Page 1 of 1
New editions, should fans/previous authors be consulted?
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 6:25 pm
by cure
I do not mean to pose the following questions in isolation from economics, that is to say, I am not presuming an ideal world.
With that as a preamble, do we as a community which has kept Ravenloft alive and in particular which is blessed with members who even were at the helm of Ravenloft 3e, have a legitimate expectation to be consulted so as to help ensure both continuity and quality in any future products and/or editions?
What level of interactivity is to be reasonably expected and reasonably demanded between seller and buyer in this move towards a largely web mediated gaming universe?
Are we, so far as Wizards are concerned, a valued resource, a fly in the ointment, something in between, or simply ignorable, or rather something all together different?
Can the partial control that we have been able to exercise over Ravenloft in the last few years find and/or have any place in the the masterplan of Wizards?
Thoughts are evidently most welcome . . .
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 6:39 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Fan point of view (and mine): yes, of course they should. They should in fact hire those guys to make the 4e version (the kargatane, Rucht, Ari, Miller, and some others).
Business point of view: maybe, but that's not the first thing they have in mind.
In any case, the 4e incarnation of the setting will first follow the orientation WotC wants to give to the setting (whatever these are, do not presume any direction, as we do not know where they want to get with RL, with 4e, with all previous settings, with D&D the game as a whole, etc.).
Maybe we'll be thrilled, maybe we won't (EtCR!).
---
Dragon will give a good idea of it.
Good news: it will be soon.
Joël
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 6:43 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Since we don't know what's going on inside it's hard to say. But I'd think in the cases of established campaign worlds that WotC would refer to the previous material and the established fan base. We're the ones who will be most interested in buying the books and thus make up a significant part of the sales, even those of us not too enamored of 4e just yet

.
But this is in the hands of executives, most likely. From experience I can say that management, especially in big companies, only cares about the bottom line. If they think something new will be better for their stock options than we might as well be dead for all they care. And, as Mr. Mangrum can attest, even the authors/fans working for the company get ignored if the folks upstairs think their idea is better (and then they blame us peons for sub-par performance when it was their "decisions" that caused the problem even when those of us who know what we're doing tried to point out the problems...

).

