Page 1 of 2
Dread Constructs - A Psychological Look
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 10:05 am
by High Priest Mikhal
Since I don't have VRGtt Created I may touch on issues that were presented in there, but hear me out. The idea of a dread golem becoming evil because of its rejection by, or of, its creator has been done to death. I ask the same question that Mary Shelly presented in Frankenstein: if a creation were to be embraced (not necessarily its creator, but someone) and taught right and wrong, would that creature become "human?" This is disregarding the telepathic link (maybe because the creator died before their creation could sense anything negative).
Also what emotions do dread constructs feel? Besides hate, fear, loathing, and arrogance? How exactly do their minds work compared to a humanoid's? And do they have similar psychological responses to physical stimuli that humanoids do? What if the creature was a living construct and thus "more human" than others?
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 10:44 am
by Jester of the FoS
In this case, they would love their creator until the slowly began to see him as flawed and fallible, as inferior as any living creature. Like when you realize your parents aren't perfect for the first time, mixed with being physically superior.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 1:00 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Jester of the FoS wrote:In this case, they would love their creator until the slowly began to see him as flawed and fallible, as inferior as any living creature. Like when you realize your parents aren't perfect for the first time, mixed with being physically superior.
In essence, a teenager. Any sentient being goes through that sort of phase. I think even a dread golem would learn to accept others as equals if given proper nurturing. Their proclivity towards violence and superiority complexes isn't all nature.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 1:39 pm
by Jester of the FoS
In a real-world setting yes.
But in Ravenloft where the deck is stacked against them with bigotry, fear, superstition and the Dark Powers pushing them to do bad (and likely giving them dark souls)...?
Plus, there's few adventures with well-adjusted, normal golems that are productive members of society and accepted by all.
For dramatic reasons and the all-powerful need of story, all golems go bad.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 2:00 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Jester of the FoS wrote:Plus, there's few adventures with well-adjusted, normal golems that are productive members of society and accepted by all.
For dramatic reasons and the all-powerful need of story, all golems go bad.
Who said they have to be well-adjusted?
That last line I have to disagree with. It's a blanket statement and doesn't always apply. Sometimes the true monster is the creator and not the created.
We also aren't even touching the second part of the OP. I'm looking for a deeper look into the psychology of a construct, beyond the stereotypical "monster-trying-to-be-human." Maybe I should just ask ManOfEvil; it was his story with Adam that got me wondering about this.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 2:18 pm
by Nikolas of the Mists
If you want to take a look at concepts like this, I highly recommend the fluff for some of White Wolf's Promethean. The entire idea behind the game is struggling to become more human.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 3:01 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Well, its partially the superiority. VRGtC really touches on it and has a list of stages.
It starts with innocence and then the creations slowly become jaded, often with their creator. Adolescence is a good name for much of it.
But since golems are essentially immortal, there's also the removal of consequence. They're stronger, tougher and thus not bound by human morals any more than they are with human frailty.
First humans are looked up to, then they are something to be pitied or afraid of. And eventually they are nought more than animals.
Emotionally, there might be some variety.
Some might be muted or dulled emotional, partially stunted without the benefit of prolonged childhood. Others might have intense, passionate emotions like very young children who feel everything 110% but vary rapidly between emotions: they don't just get angry, they have furious tantrums, they don't dislike they hate.
Posted: Sun Jul 13, 2008 3:43 pm
by NeoTiamat
Well, I imagine that certain characteristics will hold true across the alignment spectrum. Golems would probably try to isolate themselves, and in fact that may be the best bet for a well-adjusted golem (one that grows up surrounded by a very limited number of people, all of whom are good and nurturing).
Assuming that the 'non-evil' golem doesn't break and want to kill people, they'll probably quickly realize that the chances of people accepting them are slim-to-none. So depending on how the golem's personality goes, it might decide to become a hermit, living away from people altogether, or it might become a wanderer (more likely if the golem is 'mostly' human-looking and can pass for one with the right clothing/lighting).
A golem might also find that its incredible strength can also be used for certain beneficial pursuits. A golem might take up mining or lumberjacking, and only meets with people periodically.
Of course, you can still have a good adventure if someone is taking advantage of a golem for their own twisted uses. Perhaps a Dementlieuse intelligence agent has found and befriended such a golem, and instilled in it a specific love of liberty and hatred of Falkovnia.
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 10:11 am
by WolfKook
NeoTiamat wrote:...A golem might also find that its incredible strength can also be used for certain beneficial pursuits. A golem might take up mining or lumberjacking, and only meets with people periodically.
Of course, you can still have a good adventure if someone is taking advantage of a golem for their own twisted uses. Perhaps a Dementlieuse intelligence agent has found and befriended such a golem, and instilled in it a specific love of liberty and hatred of Falkovnia.
...or maybe there could be a random factor, like a nearby town becoming aware, and wary, of the strange hermit who lives in the middle of the forest and doesn't want to be bothered by anyone. It would be interesting when daring children start going to the hermit's house looking for trouble...
