Just to help this discussion along...
I, the DM, of our little group will give some insight about the creation of my campaign.
I have designed this campaign this way because I have small health problems which prevent me from spending a lot of time at the computer or writing (shoulder problem amongst other things).
SO, I can't really do a ''real'' RL campaign myself.
What I am trying to do is have some behind-the-scenes stuff happenning while using already made adventures.
In all the years I've played, I have quite a few adventures I bought, but have not ever played any of the Dungeon (RIP) adv.
So I am trying to make them more RL. Probably failing miserably at times

.
But we are having fun.
It's a little bit less introspective and somewhat more roll-playing than role for a ''real'' RL game, but what the hey!
I am also changing a LOT of RL lore, because Joël and Tarlyn know this stuff inside out...
More later on...
Patrick