Page 1 of 1
Odd little thing re the darklord of Nova Vaasa
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 11:32 am
by Brandi
The other day I checked out Medieval Folklore : a guide to myths, legends, tales, beliefs, and customs from the library, and while reading a section on Nicknames (most of which were a) hilarious and b) probably unprintable here under our usual language guidelines), notice a comment that a general nickname, "Malkin", meant "low-class or sexually promiscuous woman". (It is also, if Google searches are any indication, the word from which "merkin"-- a pubic wig-- is derived from.)
Now I know most Ravenloft names are picked for blatant symbolism (Invidia, Dementlieu, Mt. Malcredo to name just a few), but this one struck me as particularly curious. Perhaps, despite what the current origin story for Tristen/Malken hints at, it's not Romir's spirit that needs to be placated...
[This fact is also a rich source of insult potential at the expense of frothing wingnut Michelle Malkin, but I'll save that for Sadly, No!]
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 12:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
I seriously doubt that any reference of the sort was intended. "Malken", spelled exactly as in the products, has referred to cats for centuries.
If anything, it might've been an unconscious parallel to Fritz Leiber's Gray Mouser, who was a virtual "other self" to his adventuring companion, Fafhrd. Tristan -- tall, hearty, blond, a womanizer -- bears something of a resemblence to Fafhrd.
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 12:35 pm
by Catman Jim
I had always thought "Malkin" meant "cat", possibly a reference to the plains cats in Nova Vaasa, but I see from my dictionary that it does indeed have multiple meanings.
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 12:43 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
If anything, the link to prostitutes is probably derived from the word's original connection to cats. Even today, "cathouse" has similar slang implications, doesn't it?
But that's probably enough discussion on this topic.
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 3:48 pm
by Brandi
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:If anything, the link to prostitutes is probably derived from the word's original connection to cats. Even today, "cathouse" has similar slang implications, doesn't it?
And let's not even get into the slang connotations of pussy.
Anyway, what if it isn't Romir's spirit perpetuating the curse? How, if at all, do you think that would change things?
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 4:05 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Depends what you're suggesting as an alternative. Do you mean that any prostitutes Malken murders are the ones driving the curse? If so, it seems bizarre that they'd be actively perpetuating the deaths of women like themselves. You'd think there'd be a measure of solidarity among ladies-of-the-evening, at least in some cases. Or is it that Tristan's mother is driving the curse, and she sees all the women in his life as prostitutes who deserve to die?
Personally, I've never been a fan of the "Romir = Malken" notion myself ... but then, I wouldn't much like it if some other spirit were to blame, either. Saying that it's anybody other than Tristan who's the real party at fault destroys the thematic concept of a man who's at war with his own dark side, which IMO is the most captivating thing about the character.
Me, I like to think that, while his curse was initially inherited, Tristan's own evil side has savored the crimes he'd been driven to commit, to a point where Malken doesn't need Romir's curse to goad him. Together with Tristan's own hypocritical refusal to simply turn himself in or kill himself, once he figured out Malken's nature, that makes him/them fully worthy of darklordship, unlike Romir ... whom, after all, the DPs could have simply brought back as a ghost, had his crime merited their attentions more than those of his dual-natured son.
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2008 11:36 am
by Brandi
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Or is it that Tristan's mother is driving the curse, and she sees all the women in his life as prostitutes who deserve to die?
I was thinking his mother-- and less that she sees the women as deserving to die than working on ruining the male descendants-- I suspect Nova Vaasans in general and Romir in particular don't value daughters over-highly.
Me, I like to think that, while his curse was initially inherited, Tristan's own evil side has savored the crimes he'd been driven to commit, to a point where Malken doesn't need Romir's curse to goad him. Together with Tristan's own hypocritical refusal to simply turn himself in or kill himself, once he figured out Malken's nature, that makes him/them fully worthy of darklordship, unlike Romir ... whom, after all, the DPs could have simply brought back as a ghost, had his crime merited their attentions more than those of his dual-natured son.
Probably so, although the fact that the curse is potentially inheritable speaks to something more than Tristan's own inner demons.
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2008 1:19 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
True ... but the Hiregaards' tendency to mental illness, and to having a contrary "dark side" behind their do-gooder facades, is also hereditary (LotB). If Tristan dies, it may be his eldest son's alter-ego who takes up the name of "Malken" and the status of darklord, not the original. That would allow for unique character-traits in each of "Malken's" successive incarnations, while preserving Nova Vaasa's underlying theme of people fighting their own darkness, and losing.
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2008 7:51 pm
by Manofevil
I had an idea once for Tristan/Malken. I never posted it just because I wanted finish writing this story about them first. Basicly, Someone (doesn't matter who) figures out that Tristan and Malken are the same person and succeeds in assassinating Tristan. Tristan's secret is revealed to the general populace and the entire realm rejoices at the passing of Malken. Some time later, the assassin is found brutally murdered and Malken's operations somehow start up again. It's believed that Malken has somehow returned, though investigators make a point of verifying that Tristan Hiregaard is, in fact, dead. What no one knows is that Malken has somehow possessed someone else (not necessarily another Hiregaard) in the same way he possessed Tristan. This new host is far less potent than Tristan was and Malken finds himself operating without the constant interference of his other side. The new host however begins to change subtley. He begins to demonstrate skills that Tristan was known for. His appearance begins to change until he resembles the late Tristan Hiregaard. Most infuriating of all to Malken, He proves just as adept at interfering with Malken's schemes as Tristan was. Malken provokes a confrontation with the new host and rages impotently when ne discovers that he is as cursed with Tristan as Tristan is with him.
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2008 11:08 pm
by order99
Not bad at all-if the Voices In My Head ever let me finish studying for my A+ /Network exams, I may have to, er, borrow that idea...sadly, my group is on hold for the time being due to said training.
