Page 1 of 2

Well played fear and horror for PC's

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 11:27 am
by vipera aspis
First off, hello dear brothers and sisters of the frat; it has been a while.

So after many years of running Ravenloft campaigns and games: finally one of my players has picked up the torch. It is fantastic to actually play! I have never actually played before! For the record he(Cross) is doing a bang-up job as well.

However now it comes to this. As a past DM of the Ravenloft setting i have lost care of or minused out many things: alignments, badass magic weapons, certain classes(barbarian, monk), certain spells(colour spray, fireball, light, lightning bolt, magic missile), unplanned combat, easily defeated monsters, having lots of gold, most prestige classes and many other things.

Which in the begining sounds bad but I dislike all those things in favor of: detailed villans you almost feel sorry for, realistic natural dangers, thickly difficult mysteries, roleplaying well, beloved and surviving NPC's, PC/NPC backrounds full of hooks and dread possibilities and sometimes, just sometimes a true gothic feel.

With this backround i now enter as a PC. I want to help the DM, help the players, keep the game moving, stay in character, write detailed backrounds, help move away from powergaming, take levels in NPC classes, roleplay to the best of my ability(meaning voices other then grizzled lone ranger of the northern woods and 1930's private eye), bring extra candles and clove ciggarettes, stop wearing tee-shirts and wear a damn tie(it is a more adult and respectable game after all), be 100% honest with rolls, take notes on dropped names, don't lie about memed spells and finally at least TRY to roleplay fear and horror. Which for some is crazy-difficult to do. And i am a huge fan of not needing to make fear and horror saves if roleplayed correctly. Even if my DM is not a fa of this rule it could only improve the game to act it out rather then be like...

Player One: rolls a 7. "Damn i failed."

DM: "...a powerful gripping fear takes hold of your mind and before you know it you a are running away screaming in the night of horrid, flapping winged things and the mere thought of seeing them again makes you feel shallow and faint.."

Player One: "Okay, so i take off running from the shifting werebat and by seeing the transformation i have a fear of bats and i wont go near anything that resembles a bat. That sucks. Very well, were shall i write that down?"

So with that i am asking DM's and fellow players how better to roleplay fear and horror. Keep in mind though that if it isn't good enough the glorious DM can still roll and strangly the less dice being rolled the better.

-vipera aspis

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 1:42 pm
by Isabella
Don't use them.

....

....

*runs*

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:13 pm
by Archedius
I really only use them for magical fear or madness. If you describe an encounter well enough your players will naturally be afraid of whatever it is. If you decimate them with the encounter and let them live- they'll have a natural trepidation towards it. No need to railroad them.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:15 pm
by NeoTiamat
I'm starting to come to the conclusion that Isabella is, if not right, then certainly on the tail of something.

Basically, the Fear or Horror check acts as a sign to PCs "Hey, you should be scared now." All well and good, except that it's a really bad sign if you need to tell your PCs that something is scary. I also don't find that they provoke good roleplaying. Some of the best roleplaying I've seen of terror and/or horror comes without the checks.

If the last time the PCs fought a monster, they lost a character, and now the main villain is walking around with six of the things in his entourage, that's terror. Failing a will save.... not so much.

Furthermore, fear and horror checks tend to be highly disruptive and not really all that fun. You have a great scene set up where an ominous Fey Lord reveals his utterly unnatural appearance. Horror Check!.....except that if a PC rolls poorly and snags the Enraged result, you are going to be missing a few PCs after the fight ends.

As for Fear Checks? Congratulations. Your PC can't participate in this fight. Guess he may as well go and get some more pizza.

Add to this the fact the current mechanic unduly penalizes some classes over others. The raging barbarian has a higher chance of being terrified of the foe than a weedy bookworm in the back. Or of being traumatized by some corpses. In my Campaign, the person who fails the most Horror Saves is supposed to be a hardened, cynical and world-weary ranger. The person who makes the most is a priest from a fairly sheltered background (comparatively, at least).

.....on the flip side, the idea of mechanical representations of fear and horror are good ideas, rather intriguing.

And some of the horror checks in particular have utterly fascinating character-development angles. Nightmares, for instance, is really interesting and opens up avenues to use the Nightmare Court. Fascination is a wonderful way to create an evil villain who's nonetheless scarily possible for the PCs. "There but for the grace of god go I." Only replace god with the dice.