Sorry. I've just had a bad week at the office with this same exact problem.
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 9:01 pm
by NeoTiamat
Well, here's an interesting question for you: What do the fans want?
....
Not so easy a question to answer, hrm? Thing is, the more people are involved in a fandom, the more different answers to this question there will be.
I, for example, am pretty radical in Ravenloft. I'm very skeptical on a lot of the old, mechanical aspects of Ravenloft such as Fear/Horror/Madness checks or closed domain borders. This is very different from what, say, High Priest Mikhal wants on one side of me, or Isabella on the other side of me.
From the point of view of the corporations, consulting the fandom is a highly dubious venture at best, since they all have different ideas, nor are we really a representative sample of the fandom as a whole, because we're all the hardcore enthusiasts.
They might be wise to consult previous authors, if they were generally popular throughout. But fandom? Frankly, I wouldn't, were I Wizards.
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 11:01 pm
by Zettaijin
Hate to be a cheerleader, but I really think you hit the nail on the head there NeoTiamat.
If it reassures you, I too feel that many of the mechanical aspects of Ravenloft are a little on the broken side.
Posted: Thu Sep 11, 2008 11:19 pm
by HuManBing
I have a very clear idea of what I want my Ravenloft campaign to run like. It really doesn't matter what Wizards (or the Fraternity or anybody else for that matter) puts out, I'll only cherrypick what I like and ignore the rest.
This is becoming more apparent as my GURPS conversion progresses. Much of the 3E mechanics are now useless for me, and the 4E ones are worse than useless - so that means I'm only interested in the fluff. If Wizards ties this in too strongly to a core world I don't like and won't support, I will have no use for 4E Ravenloft even from a fluff perspective.
I outgrew Wizards a while ago. I have found relatively little of their fluff worth my attention. Ravenloft 4E may be different but given that I'm entirely disinterested in 4E mechanics the margin of relevance here is very slim.
Posted: Fri Sep 12, 2008 2:53 am
by DasSoviet
Joël of the FoS wrote:Fan point of view (and mine): yes, of course they should. They should in fact hire those guys to make the 4e version (the kargatane, Rucht, Ari, Miller, and some others).
Business point of view: maybe, but that's not the first thing they have in mind.
Exactly! While the fans want and what the company wants are two different things. The fans (
generally) want their setting expanded on and grown, adding more layers and concepts to the game. The company, however, wants to make as much money as possible, and if the current fanbase cannot supply that, then they must look elsewhere. That may require a complete reworking of the setting that drives most of the current fans away, but if they gain more fans by their revision, in the end that was a better decision for the company. That's what they're trying with Forgotten Realms, while they're going with the fans for Eberron. Likely future decisions will be made on the success of these two lines...
That's just my current thinking, I could be dead wrong...
Posted: Fri Sep 12, 2008 3:11 am
by Jester of the FoS
If WotC does release Ravenloft for 4e they will likely keep the rules and Player's Guide in-house for quality reasons (part of the "everything is Core" philosophy). But I can see a couple freelancers being brought in Campaign Guide.
Posted: Fri Sep 12, 2008 7:37 am
by Creepy Old Woman
I am not too worried about what WoTC would do. (Then again, I actually like 4ed... it's different from 3.5, but still enjoyable nonetheless.) If I don't like some things about it, I'll just change it in my own campaign! It's pretty blasphemous but I actually ignored most of the maths and checks needed in the canon RL lore for my own campaigns.
Having said that, I wish they would create better new domains. No more rubbishy ones like that... thing with the laughing jester and the unhappy king.
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 3:49 am
by Pamela
NeoTiamat wrote:Well, here's an interesting question for you: What do the fans want?
....
Not so easy a question to answer, hrm? Thing is, the more people are involved in a fandom, the more different answers to this question there will be.
I, for example, am pretty radical in Ravenloft. I'm very skeptical on a lot of the old, mechanical aspects of Ravenloft such as Fear/Horror/Madness checks or closed domain borders. This is very different from what, say, High Priest Mikhal wants on one side of me, or Isabella on the other side of me.
From the point of view of the corporations, consulting the fandom is a highly dubious venture at best, since they all have different ideas, nor are we really a representative sample of the fandom as a whole, because we're all the hardcore enthusiasts.
They might be wise to consult previous authors, if they were generally popular throughout. But fandom? Frankly, I wouldn't, were I Wizards.
Very well put, NeoTiamat.
If WotC did choose to listen to fans, the next question would have to be "Which fans of Ravenloft should they listen to?"
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 10:12 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
FWIW, I'm not concerned about how Ravenloft will fare in the future, even if it's never updated to 4E. Heck, the Known World hasn't had anything fresh published for it since the classic OD&D line was canceled in the early 90s, yet the Mystara fan-community has produced more high-grade material for their setting than any other, AFAIK! And that's for a setting whose fans have always been split between OD&D, 1E, 2E, 3E and/or 4E.
So if we don't like what WotC does with the Land of Mists, there's no law that says we can't write it off as Ravenloft's version of Joshuan's Almanac, and keep the setting alive indefinitely without their help. Why lock a world up into just one rule system? Ravenloft, like Mystara, is driven by its well-realized characters and engaging concepts, not mechanics. The more independent of rules a setting's selling points are, the more edition-proof it is. I could probably run a Ravenloft game using nothing but flipped coins if I had to, so why worry about rule-revisions?
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 11:47 am
by High Priest Mikhal
So long as the spirit remains the same (the darklords are prisoners of their own sins, the Mists are beyond comprehension, things are Gothic) I really don't care what happens. Like HMB I just pick what I like and toss out the rest. I am pretty interested in seeing if this fiend that's supposed to be involved with the Darkonese See of Ezra and and the Blessed Army of Ezra ever come to blows (Why do I keep hearing Stryper whenever I hear the name of the BAoE?

).
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 2:32 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Consulting fans and users is a well-established practice in design and marketing circles. Most of the time, its done through surveys, focus groups and test runs ("playtesting" in RPGs). Purists and Hard-core fans are better avoided for this purpose, as they have tastes and ideas not shared by the majority of the product's intended audience. In other words, consulting folks on this site about designing Ravenloft would make as much sense as consulting the Forgotten Realms crowd.
Also, the Fraternity never had any control over the setting at all - not even partial. Our sole power comes from choosing what stuff to include in our home games. This is both more and less.
And as NeoTiamat pointed out, we here, though we at times feel like we share common tastes in Ravenloft, seldom agree when it comes to specifics. A lot of people claim Vlad Drakov's background begs to be redone. Other folks (like me) think he is already one of the best darklords as written. Some people want to make non-human races more prevalent. Others would rework them so they are less so. Some people want to expand the setting to include Steampunk, Lovecraft and Fantasy Horror. Others want pure gothic atmosphere and nothing but.
And, though that point is almost taboo to mention, not all people here have liked all of the internet content the Fraternity has produced. That doesn't make the content bad. Just not fit for everyone's games.
Not everyone downright hated EtCR, either.
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 4:19 pm
by cure
'Control' was actually a reference back to the Kargatane.
As to fans and previous authors, I would never suggest that things be put up for votes and such. Instead, the most basic consultation with almost any handful of past authors, members of the Frat inner circle, or us plebs would have sufficed, for example, to establish that Vistani halflings or Vistani hags might be a flawed concept.
Posted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 10:24 pm
by Archedius
I want the Kargat/3rd edition authors (or even the Frat!) to be tapped for 4E Ravenloft. I have Heroes of Horror and it's ok but I really, really hate EtCR. I at least hope they acknowledge or even incorporate what's come before.