Page 1 of 1

3.5 edition spells questions

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:18 am
by kottakinge
Just a question about a spell called spike growth in 3.5 edition.
The druid launch this spell IMC and we were disagree about the spell area.
It's one 20 foot square/level.
This mean that a 8th level druid launch 8 square of 20 feet each or 1 square of 160 feet ?
Thanks.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:17 am
by Ail
I think it would be a square 160ft on each side. That is, I'd always make it a square, and consider that the 20ft/level is the defining dimension.

This stays in line with the example diagrams given in the DMG for cone and circular areas, where the radius and side always increase proportionately.

Alex

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 12:36 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
That's actually not an easy call, given that most spells don't specify one X'-square/level! The various Wall spells use that phrasing, but they also refer to their outcome as Effects rather than Areas, and give explicit examples of those Effects' versatility in their descriptions.

Moreover, there's no (S) in the Area listing for Spike Stones, as there would be if the caster could choose where each of the several contiguous 20' squares should go. So a single, unshapeable square of spikes, 20'/level on each side, is the more plausible interpretation, IMO.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 1:06 pm
by Jester of the FoS
It's 8 squares of 20'. And it is an easy call.

This is really bad math at work and being unable to visualize the spell.
20'x20' is:
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
or 16 squares.

So at third level it would twice that or 64 squares.
XXXX XXXX XXXX
XXXX XXXX XXXX
XXXX XXXX XXXX
XXXX XXXX XXXX

You cannot form a perfect square with that. It's 20'x60'. NOT 60'x60'. And if you did it would be 40'x40' which changes the shape of the spells effect.


There are a handful of spells like that, which have unusual sizes and defy the area rules in the magic section. Probably bad updates from 2e.
One 20' square per level means that you can affect 20x'20'xcaster level, in little squares. Or, on a map, a number of 4x4 squares/ caster level.

As a DM I'd argue that they need to be continuous but not a giant square (especially since, at level 8, you'd be one 20' square away from making that giant square). Instead you could make a 160' long but 20' wide wall of spike growth.

It is definitely NOT a giant 160' square because that is HUGE and each level adds an increasingly large amount of area to the spell.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 1:10 pm
by NeoTiamat
Considering that 160' feet is 32 squares to a side, and thus larger than the majority of battlefields, I'd second Jester's point. At any rate, it's what I'd rule in my games.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 2:06 pm
by Jester of the FoS
If it was the other way, it'd mean at 7th level they'd have 28sq x 28sq and gain over 100 extra squares of effect when they levelled-up. And each subsequent level would exponentially increase the area of effect.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 4:25 pm
by kottakinge
Indeed it's huge.
But it's a druid spell and i'm not surprised that he could affect such a large area of the forest.

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 8:25 pm
by Sorti
What Jester said. It's clarified in the FAQ, if I remember correctly.

Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 11:10 am
by Ail
Ok, I went over the whole PhB just to try to understand this clear. I was not convinced by Jester's arguments, not at the start, but I made a full list of all spells I encountered which had an area dependent on caster's level. Here it is:

Control Water: 10ft/lev x 10ft/lev x 2ft/lev
Control Winds: 40ft/lev radius cylinder 40ft high
Fire Storm: two 10ft cubes per level
Forbiddance: 60ft cube/level
Guards and Wards: up to 200 sq.ft/level (S)
Hallucinatory Terrain: one 30-ft cube / lev (S)
Locate object: circle with radius 400ft + 40ft/lev
Mordenkainen's Private Sanctum: 30ft cube/lev (S)
Otiluke's Freezing Sphere: depth of 6 inches over an area of 100sq feet (10ft square) per caster level (max 1500 sq feet)
Quench: 20ft cube/lev (S)
Repulsion: 10ft / level radius
Reverse Gravity: up to one 10ft-cube per 2 levels
Screen: 30ft-cube/lev(S)
Soften Earth and Stone: 10ft sq/lev
Spike Growth: one 20ft sq/lev
Spike Stones: one 20ft sq/lev
TRansmute mud to rock: Up to two 20ft cubes/level (S)
TRansmute rock to mud: Up to two 20ft cubes/level (S)
Several walls: area usually measure on number of x-ft sq / lev

Not many, as you can see. So, what do I take from here?

There is a neat class of spells, usually shapeable (Spike Growth's omission of (S) must be a bug) that specify a certain number (usually one) of cubes per level. That's the case of the OP. Count a linear number of cubes (or squares) with the mentioned side and arrange them as needed.

However, this is not so for all spells, and we should be attentive to them:
Repulsion and Locate Object specify circle areas with the radius increasing linearly with level. This means a quadratic increase in the affected area, indeed. So, at level 10, Repulsion has a 100ft radius, for an area of Pi * 10000 sq.ft. (not computing squares). At level 20, it would be Pi * 40000 sq ft, four times more for a 2-fold level increase.

Control Water and Control Winds define cylinders, one of which has a quadratic increase with level (height is fixed) but the other has a cubic increase: Each level-doubling implies an 8-fold increase in area.

Guard and Wards clearly specifies an area in terms of square feet, so there's no ambiguity there. This increases linearly in level (and it's also shapeable, like the first group I referred).

But to eliminate any doubt about what 10-ft square means, we have Otiluke's Freezing Sphere, that says in the text "an area of 100 sq. ft. (a 10-ft square)". So, 10ft cube is a cube with 2 squares per side, and 30 ft-cube has 6 squares per side.

In essence, there are spells that do increase area polynomially, and not just linearly, with area. Usually, they are utility spells, but that might not always be true in books outside the PHB.

P.S.: there may other scalable spells I missed, like purify food and drink, which have scalable dimensions listed under 'Effect' or 'Target'. I only looked for 'Area' entries.

Posted: Tue Jan 20, 2009 4:58 pm
by kottakinge
I thought it was a silly question but it seems that some people are confused too :P
Will have a look at the FAQ
Thanks.

Re: 3.5 edition spells questions

Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2009 6:55 pm
by alhoon
kottakinge wrote:Just a question about a spell called spike growth in 3.5 edition.

Just remember to tone down the EXTREMELY high damage this spell does. This continous damage that could kill high level monsters caught in the middle as it's cast on a corridor.