Page 1 of 3

What is broken in 3.5?

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 11:09 am
by Joël of the FoS
I saw a similar thread on Enworld, and the question picked my interest.

What do you think wasn't working well in 3.5 D&D mechanics?

---

1) for me, it's mainly the time taken to create a NPC - prestige class, templates, feat and skill choice, etc. If you want to do it by the book, it takes a long time, often much longer than the time it will be used in the game :)
My suggestion: only prepare the parts you think will be needed, battle for battle, or social skills for this type of role playing encounter, etc.

2) There is the skill thing. As JWM remarked, many skills are there for flavor, but will never get a dice roll in any game (ex: giving ranks in painting for D'Polarno - needed for flavor, but useless in most encounters with him).
My suggestion: different set of skills, one for "adventuring" (the system we have now), plus "social skills and what you did before adventuring" (with a separate set of points - number of points per year age may be, where one would find the crafts and similar skill).

What else? :)

Joël

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 11:22 am
by HuManBing
The feats are broad but arbitrary. Why should you need a +12 BAB to do a flying kick? I was doing those when I was 8 and my BAB in real life is probably not +12.

It's weird how there's a lot more feats in the 3.5 universe than skills. Granted a PC is never going to have more feats than skills but it's odd that you have a load of skills that apparently everybody can access, and the universe of tweakables is so large.

The skills for classes is really constraining. I think Monks do well with Improved Feint to deprive their enemies of Dex bonuses to AC and attack in the same round. But guess what? Bluff isn't a Monk class skill. They will never be as good as Rogues or Fighters in that regard. And the Bluff to deprive Dex bonus mechanic is really clunky - you have to make a straight Bluff check, but your enemy gets to add their Sense Motive AND their BAB. And all for what? At most a +4 to your next attack roll.

The current structure is basically saying "We, the WotC staff, think that your campaign of monks should not be good at bluffing. Why? Because we say so." Repeat ad infinitum for all other cross class guidelilnes.

I'm toying with a house rule that allows PCs to swap out a number of skill points per level (perhaps equal to their Int bonus) to put anywhere they want without the cross class penalty.

Grappling is a bit confusing.

Class powers and progression is a bit arbitrary. I'd be interested in a parallel points buy system. It never seemed right to me that Monks couldn't sneak attack but Rogues could. Or why Rogues got loads more skill points than Wizards.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 11:49 am
by JinnTolser
HuManBing wrote:The skills for classes is really constraining. I think Monks do well with Improved Bluff to deprive their enemies of Dex bonuses to AC and attack in the same round. But guess what? Bluff isn't a Monk class skill. They will never be as good as Rogues or Fighters in that regard. And the Bluff to deprive Dex bonus mechanic is really clunky - you have to make a straight Bluff check, but your enemy gets to add their Sense Motive AND their BAB. And all for what? At most a +4 to your next attack roll.

The current structure is basically saying "We, the WotC staff, think that your campaign of monks should not be good at bluffing. Why? Because we say so." Repeat ad infinitum for all other cross class guidelilnes.

I'm toying with a house rule that allows PCs to swap out a number of skill points per level (perhaps equal to their Int bonus) to put anywhere they want without the cross class penalty.
Class skills are VERY arbitrary. By the way, Bluff isn't class for Fighters either, though they can at least probably afford to spare a feat to make it a class skill.

The one that really bothers me is Spot. This should be a class skill for everyone, I believe. And why is it that there's a skill for hearing, two different skills for sight (that's a whole different can of worms though), but Scent is a special ability? They should definitely take a cue from Star Wars in this area and fold them all into a single Perception skill.

Speaking of arbitrary, the attack of opportunity rules need some cleaning up. I don't really want to see them done away with entirely, though I've heard of many a campaign that has done so, but I find that a lot of things I would think would provoke an AoO do not, and vice versa.

The grappling rules are too confusing to remember, for me at least. I find the rules for a lot of other things, like tripping, disarming, bull rush, etc. difficult to remember as well, though not nearly as bad as grappling.

I'd also like to see throwaway feats like Toughness, Dodge, and most of the +2 to two skills feats done away with as well. They're only there to serve as prerequisites for prestige classes or other feats, and I don't think anybody would take them if they didn't have to in order to do something else.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:05 pm
by Joël of the FoS
JinnTolser wrote: I'd also like to see throwaway feats like Toughness, Dodge, and most of the +2 to two skills feats done away with as well. They're only there to serve as prerequisites for prestige classes or other feats, and I don't think anybody would take them if they didn't have to in order to do something else.
They are a little weak indeed, and would be better if they improved the bonus with increasing levels. +3 hit points is cool when 1st level, it's negligible after the 3rd or 4th level. And as you say, making it a prerequesite is asking the player to take a cheap feat in order to get the next.

