Page 1 of 2
Mummies! (3E, 4E, history)
Posted: Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:00 am
by alhoon
After I saw
this I started thinking about mummies.
3E The mummy (particularly in Ravenloft) was a very powerful and strong creature with a devastating strength (24 in 3E), tough, which could paralyze enemies and spread a deadly curse.
In Ravenloft the above was just a low rank mummy guardian while the more powerful creatures were clerics combining spells with prowess.
However mummies were not the most active of enemies.
4E: Well, the mummy guardian is a bit lame without adding some special powers.
Mummy rot is still powerful and the mummy has regeneration making it tough to beat again, but it doesn't have any encounter powers to making mummies fun to play. They just beat and get beaten.
Posted: Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:48 am
by Jester of the FoS
That's because most of the MM mummies are just dumb, slow Universal/Karloff brutes.
We need some leaderish mummies with crazy divine powers that are arch-villains and leaders.
Feel free to add some to my "Call for Beasties" thread. Make-up some variant mummies.
Posted: Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:51 am
by Archedius
The picture of the Grecco-Roman attired mummy in VRGttAD always got me thinking of ancient Darkon. I ended up for my version of RL layering consistant ruins across the core in Roman style despite the differing origins of the core domains with only the most obscure historical texts linking them. One of those nice little details that players might notice that could either make the world seem to fit together naturally...or seem jigsawed. (I've even made certain places from earth known in passing as well as certain individuals- there's a reason that the Core uses our Roman influenced calendar: )
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 12:23 am
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Feel free to add some to my "Call for Beasties" thread. Make-up some variant mummies.
Not a bad idea. A leader mummy...
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 2:14 am
by alhoon
As posted in the other monster thread:
Mummy Warpriest:
The embalmed remains of a priest devoted to a God of war for all his life, serving his master in unlife by leading armies of undead in battle and striking terror to his foes.
Mummy Warpriest Elite Level 11 controler (leader)
Medium undead (keyword) XP 1200
Initiative +6 Senses Perception +9; darkvision
Grip of death (fear) aura 5; enemies within the aura take a –2 penalty to attack rolls and a -1 penalty to saving throws. Undead in the aura get a +1 bonus to speed for every 4 squares they move and a +1 to all four defences.
HP 222; Bloodied 111
Regeneration 5 (if the mummy warpriest takes radiant damage, regeneration doesn’t function on its next turn). (Also see allergen)
AC 27; Fortitude 25, Reflex 21, Will 22
Immune disease, poison; Resist 10 necrotic; Vulnerable 10 fire; 5 radiant (Also see allergen).
Saving Throws + 2
Speed 6
Action Points 1
M slam (standard; at-will) ✦ Disease, Necrotic
+16 vs. AC; 1d8 + 8 damage +5 necrotic damage, and the target contracts level 11 mummy rot. If the target is medium or smaller, pushed back 1 square.
r Warpriest's curse (standard; recharge 5,6) ✦ Necrotic
Ranged 5; +13 vs. Fortitude; 1d8+4 necrotic damage, and ongoing 5 necrotic damage (save ends). The target is weakened and dazed (save ends both).
C Unholy prayer (only while bloodied; minor; encounter) ✦ Necrotic, Healing
Evil energies bolster undead and harm living creatures: close burst
2; +13 vs. Fortitude; 2d8 + 4 necrotic damage. Undead within the burst gain 10 temporary hit points.
Second Wind (standard; encounter) ✦ Healing
The mummy warpriest spends a healing surge and regains 55 hit points. The mummy warpriest gains a +2 bonus to all defenses until the start of its next turn.
Allergen
There is one thing the mummy warpriest is especially vulnerable to, which is called allergen. For some Warpriests it's holy water, for others a special prayer etc. There can be different allergen effects at the DM's discretion.
When presented or in contact with its allergen (the prayer constantly sang as a minor action, holy symbol presented,soaked in holy water etc) the mummy warpriest has all the following penalties:
- -2 to all defences and to all attack rolls
- dazed when the allergen first comes to play (save ends)
- enemies receive a +2 bonus to saving throws against the mummy warpriest's powers
- doesn't regenerate
- The mummy rot it spreads is considered a level 8 disease instead of level 11 (exactly like the guardian's).
Alignment evil Languages common
Skills History +11, Intimidate +11, Religion +12
Str 26 (+13) Dex 12 (+6) Wis 18 (+9)
Con 15 (+7) Int 12 (+6) Cha 15 (+7)
Equipment unholy symbol
NOTE: The mummy warpriest's basic attack deals too much damage for a creature of his level so I decided to increase his vulnerabilities and decrease his regeneration. I threw in the allergen as yet another balancing factor.
