Page 1 of 2

Possible Origin of the Vehrteig

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 8:29 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
When I first read about the Vehrteig from DT&DL, I was disappointed that Steve Miller had apparently created the vehrteig strictly as the plot engine for "The Curse of Ashington Manor." I was even more disappointed that said creature's origins were left undeveloped beyond the hints of their ambiguous relationship with the Vistani, a relationship that seemed engineered as a "deus ex" device to explain the vehrteig's immunity to Rozaleen's Vistani powers. Finally, I was disappointed to find yet another creature that supposed "feeds" on evil and fear and whatnot, which is so often a lazy-brained explanation for an otherwise inexplicable tendency to find and attack adventurers.

Steve, if you're reading this, I believe I owe you an apology.

I don't know what made me reconsider the vehrteig, but when glancing over DT&DL recently, I gathered the following details together:

--the vehrteig are all female, and have no apparent means of reproduction. On the contrary, their unique...attack mode...actually prevents them from reproducing.

--the vehrteig are never seen as children, nor do they age.

--the vehrteig are not fey, which separates them from all other "all female" creatures I know of.

--the vehrteig are utterly immune to the worst the Vistani can throw at them.

--the vehrteig seek out evil and feed on it, BUT rather than cultivate it, they bring it to a head, force a conflict and cause it to dissapate.

--the vehrteig's origins are known to a few Vistani elders, but they refuse to speak of it.

With all this in mind, I realized the origin for the vehrteig IMC: they are the living embodiment of a horrible Vistani curse. This curse was so powerful that it created creatures whole cloth out of the Mist to enact its vengeance over all time. The vehrteig seek out sinkholes of evil to renew the energies that created them, but their nature binds them to destroy active sinkholes and move on in search of others.

Any thoughts?

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 9:25 am
by cure
I like the sinkhole angle.

While there is indeed irony in a Vistani curse backfiring upon the Vistani, it is precisely the sort of irony that Vistani are typically immune to, at least the females. When they curse someone they foresee what for others would be unintended consequences and hence craft their curses so as not to fall foul of them.

When things go wrong for the Vistani it is one of their own who goes 'bad', either a Darkling whose actions can still be foreseen however or a Dukkar who can unravel the very fabric of Ravenloft and seemingly the Vistani with it. Add fiendishness to the equation and you have something to which the Vistani are additionally blind.

The real problem with defining a non-Vistani nemesis for the Vistani is the undefined nature of the Vistani. Are the Vistani the blessed and beloved of the Mists? If so, such a creature is probably not a creation of the Mists. Are the Vistani merely the most insightful in respect to the Mists, in which case the creature could well be a creation of the Mists and even a expression of the disamusement of the Mists with Vistani insightfulness.

The solidest, and most worked, ground would be some Vistana or Vistani who were commiting some monstrous crime and who were cursed or otherwise changed into a new and different form that was indeed a danger to the Vistani but a lesser evil and a lesser threat.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 11:09 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
This is a little screwy, but ... we know that Vistani will go to extremes to eliminate potential Dukkars, right? And, doomsday prophecies aside, a Dukkar and a vehrteig have several qualities in common (not detected by Vistani seers, immunity to evil eye, compelled to foment bloodshed and to harrass Vistani). And we also know that, by definition, Dukkars are always male, while vehrteig are always female ... and the Vistani know that, too.

So what if, soon after the doomsday-prophecy of the Dukkar was made, the various raunies of the Vistani suffered a difference of opinion on how to deal with it? Some of them might've gone against the prevailing view that all male infants whose futures couldn't be predicted had to be killed ... and tried to foil the prophecy in a different way, by magically changing such newborns into females? (We know that sex-reversal magic is possible, or at least it was in 2E; heck, one of the D&D trading cards has a sex-change-belted NPC visiting Ravenloft.) If the child isn't male, such minority-opinion raunies could've argued, then it can't be a Dukkar, after all. Naturally, those seers whose own sons or grandsons prove immune to divination would favor this view, early on.

Unfortunately, the destiny of any born Dukkar is to make fellow-Vistani miserable, regardless of what sex that Dukkar becomes after birth. No longer male, the sex-changed infants could never grow up to fulfill the true end-of-the-world prophecy, yet their latent Dukkar powers weren't really destroyed: they turned in upon themselves, gradually turning the "girls" into vehrteig. Unable to rend Ravenloft apart, they instead develop an affinity for areas where the malignity of its fabric is strongest; stymied in their destinies to ravage the Vistani, they evolve a lethal form of Evil Eye and a killing kiss in compensation. Because the prophecy was made very early in Ravenloft history, before the other tasques had emerged, the vehrteig are all Manusa-tasque by birth, and possess the corresponding traits of time-travel and agelessness by way of inheritance.

