Page 1 of 2

3rd or 4th edition?

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 10:22 pm
by alhoon
After a discussion with some of my players I decided:

I won't switch to 4th edition yet. I'll steal some things, but I won't change yet. Many of the things I like in 4th edition can be incorporated in the 3rd and many of the things I like in 3rd can't be incorporated in the 4th.

Will I play 4th if I have the chance? Sure! It's a nice game! I'll definetely subscribe to D&Dinsider to play 4th! But so far everyone I know and I can play with prefers a 4thified 3rd edition.

Things I'll steal:

Starting HP for heroes: PCs and important NPCs will start with 2 more HD+con modifier.

Death rule: I'll use the death rule from 4th edition. I.e you die if you fall under 1/3rd of your HP and each round you roll 1d20 to see if you stabilize.

Defences:Saves will turn to defences.

Coins: I'll use the astral diamond as coinage

Minions: I'll include them. Each minion will count as 1/6th of a monster of the same CR. I.e 5 CR down.

Simplified monsters: I'll use more interesting and fewer powers in the monsters I make or the ones I use already.

Monster variety: Yeap, orc skirmishers and bersekers etc being more powerful sounds good.

Healing surges: Yeap, I'll include healing surges. Each char will have 3 healing surges usable once per encounter or at intervals. Each healing surge heals 1/4th of the char's HP.

Class abilities:For warrior types I'll use the book of nine swords along with some stolen powers from the fighter/ranger lists. For spellcasters I'll use the reserve feats as class features so that they will have at will powers.

Spells & rituals: I'll use spell points for battle spells and some spells will become rituals so they won't take as much space from the PCs.
It also helps to not having them able to teleport on the fly but having to pay for it.

Rogue talents: I'll steal a few powers of the rogue and make them class features for the rogue.

Skill challenges: Definetely in! XP? As if the PCs defeated a monster of CR equal to the challenge's level/5 x complexity. I.e complexity 5 skill challenge will give as much XP as a CR of equal level.

Diplomacy: You can forget the DC 25 and an unfriendly creature turns friendly. It will be a skill challenge!

Posted: Sun Aug 17, 2008 1:33 pm
by Daisu
Know how long it took me to figure where the extra hitpoints came from, and ended up being the con score +class HD+con mod :p
Anyways I am going to switch to 4th edition, I never liked 3rd edition. Did 3 days of straight gaming last week. There is still alot of problems that propped up when dealing with saves, friendly fire and conditions. And still stuff not entirely sure of yet.
I ran a dungeon crawl then short adventure then did a ravenloftesqe short adventure.
I converted 4 homebrewed horrific monsters as well since not much for their level to deal with.

Posted: Sun Aug 17, 2008 10:56 pm
by Archedius
Alhoon- I'm curious: Why are you using a standardized coinage from 4th ed? Is it easier than GP, SP and CP?/

Posted: Sun Aug 17, 2008 10:59 pm
by JinnTolser
I'm sticking with 3rd edition. A short list of what I like about 4th edition looks like this:




I still think a new edition of D&D was not necessary except to sell more books, and from leafing through the 4e core books I'm not the least bit impressed. I never needed another edition, so I'm perfectly happy to stick with what I've got.

Posted: Sun Aug 17, 2008 11:26 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Archedius wrote:Alhoon- I'm curious: Why are you using a standardized coinage from 4th ed? Is it easier than GP, SP and CP?/
I suspect he means he'll be using them in addition to regular coins, not in place of them. (Although diamonds might be easier to handle with one's facial tentacles than flat metal disks, I suppose... :wink: )

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 1:29 am
by alhoon
Rotipher of the FoS wrote: I suspect he means he'll be using them in addition to regular coins, not in place of them. (Although diamonds might be easier to handle with one's facial tentacles than flat metal disks, I suppose... :wink: )
I use the astral diamond as extra as recognised planar currency for high levels. You know, when the quasi deity tells "Go, finish off this war on X plane and I'll reward you with XX astral diamond pieces". That way the characters and the PCs have a clearer image of the reward's value than with "I'll give you a box of diamonds"

And Roti, I use mage hand or thralls. :wink:

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 6:11 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
I'm not switching to 4th Ed. I looked at the books and wasn't impressed. Frankly, I'm suprised the DMG didn't recommend having giant, floating, ethereal, golden ?'s hanging above the NPCs who will give out the plot.

