralleling the ability to hunt.
I might add "track" as a pre-req feat.
The cons with my version is that it's essentially a ranger/rogue that gains bonus hp when facing favoured enemies. Unique-esque but still less varied than a regular ranger/rogue.
And it lacks the spells of the ranger and related special abilities of the rogue, so it might need a tad more power at the high end. Maybe an attack bonus or the like.
Oh, and the organization favoured enemy stuff is pulled from the urban ranger in the SRD, which I think really works well with the avenger. Especially one possibly wronged by a group with the head of the group as the nemesis. Kinda like in The Crow or a tonn of revenge flicks.
Posted: Tue Apr 08, 2008 2:23 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
The Giamarga wrote:An Avenger who has defeated his nemesis, still has bonuses against the minions. So unless he roots out all creatures of that tyoe, he still has some nice powers left to use.
Minions are not the same as creature type.
Posted: Sat Apr 12, 2008 8:55 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, so here's my proposed "ending fix," inspired by the Blackguard PrC:
Avengers who have defeated their nemeses (that is to say, are now ex-avengers) gain extra abilities the more levels of avenger they have.
An avenger who has defeated his nemesis gains all of the following abilities that apply, according to the number of avenger levels the character has.
1-2
Favored Enemy. This is identical to the ranger ability, and stacks with other favored enemy abilities.
3-4
Bonus Feat: The ex-avenger may select a bonus feat from either of the lists for avengers or fighters. Rage 1/day as a barbarian of equal level to her avenger level.
5-6
Favored Enemy. This is identical to the ranger ability, and stacks with other favored enemy abilities.
7-8
Bonus Feat: The ex-avenger may select a bonus feat from either of the lists for avengers or fighters. Rage 1/day as a barbarian of equal level to her avenger level.
9-10
Favor of the Mists. The ex-avenger can grant a blessing to others on a quest of vengeance, granting favors once per week as if she were a Pale Rider (See VRGttM). Using this ability requires a 5% powers check, with failure causing the ex-avenger to progress down the Path of the Pale Rider.
Mystical Invitation
Knights of the Shadows keep a close watch on avengers they meet, and report promising candidates to their superiors. If an avenger slays his or her nemesis without being consumed by inner demons, the Circle may issue an invitation for the ex-avenger to join their ranks. An avenger who accepts immediately gains a Knight of the Shadows level for each level of avenger he trades in.
The character level of the character does not change. With the loss of avenger levels, the character no longer gains as many extra abilities for being an ex-avenger.