Page 1 of 2
4th edition and WoW likeness.
Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2008 10:04 pm
by alhoon
From all we have seen, do you believe that 4th edition is a rip-off WoW? Have they taken a few good ideas?
IMO they took some ideas. I don't blame them. WoW adresses a large part of the people they want to adress to and yes, Warcraft had some good ideas.
I'm not as afraid about the system turning to computer-like tabletop game. A system is just a system. I'm happy that battles will be faster paced because then I could focus more in the story. And I'm also happy that there will be a solid system for not-fighting XP awards.
On the other hand: I haven't played WoW for long to know but when I mention something new about 4th edition to my friends they start laughing since they have played WoW for 100s of days.
Latest incident the "second wind" I was asked: "Do chars also get angry when they heal?"
Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2008 10:14 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
How about adding a "No clue, dude: I don't know diddly about WoW anyway" option for that poll?

Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2008 10:59 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
Great idea, al.
I voted "3".

Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 1:24 am
by alhoon
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:How about adding a "No clue, dude: I don't know diddly about WoW anyway" option for that poll?

Well WoW warriors heal with an ability called "second wind"

Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 5:01 am
by Le Noir Faineant
alhoon wrote:Rotipher of the FoS wrote:How about adding a "No clue, dude: I don't know diddly about WoW anyway" option for that poll?

Well WoW warriors heal with an ability called "second wind"

My college humor is just about to burst out again ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff.


Seriously, I had always thought that the appeal from WoW came from the designers cutting out all the stuff that was unvoluntarily funny.

Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 7:57 am
by HuManBing
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:How about adding a "No clue, dude: I don't know diddly about WoW anyway" option for that poll?

Seconded.
In fact add a sixth option saying "I am clueless both to WoW and to 4E", and I'll vote for that with great confidence.
Back on topic [edit: who am I kidding? Not on topic at all!], you know they made an adult movie (possibly more than one actually) based on World of Warcraft. The title even rhymed. So by your rationale, we should be able to look forward to adult movies made from 4E soon.
...
This may not be a good thing.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 8:16 am
by Le Noir Faineant
Oh, already done in form of an explicitely erotic novel for 3e.
Nothing in fantasy, of any kind will ever disturb and shatter me
like the mental image of Elminster and Mystra getting it on.

Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 1:58 pm
by Paladyn
To me, 4th edition is MMorG on 'different engine'. It is computer game for situations, where no PC is available. I don't know, if it is good, or bad. There are some things I like, and there are some things i don't like. Classes' roles scared me, well for me priest s god servant not, "controller". It is almost like saying: "Play in that way, walk this way". Its not RPG is about. But on the other hand, thera are some things I like (for example all those rumbling on tests' challenges, if I remeber wording correctly). I voted third option.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 2:12 pm
by Lord Soth
I don't see the problem with roles, myself. They're nothing new to the game. It's just now that they're being codified. Check this out.
Ray Winninger's Dungeoncraft #1
Think of the ideal AD&D adventuring party-you need at least a couple of Fighters to engage monsters and protect the weaker adventurers in combat, a cleric to cast healing spells, a thief to deal with tricks and traps, and a wizard or two to decipher magical clues and provide an extra punch in important battles. If any of these key roles aren't filled, the players are bound to run into trouble; many AD&D supplements were designed under the assumption that all these skills would be available to the players' party.
Roles have always been part of the game. They just haven't been explicitly pointed out as such until now.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 2:15 pm
by Pamela
I know nothing about WoW apart from what I saw on the Mr T and Bill Shatner commercials.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:07 am
by A G Thing
To be honest I am just too paranoid and biased at the time to give a fair judgement on this.
I see WoW as impersonal but it can be a very satisfying experience. On the other side of this coin however I know that D&D has players from many stripes that could be vastly different then my group or style and I cannot say if this is bad because perhaps I will like the new system or perhaps not.
Just too soon for me to label, but when it comes out I can most definitely render a verdict on the poll.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:29 am
by alhoon
Hey,

