Page 1 of 1

4th Skill challenges

Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 4:42 pm
by alhoon
I made a table for the Percentage chance of success on skill challenges. I was somewhat disappointed. The chance to fail is very high as the numbers to show.

In the following table: NR is the "number required" in the d20 to gain a success. I.e against DC 18 with a +8 modifier the NR =10
C1 is complexity 1. I.e 4 Successes before 3 failures. C2 is complexity 2 and so forth. The table gives the percentage for success


NR..C1..C2..C3..C4
5....74....80....84....87
6....64....68....72....74
7....53....55....56....59
8....43....43....43....43
9....34....32....30....27
10...26....22....19....17
11...18....15....11.....9
12...13.....9.....6.....4
13....9.....5.....3.....2
14....5.....3.....1.....1
15....3.....1.....0.....0
16....2.....0.....0.....0

For example assume the DCs for the skill challenge is 15 and you need 6 successes before 3 failures. Assuming each character involved has the skill required trained and a +2 ability bonus (for a total of +7) the party has just a 43% to succeed!
It seems obvious WotC assumes that the PCs will help each other all the time giving +4 to +8 bonuses and that they will pool ideas to uprgrade their chances.

In case you incorporate skill challenges (as I will do) take care of this! Make sure good ideas are rewarded with +2 to +4 bonuses and that the PCs know they are supposed to assist each other or they will fail.
And never, never tie important things for your story in a skill challenge assuming the PCs will make it.

On the other hand: So difficult challenges force the PCs think. Tell your players ahead of time that in a challenge they can't just roll the dice and hope for the best. They need strategy. They need good ideas. They need to cooperate. Skill challenges are far more difficult than combat. I don't think that's a bad thing.

In a complexity 3 skill challenge the PCs have to roll a natural 10 to succeed, if the go straight "OK my turn? I use my skill." they have 1/5 to succeed. However if they do a little thinking to get a +2 bonus for good ideas and assist each other a bit getting just another +2 bonus. Their chances to succeed rise to 3/4! ! !

Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 6:13 pm
by Nikolas of the Mists
alhoon wrote:Make sure good ideas are rewarded with +2 to +4 bonuses and that the PCs know they are supposed to assist each other or they will fail.
One thing that I don't like now is that searching (Skill: Perception) now takes forever. It's almost regressed to HeroQuest standards of "I search the square in front of me for traps".

I intend to make the area in some cases much larger so it doesn't require multiple rolls for a simple 20x20 foot area or larger.

NPC: "The entry way into the burrow is somewhere in the cornfield over there"
Players: awesome guys, put on a pot of coffee and let's get the d20s stash out.

I always like to have players be especially particular about their skill rolls, giving me a description to go along with it.

4e, like previous editions, works really well with bonuses the GM can apply depending on what the players specifically mention.

"I search the room"
"I search the room for anything unusual"
"I search the room for traps"
"I search the door for traps"
"I search the doorhandle for traps"
"I search the doorhandle for contact poison"

This example of general to specific makes a huge difference in the game PCs minds are filled with a fertile creativity the best GMs tap into and incorporate, even on the fly.

"I figured the NPC was named "Black Widow" so maybe she had a propensity for utilizing poison to guard her priovate chambers."

I also like to reward PCs skill bonuses for adding interesting bits of flavour to my campaign world.

"I think I saw the people from the last town baiting their fishing poles with bugs like the ones you commonly find under rocks. I wonder if the local fish like them."

Assisting for competency bonuses (Called cooperation in 4e), also needs to have that bit of spice added, so its not just "I forage for food in the jungle using my Nature skill, and these four people help me."

Rewarding players for RP is beneficial for everyone at the table :D
"I'm gonna look for some berries while he sets up deadfall"
And never, never tie important things for your story in a skill challenge assuming the PCs will make it.
Yep, in gaming there's always got to be more than one way to skin the proverbial feline, and even that can't always save you.

I once ran a certain old edition module in which you needed to locate the true entrance to a dungeon after finding a series of dead ends, traps and false ones. The group, because of bad luck and rolls, managed to not even find any of the false entrances over a good 10-15 minutes of rolls, logical deduction and generally gaming. Finally one PC said "That's it, I give up. There was a tavern back at that town wasn't there?" and as he was leaving the area I had to have him quite literally stumble onto it (He fell into a conveniently collapsed underground corridor).