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 7:19 am
by impworks
Frankly, I'm suprised the DMG didn't recommend having giant, floating, ethereal, golden ?'s hanging above the NPCs who will give out the plot.
Now that would make for an interesting rewrite of some of the Ravenloft modules. Especially the ones where the quest chain ends with a golden ! hovering over a darklords heads who just stands their waiting grinning in the knowledge they don't have to do any work anymore because pray just keeps coming to keep the blood banks full ;-)

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 9:22 am
by Sorti
Drinnik Shoehorn wrote: Frankly, I'm suprised the DMG didn't recommend having giant, floating, ethereal, golden ?'s hanging above the NPCs who will give out the plot.
Drinnik, this were Words of Ultimate Genius. :lol: :lol: :lol:

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 10:38 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
I'll be sticking with 3.5 for a while. Maybe in 2 yrs, I go 4th ed, but not at the moment.

So will the Ancient Dead.

October 31, 2008.

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 11:50 am
by Ornum
I'm sticking to 3.5 for the duration of my gaming days, as far as I can tell. While I liked some of the ideas for 4e as they were initially presented, I don't like the majority of the rules when you look at the finished product. For me, 4e just isn't a good enough system for me to just throw out 3rd (and more importantly, the money that I have spent on that system to date).

Sure, I might throw in some of the ideas into my games. For instance, while I absolutely hate the name, Healing Surges will see an inclusion under a different guise. It'll be a feat called something like "Inner Resolve" that will allow a character to push past fatigue and the pain of their injuries to continue fighting one per day. The feat can be taken mulitple times for an additional per day usage. The difference? When they use the ability, they gain 25% of their total HPs back as temporary HPs that are either used up, or they are lost at the end of the day.

Also, starting HPs will stay the same as they are in 3e, but the negative HP rule will take their Con score into account. So, for example, a character with a Con score of 18 will die at -18, instead of the across the board -10. This will apply to all characters, from PC's to NPC's and monsters. Anything without a Con score doesn't get the luxury, and dies a 0 HPs.

At will spells? Well, the reserve feat idea was a part of 3e first, so I'm already giving players the ability to go that route as it is, so I'm not really including anything new.

I pretty much already award XP for successful skill uses (in certain circumstances, at least), but the award is pretty arbitrary and I could probably use a more straightforward system.

There might be one or two more ideas that I could possibly use in my games, but we'd just have to see. Also, Paizo may end up being the route I go (as it currently costs me nothing), though I haven't look at the current version (or any version, for that matter).

Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 8:20 am
by Jakob
Moving on to Pathfinder RPG, here. I don't think 4ed is the best system to tell the stories I want to tell. :)

Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 9:43 am
by Jester of the FoS
Pathfinder did just go Beta

Posted: Fri Aug 22, 2008 1:48 am
by hidajiremi
You're a lot better off with Pathfinder than with 4th Edition. I still haven't managed to get the stink off from being one of the official playtesters. >_<

Joking aside, Pathfinder is wonderful. I have begun to think in the last several months, however, that any iteration of the d20 rules doesn't do Ravenloft justice. The setting is intended to be much closer to the low end of the power scale, and a place in which mobs with torches and pitchforks are dangerous at all levels of play, and that's simply not the case in normal d20.

I've had a lot of success in converting the setting over to Savage Worlds and New World of Darkness, and I think that they both work better for Ravenloft than d20 ever did.

Jeremy Puckett

Posted: Fri Aug 22, 2008 2:14 am
by Jakob
hida_jiremi wrote:Joking aside, Pathfinder is wonderful. I have begun to think in the last several months, however, that any iteration of the d20 rules doesn't do Ravenloft justice. The setting is intended to be much closer to the low end of the power scale, and a place in which mobs with torches and pitchforks are dangerous at all levels of play, and that's simply not the case in normal d20.
I thought so. I think I'll just use the 0-level spells as in 3.5, as opposed to the "at-will" of Pathfinder when I play in Ravenloft.
Pathfinder did just go Beta
Downloaded the Beta as soon as it was published. I think I'll receive the print edition around the 31st of August. Damned Italian post service. :)