Anyone that feels he doesn't know enough to vote doesn't have to vote yet.
About Class roles: They were always there. The cleric was assumed to be the healer in all previous editions. The fighter was assumed to be the tank and the wizard the nuker/utility-man. After the game become more about story, the bard became the Leader of shorts dealing with social situations and boosting others in battle.
What's new there?
In 4th edition it will be different. The Fighter can deal with the right built almost as much damage as the wizard. The Cleric isn't mandatory in a party. Or the cleric can decide to become a damage dealer instead of a healer, or invest in buffing others. The rogue can do the utility work or deal damage.
I wait for their social combat system and then we will see who will be the leader, but I guess every char will.
So no, it's the other way around IMO.
A party with 4 fighters is viable
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:43 am
by Lord Soth
The Cleric isn't mandatory in a party. Or the cleric can decide to become a damage dealer instead of a healer, or invest in buffing others.
Or hey, you can do both. Healing Word, after all, is a Minor Action. So you can cast that and still attack. Or use Sacred Flame to attack and give an ally some temporary hit points.
I played Erais, the DDXP pregen Cleric, a couple weeks ago and it was a ton of fun. I usually despise playing Clerics, but this time I rather enjoyed it. It was great, as I got to mix it up in combat, and could heal any party members who needed it without having to let up. To bad there were no undead, as I would've liked to have tried out Turn Undead.
Posted: Sat Apr 26, 2008 11:10 am
by Jester of the FoS
The big list of supposed WoWifications:
1) All classes fit a hard combat role
Big in MMO games. It’s been played up in recent years, but mostly by the players and not by the game itself. “Tank” and “DPS” and “healer” were thrown about on message boards and in-game chats before developers/designers started using them. This is because it’s a team balance that works.
Even second edition knew this and divided the classes into “warriors” or “rogues” and encouraged one of each four in every party. The 3.0 and 3.5 DMG says that the game is based/balanced around a basic fighter/wizard/cleric/rogue party.
It pre-dates WoW and most MMORPGs and the inclusion of the roles are more for new players. A guideline around building a party for new people.
2) Wizards have unlimited spells
Mages don’t have unlimited spells in Warcraft. They have a mana limit and can probably only fire off 4-8 spells before they run dry and need to recharge. A 2e or 3e 10th level wizard can do more in a single fight than a WoW caster.
This is often brought-up for a couple reasons.
The biggest is the “nova” mages, the resource management of 1-3e where you have to limit the number of spells you use, or you’ll have nothing left for the next fight. The idea being that it’s removing an element from play, dumb-ing down the game.
But this still applies in 4e as you only have so many daily powers and using them all at once leaves you weakened for future fights.
Then there is the problem of a lesser number of spells that go up in level. Fewer spells, and wizards/clerics no longer have an arsenal of abilities compared to other classes.
I think this has less to do with WoW (where spellcasters still end up with more abilities and more specialized powers) and more to do with high level spellcasters being a burden with dozens of spells, sometimes even hundreds.
3) Fighters have ‘spells’ or abilities
The weakest one. I really don’t see how giving everyone something interesting to do in combat can possibly be a bad idea. Or tied back to WoW as other games have been doing this for ages.
4) Healing is fast, resting is quick
WoW was a bit revolutionary in this. Prior to it resting in MMOs was long and tedious without a cleric. Lots of downtime doing nothing both in-game and in the real world.
I think D&D took a page from this. Without a cleric it takes a really, really long time to heal between fights at high levels. A 10th level fighter would have a good 84 hitpoints and, healing 2x his level a night, would take 5 days to be fully healed. That’s a loooong time mid-dungeon or mid-story where things grind to a halt.
I think this is just two games thinking the same thing.
5) Defenders can mark, essentially a taunt to hold “agro”
I’ve seen a lot of anger on message boards about this.
MMOs use agro and hate and taunting for a good reason: to control who the AI chooses to attack.
The problem in D&D combat is always choosing who to attack. How does the fighter do their job and keep the monster from savaging the wizard? How does the DM not use their strategy and tactics when playing an Int 3 monster? How does a DM not seem like he’s picking on someone when he’s just using sound tactics.
Really, any monster with half a brain (Int 8+) knows to go after the guy casting spells. Focus on a single target and wear them down until they stop moving.
Of course, taunting has been in D&D and PnP RPGs for years. There’s been feats for taunt in 3.5 and 3.0, so it’s not really something new.
Posted: Sat Apr 26, 2008 12:04 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Jester of the FoS wrote:“Tank” and “DPS” and “healer” were thrown about on message boards and in-game chats before developers/designers started using them. This is because it’s a team balance that works.
Even second edition knew this and divided the classes into “warriors” or “rogues” and encouraged one of each four in every party.
FWIW, "tank" in particular predates MMOs. Role-players were using that term back in the days of original Zork, mostly in reference to superhero-RPG characters whose signature ability was muscle-power. As for the "healer" designation, old-time 1E gamers routinely referred to the cleric (or occasionally the druid) by crying "
Medic!".
Of course, taunting has been in D&D and PnP RPGs for years. There’s been feats for taunt in 3.5 and 3.0, so it’s not really something new.
Heck, taunting foes to control whom they'd attack was a racial ability for kender, back in the original Dragonlance modules. Old-school concept from the 1E era, again.