Joël

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:29 pm
by Jester of the FoS
1) Level adjustment and ECL. A CR8 creature does *not* play as a level 15 character.

2) Grappling. Too many side-rules, exceptions and complications

3) Spiked chains. Combined with improved trip and combat reflexes they're gross. Worse if you add enlarge person. And as piercing weapons they work fine underwater.

4) CR. It's very arbitrarily done. Some monsters are just waaaaay too powerful for their CR (gnolls, chull, fire elementals) while others are weak (ogre mage, drow).

5) Diplomacy. At level 10 you can easily knock it up to +15 without magic or feats (or charisma). With magic and a feat or two and a solid charisma score (possibly enhanced) it can easily hit +25. Bam, you can make someone friendly with a "10". With a rushed diplomacy you need a "20" but can still automatically someone from hostile to indifferent with a "1".

6) Skills (see Joel)

7) Multiclassing. You can't make a good gish (fighter/wizard).

8) Fighters still aren't as good as wizards. Feats are nice but there's just not a balance.

9) Monsters gain CR half as fast as HD. At higher levels you're fighting things with two or even three times the HD of you. Their BAB, feats and saves are through the roof. They won't fail any saves except on a "1" so don't even try a spell that save negates. They won't ever miss you except on a "1" and can reliably power attack for crazy amounts of damage.

10) Monster advancement. Want to use a rust monster but the party is too high? Advance it by adding HD increasing it's size. But as above, you'll add 3 or 4 HD before it gains any CR.

11) Prestige classes. Why be a cleric or sorcerer gaining no abilities except spells when I can take a prestige class and gain ALL my other abilities plus a stack of new ones.

12) Dead levels. Yeah, they're meant to discourage multi-classing by making you wait for the really cool abilities. But nothing sucks more than finally making a new level and getting.... nothing. Here's an extra +1 BAB and a couple hp.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:50 pm
by HuManBing
JinnTolser wrote:They should definitely take a cue from Star Wars in this area and fold them all into a single Perception skill.
Yes, that was one thing I liked about the "SPECIAL" system from Fallout. It has Perception more or less replacing the DnD Wisdom score. It affects how far you can see, your initiative, and your surprise roll (dating back to 2nd ed.).

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:56 pm
by NeoTiamat
1-Skills. There are some skills that are virtually must-have, or at least exceedingly useful (Tumble, Spot, Bluff) in combat and actual gameplay, whereas when is the last time anyone ever used Craft? Or most of the Knowledge skills?

I think Joel has the best idea. Have combat-skills and RP-skills, and don't mix the two.

2-Grappling. I really like the idea, and its a vital part of the repertoire for many, many monsters, (starting with Illithids and most snake-monsters with Constrict). Simplification.

3-BALANCE. This is the big one. The biggest problem with D&D is that past a superficial level, it's not really very balanced. Some of this is purely because there's so much stuff out there, but even then, in the basic SRD, you have classes that are far better than others. Spellcasters most particularly become insanely powerful at high levels, but so do rogues (say, four attacks with 6d6 sneak attack each?). Your poor tanks just get utterly outclassed. Same goes for the useful/useless feats (Toughness vs. Spell Focus (Evocation)). Same goes for CR, which is woefully imprecise when you start modifying monsters.

My best guess would be to either tone down casters or else to give Fighters and Barbarians a more exponentially increasing power set. As far as monsters... link their CR closer to their 'results', like damage output and AC, HP.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:58 pm
by HuManBing
The game also overemphasizes armor. The max dex bonuses are set too high, so it makes it senseless not to wear it. You can wear a chain shirt and get +4, and you take no Dex penalty unless your Dex is somehow 20 or above. (Max bonus of +4.)

You could remedy this either by instituting a Base Defense Bonus, or perhaps changing armor entirely to a Damage Reduction mechanic. This may require a complete rebalancing of hp and weapon damage so it doesn't make plate mail overly powerful against stuff like arrows and other ranged weapons.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:34 pm
by Lord Soth
Balance is the big one for me. I've never cared for the idea of the Wizard outclassing the Fighter at higher levels. You work hard, gaining XP and levelling up to become, what, the Wizard's henchman? That's the grand goal of the Fighter class? :(

Skills is another thing. I hate how several classes were given just 2 Skill Points per level. I always played a Human and started with a bare minimum Int 12 just so I could have 4 Skill Points to work with, when playing those classes. Even then it wasn't enough. It most definitely wasn't enough when I tried to take those classes out of bounds of the norm. For instance, a stealthy Paladin. Strange, but why not? I'll tell you why not. Because you don't have the Skill Points to make it work. Not without sacrificing Diplomacy, Sense Motive, Knowledge (Religion), and Ride (Which, IMO, are must haves for the Paladin).

