Page 1 of 1

Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Sat Jun 07, 2008 9:19 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
I'm preparing to start a PBEM game that will run alongside my Kara's Daughters game. Here's what I have so far on the topic:
Kara's Daughters are brokers for tiny bits of information, so this mini-game is to capture the feel of being information brokers. It's kinda like rummy, but it's played with secrets instead of cards. There will be prizes in-game and out-of-game, including XP and favors for your character.

Each of you will start with a "hand" of secrets that you know about the world and each other. I will email each of you your starting hand, and you can perform TWO of the following actions in your reply email to me:

* Find a new secret. Gather Information check, DC 20; extra info for succeeding by 5 or 10.

* Follow up on an existing secret. Each secret will have its own skill check for finding out more. You will get a small amount of XP and/or monetary rewards for following up on secrets.

* Claim a secret that has been reported by another (see below). Bluff, Diplomacy, Intimidate; opposed check with previous player. This prevents the secret from moving into the common pool of knowledge and adds it to your hand.

* Offer to purchase a secret from a player using a favor. Favors allow someone else to direct ONE attack or skill check with your character during the game. One blow in combat, one lock picked, one fireball dodged, etc.

* Use a spell to replace one other action on this list. You perform any of the other actions that require a roll, but you automatically succeed. If your spell is especially appropriate, you succeed by a greater margin, if applicable. If the spell is especially inappropriate, it fails (you can't ferret secrets with enchanted weapon). This spell slot is empty the next time your character enters play.

* Add +20 to any other action on this list. You will only get that one action, but it will yield better results.

In the same email, you MUST report (discard) one of your secrets to the group. Unless someone claims a secret the next round, these secrets make their way up the chain of reporting to Kara and become part of the group's pool of secrets.

There are several ways to gain an advantage in this game. First, awards will go each round to the people who report the most useful secrets, based upon the current needs of Kara's Daughters. Second, people who have built up their secrets by investigating and handling things before turning them over will be better rewarded. If you handle a project personally from beginning to end, you'll have an appropriate reward in-game. Finally, collecting a pile of secrets to report will allow you to bury your own personal secrets at the bottom. Awards will be given to people who keep their personal secrets out of the group pool.

There are also several ways to get yourself in trouble in this game. Reporting a secret you haven't researched can damage your reputation if it turns out to be a red herring or false alarm. Sitting on a secret too long can earn you a reprimand for not reporting to those who are better suited to handle it. A low stock of secrets will force you to report things you'd prefer to handle yourself, or even personal secrets that could endanger you. If something like this comes up, you or another PC can immediately lay claim to it next round to save it from becoming well-known, but it will attract some interest all the same.

For your rolls, use the dice roller at invisiblecastle.com and put "Kara's Daughters" into the Campaign field.
What do you think? Any suggestions?

Re: Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 5:36 am
by Le Noir Faineant
DeepShadow wrote:What do you think?
...That I want to participate because you're a hell of a DM, DS! :)

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 6:34 am
by steveflam
I'd like to play too!

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 7:42 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Well, I have thought of opening this mini game up to the web community, to have some fun and give my players a more organic "rumor mill" but I'd like to refine it first. Anyone have any thoughts on the rules from above?

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 4:55 am
by lostboy
Sounds interesting. It'll need to be playtested a while to iron out any kinks but I suppose the key thing is that it should be an even playing field for any character in your game.

Few comments below:
Use a spell to replace one other action on this list.
I think this may give a power bias to any spell user, unless they are very low level it seems an incredible bonus for the sacrifice of one spell slot.

The biggest problem I can see is that it's a little bit nebulous right now. For a succesful board game (as thats in effect what youre creating) you need clearer rules, predefined victory conditions and specific rewards. I understand this is an offshoot of a D&D game, but why would I want to play if I when I turn in the most well worked on folio of secrest and seemingly win, the DM can arbitrarily tell me they are all red herrings? It has too feel to the players that all have a chance of winning or gaining something by their own actions, not just at the DM's whim.

I think the base game mechanics are sound, but you need to look at how people win/lose or gain/lose advantage and firm them up.

It might be worth checking out the board game designers forum, they have plenty of discussions on game mechanics, power balance that kind of thing, for all types of game, includsing card games. You can find them at http://www.bgdf.com

Hope that helps

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 11:44 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
lostboy wrote:Sounds interesting. It'll need to be playtested a while to iron out any kinks but I suppose the key thing is that it should be an even playing field for any character in your game.

Few comments below:
Use a spell to replace one other action on this list.
I think this may give a power bias to any spell user, unless they are very low level it seems an incredible bonus for the sacrifice of one spell slot.
You really think so? They are 6th level, so I was thinking mostly 1st level spells that replicate or enhance a particular skill--charm for diplomacy, scare for intimidate, etc. If they don't have an appropriate spell, they have to do it the old fashioned way. OTOH using spells willy-nilly between games will mean none to cast during play.
The biggest problem I can see is that it's a little bit nebulous right now. For a succesful board game (as thats in effect what youre creating) you need clearer rules, predefined victory conditions and specific rewards. I understand this is an offshoot of a D&D game, but why would I want to play if I when I turn in the most well worked on folio of secrest and seemingly win, the DM can arbitrarily tell me they are all red herrings?
Huh? That's contradictory. "Well worked" secrets cannot be red herrings, because you would have found that out when you were developing them. Red herrings are the result of lazily turning a secret over to the group without digging a little deeper.
It has too feel to the players that all have a chance of winning or gaining something by their own actions, not just at the DM's whim.
I know what you mean, but bear in mind there are three ways to gain an advantage listed, only one of which could be influenced by the DM's whim.
I think the base game mechanics are sound, but you need to look at how people win/lose or gain/lose advantage and firm them up.
Okay, will do. Perhaps the rules need to be clearer.
It might be worth checking out the board game designers forum, they have plenty of discussions on game mechanics, power balance that kind of thing, for all types of game, includsing card games. You can find them at http://www.bgdf.com
Wow, thanks!

