4th Edition Review
Posted: Wed May 28, 2008 2:32 am
Got crazy-lucky today and got to spend a few hours with early copies of the Core books.
Enough to even make a decent review and do some comparing.
Okay, first off I’ll warn that I was not impressed, so this will likely come off as a negative.
Despite my being the devil’s advocate on the boards (and as a result pro-4e) I’ve been a little jaded over the speed of the new edition and some of the changes. Mostly the seeming money grab. Now I’m not anti-money and know businesses need to keep making money, but I believe the surest way to this is quality products that scream out to be bought. I’ve been a little worries that the books would be limited to encourage future supplements and more purchases.
Unfortunately, at this time, I feel this fear has been justified.
The PHB is a decent sized book comparable in size to the current 3.5 book. Like the current a good chunk is spells, only, unlike previous editions, this time they’re not tucked in an alphabetized appendix at the end.
The book has a length section on the main rules as well as a fairly solid introduction to game play and being a good player. A very, very nice start for new players and a good introduction to the game: advice on table etiquette and the like.
The powers are strictly combat. As we’ve seen the descriptions are keyword orientated to be succinct and very limited. They’re pretty much limited to offense and don’t lend themselves to creative solutions or uses; just use the power as intended and don’t try to think. Even the utility powers are kept svelte and combat orientated.
Most powers tend to last for single turns. So multiple-round effects are rare, with the exception being offensive powers that sometimes have save effects (with the save being a randomly determined duration that continues until the save is made).
Rituals are the exception, they’re the out-of-combat spells like raise dead or alarm and vary in level. But, again, they have a very strict purpose. They are interesting as anyone seems to be able to do them (restricted by level) and they’re found in books, so suddenly the idea of rare magic rituals that open evil portals or summon gods or recharge powerful artifacts works in-game. But you need a feat to use rituals and there’s often a (financial) cost associated and the ritual needs to be found/bought so they’re almost optional. They only come into play if someone wants to drop a feat (which are more common, with one gained every couple levels on average).
But I’m mostly disappointed by the amount of content. Classes have a very, very limited number of powers. All the classes have only 4 at-will powers that they can choose their 2-3 from and when they get a new power every couple levels they get to choose from a list of 3-4. So pick your at-will power well, you’ll be using it every other round from level 1 until level 30. Warlocks are the hardest hit as their powers are based on their pact: every single fey warlock will have pretty much the exact same powers.
One of the good ideas behind 4e was that the cool things characters do would be tied to their class, not their items. So characters would be less tied to their equipment. While this is true, the sheer limited number of options still mean characters will be trying to differentiate themselves based on their few variances in feats and items. And there’s no ranks in skills to differentiate between characters. There are feats, but these seem less impressive in general.
Even feats are slim. There are god-based feats (for clerics, maybe one/god), and racial feats (so choice of race matters more from level 1-30) but there’s only three or four feats for every race and a few obvious choices are absent (sorry dragonborn fans, no wings or claws here, even though winged dragonborn pop-up in the MM).
And the much talked-about paragon paths and epic destinies… well, each class gets three or four paths (each given a paragraph or so of flavour text) and there are like four epic destinies in the entire book. FOUR! And one is wizard-specific.
Equipment is equally limited. A few key cannot-miss items and weapons but no alchemical items. There’s really one type of armour per category (cloth, leather, chain, etc) unless you count the uber-magical masterwork armours (which aren’t given much description or rules at all).
Even magical items (moved here from the DMG) are limited. A couple options at each level for armour and weapons but only a single choice for other magical items.
So WotC seems to be saying “here’s the rules. But if you want some real choices buy some other books.
“Want some more options for powers, paths and destinies? Well, buy this.
“Want some alchemical equipment? Or a choice or more than three spears, four maces, one staff, four axes, one pick, two flails, etc? Well then buy this.
“Want more than a two-page description of the planes that is less complete than the free blurbs on the website or in the preview books? Well, buy this.”
But, your say, the book is the same size as the current PHB. Maybe they just had to cut that stuff for space?