Those two are big reasons why I'm looking forward to 4E. Class balance, so the Level 20 Fighter doesn't feel like a schmuck next to the Level 20 Wizard. And skills, as several skills have been folded together (giving you more bang for your skill buck), and all classes now have the equivalent of 4 Skill Points per level, minimum (So even the Fighter gets some pretty nice play with skills. He's also gotten Streetwise, the 4E version of Knowledge: Local. So his out-of-combat repertoire is no longer limited to intimidating people). I just wonder how selecting non-class skills as Trained Skills will be handled? Hopefully one will be able to freely choose any skill and make it a Trained Skill with the use of a Feat.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 3:08 pm
by HuManBing
I'm thinking one way to get out of the balance issue is to make things more accessible generally. Give each character, regardless of class, a few discretionary skill points to spend as they want without cross class hindrances.

Things that are arbitrary should be reduced and made more accessible. Class limitations on skill points struck me as arbitrary.

Likewise I think the spell progression tables and certain class based skills don't really have much rhyme or reason to them.

If I had enough time, I'd like to knock down every single class and separate out the skills, and assign an XP cost for every single feature and then let the PCs construct their own characters from the ground up.

So after you have a load of XP, you could spend a large amount to roll a d12 hit dice, or you could spend a little to roll a d4 hit dice. You could spend a load for certain feats and skills, which might be cheaper if you have a certain ability score. If you fancy the Sneak Attack power, you could spend XP to get that too, and add it to your Monk character. You could simplify the skill list (since that's basically just an ability check with a modifier) and make it situational.

I'd like the flexibility to play as a character who had a massively high BAB with ranged weapons, but who had to keep moving quickly because he can't take damage. Or maybe a Monk character who doesn't do a whole lot of damage in combat but is great at blocking blows. (Right now, apart from Dodge and another feat, there's really not much going for AC-boosters right now.) Or maybe I'd like a character who has a load of hit points but is clumsy in battle and can't hit stuff so well. Under the current rules you can't really do that.

That sort of revamping, I think, would seriously overhaul the system and really be worthy of a new edition moniker. I'd pay good money for that.

4E, however, sounds like a few rules tweaks that are somewhat broader than 3.5, but still merely progressive, not revolutionary. I'm not interested in paying money for that, and I'll restrict myself to borrowing whatever's available for free and incorporating that into my game as I like.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 3:13 pm
by Charney
For me it's imbalance between attack and defense. IMC, attack bonus go up way too fast for AC to follow. A 9th level ranger can easily hit AC 30 with most monsters barely having more than 25 in AC.

BTW about useless skills, I solved that. For craft and all, I never put more than maybe 3 ranks in such skills. If I do, it's because it's the master smith dwarf hidden in the mountain or something.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 5:47 pm
by A G Thing
The rules I am trying to change currently because of a dislike of the D20 imbalance issues. I just want to see if they work and if so I will most likely begin using them..

1: Feats: Messed up precisely because there are so many like Dodge or Power Attack that don't discribe complex techniques so much as things a player could just do normally.
I watch that guy and try to anticipate and dodge better is something anyone should be able to do.
I swing as hard as I can with less precision to hit, anyone can do that too.
I have started a list of feats that are free for all classes from the start and have started giving higher numbers of starting feats depending on the classes involved from lists that make sense.

2: Skills: Messed up for a lot of the above reasons such as Diplomacy being too powerful, class and cross class skills, set class skills and class specific skill points.
I have still been working out a system based on giving skill points based on the statistics of the person more so than intelligence being the end all be all of the bunch. I have come to little on this front but it seems odd that there are no unskilled Rogues at all...
So far I have made the class lists the standard for the characters and have decided that they gain a number of skills as class skills of each relevent statistic such as Strength based skills equal to their modifiers in the relevent stat. A fighter with a high Dex such as 16 could add Balance, Tumble, and Move Silently. If he also had a 12 in Wis he could add Sense Motive too.

3: Magic Spells: Made a spell point system and gave the Wizards, Clerics and Sorcerers the option of memorising more spells of any level. Wizards are powerful at least their supposed to be and are an asset to the group if you can keep them alive. But in the old system they had to memorize high power spells when perhaps they just needed a lower level spell more.

