Page 1 of 2
Vlad Drakov's Curse - Application to Defensive Wars?
Posted: Sun Jul 27, 2008 10:12 am
by Lord Cyclohexane
So, we all know that Vlad Drakov seeks to conquer neighboring lands and increase his own land holdings, that this has always been his greatest desire, to become a powerful lord. And we all know that the Drakov's curse is that he is fated to lose any conflict he begins with his neighbors.
BUT... I am seeking clarification on this one singular point: In regards to Drakov being cursed to never again win a battle, does this also include DEFENSIVE battles?
We know Drakov will never be able to take a single inch of his neighbors' lands. But if, say, Dementlieu should press into Falkovnia, will Drakov find that his curse also prevents him from winning any battles on his own territory, as he must cede battleground after battleground to the invading forces?
And similarly, as resistance forces grow within Falkovnia, will Drakov find himself increasingly unable to quell them?
This also applies to my idea of having barbarians in Ravenloft, as I'd love to see Drakov get his ass kicked by someone who is far, far too similar to his younger self, taking land from Falkovnia to create their own homeland, with Drakov being unable to stop them just as the nations of Drakov's old homeworld were unable to stop young Drakov.
ANYWAY... Does Drakov's curse apply only to wars of aggression (preventing him from taking others' lands), or does it also apply to DEFENSIVE battles (affecting his ability to hold on to his own deeply cherished lands)?
Posted: Sun Jul 27, 2008 11:03 am
by Zettaijin
As is, I don't think the idea of anyone brave enough to attack Drakov was ever considered seriously. And even if the political powers of Dementlieu decide to attack and end up winning, they might suffer enough losses to hold their ground for some time.
Myself, I never saw Drakov as a great military mind with regards to defencive tactics: I prefer to imagine him always pressing forward to gather more territory, attacking others before anyone thinks of attacking him. Not the best tactic, to be certain, but for a man surrounded by weaker and somewhat naive military powers, defence might not be as much of an issue (all extrapolation and guess work as we don't know that much of his pre-RL victories and adversaries).
However, the idea of Drakov losing territory bit by bit over time is interesting as it might make him even more desperate, leading to a greater loss of lives.
Considering that Drakov is still mortal (yet long lived), it doesn't matter that Falkovnia might stop existing as we know it.; the conqueror will bite the bullet one way or the other at some point.
The geo-politic ramifications of such an upheaval could be major seeing as how Falkovnia - as a territory - has the potential to be a major economical boon to its would-be conquerors.
Posted: Sun Jul 27, 2008 11:34 am
by ewancummins
I'd love too see a conjunction across the Core. Darklords are unable to close their borders, but they can move about and leave their little prsions, for a time.
Modify Drakov's curse, and take away his DL status [like what happened to Nathan Timothy]. Let him off his leash, but when he leaves Falkovnia with his elite troops, there is a huge rebellion and the kngodm is lost to him. Maybe Gondegal takes over? One of Drakov's sons? Something like that.
Vlad crushes many of his petty foes, but the war grinds to a halt in Darkon, where he cannot overcome the lich king's minions. He escapes with his life from a terrible final battle, taking the best of his troops with him into the Mists.
He'd become a bandit king, wandering the Core with the bloodthirsty remnants of his army, leaving a trail of looted villages and impaled bodies in his wake. An old bitter man, clinging to past glories, free to make war, but robbed by fate of the throne he so desired. In a way, he'd become an evil version of what Gondegal had been, which would be ironic if it is Gondegal who now sits on the throne of Falkovnia.
Posted: Sun Jul 27, 2008 1:04 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Interesting idea, a dispossessed Drakov. Not sure he'd last very long as a bandit, considering how everything from Kargat agents to bitter Falkovnian rebels to Dilisnya assassins would be racing one another for the chance to cut his throat, but he could probably kick up a lot of trouble before they nail him.
Posted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 6:42 pm
by Pale
To me, war has always seemed... too big of a topic for Ravenloft. It's not personal enough for "gothic horror". Now, that's not to say that the horrors of war can't be mined for great riches, but I think that's another story - the consequences of the act, vs the act itself.
I think Zettaijin offers an interesting take on Drakov's tactical sense - and I think to a degree, Drakov is ... doubly cursed - not only can he not conquer his neighbors, but I don't get the sense that the neighbors, even with their defensive alliance, are terribly interested in conquering him. He's only interesting to them when he's an actual threat, and when he's not, he and his country are kind of ... a punchline.... in the salons of Dementileu and Richemulot. I'd almost wager that Drakov has more to worry about from his own lieutenants/Falkfuhrers than his neighbors. I suppose I assume (deadly as it is!) that Drakov's powerbase is stable enough, between his draconian state and its enforcers, and his consuming preparations for war. My assumption is that there's not enough "resistance" to provide an effective foothold for true conquest/upheaval, and an opposing army is always going to think twice before taking him on. Domains of Dread doesn't paint a pleasant picture of Falkovia, but it does clearly state that the towns are fortified. Cursed to failure or not, I doubt Drakov would make it easy on an invading army. He'd be a brutal opponent in terms of morale alone.... I could easily picture him conducting a scorched earth retreat, and leaving his own custom forests to greet any interlopers.