True, but they did ADD magic items to this book, something normally found in the DMG. And while the PHBs are comparable, (3e=317, 4e=317) the new DMG is much, much, much smaller (3e=320, 4e=221!). They could have easily, easily moved the 45 pages of magic items to the DMG and added dozens of new powers, weapons and feats. PLUS they could have added more magic items giving us more than 4 potions, 13 wondrous items, 9 rings, etc. But then we wouldn’t need to buy this, would we? (Hell, that book alone is larger than the DMG!! and, curiously, $5 less).
Otherwise the DMG is hard to review. It looked like a decent book for beginners with guides to types of players, building adventures, building encounters, etc. And the much vaunted treasure packets? One for each level. Yes, no optional treasure or variants for low/high magic. Just the single option for consistent (and cookie-cutter) treasure. There’s plenty of advice but NO optional rules or variants.
It has some small information on making monsters, mostly how to calculate hp and damage while advising DMs to “eyeball” special powers in the MM to figure out the level of the creature.
And like the PHB, there’s some glaring missing rules. Nothing on creating new magic items or making new powers or weapons or classes. No guidelines or behind-the-curtain looks at how things are balances. Hey, you can’t have people making their own content; then they won’t buy books.
I wish I could say more about the DMG but I spent the least time looking though it and only had so much time with the books. Really, nothing much grabbed my attention.
Finally there’s the MM. As most have seen, there are NO default monsters anymore. It’s more like the mini game (which seems to have been a HUGE influence on 4e, likely moreso than MMORPGs). There’s no longer just goblins, there’s goblin cutters or goblin sharpshooters. So, really, with no baseline you just make variants. You could have a ogre punk-bitch that was a level 1 lurker.
And despite the much vaunted “hard math and consistent numbers” there are some crazy mistakes. As has been pointed out in reviews of Keep on the Shadowfell, there’s some L3 zombie minions that are inferior in every way with L1 goblin minions.
And there’s no quick rules for making up monsters, it’s just as hard as 3e where you need to plan out the level and stats then calculate the AC/attacks based on level and stat bonuses, plus the creation of special abilities which every monster seems to have. So if I want some quick level 1 orc minions to throw at my PCs I’ll need to make them from scratch (yes, or level-down the provided L4 minions, which doesn’t seem as accurate as you reduce stats by -1 for each decrease, but you calculate the numbers based on 1/2 level so they drop in numbers twice as fast).
The table of contents/index is also ass. While the opening does list all the categories of monster (aberration, giant, orc, goblin) there’s no listing of the sub-monsters, so unless you know the creatures already you need to flip to the level index at the end. Which works well if you know what level the creatures are. So if you’re looking for the tarrasque or bugbears you just have to flip about until you find them.
And searching by environment and terrain has also been removed, so if you need that cold-based foe to inhabit your glacier be prepared to flip.
And the monsters are very limited in use. You fight them. Or have skill challenges negotiating with them. While I agree that monsters shouldn’t have out-of-combat powers cluttering up their stat-blocks there’s no sub-powers or unique rituals for most monsters (liches have a phylactery creation one, and vampires have a vamp-lord creation one). So no devil pacts or efreet wishes.
And, as people were worried about, sunlight apparently does NOT hurt vampires. And they can no longer be staked (because a stake-to-the-heart makes a lousy in-combat move and they’ll be darned if killing something happens without combat).
Most striking is the list of absent monsters. While the book contains a good 300+ monsters, with 15 or so per level except 28, 29, and 30 (you’re okay with alternating between Ancient Red Dragons and tarrasques after level 29, right?) at 288 pages (3e=319) it’s also rather small. They could have easily, easily bumped it to 300 pages and added another 12-30 monsters.
Everyone is familiar with how they bumped frost giants for this book, and metallic dragons. But what other monsters are missing. Well, I scanned my 3e MM and didn’t recall seeing 4e: dinosaurs (except ankylosaurus), metallic dragons, frost giant, Clay golems, Iron golems, Grey render, invisible stalker, lycanthropes (other than werewolf and wererat), merefolk, mohrg, nymph, rust monster, sea elves, shadows, specters, sprites (pixies, nixies, etc), and most common animals (lions, tigers, elephants, dire badgers, cat, dog, rhino, etc) although they did have bats, bears, boars, wolves, etc.
