Page 1 of 3

Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 7:13 pm
by Manofevil
Okay fellow fratties, It works like this: A scenario is proposed in which a character or characters, not necessarily PCs, commit various acts that merit powers checks and Fraternity members calculate these powers checks. Here's the first scenario.

Bandits Tom, Dick, and Larry come across a farm and decide to rob it. They quietly break in through the kitchen and begin to search for valuables. Tom is surprised by the farmer and stabs him to death before either knows what has happened. This is witnessed by the farmer's wife, who begins to scream and throw things. This incites Dick and he attacks the wife in frenzy and beats her to death rather brutally. Larry then comes across a baby in a crib. He realizes the child is now an orphan and quietly smothers the baby with its own blanket to put it out of its misery. Calculate the powers checks.

Have fun!

Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 7:41 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Okay, let's start with a base 1% for Major Theft from a Neutral NPC (a farmer is often poor in RL) for each.

Tom performed Nonbrutal Murder on a Neutral, so his check would be around 4% all told.

Dick, who beat the woman to death brutally, gets 7% for Brutal Murder of a Neutral in addition to theft.

Larry, who smothered an Innocent, gets a whopping 11% in total.

That's going on the RAW. Personally I'd put Tom's around 2-3% since he's acting on surprise and fear, and has no idea what he's done until it's too late. Dick, who knowingly and brutally beats a woman to death, gets closer to 9% in my eyes. And Larry, who kills a child (this is not a mercy killing, and you otherwise never harm a child!!!), gets 13% for killing this child just to cover up a crime. Actually I'd make the last one suffer an Act of Ultimate Darkness (there are things even I won't tolerate).

Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 8:03 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
If you use the UTPC rules, the first murder would be an Atrocity (5) (murder as a crime of passion) against a neutral or unknown victim (-2), for a Sin (3), which has a 4% chance of failure.

The second murder would probably be an Abomination (6) (cold-blooded murder), although you could rule "crime of passion" since the guy is frightened and the woman is attacking him (not very effectually, but it's quite different from the next case...) against a neutral or unknown victim (-2) for an Enormity (4), with an 8% chance of failure.

The last murder would be an Abomination (6) (cold-blooded murder) against an Innocent (no modifier). 32% chance of failure.

All of those would be crimes of Violence, of course.

If you consider the robbery separately it would be a Trepass or Sin in the Betrayal category, for a 2 or 4% chance of failure. If you fold it into the murders all the above go up by one (compouding the felony, so to speak) making them Enormity/Atrocity/Act of Darkness, respectively, with an 8/16/100% chance of failure.

This assumes no previous power check failures on the part of the participants, of course.

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 12:37 am
by Manofevil
This has the potential to go some wonderful places. We can take the most memorable massacres or horrors from movies, books, TV, and the news and apply powers checks to them. Some of you might recognise this next one from the movie 'Tears of the Sun'. I've Ravenlofted it up a little tho.

