Page 1 of 1

Ravenloft Psionic Rules Help Needed

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 6:01 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
I remember reading a Dead Sea Scroll that had rules for the old 3.0 Psionics Handbook, though it's since been trumped by the RDMG. Has there been any serious, thorough conversion of the Expanded Psionics Handbook and Complete Psionic to account for Ravenloft's unique warping of powers and sometimes class features? I can make guesses at what happens to what, but I'd still like to hear what others think.

This one's bugging me the most so I'll ask now: Does the 3.5 soulknife's "Knife to the Soul" ability really call for a powers check anymore? In the original PH IIRC it was an attack to the soul via the Con attribute. But in the EPH it's an attack against a mental attribute (a Mental Sever, if you will). Does that really in and of itself call for a powers check? I'm really having a hard time deciding on that.

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 2:43 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Other questions are what about dread elemental envoys? Outside of Kalidnay, Sri Raji, and Pharazia, what other groups and domains know about psionics? How are psionics viewed by arcanists and divine casters? Would Lamordians put more stock in psionics than magic? How does Azalin view psionics and psionicists?

Questions and answers alike are welcome. I'd like to hear what others think.

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 3:50 pm
by NeoTiamat
Well, in the end, converting abilities to Ravenloft is fairly simple if you keep in mind a few, basic rules.

1. No planar travel, and no summoning of outsiders.

2. No direct moral-alignment detection. Indirect (Such as Protection from Evil, Blasphemy) are allowed.

3. No power may override a Darklord's control over his domain and its denizens.

4. No power may breach a closed domain border.

5. Evil powers are strengthened by the Mists, and may have particularly negative consequences (most commonly that victims of dark spells may rise up as undead).

6. No power may override the Mists.

There were some others in the RLPHB, but those are the main ideas. I think if you look at any given spell with those rules in mind, it'd work well for Ravenloft.

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 5:03 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
NeoTiamat wrote:Well, in the end, converting abilities to Ravenloft is fairly simple if you keep in mind a few, basic rules.

1. No planar travel, and no summoning of outsiders.

2. No direct moral-alignment detection. Indirect (Such as Protection from Evil, Blasphemy) are allowed.

3. No power may override a Darklord's control over his domain and its denizens.

4. No power may breach a closed domain border.

5. Evil powers are strengthened by the Mists, and may have particularly negative consequences (most commonly that victims of dark spells may rise up as undead).

6. No power may override the Mists.

There were some others in the RLPHB, but those are the main ideas. I think if you look at any given spell with those rules in mind, it'd work well for Ravenloft.
Thanks, but I already know all that. What I'm asking for is more about the fluff, class features of core and prestige classes, and what not-so-obvious changes would me made to certain powers? What do others do to reflect the changes made to any mortal power in Ravenloft?

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 6:25 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
The rule of thumb I've gone by is that the fluff for a class is always expendable, whenever it comes down to a choice between preserving that class's functionality, and preserving the fluff. You can nearly always come up with a new rationale behind a class's abilities, that lets you avoid hamstringing it in Ravenloft.

For example, the fluff-text for the Incarnum-based classes traces their powers to soul-energy, which technically may constitute Necromancy by Ravenloft's definitions. As it stands, those classes might well have to be axed altogether in a Land of Mists campaign. But how hard is it to whip up an alternate power-source for those classes, that doesn't have to do with souls? Not hard at all.

So rather than nerfing a "borderline evil" class ability, it's simplest to re-write the fluff that goes along with it. If Knife To The Soul seems dubious, just call it "Thought Severence" or something, and it's fine. If elemental envoys are too creepy, swap them out for something else. And so on.

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 6:44 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Outside of Kalidnay, Sri Raji, and Pharazia, what other groups and domains know about psionics? How are psionics viewed by arcanists and divine casters? Would Lamordians put more stock in psionics than magic? How does Azalin view psionics and psionicists?
There were a number of references to people with psychic abilities in the original Ravenloft products, although most were along the lines of spirit mediums giving seances, rather than trained psionicists. The uneducated probably confuse magic and psionics, but scholars of the arcane would be aware that there's a difference.