And the new, shiny archons were limited to fire and ice leaving out water, air, and earth.
And they have a tonn of new monsters that have ‘graduated’ from the MM 3, 4 and 5 or other books and, while often neat, I can’t imagine adding them into my games. And many seem like generic badass creatures meant to look 'cool' or 'fantastic' but would look outright silly if taken out of context.
It really feels like the MM is the worst offender of the “buy more books” syndrome. I can easily picture the MM2 with it’s mix of 1/3rd new monsters, 1/3rd updated monster (some unused classics and some from 3e MMs), and 1/3rd new versions of monsters. I can’t wait to see new gnolls in the MM2, the four in the MM1 just aren’t enough and only go from L5-8…
While I’m sure monsters will be some of the more frequently added creatures, 4e isn’t off to a good start. Keep on the Shadowfall apparently uses monsters right out of the MM (adding new monsters would have been a great reason to encourage people to buy the book, even after they bought the core books and didn’t need the quick-start rules and PCs).
And the D&D Mini starts (which have complete game stats on their back) seem to be crazy inaccurate and even the latest set don’t match the rules from the Core books (compare the vampire lord card to the rules in the vampire excerpt). While I’m sure they’ll update the cards with errata they don’t seem to be in any rush.
There’s also the growing problem of piracy. I really feel WotC should (and likely does) take into consideration the growing trend of book copying. With torrents and pdfs it has never been easier.
Now, 3e books were easily pirated but the good books were still must-buy. If you found a class or item or spell you liked you had to print out a page or two and couldn’t count on your memory to remember the details. And referencing laptops (or PDAs or iPod touches) was never as speedy as having the book.
Now, with powers designed to fit on an index card, piracy has become simple. Even if you have a couple powers and items from a book you can fit that information and ALL the relevant rules onto a small page.
And with the Core books all but requiring additional products, I think more people are going to be driven online just to play the game. And once a book is illegally pirated it’s not going to be bought.
Enough to even make a decent review and do some comparing.
Okay, first off I’ll warn that I was not impressed, so this will likely come off as a negative.
Despite my being the devil’s advocate on the boards (and as a result pro-4e) I’ve been a little jaded over the speed of the new edition and some of the changes. Mostly the seeming money grab. Now I’m not anti-money and know businesses need to keep making money, but I believe the surest way to this is quality products that scream out to be bought. I’ve been a little worries that the books would be limited to encourage future supplements and more purchases.
Unfortunately, at this time, I feel this fear has been justified.
The PHB is a decent sized book comparable in size to the current 3.5 book. Like the current a good chunk is spells, only, unlike previous editions, this time they’re not tucked in an alphabetized appendix at the end.
The book has a length section on the main rules as well as a fairly solid introduction to game play and being a good player. A very, very nice start for new players and a good introduction to the game: advice on table etiquette and the like.
The powers are strictly combat. As we’ve seen the descriptions are keyword orientated to be succinct and very limited. They’re pretty much limited to offense and don’t lend themselves to creative solutions or uses; just use the power as intended and don’t try to think. Even the utility powers are kept svelte and combat orientated.
Most powers tend to last for single turns. So multiple-round effects are rare, with the exception being offensive powers that sometimes have save effects (with the save being a randomly determined duration that continues until the save is made).
Rituals are the exception, they’re the out-of-combat spells like raise dead or alarm and vary in level. But, again, they have a very strict purpose. They are interesting as anyone seems to be able to do them (restricted by level) and they’re found in books, so suddenly the idea of rare magic rituals that open evil portals or summon gods or recharge powerful artifacts works in-game. But you need a feat to use rituals and there’s often a (financial) cost associated and the ritual needs to be found/bought so they’re almost optional. They only come into play if someone wants to drop a feat (which are more common, with one gained every couple levels on average).
