Great questions! I've been trying to think of things like this, as I want to do a game where everyone starts as Darkonian natives, and so concerns like these are also of interest to me. Here's my thoughts on it (reject if undesirable):
gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #1: Would you be affected sooner if you are younger? (Since there is less to write about) If a family including a 5-year-old kid, some adults, and an 80-year-old grandfather moved in, would the kid go first, then the adults, then the grandfather? Or is the variable time simply due to backlog of stories to write? There's only one quill, and presumably many people entering the land each day. Does it do one whole life at a time or switch between them?
Since there is only one Quill but many stories to write, I'd say that the time variable is due to the backlog of people's stories to write and would be unrelated to the age of the individual. I figure it'd only take a few days to write any particular individual's lifestory (I doubt the Quill would write down detailed notes about "slow time" like eating meals, sleeping, etc that the individual did, so it shouldn't take too long). But, most likely, the Quill won't start writing about that individual until they've been in Darkon for a few months.
But as to whether the 5-year-old's memory would be wiped first? I'd say not. I'd say that a major variable in the "time until mindwipe" would be how many people you enter Darkon with and thus how much correlation needs to be done for false memory creation. I believe that Gaz II mentioned that, when a group of people enters at the same time, their false memories still carry referents to each other so that they remain as one group. As such, I think that none of the people would have their memories wiped first, but rather that they'd all have their minds wiped simultaneously, that it wouldn't be until the Quill had finished writing the lifestory of every member of that group and had linked all of their stories together, it wouldn't be until then that any of them had their minds wiped.
So the 5-year-old's story might have been completely written to the last detail, but the 5-year-old might have still retained his memory while waiting on the others to have their stories finished.
Or, I guess to clarify a bit: I don't think that the person's memories are wiped immediately after the book is written. I think the 5-year-old's book would have every detail in it, as the Quill would have finished the writing during those few weeks that the 5-year-old was in Darkon. However, the 5-year-old's memory would not have been wiped yet.
As to what kind of time difference there would be in writing the 5-year-old's lifestory vs the 80-year-old's life story would, I think, be a couple of days. Say perhaps that it can cover a decade per day?
But whose story would be written first, out of that group of individuals? Perhaps it'd be best to start with the youngest, as (s)he would have the least number of referents to other individuals and so would be the best starting point for creating the web of social interaction for rewriting the group as a whole. Not to mention, family members tend to sacrifice a lot of their own desires to provide a better life for the children, which also includes older children being taught to sacrifice for the younger ones... I dunno.
Anyway, though, the question was whether the 5-year-old's book would have every detail of the kid's life in it after only being in Darkon for a few weeks. I'd say that it is most definitely possible and is quite likely, unless there is a reason that you'd like to have had the Quill cut off mid-word, missing those last few crucial details of the kid's story, so as to add some mystery to your plot.
Anyway, this is my opinion as to what is most palatable, along with way more rambling than is relevant... Take what you will and throw out the rest.
gonzoron wrote:Puzzle #2: Leaving Darkon restores your memories. But if you return, they get re-written again 1d3 months later. Do you get a new book in that case? If so, does it cover only the new info or the whole story? Do you get written in the Book of Names again?
I'd say, as above, that backlog is the biggest variable in the time delay. Since you left and re-entered, you're back at the end of the line and have to wait until the others are finished. After those 1d3 months to work through the backlog, the Quill starts adding the few additional details to your story since leaving and re-entering Darkon and then rewipes your mind.
If you hadn't destroyed your own book, I'd say the Quill just sticks with the previous entry and adds a few notes to the end. Since I'd say each lifestory doesn't take too long to jot down, the 1d3 still makes a good metric as the length of entry isn't a real variable in how long you have until mindwipe. It'd maybe take a day tops to add any additional details to the end of your previous book.
<><><><><><>
A question for you, though, as your entry made me think of it: Since crossing Darkon's border will cause you to regain your memory, what would happen to the book with your lifestory if you took it across the border with you?
Would the book be destroyed and the Quill would have to create a new book? Would you retain your false Darkonese memories since there's wouldn't be a domain border between you and your book, same as if you'd remained in Darkon with the book? Will it flip its information and instead contain the detailed history of your false persona?
And, for your above case: If you take someone else's book across the border, what happens to their memory? If the kid is still in Darkon and you take his book out, will he regain his true memory?