In addition to fakirs in Sri Raji, the Thaani ethnic minority in Barovia may be the only formal practitioners of psionics in the Core. There was a minor secret society dedicated to preserving and concealing their psionic skills in the Forbidden Lore boxed set, although whom they were hiding their abilities from -- superstitious Barovians, Strahd, rivals who practice arcane magic, etc -- wasn't too clear.

Lamordians probably wouldn't believe in psionics until they actually see it in action for themselves. Even then, they'd probably find it unnerving.

FWIW, judging by Dr. M's own attitude in the novel Mordenheim, he seems to believe all magic is basically psionics -- i.e. an as-yet-undocumented branch of science, based on mental energy, whose rules a rational mind could extrapolate logically -- instead of the 'fairy-tale bunkum' he's heard stories about.

Azalin may actually have been a "wild talent" when he was alive, depending on how you interpret his Sight in King of the Dead. None of his stat-blocks have mentioned this, so his psionic abilities (if they ever existed) may have been subsumed into his power as a lich and darklord.

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 1:12 pm
by Tykus
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Lamordians probably wouldn't believe in psionics until they actually see it in action for themselves. Even then, they'd probably find it unnerving.

FWIW, judging by Dr. M's own attitude in the novel Mordenheim, he seems to believe all magic is basically psionics -- i.e. an as-yet-undocumented branch of science, based on mental energy, whose rules a rational mind could extrapolate logically -- instead of the 'fairy-tale bunkum' he's heard stories about.
By that rationale, Mordenheim's belief about psionics should filter down into the domain's psychology. Mordenheim did try to use his non-existent psionics when he attempted to communicate with his creation "The Brain."

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 1:49 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Good point! Which, among other things, suggests that the Smothering of Reason (if used) wouldn't impact psionic powers.

It also begs the question of what the Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens might think of psionics. On the one hand, they could regard it as a rational mind's countermeasure against supernatural forces, and hence, use it as a weapon; on the other, it's something that can crop up at random in common-born riffraff, potentially upsetting the social order that keeps the SEC's membership securely on top.

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 5:18 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Good point! Which, among other things, suggests that the Smothering of Reason (if used) wouldn't impact psionic powers.

It also begs the question of what the Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens might think of psionics. On the one hand, they could regard it as a rational mind's countermeasure against supernatural forces, and hence, use it as a weapon; on the other, it's something that can crop up at random in common-born riffraff, potentially upsetting the social order that keeps the SEC's membership securely on top.
The SEC would likely recruit any and all psionicists it could find to try and monopolize that segment of society. Of course, they could wind up being the used instead of the users just as easily once the psionicists decide to stop playing around.

This is off-topic, but this post did raise it: does the SEC use magic in spite of its disdain for it (fight fire with fire tactics)?

Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 2:39 pm
by Tykus
High Priest Mikhal wrote:
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Good point! Which, among other things, suggests that the Smothering of Reason (if used) wouldn't impact psionic powers.

It also begs the question of what the Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens might think of psionics. On the one hand, they could regard it as a rational mind's countermeasure against supernatural forces, and hence, use it as a weapon; on the other, it's something that can crop up at random in common-born riffraff, potentially upsetting the social order that keeps the SEC's membership securely on top.
The SEC would likely recruit any and all psionicists it could find to try and monopolize that segment of society. Of course, they could wind up being the used instead of the users just as easily once the psionicists decide to stop playing around.

This is off-topic, but this post did raise it: does the SEC use magic in spite of its disdain for it (fight fire with fire tactics)?
I sort of see the relationship between the SEC and psionics similar to the one the Company (or Linderman's organization) has with Heroes within their world.