Page 1 of 1

Progress and the passage of time

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 7:54 pm
by Zettaijin
The cyberpunk thread brought to the forefront the issue of technology in the demiplane.

Now we all know that Dementlieu, Lamordia and Paridon are by design more advanced than most of the other domains and islands with the sole exception of Nosos and, in a way, Vechor.

And we also know that time passes and canon material attempts to address the possibility of characters growing old and dying to avoid comic book-like situations where a character could have served active duty in WWII, Viet-Nam and Iraq all thanks to timely reboots that bring him back to his prime as the narrative commands.

So the demiplane is not static and there exists places where rational thought and scientific research and proper methodology is not completely frowned upon, and might even be actively encouraged.

Is it then conceivable that progress might eventually start booming? That the industrial era might, whether some people like it or not, find some manner of RL counterpart? I know MotRD is the answer I'll be given, but I'm talking about places like Paridon, Lamordia, Nosos and Dementlieu.

I know the laws of physics, and, by extension, pretty much everything else, doesn't quite "work" the same way as in the real world, but we've already accepted so much from the real world that it's hard to go back and close the floodgates. And the old "DPs will negate it" excuse is, in my view, getting a little too much mileage.

So, how long before things start getting interesting in the core?

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 7:58 pm
by Isabella
Steampunk! Steampunk! Steampunk!


I'm done now.

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 8:10 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Keep in mind that technological changes have historically taken years, even decades, to complete. Since technology only travels as fast as the people that use it, it's also slow to spread until more efficient means of transportation are perfected. Then there are existing biases that keep the inventor from publishing his/her findings; various churches may not want scientific ideas being spread because they clash with religious teachings, for example.

All things in due time, Isabella. Just be patient. :)

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 8:11 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Sure, you could do that. There's actually one domain (Farelle) where the demi-canon idea behind the domain is one of extremely rapid technology progress (it was written up by Ryan Naylor for the Book of Sacrifices). So that's another place I'd add to the list of potential technologically advanced domains. (The Lonesome Road's write-up of Arkandale also has an inventor with a prototype steam engine, come to that.)

There are a bunch of weird confounds to think about, of course. Mordenheim has a lot of scientific stuff figured out, it's just that no-one believes him; there are a lot of things to investigate scientifically in Ravenloft that don't exist in the real world; there are some things which simply might not exist in Ravenloft (universal gravitation, for example); and there's the influence of magic on the sciences (for my money "magic" would be a kind of science, not "something opposed to science", in a place like Ravenloft where magic worked consistently and according to defined principles).

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 8:20 pm
by Isabella
I've often wondered why revolvers are unknown in the setting despite Paridon being taken wholesale from Victorian England.

The biggest problem would be the Darklords. Religion isn't a huge factor in the High CL Domains, and the spread of technology wouldn't be stopped by geographical barriers (given that a lot of 3e was spent opening the Core up, and the Core is about the size of Belgium). Magic, which would be the other huge factor for slowing progress, isn't looked upon well by most Domains.

So probably the only thing keeping things at the status quo are control freak Darklords like D'Honaire who have decided they don't like where this industrial revolution thing is going.

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 8:40 pm
by Zettaijin
Thanks for reminding me of Arkandale, Nathan. I'm afraid I forgot that the former darklord of Arkandale is the happy owner of a steamboat.

Or that's how it was portrayed for much of Timothy's existence.

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 8:56 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Isabella wrote:I've often wondered why revolvers are unknown in the setting despite Paridon being taken wholesale from Victorian England.
Revolvers are one I've also wondered about as well. Self-contained cartridges are probably not viable just yet simply because you need standardized parts, and mechanization to create said parts. Cap and ball revolvers are more feasible; they're just lead balls and gunpowder loaded into the revolver chamber with an explosive cap put on the nipple (the pointed end behind the chamber where the hammer hit). Maybe they do exist, but just aren't widespread beyond Paridon and Nosos.

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 9:07 pm
by ewancummins
Isabella wrote:I've often wondered why revolvers are unknown in the setting despite Paridon being taken wholesale from Victorian England.

The biggest problem would be the Darklords. Religion isn't a huge factor in the High CL Domains, and the spread of technology wouldn't be stopped by geographical barriers (given that a lot of 3e was spent opening the Core up, and the Core is about the size of Belgium). Magic, which would be the other huge factor for slowing progress, isn't looked upon well by most Domains.

So probably the only thing keeping things at the status quo are control freak Darklords like D'Honaire who have decided they don't like where this industrial revolution thing is going.


Revolvers were probably left out for reasons of game balance. Anything past the very primitive and expirmental early revolvers would be very useful and represent a weapon that couldn't easily be ignored. Actual cap and ball revovlers, such as one sees in them mid 19th century, were , for all their flaws, pretty amazing weapons. Not having to reload after each shot makes pistoleers a lot more dangerous!

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 9:11 pm
by ewancummins
Zettaijin wrote:Thanks for reminding me of Arkandale, Nathan. I'm afraid I forgot that the former darklord of Arkandale is the happy owner of a steamboat.

Or that's how it was portrayed for much of Timothy's existence.
I use something based on Andrew Wyatt's version of Arkandale. It's very Old South. There are definitely primitive steamboats- some of which use a combination of steam tech and wizardly magic to operate.

Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2008 11:52 pm
by Jester of the FoS
We're seeing some progress in the game world, but it's really advancing along real-time. It's been roughly 15 or so years since the start of the campaign, long enough for young girls to grow-up and an already senior monster hunter to need to 'die' but not long technologically.

Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 12:01 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Don't forget: the Core's single biggest technological revolution of all time took place barely a decade ago, when movable-type printing finally made it from Zherisia to the other Renaissance domains. The Twins' reprints of Van Richten's original works (aka the Monster Hunter's Compendium books) are a product of that, and they weren't published until ~754 BC.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 11:05 pm
by Zettaijin
I just read the second issue of QtR. Yes, I know, I'm a little late.

Anyhow, I was interested in how ScS would handle Nosos and technology in order to gain some potential solutions to my own ongoing revision of Nosos.

To my surprise, his version includes trains of all things - and to think I was trying to find creative ways to lower the technology level! Later, higher cultural levels than those proposed in canon material are detailed (including Enlightenment).

I still find it odd that trains would feel so out of place to me after expending so much energy defending cyberpunk and suggesting an industrialrevolution in RL. But anyhow, I couldn't find feedback on this issue, so I'm curious as to how people here feel about the addition of mass transportation, even if it is on an isolated island.

Furthermore, the Zherisia Gaz brings up the topic of steam power.

In a world of time travelling gypsies and all powerful liches cum death gods, where a tiny isolated cluster of land with so little people can produce so much wondrous technology, how hard is it to believe that progress couldn't possibly occur at a much accelerated rate? How long before Isabella gets her steampunk for Christmas?

Again, once you open the floodgates...

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 1:08 am
by Archedius
lol well it's a good thing we have Darkon, the southern and eastern core to stymie all this technological advancement. Trains and moveable type could help move peasants out from under certain rulers and religions thumbs so to speak.