Explanation From the start I wanted a monster that could deal serious damage with a blow. On the other hand, Brute seemed a bit too harsh (And had too many hp with low hit rolls) for what I had in mind.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 3:44 am
by Brandi
Jester of the FoS wrote:That's because most of the MM mummies are just dumb, slow Universal/Karloff brutes.
I actually wouldn't call the mummy in the Karloff film a brute-- he does a pretty good job of insinuating himself into modern society given his somewhat... peculiar appearance.
(The 40s cycle of Mummy films did tend to have mummy-as-attack-dog, though.)
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:40 am
by Jester of the FoS
Glee, now It get to nitpick.
alhoon wrote:...and a +1 to all defences and AC.
AC is a defence
alhoon wrote:M slam (standard; at-will) ✦ Disease, Necrotic
+16 vs. AC; 1d8 + 8 damage +5 necrotic damage, and the target contracts level 11 mummy rot. If the target is medium or smaller, pushed back 1 square.
all damage here should be necrotic. ie 1d8+13 necrotic.
alhoon wrote:A Unholy prayer (only while bloodied; minor; encounter) ✦ Necrotic, Healing
Evil energies bolster undead and harm living creatures: close burst
2; +13 vs. Fortitude; 2d8 + 4 necrotic damage. Undead within the burst gain 10 temporary hit points.
Is this an area power, or a close power?
alhoon wrote:NOTE: The mummy warpriest's basic attack deals too much damage for a creature of his level so I decided to increase his vulnerabilities and decrease his regeneration. I threw in the allergen as yet another balancing factor.
1d8+8+5?
2d6+5 Wouldn't be unreasonable, especially for an elite. It is replacing two monsters possibly doing 3d6+5 & 2d6+5.
Even an average fighter should be pushing 75-80 hit points at this level. They should be able to go 4-5 rounds of that kinda damage without blinking.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 7:13 am
by Nikolas of the Mists
There are some "templates" in the back of the DMG which can fit. Drop on a class template to a mummy and he's suddenly a real threat.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 9:39 am
by alhoon
And I get to answer!
Jester of the FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:...and a +1 to all defences and AC.
AC is a defence
Sure? I think you're right, but I added it just in case.
Jester of the FoS wrote: alhoon wrote:M slam (standard; at-will) ✦ Disease, Necrotic
+16 vs. AC; 1d8 + 8 damage +5 necrotic damage, and the target contracts level 11 mummy rot. If the target is medium or smaller, pushed back 1 square.
all damage here should be necrotic. ie 1d8+13 necrotic.
Who says that? Just because it's that way for the mummy in MM? I disagree

. The main damage source of the mummy's attack should be it's immense strength.
It's
not a corrupting touch or something to be all necrotic. It's a fist that throws back a man sized creature, charged with some necrotic energy.
Check the dragons and many other monsters. They have similar attacks that deal damage +some energy damage.
Jester of the FoS wrote:alhoon wrote:A Unholy prayer (only while bloodied; minor; encounter) ✦ Necrotic, Healing
Evil energies bolster undead and harm living creatures: close burst
2; +13 vs. Fortitude; 2d8 + 4 necrotic damage. Undead within the burst gain 10 temporary hit points.
Is this an area power, or a close power?
A close area power. Hence the A in the front. I think that's the way they are written. Correct me if it's wrong.
Jester of the FoS wrote: alhoon wrote:NOTE: The mummy warpriest's basic attack deals too much damage for a creature of his level so I decided to increase his vulnerabilities and decrease his regeneration. I threw in the allergen as yet another balancing factor.
1d8+8+5?
2d6+5 Wouldn't be unreasonable, especially for an elite. It is replacing two monsters possibly doing 3d6+5 & 2d6+5.
Even an average fighter should be pushing 75-80 hit points at this level. They should be able to go 4-5 rounds of that kinda damage without blinking.
Well, it's not that way in DMG. Yes, elites should do more damage but not double the damage of a monster. And according to DMG a high normal attack for a monster of this level should be 3d6+5 = 15,5 average.
The mummy's attack deals 17,5 average
and 5 ongoing.
Since you save
at the end of your round, while you take the damage
at the beginning, you always get 5 damage and have 50% to get 5 more.
I.e on average 25 damage. It also pushes back the enemy and spreads mummy rot.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 1:53 pm
by DocBeard
The thing is, we have a manipulated, sorcery-using villain that is a preserved corpse that rises from the grave and keeps itself powerful through dark rituals and wave after wave of expendable minions. They're called "liches".
I could see a separate 'mummy lord' monster as, like, a soldier or skirmisher who represents the buried warrior-king who wanted to prepare for an immortality that never came, but I think that controller-style mummies and liches use so many of the same themes that I don't really see a reason to have a separate monster.
Which has never stopped D&D before, but when it comes to a recurring 'breed' of monster, I think it'd be more efficient to make liches a sort of mummy. But I am not a doctor.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 4:31 pm
by alhoon
Oh, I'll be making liches soon.

