Page 1 of 1

Maps - Prop or tool?

Posted: Mon Oct 13, 2008 6:40 pm
by ReDeeMeR
Greetings,
After countless attempts to register on the forum, using over half a dozen different email accounts, i finally made it :D. I've been a lurker for quite some time now, and a dedicated RL fan and DM for over 12 years.
And it's because of guys and gals like you, and all the other people in past RL forums, that I still find inspiration for running successful campaigns despite the setting's 'official' demise. So, before I say anything else, a big thank you goes to each and every one of you in here. And please (oh please) keep up the great work!
Now, I thought it would be impolite to make my first post without anything to offer, being greek and all (and no trojans are involved this time :))
So I'm linking a few of the maps I've made this year, and hope they'd be of use to you somehow.

Core map Pre-CG This is the core map, closely based on the original of the 1st edition boxed set. With a lot of additional details (canon, semi-canon, or fan-based) from the various official or netbook sources.

Souragne This is my version of the island of Souragne, with as much details I could find about it (many thanks to the excellent gazetteer of the FoS).

Port-a-Lucine This is my version of Dementlieu's capital city, hand drawn and losely based on the map of the 1st edition boxed set. Legends are missing (because I usually use a transparent slide on top of the maps with all major sites, districts and buildings marked on it) but some things should be (semi)obvious like the Cathedral in the center and Rose avn. in a spiral form. The clouds are there because I made that map having a gallery-piece-of-art prop in mind, so I apologize if they get in the way too much :wink:

(Currently working on a map of the Shadowlands.)

So, how do you use maps in your game? Have you ever used one as a prop? Was it successful? And if you are using maps only as a reference tool do you prefer them sketchy but practical or elaborate but loaded?

Hope to hearing from you,
my regards

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 3:26 am
by The Giamarga
Welcome to the forums! Those are some very nice maps. Good work. If you 've got more of these by all means post them. Or better yet submit them to the site and let them be hosted in the approrpiate room here. The Shadowlands map would be a nice contribution to the WIP Shadowland Gazetteer netbook, if the project should really survive it's birthing pains.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 4:10 am
by ReDeeMeR
Thank you Giamarga, I will try to upload as much as possible.
One question though, how should I submit them?

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 4:55 am
by cure
If every new member brought maps like this, we would have to offer a bounty on new members.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 5:03 am
by ReDeeMeR
I am very glad you like them cure :)

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 5:13 am
by ReDeeMeR
If anyone knows any additional canon geographical details about the Core map, such as some missing river, lake or hill names, please point them out to me so I can update the map properly.
Thank you again.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 7:54 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Glad to see you finally registered successfully, ReDeeMeR! :D


If you're looking for more things to add to the map, Ghastria ought to be tacked onto the western edge of the Core. That's where it was when the domain was first introduced, before the expansion of the Sea of Sorrows.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 8:48 am
by Strahdsbuddy
Very nice work ReDeeMeR. Much easier to read than the Black Box maps.

To answer your question, i enjoy maps in all forms, but i only ever made ONE for my players to see. It was a VERY rough sketch of the Core on a piece of yellow legal paper. Just borders and country names. As i think about it it is pretty ridiculous, but my players still tease me about how they eliminated the Falkovnian threat by simply burning Drakov's land out of the center of my map while i went to the refrigerator. I guess that would constitute "prop."

On a related note, i know it has been brought up in the Ultimate Ravenloft thread and in several before that, if you were really going to use the map as a prop you should probably redraw it as it would be seen by a native. Political borders are probably the first things to change, as Forlorn, Arkendale, Verbrek and possibly even Tepest and Invidia wouldn't really register to Ravenloft Natives as "Countries." Same with lands that don't have human residents, like Bluetspur and Arak.

Once again, excellent work! And welcome to the family!

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 9:20 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Excellent maps! Some of the best fan-made maps I've ever seen! (and better than some published ones!)


I haven't made my own maps, but I've heavily altered the published ones, removing DM-only info, adding new canon info, like you did, and adding my own non-canon additions for the adventure in question.

I definitely use maps as props. They give the players a real sense of space that's lacking if they don't know where anything is. Even in a town, just knowing the general layout makes it stand out from all the other hundreds of towns. And when you're talking about Falkovnian's mobilizing for war against the Four Towers, if the players can't see a map, you might as well be talking about the "thingamabobs attacking the whozeewhatsits."

It's actually become a running gag in my campaign that the first thing they do in a new town is look for a scribe to buy a map of the area.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 1:05 pm
by ReDeeMeR
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Ghastria ought to be tacked onto the western edge of the Core
Oh, Ghastria. That one struck a long forgotten chord in my brain. Are there any maps depicting the position of the domain in relation to the Core? I though it was in the black box that we first took a glimpse of the map as a whole, though I may be wrong (and that first map included the Sea of Sorrows which appeared in 630BC).
Strahdsbuddy wrote:if you were really going to use the map as a prop you should probably redraw it as it would be seen by a native. Political borders are probably the first things to change, as Forlorn, Arkendale, Verbrek and possibly even Tepest and Invidia wouldn't really register to Ravenloft Natives as "Countries." Same with lands that don't have human residents, like Bluetspur and Arak
Excellent point, and though I haven't read that thread yet, I made the maps using multiple layers just for the sake of easy & custom configuration (i.e a layer for the rivers, one for the roads, one for text etc).

---If anyone wants any of the maps in the layered, high-res format just let me know. Have in mind though that most of the files are over 100mb.---
gonzoron wrote:I haven't made my own maps, but I've heavily altered the published ones, removing DM-only info, adding new canon info, like you did, and adding my own non-canon additions for the adventure in question.
Again, a layered format is the best choice for that kind of work. It even allows me to slowly update the player's map as they get to know more of the world (at first they usually get a very lite version of their homeland and surrounding area, modified by ranks in various knowledge skills). The only con is that I get to print alot :)

My thanks to all you guys and girls for your kind words and the most warm welcome I could ever hope for.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 1:25 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
ReDeeMeR wrote:Oh, Ghastria. That one struck a long forgotten chord in my brain. Are there any maps depicting the position of the domain in relation to the Core? I though it was in the black box that we first took a glimpse of the map as a whole, though I may be wrong (and that first map included the Sea of Sorrows which appeared in 630BC).
Ghastria was actually introduced in the Darklords supplement, which is why it's not on the original Black Box map. It was initially wedged in between the Misty Border, Sithicus, and one of the adjacent nations (I forget which). It was relocated after the Grand Conjunction, once the Sea of Sorrows -- the body of water, that is -- to grew big enough to encompass several island domains.

There was never a map of Ghastria as a whole, just its village of East Riding. It was always tiny, though ... so very small, in fact, that Darklords' writers could get away with adding the domain, despite it not being on the early maps. It's like if a large-scale map of IRL Europe left out Luxemburg or Andorra.

Posted: Tue Oct 14, 2008 2:55 pm
by ReDeeMeR
Got it ;) I have Darklords somewhere, im gonna find it and try to fit the little beauty in the map. Thanx Rotipher

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 3:59 am
by The Giamarga
ReDeeMeR wrote:One question though, how should I submit them?
I'm not sure. Any of the admins care to comment? Is there a map section?