Page 1 of 1
"Is this Evil? Or Just Taking Out The Trash?"
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2008 4:58 pm
by Leliel
Technically not Ravenloft, but still, this is the system that gave us DP checks...
I found a thread, this one by RavingDork, about one of his 4E pallies:
We have a paladin of Bahamut in our group who is absolutely ardent about battling evil without mercy. Now, I know paladins can no longer lose their powers in 4th Edition, but if they break their vows/code/whatever, their church might seek to punish them for their transgressions. Their alignment might change to match their continuing deeds as well. Hopefully, you see where this is going by now.
After a successful adventure involving the tracking down and capture (via a vicious battle followed by an Intimidate check) of a known killer and heretic, the party is traveling back to the church on their horses with the prisoner in tow (being pulled along by the paladin's horse with hands bound). The heretic called out to his captor, tha paladin, and insulted his faith and threatened death and dismemberment to his loved ones (something about having powerful friends).
Suddenly, the paladin stopped his horse, dismounted, drew his sword as he made his way to the captive (who began to scream for mercy) and then brutally hacked at the tendons in the captive's legs. The paladin then remounted and began DRAGGING the now crippled heretic behind his horse. He did not survive the two day journey to the church for trial.
The other characters were too feaked out by the deed and too intimidated by the paladin to do anything about it.
Having killed a heretic of the church, the paladin likely won't suffer much more than a slap on the wrist from his superiors (it is not for you to decide who is to be punished before trial!), but I'm wondering if I should change his alignment to evil. The paladin has always been brutal and merciless in his fight against evil, but this seems to me like a new height of depravity for him.
Looking for opinions on the matter. What would you, as a DM do, if anything?
I personally suggested he homebrew a Blackguard PP for him, but what do you think?
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2008 7:38 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Definitely evil. The prisoner hadn't actually done anything nasty, he'd just threatened to. Sounds to me like this paladin was acting out of sheer hot temper and personal affrontedness, without any moral warrant or justified necessity whatsoever. Sounds pretty Chaotic Evil to me.
At the most, the paladin might've been justified in gagging the captive to prevent further verbal slurs against his faith. Instead, he quite literally tortured a helpless prisoner to death for mouthing off: an act even many Evil-aligned people would be ashamed of, considering how thin-skinned and undisciplined it shows the (rotten excuse for a) paladin to be.
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2008 8:03 pm
by Archedius
wow- that player is poor at playing a pally. umm the only way I could see that working is of he were the paladin of a chaotic evil deity (if we allow all faiths to have paladins). Otherwise- wow, just wow.
Why didn't the other players do anyhting about this? The church certainly should as the 'paladin' not only went against procedure he presumed to judge the prisoner instead of the church not to mention tortured and killed a defenseless man. There's no honor, no restraint, no respect and no justification for what he did. I have no clue how that character could've even gone through training nor how his God would choose him as a paragon.
If I were the DM, I'd have the player kicked out of the group. If a player chooses to play a paladin and out of the blue does something this childish... well the other players deserve someone better to play along with.
For in game I would have the players character put on trial and executed by the church. It would be different if this was a planned fall from grace or possession but the example doesn't seem to be in this context.
Reading this makes me glad that I've never really had childish players.
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2008 8:54 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Yup, evil. I'm slightly lenient on what paladin's can lawfully do (legal codes being more lenient and death sentences more common). I'd have accepted the pally gagging or even removing the tongue as cruel and harsh but not necessarily eeee-vil.
Or even a quick coup de grace. Saving the courts an expensive trial. Evil is punished, yay good.
But crippling the person then dragging them behind you is torture, and a painful agonizing death. That's a slow unnecessary way to kill someone. That's evil. Heck, that's chaotic evil.
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2008 11:19 pm
by ewancummins
Well, in Ravenloft he'd definitely be making a couple of powers checks.
Paladins cannot fall from grace in 4E? That, my freind, is very lame. Well, maybe I'm just old fashioned.
Executing enemy rather than bringing him to trial might well be perfectly acceptable under certain circumstances, but cripplng and then dragging a man to death for talking smack seems a bit much. The guy was a murderer? Then hang him. But the personal cruelty and rage of that paladin were very much giving in to the Dark Side of the Force, IMO.
Now, I've played a PC who would have done the exact same thing. Not a paladin, though [actually that PC was lawful evil - ruthless but with a code of honor].
Re: "Is this Evil? Or Just Taking Out The Trash?"
