Page 1 of 3

Review of Open Grave

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:41 pm
by Lord Soth
You can read the review HERE.

This picture's pretty nice.

Image

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 6:49 pm
by NeoTiamat
My PCs will not thank you.

:twisted:

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:12 pm
by Amicus
Well this is a fine how-do-you-do. It's just a bestiary for variant undead? Back when it was first announced, I had gotten the impression that it would also incorporate rules for necromancers, expanding beyond the nerfed necromancy spells in the PH. I guess that material must have gone by the wayside, or was just a rumor to begin with.

"This is crap!" said I after reading the previews. "The 4E designers are bragging about having gutted arcane necromancy! This leaves no alternative but kidnapping."

"Calm down!" said others. "They're just saving that stuff to release later. Word on the street is that the arcane necromancer will be a separate core class in The Open Grave."

"Oh... well ok then," I grumbled, and set aside my plans of retribution.

Where is the arcane necromancy?!! How can there not be arcane necromancy?!

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:17 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Amicus wrote:Well this is a fine how-do-you-do. It's just a bestiary for variant undead? Back when it was first announced, I had gotten the impression that it would also incorporate rules for necromancers, expanding beyond the nerfed necromancy spells in the PH. I guess that material must have gone by the wayside, or was just a rumor to begin with.
...
Where is the arcane necromancy?!! How can there not be arcane necromancy?!
WotC is dumping the idea of having every book have PC rules (classes/PrC/feats/spells) AND having DM information (monsters, traps, etc). Books will be DM or player specific (with very few exceptions like the Manual of the Planes).
Necromancers will likely be tied to the shadow power source (like illusionists), probably in the PHB3 or 4 (in '10 or '11)

Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:25 pm
by steveflam
Has anyone read the entry on Strahd or Vecna?

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:26 am
by Lord Soth
Amicus wrote:Well this is a fine how-do-you-do. It's just a bestiary for variant undead? Back when it was first announced, I had gotten the impression that it would also incorporate rules for necromancers, expanding beyond the nerfed necromancy spells in the PH. I guess that material must have gone by the wayside, or was just a rumor to begin with.


It was just an erroneous rumor. They've made it pretty clear that new classes will only ever be introduced in two places: Players Handbook's and campaign setting Player Guides. They won't be introduced anywhere else (Same goes for races, except you'll also find them in Dragon Magazine).

As Jester pointed out, the Necromancer class will come to be, eventually. It'll just be in PHB3 or PHB4, however, and will derive their power from the Shadow power source, like the Illusionist.
Has anyone read the entry on Strahd or Vecna?


Sadly, no. Although I know somebody on some other site got the book early and said Strahd was a Level 20 Solo Skirmisher with 930 HP. Here's a link to the thread.

http://forum.rpg.net/showthread.php?t=431022&page=2

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 9:03 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Hey, alhoon, looks like your namesake is included in Open Grave's lich variants!

Re: Review of Open Grave

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 10:17 am
by Brandi
Lord Soth wrote:Image
Fetal Steve! Nooooooo!

Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 11:25 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Stats for Strahd? Hrmph... looks like I'll need to be getting this to keep my RL collection complete. Hope it has some inspiration for a 3e game. At the least, the art is nice.

Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 8:47 am
by Lord Soth
Here's Strahd in Open Grave.

Image

Hardly the best picture of him I've ever seen, but you gotta admit, that's several leagues better than THIS guy.

Image

Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 11:25 am
by EO
I'm pretty satisfied with the Strahd section. It doesn't go into details about his life, but what is there is consistent with the Ravenloft setting, not just I6.

Additionally, the Strahd Zombies are there as well.

The von Zarovich sword is a new item I think, doesn't seem related to the Sunsword, it's sort of an intelligent sword that corrupts its wielder. Supposedly, Strahd had the Alchemist create it then he killed the Alchemist with this sword.

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2009 2:26 am
by Jester of the FoS
Open Grave has some nice bits. Too much of it is lairs for my taste (and those vary wildly) and the new monsters are too often, well, new monsters. Instead of going through the classic 2e and 3e monsters they're just making straight new ones and updating icons.
I miss the 2e and early 3e transition where they worked to update, before it was all about the authors just making new stuff 24-7 (i.e. MM3-5).

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2009 6:50 am
by Amicus
Jester of the FoS wrote:WotC is dumping the idea of having every book have PC rules (classes/PrC/feats/spells) AND having DM information (monsters, traps, etc). Books will be DM or player specific (with very few exceptions like the Manual of the Planes).
Necromancers will likely be tied to the shadow power source (like illusionists), probably in the PHB3 or 4 (in '10 or '11)
Well pfui on them. As far as I'm concerned, this was their big chance to lure me in, and they blew it.

"Okay, they are publishing a big book on the undead next year... this will surely contain enough tasty fluff to allow me to ignore HALFLINGS WITH RECTANGLE EARS."

I have no doubt that WoTC has a big database somewhere which contrasts the loss of sales from ex-fans who enjoy arcane necromancy vs. new sales to people attracted by the idea of their demonic half-dragon PC battling a skeletal fetus, and has chosen accordingly. I trust that their business model doesn't count on people like me compulsively buying their product in the hope of getting information about necromancers in another year or two. As it happens, there's still lots of 2E and 3.5 product that I haven't been able to pick up at scandalously reduced prices yet.

At this point, even if they published a big thick book totally devoted to the lore of shapeshifters and werecreatures in 4E, I am pretty sure I'd pass on it; and coming from me, this is a pretty profound statement.


How do people handle this sort of thing in 4E-adapted campaigns? Dealing with stuff like necromancers, while knowing that at some point new game rules will be published that will likely be grossly inconsistent with whatever rules you haved adopted in the meanwhile? I mean, are high-profile necromancers just generally going on sabbatical in people's campaigns until 2011?

Lord Soth wrote:Here's Strahd in Open Grave.

Image
Everything works for me except the feet.

"Tatyana, my love... for centuries you have spurned my love. But today at last I will win your heart forever with my adorable penguin impersonation."
Hardly the best picture of him I've ever seen, but you gotta admit, that's several leagues better than THIS guy.

Image
"ONE! ... singular sensation!..."

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2009 10:11 am
by Jester of the FoS
Amicus wrote:I have no doubt that WoTC has a big database somewhere which contrasts the loss of sales from ex-fans who enjoy arcane necromancy vs. new sales to people attracted by the idea of their demonic half-dragon PC battling a skeletal fetus, and has chosen accordingly. I trust that their business model doesn't count on people like me compulsively buying their product in the hope of getting information about necromancers in another year or two. As it happens, there's still lots of 2E and 3.5 product that I haven't been able to pick up at scandalously reduced prices yet.
No, but they do have many, many complaints from players and fans who are annoyed with picking-up a $35 DM/monster book for the ten feats and three spells it includes. And the DMs who are annoyed when every player has a copy of the adventure they're running because it contains a couple prestige classes.

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2009 10:37 am
by Amicus
Jester of the FoS wrote:No, but they do have many, many complaints from players and fans who are annoyed with picking-up a $35 DM/monster book for the ten feats and three spells it includes. And the DMs who are annoyed when every player has a copy of the adventure they're running because it contains a couple prestige classes.
Oh certainly, I realize that there are sound financial reasons for their strategy. I'm just a bit cheesed on account of my erroneous expectations for the product. "Okay, 4E... here's your chance. Awe me with the dark horizons of your fearsome necromantic power!" And the skeleton fetus did a little dance.