Once a few transformed Dukkars had grown to womanhood, and turned on their own people, of course, the raunies who'd changed them realized they'd made a terrible mistake, and from that point on, all males born immune to prophecy were targeted for death, not sex-reversal. But those vehrteig which had already been created still posed a threat, and (thanks to their Manusa independence from time) yet continue to do so.

Naturally, the raunies are too embarassed about their screw-up to admit that the vehrteig are their fault. So those few who date back far enough to know what happened have hidden the truth from the majority of Vistani, leaving their descendents to speculate in vain about the origin of the vehrteig.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 3:22 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Wow, Roti, I really like that one... nice! I think that's just the thing to add in to my anti-Dukkar thread in my campaign.

I agree that the parallels between Dukkars and Vehrteig are too big to ignore. DS, even if you don't go with the sex changing idea, I definitely think you should try to link it to Dukkars somehow.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 4:09 pm
by Steve Miller
Good ideas all.

I was all ready to defend my creation, but then, Deep Shadow, you listed most of the points I was going to raise in the defense.

Instead, I'll just mention two things:

First, in my own use of the Verhteig (which has involved one traveling with a party of PCs for an extended period of time, with the PCs being totally aware of what she/it was--and one PC constantly trying to convince her that she was not an instrument of righteous vengeance as she viewed herself, and another PC taking the POV that the Verhteig's actions had a "certain kind of dark justice to them" and at one point letting her take a day or two to turn a slaver compound into a slaughter house while the party got most of the slaves to safety) predates the idea to use them in "Dark Tales" and in the "Ashington Manor" adventure.

Secondly, I have used two different origins for the creature in my personal campaigns (in case anyone cares).

The first has them sponteneously come into existence in places where great evil and horror has taken place. Nazi concentration camps, mass execution sites, terrorists executing innocent victims or doing suidice bombings, drowning of babies... even the wanton slaughter of animals if done maliciously can "give birth" to a Vehrteig. They are noncorporeal for a while, but they eventually solidify and become a sort of "angel of vengeance" that destroys evil but which also creates evil because of the nature of their "birth."

The other origin was that they are the children/creation of a god of death and vengeance. They were living happily in with their "father" who would occassionally dispatch some of them to destroy people, towns, or nations that enough someones were praying to see destroyed. Their happy existence came to an end when some Vistani/adventurers infiltrated their land, stole an artifact, and greatly weakened their father. Their home melted away as he grew weaker, and no more Vehrteig can now ever come into existence... unless they find a way to bring back their father's vitality and their land. The Vehrteig have been hunting for the artifact and Vistani in general ever since, even persuing them into the Ravenloft plane.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 7:33 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
cure wrote:While there is indeed irony in a Vistani curse backfiring upon the Vistani, it is precisely the sort of irony that Vistani are typically immune to, at least the females. When they curse someone they foresee what for others would be unintended consequences and hence craft their curses so as not to fall foul of them.
I have no problem with this. I was figuring the curse would probably involve a Dukkar or at least a fellow Vistani, hence the blind spot. Still, is there a source on this? Do we know that Vistani can and do use their sight to avoid unintended consequnces?
Add fiendishness to the equation and you have something to which the Vistani are additionally blind.
Wow, I'm learning all kinds of new things here! Fiends are a blind spot for Vistani? Really?
The solidest, and most worked, ground would be some Vistana or Vistani who were commiting some monstrous crime and who were cursed or otherwise changed into a new and different form that was indeed a danger to the Vistani but a lesser evil and a lesser threat.
I don't know if I will go into all the specifics IMC, but here are some variations on that general theme:

--The vehrteig are the result of a curse on an early Dukkar. He has since gone the way of all the earth, perhaps with their help, but the vehrteig remain as a warning against rash curses.

--The vehrteig are the result of a curse on ALL Dukkars. Someone was unfortunate enough to encounter more than one over a lifetime, and cursed the entire phenomenon.

--The vehrteig were created by a Dukkar. An earlier Dukkar issued a dying curse against the Vistani, and the vehrteig were the result.

--The vehrteig were created by all the proto-Dukkars, murdered as children. The combined psychic scream of murdered infants created their revenge, tinged with femininity as a protest against their mother-murderers.

--The vehrteig were the accidental offspring of a Dukkar-prophesied bloodline. A Vistani foretold that one of her many progeny would bear a Dukkar, so she cursed her bloodline to bear only female children. *Note that this contradicts the detail about no vehrteig children.*

--The vehrteig were created to destroy one or more Darklings. Someone among the Vistani thought that the vishnadd was not enough, and issued out a horrible curse to see vengeance done. Perhaps against the Tribe of Hyskosa?

