Page 1 of 1

3rd edition treasure system

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 12:13 pm
by alhoon
Yes, I know I'm about 9 years late, but it's the lamest thing I have ever seen in the DMG. I'm glad I didn't look at the tables until today.
I really haven't ever read or heard or participated in a game that anyone was using it thank goodness.

Reasons: There can only be one type of coins in a single hoard. That's right. You can't have copper, silver and gold coins in the same hoard. :shock: You can't have gems and art objects in the same hoard.

Examples:
- You can kill a young adult dragon and gain nothing or just a hoard of copper pieces for your trouble. Now, how would carry around 200000 copper pieces that cost about 2000 gp? They weight 4000lbs. That's a cartfull of copper for defeating a dragon. It's a scene from a comedy really! After defeating the dragon that terrorized the local towns and villages the heroes find a cavern full of... copper. What kind of dragon collects only copper pieces?

- You can kill a juveline young adult dragon and find... a nine lives stealer. Or a +3 holy, undead bane mace. :shock: Yes, right at 7th level.

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 12:32 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Well, dragons and the like have double or triple standard so you roll twice or three times and can end up with multiple coins.

3e does have some flaws. They spent 18 months updating the game from 2e and then less than a year to move between 3.0 and 3.5; they focused on the BIG problems such as class, magic, monsters, etc. They added skills and feats and new classes and such.

But some things were only given a once-over. They never sat down and crunched the numbers for combat.

4e is shaping up to be the first real new edition where they looked at everything as they would designing a game from scratch. Where they didn't just throw something together based on an older version and say "good enough".

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 12:37 pm
by steveflam
As a DM it is always nice to have the DMG standard treasure system but I just use my common sense and go by what level the party is, the monsters are etc and make the treasure according to the p.c's., not the monster, and that without going overboard ;)

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 12:56 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:Well, dragons and the like have double or triple standard so you roll twice or three times and can end up with multiple coins.
No. You triple the amount rolled, you don't roll again. :) I.e 2d6x10000 cp becomes 2d6x30000 cp for dragons.

And they spent 4 years to go from 3 to 3.5

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 4:59 pm
by Jester of the FoS
From the SRD:
Standard

Refer to the treasure tables and roll d% once for each type of treasure (Coins, Goods, Items) on the Level section of the table that corresponds to the creature’s Challenge Rating (for groups of creatures, use the Encounter Level for the encounter instead). Some creatures have double, triple, or even quadruple standard treasure; in these cases, roll for each type of treasure two, three, or four times.
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/treasure.htm

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 5:00 pm
by Jester of the FoS
(I can never be bothered to look in the book anymore and go straight to the hyperlink SRD. I even have a quick-search thing at the top-right1 of my browser. )

Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 8:27 pm
by alhoon
Thanks Jester. I apologize. As I said, I checked the random system today... less than a month from 4th edition. :)

Posted: Sat May 17, 2008 7:17 am
by HuManBing
The only rational solution is to wet your pants, wipe it on the windows, and then run hooting and gibbering through the hallowed halls of Congress with your hands in the air like a lunatic.

Or use a different game system.

Or, indeed, do both.

Posted: Sat May 17, 2008 7:47 am
by Chris
There are different Rules to create Hoards in the Magic Item Compendium. I haven´t read ist so I can´t confirm it. But my brother who is DMing most of our Realms Groups likes it.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 12:08 am
by norms29
Jester of the FoS wrote:4e is shaping up to be the first real new edition where they looked at everything as they would designing a game from scratch. Where they didn't just throw something together based on an older version and say "good enough".
you sincerely believe that?

I don't know wether to laugh or cry.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 12:30 am
by alhoon
Personaly I do believe that. I don't think the 4th edition is the best thing to happen to D&D ever but they really seem to have put real effort this time around.
Perhaps the result will not be to our tastes. However I have to admit that they put a lot of work and they heard the community and what it was asking. I have to admit that as a person I disagree with most of the gaming community.
I would prefer less flashy moves and more realism. But that's me. I admit that most of the D&D community wanted more action-game like rules.

As for the work that has been done just look at the playtests. They had hundreds of playtesters for more than half a year. They even had the D&D experience so that thousands of people could playtest and say their opinion.

Personaly I will probably change to 4th edition and house-rule some more realism.
Others (and I know a few) will keep to 3rd edition for at least some time. remember: 3rd edition is complete.

To expand your character concepts:
- There are books for all the standard PC races.
- There are books for all the standard PC classes and expansions on those books (complete arcane and complete mage for example).
- There are books for the good and evil alignments.

To help you make adventures:
- There are 5 monster manuals.
- There are books about most if not all the enviroments.
- There is the manual of the planes and the planar handbook for high levels
- There exist a good and solid epic rules book for higher levels
- There exist the Deities and Demigods with rules on how to become a God for extremely high power...

As for easy reference:
- There is a book that compiles more than a 1000 spells
- There is a book that compiles many feats.

And then there are tons of books that add options/flavor:
- Draconomicon, Fiedix Codex I, II and Lords of Madness.
- Tome of nine swords, magic of inca-whatever, etc
- Stronghold's builder guide

Really if you want to keep in 3rd edition there are more books than you'd ever need.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 7:51 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
norms29 wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:4e is shaping up to be the first real new edition where they looked at everything as they would designing a game from scratch. Where they didn't just throw something together based on an older version and say "good enough".
you sincerely believe that?

I don't know wether to laugh or cry.
Jester and others have provided factual basis for their beliefs. Would you like to do the same?