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 2:37 am
by The Giamarga
It is also a very unlawful act for a paladin. I think he wouldn´t just earn a slap on the wrist from his superiors. At least not if they are paladins aor lawful aligned.
Try to translate it into modern terms and then see what peoples reactions to it would be. (I.e. paladin = Texas Ranger or FBI special agent, etc...)
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:49 am
by Desertrising
I am one of those Dungeon Masters who does allow his players to use more than lawful good for their paladins. However in fourth ed alignment is a joke and the paladin does not have any kind of code.
The act the paladin in question committed was evil there is no doubt. However we only have to look back at the catholic church to see why his actions may have gone unpunished. After all the inquisition did many many evil things, but because they were not only members of the church but also were able to intimidate citizens and the like they got away with horrible things.
Personally as a DM unless this was the kind of character he stated he planned on playing (which I would of said no too) then I would feel like I needed to punish his character. Also I would have to really wonder if I would want him to continue in my game...
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:53 am
by Jester of the FoS
ewancummins wrote:Paladins cannot fall from grace in 4E? That, my freind, is very lame. Well, maybe I'm just old fashioned.
It's one of those things that was never done well.
In 2e you pretty much became a figher, which was just losing your paladin powers.
But in 3e you pretty much became a fighter w/o bonus feats and were suddenly little more than a spiffy NPC warrior. Unless you went blackguard. There was no CG or Neutral options to make those paladin levels more than a waste.
In 4e with the giant stacks of powers and class-feats it suddenly becomes even a larger headache.
Fall from grace. Should there be fallen powers that replace yours? Should you suddenly become a fighter? Do you take alternate class features?
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:59 am
by Desertrising
From a lots of fun POV, falling from power could be replacing powers with fallen powers. For the most part you wouldn't atually have to change more than the flavor and the power source I suppose (instead of divine move it too shadow or elemental maybe?)
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 10:00 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
FWIW, even if the so-called paladin's church is totally corrupt, it's likely that his superiors would frown on his actions. Letting a hothead like him get away with performing such a grotesque deed on his own initiative would mean surrendering some of their authority to a 'loose cannon', and forfeiting authority is something a power-corrupted institution is never eager to do. After all, who's to say he might not turn against them one day, if he thinks his own judgement supercedes that of his bosses?
Even if it's just for violating procedure, he should get a lot more than a slap on the wrist for this. Paladins are militant characters, and should be held up to a military standard of discipline by their church superiors.
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 12:50 pm
by HuManBing
This is a cold blooded act of torture against a helpless individual that no morally good being would brook. It is devoid of even the slightest justification of self-defence, and would be punished in all but the most amoral of legal codes.
...
Needless to say I'm going to steal it for the Bladeforge. Thumbs up!
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2008 7:29 pm
by Archedius
It's always a good feeling when Rotipher shares an opinion with you : )
I had a thought- it is rather frightening to realize that in our history, the closest people to paladins we had were priests that went into battle with maces. They wouldn't shed blood, but they found a way to still kill in the name of their God.
I can see Ravenloftian Paladins sometimes going this route of loose interperetation. This is disturbing to me, especially seeing as how the DP's seem to grant all 'divine' power and emphasize dogma over alignment.
Posted: Tue Sep 30, 2008 11:28 am
by ewancummins
Jester of the FoS wrote:ewancummins wrote:Paladins cannot fall from grace in 4E? That, my freind, is very lame. Well, maybe I'm just old fashioned.
It's one of those things that was never done well.
In 2e you pretty much became a figher, which was just losing your paladin powers.
But in 3e you pretty much became a fighter w/o bonus feats and were suddenly little more than a spiffy NPC warrior. Unless you went blackguard. There was no CG or Neutral options to make those paladin levels more than a waste.
In 4e with the giant stacks of powers and class-feats it suddenly becomes even a larger headache.
Fall from grace. Should there be fallen powers that replace yours? Should you suddenly become a fighter? Do you take alternate class features?
I actually prefer the way 3E handles it, oddly enough. Becoming a fighter seems unsatisfactory, because it implies paladins are better than fighters. They aren't, they are just different.
If you really want champions of other alignments, the work has already been done for you. There are , in fact, options for ''paladins'' of every alignment, from LG to CE. Check out the Dragon Magazine article ''A Plethora of Paladins.'' In the Paizo published Dragon Compendium, the article was updated for 3E. There are also three paladin variants in the 3E Unearthed Arcana.