Anyways, just some thoughts. I'm still letting my ideas gel.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 7:39 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Some of them might've gone against the prevailing view that all male infants whose futures couldn't be predicted had to be killed ... and tried to foil the prophecy in a different way, by magically changing such newborns into females?
Very interesting. Wouldn't they have additional Vistani powers?
Unfortunately, the destiny of any born Dukkar is to make fellow-Vistani miserable, regardless of what sex that Dukkar becomes after birth. No longer male, the sex-changed infants could never grow up to fulfill the true end-of-the-world prophecy, yet their latent Dukkar powers weren't really destroyed: they turned in upon themselves, gradually turning the "girls" into vehrteig. Unable to rend Ravenloft apart, they instead develop an affinity for areas where the malignity of its fabric is strongest; stymied in their destinies to ravage the Vistani, they evolve a lethal form of Evil Eye and a killing kiss in compensation. Because the prophecy was made very early in Ravenloft history, before the other tasques had emerged, the vehrteig are all Manusa-tasque by birth, and possess the corresponding traits of time-travel and agelessness by way of inheritance.
All quite plausible, but then what happened to their Sight?

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 7:47 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Steve Miller wrote:First, in my own use of the Verhteig predates the idea to use them in "Dark Tales" and in the "Ashington Manor" adventure.
I'm quite happy to be wrong about that. Maybe it was just because they had you follow Harold "Vomits Random Ideas" Johnson that I felt like the vehrteig came straight out of left field. Mea Culpa.
Secondly, I have used two different origins for the creature in my personal campaigns (in case anyone cares).
Very interesting! With the first idea, wouldn't that make them fey, like the bogeymen? Why would this make them tied to the Vistani?

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 12:43 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
DeepShadow wrote:Very interesting. Wouldn't they have additional Vistani powers?
Most likely, their habit of lingering in one place to savor their evildoings' consequences would've caused the vehrteig to lose their ancestral Vistani abilities to static burn, ages ago. The possibility would still exist for PCs to meet one who did retain her hereditary powers -- Sight included -- if the DM wants an even more dangerous vehrteig, however.

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 6:53 am
by The Giamarga
Could they be somehow tied to Allisandro Tselikov, the first Darkling and creator of the spell Allisandro's Binding Curse ?

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 8:35 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
The Giamarga wrote:Could they be somehow tied to Allisandro Tselikov, the first Darkling and creator of the spell Allisandro's Binding Curse ?
Funny, I was actually mulling the idea of using Allisandro in this. I think I'll make it official that he was involved, though I'm still not sure how. Maybe he invoked a curse on all Vistani because of his unprecedented punishment. Maybe someone else cursed him because they thought the Vishnadd was too good for him. I'll mull it over some more.

BTW, would/could Allisandro be a Dukkar as well, what with his spellcasting powers?

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 11:44 am
by Joël of the FoS
Considering the hate at first sight between them and vistani, that vehrteigs are linked to vistani, and perhaps dukkars too, makes a lot of sense.

Joël

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 1:56 pm
by The Giamarga
Not sure about the dukkar status, but i pegged him as a Necromancer13/MasterOfCurses*5. So maybe you can work that prestige classes special ability Willing Sacrifice, with which he takes another´s curse upon himself. In this process the curse is magnified by one step in any case and possibly rebounds on the victim if any of the two fails his save.

(* from Champions of Darkness)

Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 3:52 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
DeepShadow wrote:BTW, would/could Allisandro be a Dukkar as well, what with his spellcasting powers?
A conventional spellcaster doesn't seem to make the cut for Dukkar. A Vistani male has to be a seer, with inborn prescience, not merely someone who's learned a few Divination-school spells. The Canjar, for instance, supposedly all practice magic, yet other tribes don't seem obligated to exterminate their males. Even the use of Vistani tracking-senses or Mist-navigation don't appear to qualify, if the guidelines in VRGttVistani are to be trusted: if the Vistana can't actually see the future, he's okay.

None of that, of course, would disqualify Allisandro from being a potential Dukkar. OTOH, the fact that the other Vistani banished him, rather than killed him outright, suggests he wasn't one ... unless the raunie who condemned him to the shalach-ti was deceived or corrupt.

Posted: Mon May 26, 2008 10:17 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Nitpick alert: in the vehrteig description, it gives the chief distinction between a vehrteig and a succubus as the vehrteig doesn't encourage evil. Skip down a little, and it says that she encourages evildoers to greater and greater acts of depravity before driving them to self-destruction.