A group of rangers caught in the middle of a Darkon/Falkovnia conflict come across a village in which Drakov's soldiers are engaged in their usual atrocities. Through a spyglass they witness women hauled from their houses and executed and resolve to intervene. One of the old men is being doused with lamp oil by one of the soldiers while his companion is fiddling with flint and steel trying to light a torch. The lead ranger takes half the group left and sends the other half right, surrounding the village while the elven ranger, let's call him ranger 1 climbs a tree and plants a steel tipped arrow throught the eye of the soldier(1) dousing the villager followed quickly by another arrow through the eye of the soldiers companion(2). Another soldier(3) sees the other two fall and rushes to them to see what happened. He receives one of ranger 1's arrows through his skull for his trouble.
The rangers on the left approach the village cautiously trying avoid getting caught by the soldiers. They find themselves standing in the impaled remains of all the villages men of military age. Two soldiers(4-5) come out with a corpse and pile toss it on a pile of corpses next to the impaled. The leader hears a birdcall indicating that the adventurers on the other side of the village are ready and he shoots both soldiers, cleanly killing them.
The rangers move quietly into the village. Ranger 1 sees two soldiers(6-7) interrogating a villager and draws a bead on them, the soldiers stab the villager in the heart before Ranger 1's arrows reach their target.
The leader with another ranger we'll call ranger 2, move into a house from which a woman's screams are heard. Ranger 2 looks in through the door just in time to see a soldier(8 ) smash a child's head with a rock. While another(9), with his back to the ranger, is doing something, the ranger can't see what, to a woman who is screaming. The leader and Ranger 2 move in quickly and the leaders quickly stabs both soldiers in the heart before they can react. Ranger 2 takes all of a split second to notice that the screams haven't stopped and follows them to a third soldier(10) whose throat he quickly slits from behind. The woman, who had in fact been being beaten, is completely hysterical, and moves to the corpses of her dead family as she continues to scream. The rangers move quietly on.
On the other side of the village, Rangers 3, 4, and 5 move quietly into the village. They come to a house where a soldier(10) is raping a girl and another(11) is standing by. The soldier standing by walks out the door and is quickly stabbed in the heart by ranger 5. Rangers 3 & 4 charge into the house and Ranger 3 searches for unseen enemies while Ranger 4 moves quickly up behind the rapist and garrotes him. When the rapist thrashes and almost shouts, ranger 4 siezes hold of his skull and breaks his neck. The girl whines at whimpers at the site of the rangers. Ranger 4 throws her a blanket and tries to reassure her verbally. Ranger 3 called to him and ranger 4 tells the girl to hide and the rangers move on .
The rangers converge on the town square where they find a very peculiar sight. There is a group of four soldiers(12-15) forcing a group of villagers, men and women, to dance and sing the praises of Vlad Drakov. The rangers move in smoothly and swiftly. The soldiers are quickly dispatched and the leader himself kills one of them and two sentries(16-17) which he spots standing inside a house. When the leader turns to tell the villagers to hide, the soldiers Commander, whom the leader hadn't seen charges him with a sword. The leader is caught flatfooted, but before the commander can strike, a spear comes from the leader's left and strikes the commander through the heart. The leader looks to where the spear came from and sees a stout villager with eyes burning with hatred. The leader and villager exchange grateful looks before moving on.
Rangers 3, 4, and 5 move on a house from which more woman's screams are coming. These are far worse than any they've heard up to now. The rangers 3 and 5 move in the front swiftly stabbing with their swords. killing a sentry(18 ) and wounding an officer who is on his knees over a woman. A third soldier races out the back door straight into ranger 4's sword. Ranger 4 looks into the dying soldiers eyes and notices that he is barely 10 years old. Rangers 3 and 5 have their swords to the officers throat and look down at his victim. The officer has hacked off her breasts. Ranger 3 siezes the wounded officer and forces him to look at the womans bloody wounds while snarling 'Look at your work Mother F----er', before taking his knife and disemboweling the officer. He lets the officer think about it for a few seconds before stabbing him in the heart. Ranger 5 sends up a signal for the groups healer. Ranger 3 leaves the house while Ranger 4 tries to comfort the dying woman. He discovers the womans dead baby beneath a blanket. He can bear no more so he leaves her with Ranger 5, who begins to pray over her.
The healer arrives but she has no magic spells, just potions and salves. She can do nothing for the woman besides make her last minutes painless. She stays until the poor woman dies. Calculate the powers checks for both sides.
Whew! That was a long one. Clearly there are more checks on one side than the other. I also don't know if the DPs take points off for striking from behind with no warning or opportunity to defend. Most of the rangers strikes were like that. I look forward to seeing the results.

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 9:27 am
by High Priest Mikhal
...::head explodes:: Ouch! This is way too complicated for me to use the UTPC or even the RAW. It also sounds like the atrocities of war, something I don't want to relive.

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 9:40 pm
by Troile
This is a little off topic but has anyone written up an alternative system to powers checks here?

Something that doesn't involve rolling dice would be best.

I was thinking a point based system might be good.

As it stands I see 2 problems with the system. The complete randomness gets me...and the amount of people that should be darklords or close to it would be quite high.

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 9:46 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Troile wrote:As it stands I see 2 problems with the system. The complete randomness gets me...and the amount of people that should be darklords or close to it would be quite high.
I dunno, I think the complete randomness is intentional. Sometimes the Dark Powers are watching and they zap you, sometimes they aren't and don't, and that's just all there is to it. As for the other, that's part of what the United Theory of Powers Checks was intended to address, so if you haven't read it, please do, and tell me what you think. (The thread is here.)