However, note that in Zettaijin's description of his curse, he clearly states that Drakov is doomed to lose any conflict he begins. If Drakov's on the defensive, he's probably in a loophole situation, and can lose or win based on his own ability.
Ewan's dispossessed Drakov is a really neat idea, and I really like how the curse is so neatly inverted - finally able to conduct "conquest" freely, but unable to enjoy or maintain the gains - he can't hold a throne, can't establish a legacy, his dominion only extends as far as his soldiers, there is no rest or security to be had - perhaps Falkovia is also barred to him. Is like having drink just out of reach for years, only to suddenly be flooded with it and discover it cannot satisfy your thirst. Everything you want in the worst possible way.
Ah! I found what I was looking for. I apologize if it's inappropriate to quote as much:
"The dark powers gave [Drakov] what he sought - a position of ultimate leadership - but not what he truly desired: the respect of other rulers and the strength to instill fear and awe in them. His former masters were no longer present to appreciate his position, and Azalin of Darkon was so powerful that he looked down on Drakov just as Drakov's former employers had. The other nearby rulers were women and fops, not the powerful men of war Drakov wanted to be acknowledged by.
....
The strength of the lords in their own domains make such conquests (Drakov's) unrealistic."
Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 12:13 am
by ewancummins
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Interesting idea, a dispossessed Drakov. Not sure he'd last very long as a bandit, considering how everything from Kargat agents to bitter Falkovnian rebels to Dilisnya assassins would be racing one another for the chance to cut his throat, but he could probably kick up a lot of trouble before they nail him.
I don't know that the Kargat would bother. Even when Drakov was a king, he wasn't a real threat to Darkon- just a nuisance.
Of course, he could prove a danger that Azalin might want to remove, if he were operating near Darkon's borders.
Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 12:16 am
by Zettaijin
Drakov is a bit of an anachronism when compared to his neighbours: a man who sees power as something to be gained and held solely through violence. Notions of legitimacy are lost on him while the other rulers understand that sheer violence, even legitimate violence, isn't enough to keep power on a long term basis.
So-called civilized political powers have outgrown warfare. Sure, they still use physical violence - they all have a police force or a militia of some kind to help ensure that laws are obeyed - but they also have a complex social and political system; more advanced means of social control which allows for symbolic violence to overtake traditional physical violence.
At worst, the powerful men and women of the "polite" core probably see Drakov as a wild animal: dangerous but nothing time, technology and superior tactics can't overcome.
Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 1:00 am
by ewancummins
Zettaijin wrote:Drakov is a bit of an anachronism when compared to his neighbours: a man who sees power as something to be gained and held solely through violence. Notions of legitimacy are lost on him while the other rulers understand that sheer violence, even legitimate violence, isn't enough to keep power on a long term basis.
So-called civilized political powers have outgrown warfare. Sure, they still use physical violence - they all have a police force or a militia of some kind to help ensure that laws are obeyed - but they also have a complex social and political system; more advanced means of social control which allows for symbolic violence to overtake traditional physical violence.
At worst, the powerful men and women of the "polite" core probably see Drakov as a wild animal: dangerous but nothing time, technology and superior tactics can't overcome.
I agree.
Ah, but longbows and steel crossbows aren't really inferior weapons compared with most primitive firearms. Such weapons were used for some time after the introduction of the matchlock, after all. It's cannon that are the BIG problem, and there are ways of getting around those. Go someplace the enemy has trouble using his cannon to good effect, of cannot easily transport them. Lower tech level bandits who made good use of terrain [woods, swamps, rugged hills and mountains] could spell serious trouble for the soft, untried militia of lands like Dementlieu and Mordent.
Drakov's men may have lost a lot of battles against zombies and such, but they probably have more fighting experience than any other army in Ravenloft. That means there are more high level dudes in his forces. The Talons are pretty wicked. If even a small corps of men remain loyal and follow their king into exile......

Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 2:07 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
True, the Falkovnian military is formidable, and the Talons are particularly fearsome. It wouldn't be a cakewalk for the Treaty Nations to keep them out, even with advanced weaponry.
Amusingly, the Talons' behavior in the wake of Drakov's ousting might come down to semantics. Just how is the charm-effect that's bound within their bracers
worded, anyway? If it compels them to serve "Vlad Drakov I", they'd presumably keep on obeying him regardless of his status ... but if the old mercenary's ego led him to demand it be phrased "
Kingfuhrer Vlad Drakov I", then the effect may dissipate once he's no longer a king....

Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 2:11 am
by Brandi
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Just how is the charm-effect that's bound within their bracers
worded, anyway? If it compels them to serve "Vlad Drakov I", they'd presumably keep on obeying him regardless of his status ... but if the old mercenary's ego led him to demand it be phrased "
Kingfuhrer Vlad Drakov I", then the effect may dissipate once he's no longer a king....

Or worse, if it simply demands that they serve "der Kingfuhrer" without naming names, whoever took the throne--
and the title-- would have control. (I don't think Gondegal would use that title, but one of Drakov's heirs or bastards might.)
Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 3:32 am
by ewancummins
Brandi wrote:Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Just how is the charm-effect that's bound within their bracers
worded, anyway? If it compels them to serve "Vlad Drakov I", they'd presumably keep on obeying him regardless of his status ... but if the old mercenary's ego led him to demand it be phrased "
Kingfuhrer Vlad Drakov I", then the effect may dissipate once he's no longer a king....

Or worse, if it simply demands that they serve "der Kingfuhrer" without naming names, whoever took the throne--
and the title-- would have control. (I don't think Gondegal would use that title, but one of Drakov's heirs or bastards might.)
Or you may be like me, and think that the title of 'kingfuhrer' sounds so silly that you just ignore it entirely.
I would imagine Vlad had the bracers attuned to his person. After all, he should be smart enough to realize what could happen if they weren't.
Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 5:37 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Even
that could backfire on him, if you're using the doppelganger-takeover Dread Possibility and the bracers aren't smart enough to tell the difference.

Posted: Tue Jul 29, 2008 10:14 am
by Zettaijin
I forgot about the bracers.
My post had more to do with the way he ruled and how Drakov had a very limited understanding of how to rule men and that his Talons might eventually rebel.
But seeing as how I hadn't read up on RL in ages and mostly go by memory, I forgot about the bracers which add a very serious flaw to my ideas.
Still, the point remains that the north western core domains have outgrown simple warfare and are unlikely to attack Falkovnia. Moreover, conquest-happy Drakov has yet to make a single move against Richemulot/Mordent/Dementlieu/Lamordia/Borca while maintaining strong diplomatic ties with Invidia.
So, say Drakov does try an invasion of the above domains, how would he lose? His curse forces him to lose any offencive war, but if Darkon has the dead rising up to defend the land, are we to assume that the considerable wererat population of Richemulot would overcome the Talons? That D'Honnaire and the Brain could break the bracers' charm to impose their own wills? Borcan assassins using poison or their rations become tainted with some foul substance? What about Lamordia then? Freezing weather?
But what if his pal Malocchio offers his aide in a campaign against Borca? Mind you that might give the Dukkar's mom a shot at taking over with the help of the Matton-led wolfweres...
Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 1:38 pm
by Tykus
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Even
that could backfire on him, if you're using the doppelganger-takeover Dread Possibility and the bracers aren't smart enough to tell the difference.


??? Please, refresh my memory.
Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 1:41 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Talon bracers charm the Talons to be permanently loyal to Drakov. If a doppleganger took his form and the Talon bracers made their wearers loyal to said Drakov-dopple, well the real Drakov's SOL.
Zettaijin wrote:But what if his pal Malocchio offers his aide in a campaign against Borca? Mind you that might give the Dukkar's mom a shot at taking over with the help of the Matton-led wolfweres...
Either Ivana Boritsi will seal her borders, or wait until Drakov's men have killed Ivan
and only then seal her borders (which is what I'd do). Malocchio's army would be decimated along with Drakov's either way, and the Dukkar would be overthrown by the rebels. Traditional warfare is a little hard to use when one person can seal the country up like a drum at will.