So in the end, I'm torn about them. They're an interesting idea, but I'm coming to think they're a flawed execution. They have the potential for genuine character development, but even more potential for ticking off Players and character derailment when angry gods of chance rear their head.

For my part, I'm starting to use fewer of them, and in less critical situations. If I had to say how to fix them, I'd suggest you:

A. Remove the random chance element from them (at least in choosing what effect a failed roll gets).

B. Alter it so that they don't penalize certain classes any more. Perhaps just make it a level check?

C. Make the effects less intrusive. Sitting out a fight due to your mighty Forfarian woodsman crying like a little girl because of a zombie is not fun. The main point of the game is fun, after all.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:49 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Fear/horror checks are optional if the players role-play the fear and horror their character's would experience in a situation. It's supposed to be a tool to make people act as their characters would. But even I agree it's a flawed system. Negative reinforcement usually doesn't work.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:50 pm
by HuManBing
Call of Cthulhu has essentially a completely separate list of effects of failed madness rolls for each encounter.

I think the Fear and Horror checks have good creative outcomes but ideally you'd have collaboration between the DM and the player about what happens.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 3:15 pm
by Isabella
I'd suggest, at the very least, stripping out all of the most intrusive failure penalties. Nightmares means that an arcane caster can't regain spells, and I guarantee that the player is going to focus a lot more on that then the horrible, soul-wracking visions that plague his dreams every time he tries to sleep.

The reason I say don't use them is more to see if you can frighten the players without them. But let's be honest, a lot of them are exceptionally intrusive. Yeah, and it seemed like such a good idea the first time I played. But if you're just not feeling it... rolling a die doesn't make it any better, it just annoys you even more.

D&D's system doesn't help. I might be scared of zombies in "real life," but it's hard to be frightened of a monster that can only take a standard or a move action, not both. And I know that immediately people start screaming "metagaming!!!" at that assertion, but I can't really magically forget that the zombies pose absolutely no threat to my character. And metagaming works both ways. What do think a player can assume if the GM has a Darklord shut the domain boarders when they try to cross?

-An experienced Ravenloft Player knows the Darklord is mad, is coming for them, and there's nowhere to run!
-A Ravenloft newbie assumes the GM is railroading them. Badly.

I am reminded of a story from our old Ravenloft gaming group - the GM was running the players through the original Ravenloft module when the players ended up in the Balinoks. They were camping and trying to set up shelter when they felt the air around them become even colder, and heard an eerie singing coming towards them.

The Ravenloft newbies went ".....ooookay."
The man who had bought every Ravenloft book from 2nd ed. onward and had read them all cover to cover said "....Oh no. It's JEZRA WAGNER! RUUUUUUUN!"
The newbies, knowing that man had read every Ravenloft book cover to cover, agreed, and they ran before Jezra even reached the camp. It was the only time I'd ever seen the group realize they were outmatched before half the party was dead.

I've forgotten where I was going with that, but it's a good lesson, nonetheless.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 3:20 pm
by HuManBing
Isabella wrote:D&D's system doesn't help.
This is sadly the truth.

I'm DM'ing a 3.5 ed game that I inherited. They won't switch to GURPS, so my first step is to create new monsters from the ground up. This knocks out a good amount of metagaming.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 12:24 am
by Jester of the FoS
Fear and horror and madness are checks for those people who don't want to roleplay fear. If you're willing to role-play it shouldn't come up.

That said, I'm more in favour of a system that affects people for a round or two at most. If it takes a PC out of a fight it essentially screws the rest of the party. Monster effects that remove characters from play are factored into the XP, but environmental effects (like fear) aren't and essentially make fights harder for no compensatory reward.

I was long-tempted to make an alternate fear/horror system (there might even be one in a netbook somewhere) but with 4e I'm less interested in making 3e mechanics.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 7:24 am
by HuManBing
I suspect a lot of this was a 2e carryover from the fact that monsters and NPCs had Morale checks but PCs didn't. Ravenloft introduced a mechanic that evened the playing field.

Now 3e doesn't even have morale checks for monsters and NPCs, preferring to leave that to DM roleplaying. It stands to reason that PCs should have something similar too.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 3:09 pm
by vipera aspis
so uhhh......
no tips for roleplaying fear or horror then eh?