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 9:56 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Manofevil wrote:This has the potential to go some wonderful places.
Um. This I was not expecting. :shock: If this is a "wonderful place", I'd like to get off before we reach "horrifying" territory...also, I think it's more useful to examine the general principles involved than to detail every hair-raising scenario possible.

This is a pretty interesting general-principle example, I think, because I would say there's actually not much Powers Check material here. The Dark Powers are, by all appearances, much more attracted to what I might call "intimate" evil--personal, one-on-one, done by individuals to individuals. Mob violence and war don't get much traction. Since this is a battle scene I'd put the culturall condoned/officially sanctioned -2 modifier on most actions.

(This is also a reason PCs would tend to get powers checks more readily than John Doe on the street...PCs are almost always acting as individuals, because, well, that's the point of role-playing, whereas a lot of horrible things in Ravenloft are done by people who are effectively cogs in an evil societal machine. A prison warden in Falkovnia may do all kinds of evil things and fail only one or two checks over the course of his life because he's enmeshed in an evil institution that warps all his moral decisions. His actions are equally evil, but they're not individual in the way the Dark Powers are most attracted to.)

The rangers are in combat, which doesn't require powers checks. The death of the commanding officer (disembowelment first, then the coup de grace) might be consider torture or brutal murder (5), but the officer killed would probably fall into the Evil bin (-3), so you're looking at an Offence (2, 2% chance of failure) or thereabouts.

Soldiers' action versus the rangers are also combat and get no checks. The soldiers brutalizing their victims are committing Abominations (6) on neutral parties (for the most part, the kids are Innocent), but "fog of war" conditions and the official/cultural modifiers mean that we're looking mostly at Offenses, Sins and perhaps a few Enormities for the murder/torture of children (2/4/8% chance).

That's how I'd call it, myself.

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 10:00 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, here are a few samples for people to chew on:

Princess Bride: Count Rugen the Torturer, draining life out of Wesley. Prince Humperdink, hiring Vizzini to kidnap and murder his fiancee. Miracle Max, bringing Wesley back from the dead.

Possible plot IMC: Vjorn Horstmann is put out with Kara's Daughters, but when a captive doppelganger dies he agrees to endorse them if they find a suitable replacement within three days. They agree, but later run into the Dark Men and also agree to help the Dark Men kill Horstmann.

Assuming these resourceful yougn women work it out so that the capture the doppelganger, milk Horstmann for glowing support and then kill him without being implicated, what are their powers checks?

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 10:14 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Princess Bride: Count Rugen the Torturer, draining life out of Wesley.
Routine torture, possibly with a twist of Black Magic, against a (*gulp*) Evil subject. (Dread Pirate Roberts, anyone? One never likes to think about these things, but if Wesley really spent five years as the Dread Pirate himself he's got a lot on his conscience.) So, Violent Atrocity (5) with Black Magic (+1) against an Evil subject (-3). Since Rugen's undoubtedly done this before and failed a few checks (where do you like that sixth finger came from, h'm?), he's probably got another -1 at least. Make it 5+1-3-1 for a total of 2, an Offence with a 2% chance of failure.
Prince Humperdink, hiring Vizzini to kidnap and murder his fiancee.
Murderous Betrayal, an Abomination (6). Since the victim is his fiancee, that would go to the Innocent/intimate side of the ledger, no modifier. Betrayal Abomination, 32% chance of failure. Since the point is to start a war with Guilder, you could rule he's betraying the whole country and just slap the AoUD on him.
Miracle Max, bringing Wesley back from the dead.
Miracle Max gets a pass. Who are we to argue with True Love? :lucas:

Just kidding. This is Miracle Max in Ravenloft! Nobody gets out unscathed! It's not clear just how powerful his necromancy is--he doesn't seem to believe it will work, and just how dead was Wesley anyway? Let's say it's a Sin in the Black Magic category--fairly minor tampering with the powers of life and death. He doesn't get any credit for good motives ("Humiliations galore!", plus the sixty in payment), so I'd put him on a straight Black Magic Sin for 4% (barring modifiers from past failures).

Posted: Thu Jul 31, 2008 10:21 pm
by Isabella
Well, he was only mostly dead...