4: Magic Items: Characters survival against their encounters in every level depends on them having the correct equipment. Unfortunately with the lack of stackable spells that a Mage can cast Magic Items become mandatory for their survival. They cannot meet the challanges because they will die due to the unbalanced monsters.
Solution to this problem is to make mundane Items more valuable. Make armor provide DR/bonus equal to hardness One Damage type such as slashing, bludgeon, peirce in addition to it's AC bonus equal to hardness. On any hit make the damage be divided by half between the armor and the character.
Natural Armor does not provide Damage reduction as it is a part of the creature and Damage against it is damage against the creature.
Make weapons do flat damage based on their dice to give the player a decent chance and to speed up combat.
Make some effects such as wounding or Keen mundane enhancements that can be added fairly easily but leave the keen not to stack with the Magical effect or the Improved Critical Feat.

5: Level Adjustments: Annoying and pointless on the most part any creature with a lvl Adjustment should either be upgraded to have Hit Dice equal to the adjustment and suffer penalties on interactions with other races. Commoner lvls are a possible substitution for such lvl adjustment replacements.
If not possible or just too unbalanced then it should simply be unacceptable or have some serious drawback but a loss of levels seems absurd especially if it comes into play mid game.
Also the benifits of a lvl adj creature, if not immediately worthless are slowly but surly made worthless for the character vs the loss of his BAB, Skill Points, Spells, Saving Throws, ect. ect. that Hit Dice or Class Levels would bring.
A 4th lvl Fighter with decent stats vs a 4 Hit Die Ogre with no real adjustments are fairly even in most regards.

6: Prestige Classes: I dislike most of them very much and others I do not see why a player could not just lengthen it to start as said class in a 20 lvl progression.
In some cases I have combined the progression in a regular class to make a new 20 lvl progression. I will list these later depending upon play test success.

These are just some of the things I am planning to try in an adventure I plan to run as an experiment. I plan to let the characters use the varients presented here and will give listings of the success of these changes as I come across them. Someone else in the group is currently running however so this may appear in a new thread but I do plan to list them.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 8:33 pm
by alhoon
Well, in defence of the 3.5:

Wizards should be more powerful in higher levels because they are weaker in low levels. Also most great warriors weren't a match against most great wizards.
However To have as many great wizards as great warriors is antithematical.
IMO a 9th level wizard with his/her creations should pawn a party with a 9th level fighter and his/her minions. However getting 9th level should be harder for wizards than warriors.
How many 26 year old archmages have you seen in literature compared to 76 year old archmages?
Setting the XP for next level for wizards to 1250 x level and fighters to 750 x level should be fine. Why we have a single XP column after all?

Multiclass Fighter/wizard? 8th level fighter: "I want to take my next level as a wizard" answer "OK instead of 6000 XP you need 10000 XP."
NOTE: I agree that wizard/fighter combos aren't as good. Insert Eldrich knight. Problem solved.

Skills: Mostly I twink "class" skills according with background. I.e You're not a cleric of pelor but of the god of lies? Bluff becomes class skill, religion goes out.
Fighter and having served 4 years as a spotter for an army? Spot becomes class skill. Nothing is taken out.
Somehow I thought most people do that. :)

Feats: Toughness: 1hp/level instead of 3 hp and it becomes nice. Not a must but nice.
Skill focus: For diplomacy, this is a broken feat! For ... profession (cobbler) I don't think that more than 20 of the 4 million or so active players of D&D have taken that. Ever.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 8:54 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Wizards should be more powerful in higher levels because they are weaker in low levels. Also most great warriors weren't a match against most great wizards.
However To have as many great wizards as great warriors is antithematical.
IMO a 9th level wizard with his/her creations should pawn a party with a 9th level fighter and his/her minions. However getting 9th level should be harder for wizards than warriors.
How many 26 year old archmages have you seen in literature compared to 76 year old archmages?
Setting the XP for next level for wizards to 1250 x level and fighters to 750 x level should be fine. Why we have a single XP column after all?
That's very... second edition of you.
Works in theory but hurts the group when the spellcaster is a level or two behind everyone else because he's essentially taking a 25% xp hit.

There's not many young archmages, that's true. But mostly because wizards are stereotyped as old with beards and essentially Merlin/Gandalf rip-offs. Wizards work just as well as young characters (John Constantine, Harry Dresden) and most modern "magicians" (Houdini, David Copperfield, David Blaine) are equally young.

That's another good example of a problem with 3.X, low-level spellcasters.
alhoon wrote:Multiclass Fighter/wizard? 8th level fighter: "I want to take my next level as a wizard" answer "OK instead of 6000 XP you need 10000 XP."
NOTE: I agree that wizard/fighter combos aren't as good. Insert Eldrich knight. Problem solved.
Except you still have a huge armour check penalty.
And have fewer hp than a cleric.

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2008 9:08 pm
by Charney
Mage do progress more slowly in XP in a way because they use it to create items.