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 10:43 am
by HuManBing
This thread made me think of the replicants in Blade Runner, which might be able to fit in in Borca, Dementlieu, or Nosos.
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 12:36 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Good ideas, but ones you have to be very careful with, otherwise you run the risk of blatant or even comedic role reversal. Saving the dragon from the evil princess and such.
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 12:44 pm
by Zettaijin
Ravenloft, as per most rulebooks, is a setting where going against "the laws of God/Nature/DP/supreme omnipotent and aloof power" is a sin and punishable by various curses and poisoned gifts.
RL is a microcosm with its own rules and obedience to these rules is not an option, or rather, you may disobey, but at your own risk.
Sin, to make matters worse, almost always entails dire consequences for innocents - if only to rub in the fact that some actions/thoughts are wrong. Why these said actions/thoughts are wrong is never fully explained but meant to be understood by all as "natural" and "in accordance to what decent people believe."
Dread Golems "turn bad" because they are by their very nature an abberation, something that should not be: life created by humans as opposed to a "perfect" (or at least "natural") force (God(s)/Nature/Whatever). Their mental patterns are already rigged to "turn bad" from the onset of their unnatural lives and forced to go along a path that is pre-ordained.
Humans make choices, while monsters are driven by their nature. It's very D&Dish when you come right down to it.
I of course prefer to abstain from running games under this notion, as do many DMs. Yet, much like the "orcs will always be evil because its in their nature" camp found in the various Fantasy RPG community, it has its fans.
Frankly, I find that the idea of a lone golem wandering aimlessly and doing odd jobs to maintain a semblance of humanity isn't all that impossible, improbable or uninterestiing. In fact, faceless, anonymous miners coming in for a spell and then leaving for more lucrative contracts elsewhere was the norm for much of my hometown's history. Some of these men had families to support (which forced them to adopt a nomadic lifestyle), others were loners who'd work because that's all they had in life.
Mind you, we are all assuming flesh golems, the most versatile and easiest to understand out of all golems. How would, say, a glass golem, a sand golem or even a straw golem understand the world around itself? How does it perceive itself? Does it really have a notion of self-awareness similar to what humanoids possess?
Ahmi Vanjuko the mechanical golem and former ranger is an odd case since he falls into the Robotman (see the Doom Patrol comic book, preferably the Grant Morrison run) category, but what about those who never experienced a flesh and blood existence beforehand?
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 8:38 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
My breakdown of the problem:
Problem: psychic connection with a (probably deranged) inventor
Solutions: inventor dies early OR isn't deranged OR is repentant.
Problem: dark soul from DP's
Solution: soul transferred whole cloth from a living subject, like the clay golem from VRGtC.
Problem: rejection as a freak by humankind
Solution: hide deformities
Based on this, I think the best bet for a non-evil golem would be a construct created by a master who dies shortly thereafter, who has the soul of a former mortal, and who doesn't appear to be a monster. Angelique from CotN could qualify if the PC's could keep her from killing herself at the end of the adventure. The self-made golem from the netbooks...Henry, I think his name is?...would be another example of unusual circumstances.
Even without the dark soul provided by the DP's, a fully invented golem is going to have a terrible problem learning empathy for suffering if it cannot feel the pain others feel. A properly moral golem would almost have to be sensitive to normal weapons and damage.
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 8:57 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Way ahead of you on all three points there, DeepShadow. Actually the golem that helped inspire this is a dread flesh golem (with the living construct subtype) created using magic instead of a thread and needle, parts that match, and is otherwise indistinguishable from a normal human. Her creator died mere hours after her "birth," and she's actually inherited the soul of the young lady whose brain was used to complete her (hence her beginning with levels of monk) though she doesn't realize who she is until later.
As a living construct she has no damage reduction, no regeneration like a regular dread flesh golem, and no immunity to magic in general. But also no fear of fire and normal living construct traits. This means she feels pain as well as pleasure and emotions--positive and negative.
Look for her in the rewrite of The Lost Journals Compilation. (not yet released).
Posted: Mon Jul 14, 2008 9:03 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Way ahead of you on all three points there, DeepShadow. Actually the golem that helped inspire this is a dread flesh golem (with the living construct subtype) created using magic instead of a thread and needle, parts that match, and is otherwise indistinguishable from a normal human. Her creator died mere hours after her "birth," and she's actually inherited the soul of the young lady whose brain was used to complete her (hence her beginning with levels of monk) though she doesn't realize who she is until later.
As a living construct she has no damage reduction, no regeneration like a regular dread flesh golem, and no immunity to magic in general. But also no fear of fire and normal living construct traits. This means she feels pain as well as pleasure and emotions--positive and negative.
Look for her in the rewrite of The Lost Journals Compilation. (not yet released).
You say she wasn't created using thread and needle, but she was still cobbled together from several people? How was the magic used to make this superior to a surgical golem?
Sounds a lot like Angelique to me. Have you taken a look at Angelique?