Re: Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 10:47 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
DeepShadow wrote: * Offer to purchase a secret from a player using a favor. Favors allow someone else to direct ONE attack or skill check with your character during the game. One blow in combat, one lock picked, one fireball dodged, etc.
I don't quite understand this one. What do you mean by "direct"? Like if I offer Rafael a favor, and he accepts, he has to give me a secret. Then the next time we play, if we're in the middle of a fight with some zombies, Rafael gets to say: "come over here and hit the zombie next to me!" and I'd have to do so?

What about offers to trade secrets one for one? Or to offer bribes of GP for secrets?

Re: Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:52 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
gonzoron wrote:I don't quite understand this one. What do you mean by "direct"? Like if I offer Rafael a favor, and he accepts, he has to give me a secret. Then the next time we play, if we're in the middle of a fight with some zombies, Rafael gets to say: "come over here and hit the zombie next to me!" and I'd have to do so?
That's the basic idea. You'd want to make sure it wasn't a stupid move, like exposing the helping PC to a load of AoO in your example, but the general idea is that they help you out of a jam.

* You make a bad save against a fireball, the PC next to you makes a Tumble check to save your skin and says, "we're even."

* PC stops briefly to help you clobber a foe in combat before proceeding to her preferred foe.

* You botch a Diplomacy check at a social engagement, and the PC covers for you with a Bluff.

It shouldn't be anything that puts the other PC in mortal peril...but if you're both already in mortal peril, then that's fair game.
What about offers to trade secrets one for one? Or to offer bribes of GP for secrets?
You're right, I should offer both of these options, too. I'll have to develop a rough ranking system for how developed a lead is. It'll mostly depend on how many skill rolls have been used on it already.

Re: Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 4:27 am
by Le Noir Faineant
gonzoron wrote:Like if I offer Rafael a favor, and he accepts, he has to give me a secret. Then the next time we play, if we're in the middle of a fight with some zombies, Rafael gets to say: "come over here and hit the zombie next to me!" and I'd have to do so?
:shock: If we were attacked by zombies, you would let me fight them all alone?!

Re: Secrets Game IMC

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 9:04 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rafael wrote:
gonzoron wrote:Like if I offer Rafael a favor, and he accepts, he has to give me a secret. Then the next time we play, if we're in the middle of a fight with some zombies, Rafael gets to say: "come over here and hit the zombie next to me!" and I'd have to do so?
:shock: If we were attacked by zombies, you would let me fight them all alone?!
No, don't worry, I've got your back. :) That's exactly what I'm getting at. I'd have no problem getting a zombie off your tail, but I'd probably do that anyway, so it seems like this particular "favor" is either:

1) Way overpowered, if your party are made up of cutthroat backstabbers, who would try to force each other to soak up damage for them.

or

2) Way underpowered, if your party is a normal one that helps each other out anyway.

If it's just a compulsion effect to do what a good teammate would do anyway, why would I ever accept a favor for my precious secret?

Now this example is a bit better:
* You make a bad save against a fireball, the PC next to you makes a Tumble check to save your skin and says, "we're even."
In this case, it's going above and beyond what a buddy would do, because in the rules as written, he couldn't do that. So to write it up more formally, I'd say something like:
A favor entitles the favor-receiver to a "reroll" when something bad happens due to a bad d20 roll, but instead of simply rolling again, the favor-giver makes the roll, using either the same type of roll or a similar, appropriate one.

So in the zombie case, maybe if we're near the same zombie, and you attack and miss, I can shove the zombie back onto your sword with an extra attack roll of my own.

Alternatively, you might also let the favor-receiver borrow the favor-giver's AC for one attack that would hit the favor-receiver, but not the favor-giver. (i.e., I see the zombie about to slam Rafael and reach out and block for him.)

Posted: Wed Jul 23, 2008 1:59 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Thanks for all your help, it's working great! I'm tweaking the rules according to your ideas here, but I still don't have a good way to handle trading favors. OTOT, the players are loving it and have come up with a few things themselves: they tell each other when another player might want to bury a secret they are reporting, and deliberately fail their opposed check so that the secret is buried quickly.

Also, I've decided that red herrings are perfectly viable discards; it's fine to say that you investigated something and it turned out to be nothing. This is one way that red herrings can actually be a good thing. Also, whenever a rumor is pursued to its conclusion, one of the benefits is that the player gets a free rumor without making another roll.

I'm also working on a pattern for the investigation. Most rumors start out with Gather Info/Knowledge to find a specific person who can authenticate the rumor, then a round or two of Bluff, Diplomacy, or Intimidate to work with that person.