But I’m mostly disappointed by the amount of content. Classes have a very, very limited number of powers. All the classes have only 4 at-will powers that they can choose their 2-3 from and when they get a new power every couple levels they get to choose from a list of 3-4. So pick your at-will power well, you’ll be using it every other round from level 1 until level 30. Warlocks are the hardest hit as their powers are based on their pact: every single fey warlock will have pretty much the exact same powers.
One of the good ideas behind 4e was that the cool things characters do would be tied to their class, not their items. So characters would be less tied to their equipment. While this is true, the sheer limited number of options still mean characters will be trying to differentiate themselves based on their few variances in feats and items. And there’s no ranks in skills to differentiate between characters. There are feats, but these seem less impressive in general.
Even feats are slim. There are god-based feats (for clerics, maybe one/god), and racial feats (so choice of race matters more from level 1-30) but there’s only three or four feats for every race and a few obvious choices are absent (sorry dragonborn fans, no wings or claws here, even though winged dragonborn pop-up in the MM).
And the much talked-about paragon paths and epic destinies… well, each class gets three or four paths (each given a paragraph or so of flavour text) and there are like four epic destinies in the entire book. FOUR! And one is wizard-specific.
Equipment is equally limited. A few key cannot-miss items and weapons but no alchemical items. There’s really one type of armour per category (cloth, leather, chain, etc) unless you count the uber-magical masterwork armours (which aren’t given much description or rules at all).
Even magical items (moved here from the DMG) are limited. A couple options at each level for armour and weapons but only a single choice for other magical items.
So WotC seems to be saying “here’s the rules. But if you want some real choices buy some other books.
“Want some more options for powers, paths and destinies? Well, buy this.
“Want some alchemical equipment? Or a choice or more than three spears, four maces, one staff, four axes, one pick, two flails, etc? Well then buy this.
“Want more than a two-page description of the planes that is less complete than the free blurbs on the website or in the preview books? Well, buy this.”
But, your say, the book is the same size as the current PHB. Maybe they just had to cut that stuff for space?
True, but they did ADD magic items to this book, something normally found in the DMG. And while the PHBs are comparable, (3e=317, 4e=317) the new DMG is much, much, much smaller (3e=320, 4e=221!). They could have easily, easily moved the 45 pages of magic items to the DMG and added dozens of new powers, weapons and feats. PLUS they could have added more magic items giving us more than 4 potions, 13 wondrous items, 9 rings, etc. But then we wouldn’t need to buy this, would we? (Hell, that book alone is larger than the DMG!! and, curiously, $5 less).
Otherwise the DMG is hard to review. It looked like a decent book for beginners with guides to types of players, building adventures, building encounters, etc. And the much vaunted treasure packets? One for each level. Yes, no optional treasure or variants for low/high magic. Just the single option for consistent (and cookie-cutter) treasure. There’s plenty of advice but NO optional rules or variants.
It has some small information on making monsters, mostly how to calculate hp and damage while advising DMs to “eyeball” special powers in the MM to figure out the level of the creature.
And like the PHB, there’s some glaring missing rules. Nothing on creating new magic items or making new powers or weapons or classes. No guidelines or behind-the-curtain looks at how things are balances. Hey, you can’t have people making their own content; then they won’t buy books.
I wish I could say more about the DMG but I spent the least time looking though it and only had so much time with the books. Really, nothing much grabbed my attention.
Finally there’s the MM. As most have seen, there are NO default monsters anymore. It’s more like the mini game (which seems to have been a HUGE influence on 4e, likely moreso than MMORPGs). There’s no longer just goblins, there’s goblin cutters or goblin sharpshooters. So, really, with no baseline you just make variants. You could have a ogre punk-bitch that was a level 1 lurker.
And despite the much vaunted “hard math and consistent numbers” there are some crazy mistakes. As has been pointed out in reviews of Keep on the Shadowfell, there’s some L3 zombie minions that are inferior in every way with L1 goblin minions.