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 6:29 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
K, here we go:
Anakin Skywalker:
1) Somewhat accidentally destroys the doid control ship, no doubt conatining some semi-innocent Niemoidians.(sp?)
2) Slaughters an encampment of sandpeople (men, women, and children) in revenge for his mother's death
3) At Palpatine's urging, cuts off the arm of Mace Windu (Jedi Master, one of the leaders of Anakin's own Order) allowing Palpatine to get the advantage and kill him.
4) Betrays his Order completely, allies with the Evil Palpatine and slaughters (Good) Jedi by the dozens, including "younglings" (Innocent children)
5) Thinking she's betrayed him, force-chokes his own pregnant wife, Padme.
6) Assists Palpatine in creating a brutal, oppressive regime (the Empire)
{darklord yet?}
7) continues to hunt down and destroy remaining Jedi
8) Tortures his daughter, though he doesn't know it's her
9) Kills his mentor and friend Obi-wan in battle
10) Routinely force-chokes subordinates, sometimes to death.
11) Cuts off the arm of his own son.

(Did I miss anything?)

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 8:47 am
by Troile
(Dread Pirate Roberts, anyone? One never likes to think about these things, but if Wesley really spent five years as the Dread Pirate himself he's got a lot on his conscience.)
Actually the whole point of taking the name Roberts is to get people to surrender to him. He also had the position thrust upon him. We don't really know what he did, I'm sure it involved theft but we don't know much else. He was probably mostly talk, he's good at that. He probably spent the time plotting to get away too, the dread pirate roberts cannot simply abandon his post without having people come looking for him.
Well, he was only mostly dead...
Exactly, which is slightly alive.
("Humiliations galore!", plus the sixty in payment)
I think he mostly did it for his wife, and just used those as an excuse. Besides he had never worked for so little before so the money isn't a factor.

Plus he put a chocolate coating on it so it would go down easier, isn't he a nice guy?
I dunno, I think the complete randomness is intentional. Sometimes the Dark Powers are watching and they zap you, sometimes they aren't and don't, and that's just all there is to it.
I suppose its just a matter of personal taste then.

The chances are so low that I think it loses focus. I can see a system with no chance not working very well either though.
As for the other, that's part of what the United Theory of Powers Checks was intended to address, so if you haven't read it, please do, and tell me what you think. (The thread is here.)
I will, thanks.

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 8:54 am
by Nathan of the FoS
gonzoron wrote:K, here we go:
Anakin Skywalker:
1) Somewhat accidentally destroys the doid control ship, no doubt conatining some semi-innocent Niemoidians.(sp?)
2) Slaughters an encampment of sandpeople (men, women, and children) in revenge for his mother's death
3) At Palpatine's urging, cuts off the arm of Mace Windu (Jedi Master, one of the leaders of Anakin's own Order) allowing Palpatine to get the advantage and kill him.
4) Betrays his Order completely, allies with the Evil Palpatine and slaughters (Good) Jedi by the dozens, including "younglings" (Innocent children)
5) Thinking she's betrayed him, force-chokes his own pregnant wife, Padme.
6) Assists Palpatine in creating a brutal, oppressive regime (the Empire)
{darklord yet?}
7) continues to hunt down and destroy remaining Jedi
8) Tortures his daughter, though he doesn't know it's her
9) Kills his mentor and friend Obi-wan in battle
10) Routinely force-chokes subordinates, sometimes to death.
11) Cuts off the arm of his own son.

(Did I miss anything?)
Force-strangulation and force-lightning count as Black Magic, I suppose, since as I recall only the Sith can (will?) use those powers. I'd say 2) and 4) are Acts of Ultimate Darkness--4) is probably at least two AoUDs, one for betraying the Order (Betrayal) and one for the younglings (Violence). If you want to give him 4 AoUDs for that rampage and then drop a Black Magic dime on him for his first use of the dark side of the Force, I wouldn't complain--and it would make him a darklord then and there.

I don't think 1) gets a check. 6), 7) and 10) are kinda diffuse--there were probably Powers Checks involved at some point, but they're not individual actions.

The others are a bit harder; I'll come back to them when I have a little more time.

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 9:41 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Possible plot IMC: Vjorn Horstmann is put out with Kara's Daughters, but when a captive doppelganger dies he agrees to endorse them if they find a suitable replacement within three days. They agree, but later run into the Dark Men and also agree to help the Dark Men kill Horstmann.

Assuming these resourceful yougn women work it out so that the capture the doppelganger, milk Horstmann for glowing support and then kill him without being implicated, what are their powers checks?
Do people need more details on this one? I'd really like to see how it measures up.