And the mummy presented here has a great difference from the lich.
It doesn't hide behind minions throwing spells. It leads the attack and glories in melee.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 6:07 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Jester of the FoS wrote:alhoon wrote:A Unholy prayer (only while bloodied; minor; encounter) ✦ Necrotic, Healing
Evil energies bolster undead and harm living creatures: close burst
2; +13 vs. Fortitude; 2d8 + 4 necrotic damage. Undead within the burst gain 10 temporary hit points.
Is this an area power, or a close power?
A close area power. Hence the A in the front. I think that's the way they are written. Correct me if it's wrong.
It's a close power. Bursts and blasts centered by the caster (ie, not ranged) are close. It's an area if it's a burst with a range.
alhoon wrote:Jester of the FoS wrote: alhoon wrote:NOTE: The mummy warpriest's basic attack deals too much damage for a creature of his level so I decided to increase his vulnerabilities and decrease his regeneration. I threw in the allergen as yet another balancing factor.
1d8+8+5?
2d6+5 Wouldn't be unreasonable, especially for an elite. It is replacing two monsters possibly doing 3d6+5 & 2d6+5.
Even an average fighter should be pushing 75-80 hit points at this level. They should be able to go 4-5 rounds of that kinda damage without blinking.
Well, it's not that way in DMG. Yes, elites should do more damage but not double the damage of a monster. And according to DMG a high normal attack for a monster of this level should be 3d6+5 = 15,5 average.
The mummy's attack deals 17,5 average
and 5 ongoing.
Since you save
at the end of your round, while you take the damage
at the beginning, you always get 5 damage and have 50% to get 5 more.
I.e on average 25 damage. It also pushes back the enemy and spreads mummy rot.
That is true, but the non-randomized bits of the damage are what knocks the average up. 1d8+8+5 is really 1d8+13 which is really fairly hefty compared to average damage rolls.
Mid-damage for the level is 2d6+5, so it's not unreasonable to split that into 1d6+5 damage plus 1d6 necrotic damage. It does the same thing but lowers the damage a tick.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 6:13 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote: Mid-damage for the level is 2d6+5, so it's not unreasonable to split that into 1d6+5 damage plus 1d6 necrotic damage. It does the same thing but lowers the damage a tick.
Agreed. But that's
exactly what I didn't want the Mummy warpriest to have.

I want it to deal very high damage, not a puny 1d6+5+1d6 necrotic.
Why should most melee fighting monsters of 11th level do the same amount of damage with their at will attacks?
Back in 3E a mummy had +14 str. So a mummy fighter/cleric could easily have 30 strength without magic items. Add in this divine favor and power attack, and you had a very, very powerful attack that would carve a hole through an enemy.
That's what I wanted to capture. You want to take down the mummy? Use ranged attacks, fire or the allergen. Don't come close.
I tried to balance out the very high damage "the 3E way" i.e by adding weaknesses. I didn't want the mummy to be just another "out of the box" monster that deals mostly the same damage as every other 11th level monster with different types.
I'm quite sure that on the 4E Ravenloft table, the 11th level party will have to think of different tactics to stop the mummy than other monsters, utilizing the creature's great weaknesses and trying to minimize the creature's great melee prowess.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 6:38 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Why should most melee fighting monsters of 11th level do the same amount of damage with their at will attacks?
Because its the amount of damage characters should be expected to take?
Because its similar to the damage of PCs?
It should
really be a brute then. Controllers are all about slowing down enemies and doing small damage to large numbers.
Your mummy doesn't really do alot of control and seems to be pushing the brute feel (tough, high meaty damage on a hit).
The other option is lurker.
Or limits on the power. Perhaps something other than its basic attack but which is usable at-will. Then you can justify amping up the damage to crazy extremes. Maybe a bonus to damage against weakened and/or dazed targets or a power usable against the same. It works nicely with the curse.
On another design note, it could also use some immediate or free powers, or one that recharges when bloodied or under other conditions.
Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 7:28 pm
by alhoon
Many of the controlers I have seen do even
less control than this mummy.
As for controlling the battle field: A dazed opponent is a controlled opponent. Pushing people around is controlling power. Giving speed to allies is a controller power.
Now I understand that's this may not be "much" battlefield control. But there's no monster role like what I wanted.
And truth be told, I'm a 3E DM at heart. I disagree that there should be only a few monster roles.
There's not an exact monster role for what I had in mind, so I though that controller is closer. Perhaps lurker fits better. I'll check.
Also as a 3E DM that doesn't like 4E "boxed and limited" choices I don't think that the only way to balance a monster to the chars is to fix hp and damage. Adding weaknesses is IMO an interesting way. Balance issues? Well... it's not like all the monsters are balanced.
