Page 1 of 1

commoner advancement

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 4:52 am
by Strahdsbuddy
This is probably an antquated concept with the 4e genisis, but was any thought ever given to the way commoners (And experts, and all NPCS for taht matter) advance in level? Is it an even system, like 4XP per day, or would you average out the number of times in his life he's used his profession/craft skill and assign XP based on that? And How high do they rise? What does a 20th level Commoner do for fun?

From a Ravenloft point of view, the "Huddled Masses" should be difficult to tell apart, but i am trying to figure out if there is a method that i am missing, or does the DM just say "THis guy is the town elder, so make him level 5"

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 6:02 am
by The Giamarga
Here's a summary post about 3E NPC classses and advancement (the 10th post in the thread is about NPC classes, has lots of further links with depth discussions and example NPCs from ENWorld)

The 1xp per day theory works out quite nicely with human NPCs advancing to 6th or 7th level or so before dying of old age. This would of course be the default, the DM can assign the town elder any level he wants to. But it is a helpful reminder that most people of the game world need not be 1st level. Those are only the adolescents imho.

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:21 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Unlike PCs, non-player characters do not accumulate XP. No matter their class, they are simply assigned a level based on their story purpose and concept. For example, the local sheriff, who's been obstinately studying swordmastery his entire life, might be a 5th-level fighter, despite never having a faced a single monster. In the same manner, a 12th-level wizard might have hardly ever left his tower, but acquired his powers through years of study.

The same goes for commoners and experts. When it would be logical for them to get better at their job, they do.

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:58 pm
by ewancummins
Igor the Henchman wrote:Unlike PCs, non-player characters do not accumulate XP. No matter their class, they are simply assigned a level based on their story purpose and concept. For example, the local sheriff, who's been obstinately studying swordmastery his entire life, might be a 5th-level fighter, despite never having a faced a single monster. In the same manner, a 12th-level wizard might have hardly ever left his tower, but acquired his powers through years of study.

The same goes for commoners and experts. When it would be logical for them to get better at their job, they do.
That's exactly my view.

re

Posted: Wed Oct 15, 2008 11:28 pm
by Jack of Tears
Ultimately, yes, the level of an npc is determined by what you need in your story ... if you are looking for a rule, to determine how to measure xp as befits age, I tend to assign 1 level per ten years of life after age six ... so 1st lvl at 16, then I level every ten years which follow ... considering most midieval people live about 50, that works out just fine.

Posted: Thu Oct 16, 2008 6:16 am
by Strahdsbuddy
I certainly get that it is a story-driven system, and you assign levels as you see fit. I was just curious if there was a system out there. From a demographic standpoint, i was curious if there was some sort of pyramid whereby a own of a certain size could be expected to ahve this many NPCs of 1st level, this many of 2nd, etc.

I can imagine, however, a system whereby someone with the skill Profession (Farmer) would wake up on his first day of his new live as a farmer, Take 20 on his Farming skill, and gain XP for it...or a lazy one would not. It is simple to say that every 26 year old in the village is level 2, but also a little silly, don't you think?

I like the idea of each month being an encounter, though again it pretty much evens out everyone by age alone. Not that it is necissary to map out the month-by-month life of every NPC in the game.

Thanks Giamarga for all the links! SKR's theory makes the most sense to me, honestly. I still wouldn't mind pitting my players agaisnt a canny 20th level Commoner Overlord, though.

Posted: Thu Oct 16, 2008 6:34 am
by The Giamarga
My pleasure. I love those ENworld threads (unfortunately the Common commoner thread link is dead, though you can still find bits of it in the google cache)

I for one really like that the system works if you go with a more simulationist approach than "it works as the DM says". And i enjoyed MavrickWeirdo's and Blackdyrge's NPC over a lifetime threads immensely.

PS: There's a 12th level commoner in the links too and he actually makes sense.

PPS: Here's an ongoing Story Hour called the Commoner Campaign from wizards forums which might interest you. It recounts the adventures of Joe Wood the commoner as has some adventures but only levels up in the commoner class. (It's an acount of an actual solo campaign DMed by the author.)