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 3:40 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Try looking at the effects of failure for fear and horror saves. Use them as ideas on how to express fear and horror via the character by acting like them. Of course if the atmosphere isn't scary, the DM isn't doing their job. You can't really portray fear without actually feeling it and evoking such emotions is part of the DM's job through narration, description, and ambiance.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 4:41 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
For that matter, you could try "reverse role-playing": stepping back from portraying your PC -- a trained and experienced adventurer -- for a moment, and trying to capture how you, yourself, might respond to the terrible threats your PC encounters. Let's face it: if a REAL enraged were-beast or ghostly apparition or filthy, rot-reeking, animated corpse pounced on any one of us, outside of a movie or a role-playing game, our immediate, instinctive reaction would not be jaded wisecracks or rolling-eyed disdain.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 7:54 pm
by Archedius
One thing you could do is actually make the monsters as nasty as they appear (or at least describe them in such a way that your PC's don't want to go near it).
An example would be your zombie burnout. Let's look at this in real life- why would people be afraid of a rotting corpse. It's a vivid reminder of our mortality yes, but why else? It offends all of our senses, it's simply not right to be around it. Why do our senses rail against a rotting corpse? We can get sick if we're near one or worse yet...touch one.
All rotting undead and most fleshed undead IMC carry at the very least filth fever. If a character is injured and fights one up close the DC to resist the disease is raised by +2. Bite and claw attacks always carry the disease as well. I also have the stench ability of the ghast on all rotting undead localized to an area of 10 feet around the individual.
...My players now use ranged and polearms against them for obvious reasons.

As Rotipher said- look at monsters and find out WHY they would be frightening in real life and emphasize that in your description, or as an extra step, houserule it in.

Posted: Sat Aug 16, 2008 2:45 pm
by Dr Carnivean
I think Fear and Horror checks can work, but only if used sparingly at the DM's discretion, mostly because of the randomness of the mechanic that people have been mentioning. If the checks are used too often, inevitably at some point there will be the situation of "well my character faced down Strahd von Zarovich with no problem, but something about
the way that zombie looked at him just now made him crap his pants"

But if they're only used for really major things, then it becomes more reasonable that someone would freak over one thing and not another.
In the last 13 sessions of my current campaign, I think I've only called for three fear checks; one in Castle Ravenloft, one for a powerful ghost's fear ability, and one for a Jason Voorhees style flesh golem that just cut an NPC in half right in front of them (and I had given him a couple fear causing abilities as well). The two horror checks I've called for were for an adventure I ran based on the "To Grandmother's House" scenario from the Heroes of Horror book which truly has a repulsive scene in it, which I felt warranted a check. I think a good rule of thumb for the DM is whenever thinking of calling for a check, to assume the characters will fail it and then decide whether that would be a reasonable response considering their level and what they have experienced in the past.
Of course, even a zombie can be horrifying to the experienced PC if it is the corpse of a loved one or a close friend. Or even an innocent, such as the zombie of a little girl dragging a human arm...


Speaking of zombies, I totally agree that the D&D system doesn't make them scary and I think that is one of the biggest problems Ravenloft DM's face. The D&D system is built for fighting dragons, giants, demons, and the avatars of people's evil gods that seem to show up every other week. The system doesn't favor 'stalking killer' monsters like Jack the Ripper or 'strength in numbers' monsters like zombies, rats, spiders, flesheating goblins, etc.
Ol Jack would have to be a high level rogue with lots of magic gear to even have a chance at taking out an average mid level D&D PC in a dark alley with a knife, and the zombies get it worst of all from the d20 system, as each zombie is made to keep a respectable five foot distance from his rotting companions, and only attack their victim two, or at most, three at a time.

I've tried to do the Night of the Living Dead thing on a number of different occasions, but never really got it to work. The closest I ever came was having the zombie mob take damage as individuals, but attack as a whole, meaning that each one was still relatively easy to put down, but they got attack and damage bonuses for each zombie in the mob, so that a group of ten zombies was hitting really hard, reflecting the fact that they would all be pushing in towards their victim, clawing and grasping with a dozen filthy nailed hands. I think the VRG to the Walking Dead has some good ideas for abilities to give zombies that break the normal rules to make zombies more of a threat. I think what made Night of the Walking Dead such a great module was that it was for very low level groups, so both the zombies and the serial killer were actually real threats to the group.