Alven Crown (Magic Item help)
Posted: Fri May 23, 2008 10:21 am
Gaz V gives stats for the Signet of the Arak, a ring that is part of the Regalia of Arak, and currently is used as a crown by the Queen of the Alven. I tried to make a toned-down version for my Alven-blooded PC to be gifted with by the Alven. I figure that the Alven crafted some crowns for their lesser royalty, inspired by the Queen's crown, but weaker. So here was my first attempt:
Alven Crown
This ring grants the wearer a +1 luck bonus to AC, Skills, and Saves
1/day, the wearer can cast one of the following spells as a Drd10: Wood Shape, Shillelagh
My best guess at a cost based on the 3.5 guidelines would be 23,800gp.
I know she won't sell it, but I try to keep my PC's wealth-by-level close to the DMG guidelines.
(the original Signet had a +2 bonus, 5 different spells, 3/day, as Drd15, plus a bonus to interacting with plants)
But then I discovered that the PC's Fey Friend PrC already grants her a luck bonus to saves, which makes the pricey +1 luck bonus to Saves redundant. So I have three options that I see:
1) Be a stickler for RAW, and just leave it alone.
2) Keep the ring as is, but reduce the assessed gp value when deciding what treasure to give her in the future
3) Add a comparably priced ability in place of the +1 to saves.
I think I'd like to go with #3, but I'm stumped for ideas. The player suggested a charisma bonus, but I think that's a bit too good, and also the fey are already high-CHA creatures, so it seems a bit out of character to me for them them to rely on magic items for more CHA.
Any thoughts?
Alven Crown
This ring grants the wearer a +1 luck bonus to AC, Skills, and Saves
1/day, the wearer can cast one of the following spells as a Drd10: Wood Shape, Shillelagh
My best guess at a cost based on the 3.5 guidelines would be 23,800gp.
I know she won't sell it, but I try to keep my PC's wealth-by-level close to the DMG guidelines.
(the original Signet had a +2 bonus, 5 different spells, 3/day, as Drd15, plus a bonus to interacting with plants)
But then I discovered that the PC's Fey Friend PrC already grants her a luck bonus to saves, which makes the pricey +1 luck bonus to Saves redundant. So I have three options that I see:
1) Be a stickler for RAW, and just leave it alone.
2) Keep the ring as is, but reduce the assessed gp value when deciding what treasure to give her in the future
3) Add a comparably priced ability in place of the +1 to saves.
I think I'd like to go with #3, but I'm stumped for ideas. The player suggested a charisma bonus, but I think that's a bit too good, and also the fey are already high-CHA creatures, so it seems a bit out of character to me for them them to rely on magic items for more CHA.
Any thoughts?