And there’s no quick rules for making up monsters, it’s just as hard as 3e where you need to plan out the level and stats then calculate the AC/attacks based on level and stat bonuses, plus the creation of special abilities which every monster seems to have. So if I want some quick level 1 orc minions to throw at my PCs I’ll need to make them from scratch (yes, or level-down the provided L4 minions, which doesn’t seem as accurate as you reduce stats by -1 for each decrease, but you calculate the numbers based on 1/2 level so they drop in numbers twice as fast).
The table of contents/index is also ass. While the opening does list all the categories of monster (aberration, giant, orc, goblin) there’s no listing of the sub-monsters, so unless you know the creatures already you need to flip to the level index at the end. Which works well if you know what level the creatures are. So if you’re looking for the tarrasque or bugbears you just have to flip about until you find them.
And searching by environment and terrain has also been removed, so if you need that cold-based foe to inhabit your glacier be prepared to flip.
And the monsters are very limited in use. You fight them. Or have skill challenges negotiating with them. While I agree that monsters shouldn’t have out-of-combat powers cluttering up their stat-blocks there’s no sub-powers or unique rituals for most monsters (liches have a phylactery creation one, and vampires have a vamp-lord creation one). So no devil pacts or efreet wishes.
And, as people were worried about, sunlight apparently does NOT hurt vampires. And they can no longer be staked (because a stake-to-the-heart makes a lousy in-combat move and they’ll be darned if killing something happens without combat).
Most striking is the list of absent monsters. While the book contains a good 300+ monsters, with 15 or so per level except 28, 29, and 30 (you’re okay with alternating between Ancient Red Dragons and tarrasques after level 29, right?) at 288 pages (3e=319) it’s also rather small. They could have easily, easily bumped it to 300 pages and added another 12-30 monsters.
Everyone is familiar with how they bumped frost giants for this book, and metallic dragons. But what other monsters are missing. Well, I scanned my 3e MM and didn’t recall seeing 4e: dinosaurs (except ankylosaurus), metallic dragons, frost giant, Clay golems, Iron golems, Grey render, invisible stalker, lycanthropes (other than werewolf and wererat), merefolk, mohrg, nymph, rust monster, sea elves, shadows, specters, sprites (pixies, nixies, etc), and most common animals (lions, tigers, elephants, dire badgers, cat, dog, rhino, etc) although they did have bats, bears, boars, wolves, etc.
And the new, shiny archons were limited to fire and ice leaving out water, air, and earth.
And they have a tonn of new monsters that have ‘graduated’ from the MM 3, 4 and 5 or other books and, while often neat, I can’t imagine adding them into my games. And many seem like generic badass creatures meant to look 'cool' or 'fantastic' but would look outright silly if taken out of context.
It really feels like the MM is the worst offender of the “buy more books” syndrome. I can easily picture the MM2 with it’s mix of 1/3rd new monsters, 1/3rd updated monster (some unused classics and some from 3e MMs), and 1/3rd new versions of monsters. I can’t wait to see new gnolls in the MM2, the four in the MM1 just aren’t enough and only go from L5-8…
While I’m sure monsters will be some of the more frequently added creatures, 4e isn’t off to a good start. Keep on the Shadowfall apparently uses monsters right out of the MM (adding new monsters would have been a great reason to encourage people to buy the book, even after they bought the core books and didn’t need the quick-start rules and PCs).
And the D&D Mini starts (which have complete game stats on their back) seem to be crazy inaccurate and even the latest set don’t match the rules from the Core books (compare the vampire lord card to the rules in the vampire excerpt). While I’m sure they’ll update the cards with errata they don’t seem to be in any rush.
There’s also the growing problem of piracy. I really feel WotC should (and likely does) take into consideration the growing trend of book copying. With torrents and pdfs it has never been easier.
Now, 3e books were easily pirated but the good books were still must-buy. If you found a class or item or spell you liked you had to print out a page or two and couldn’t count on your memory to remember the details. And referencing laptops (or PDAs or iPod touches) was never as speedy as having the book.
Now, with powers designed to fit on an index card, piracy has become simple. Even if you have a couple powers and items from a book you can fit that information and ALL the relevant rules onto a small page.
And with the Core books all but requiring additional products, I think more people are going to be driven online just to play the game. And once a book is illegally pirated it’s not going to be bought.