Page 1 of 2
Your Experiences in 4E Ravenloft
Posted: Sun Feb 01, 2009 7:20 pm
by The_Confessor
I'm in the very early stages of a 4th Edition Ravenloft campaign using Jester's amazing rules and wanted to hear how other people are fairing in the Domains of Dread with the new rules set.
Basically, how are your 4e campaigns going? Are you still able to maintain that gothic feel given the new 'action-packed' feel of 4e, not to mention the fact that the PCs are now clearly a step above normal people and the more combat-focused mechanics of 4e.
I'm looking for insight and experience from those few who have gone before me, so thanks ahead of time!
Posted: Sun Feb 01, 2009 9:07 pm
by Igor the Henchman
I DMed a total of one (big) Ravenloft adventure using the 4E ruleset, and currently enjoy a rare DM sabbatical so I can play for once. Oddly enough, the new DM kicked off his game with a homebrew adventure that I thought was quite Ravenloft-y. So you might say I both run and played in a horror 4E game.
The game I DMed (1st level) had the PCs rescue a small town from a horde of undead fey bent on kidnapping human children to bring to Tristessa. The PCs eventually fought Tristessa herself, as well as a nightmarish Aspect of Gwydion. It turns out that even at 1st level, you can have adventures that feel quite epic.
The game I played in had us investigate why people in a small town took to suddenly dying and rising as zombies. The culprit turned out to be the local celebrity artist who did it through his paintings. The adventure was very short and we were 3rd level, but the sense of vulnerability and fright was very present.
What I believe I learned:
4E combat is fun. No, really, really fun. The rules are simple, and the pace flows fast. Once the new rules have sunk in, dropping a combat encounters on the players becomes akin to giving them a tasty snack. Every time I saw a combat happen so far, the level of tension and glee around the table jumped up in short order. In a combat situation, players feel firmly in control.
During roleplaying and exploration episodes, on the other hand, the DM appears to be in control. Players take to becoming cautious and prudent, and watch out for the unexpected. I felt affected by it as well. It felt weird - there were almost no dice rolls, or game rules involved. The choices of the player were a lot more important than the stats of the character. When combat came, it became a moment of tension relief, a patch of safe territory amid the unknown.
Pace between the two states, and you can get a good recipe for horror - instead of fighting the players' interest for combat, it pays to drop them in a nice, good fight very early in the scenario - once you've allowed everyone to savor that pleasure, the players become more receptive to the more atmospheric stuff. Use roleplaying and exploration encounters to set the players on edge, then relieve the tension by dropping a battle on their heads. Repeat the cycle, and each time you find the players immerse themselves deeper and deeper into the game.
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 10:26 am
by alhoon
Actually when you hit 12th -13th level combat stops flowing so fast again.

Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 11:51 am
by Igor the Henchman
alhoon wrote:Actually when you hit 12th -13th level combat stops flowing so fast again.

Oh? Haven't gotten to Paragon levels yet myself. What slows it down? The information load? Too many powers to choose from? Book flipping? Monster complexity? Modifier and bonus tracking? Conditions and ongoing damage?
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 5:05 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Igor the Henchman wrote:alhoon wrote:Actually when you hit 12th -13th level combat stops flowing so fast again.

Oh? Haven't gotten to Paragon levels yet myself. What slows it down? The information load? Too many powers to choose from? Book flipping? Monster complexity? Modifier and bonus tracking? Conditions and ongoing damage?
Damage goes up by 1 every 2 levels while hp go up by 5+ every level.
There's more to it than that, but while everything flows faster and people can break out the high-damage when needed you're looking at alot more rounds per combat.
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 6:36 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Damage goes up by 1 every 2 levels while hp go up by 5+ every level.
There's more to it than that, but while everything flows faster and people can break out the high-damage when needed you're looking at alot more rounds per combat.
I gathered from Alhoon's comment he was saying that the average combat round itself was going slower. Is that the case? Or does the encounter simply last more rounds? Because I wouldn't necessarily mind the latter.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:26 am
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote:Igor the Henchman wrote:alhoon wrote:Actually when you hit 12th -13th level combat stops flowing so fast again.

Oh? Haven't gotten to Paragon levels yet myself. What slows it down? The information load? Too many powers to choose from? Book flipping? Monster complexity? Modifier and bonus tracking? Conditions and ongoing damage?
Damage goes up by 1 every 2 levels while hp go up by 5+ every level.
There's more to it than that, but while everything flows faster and people can break out the high-damage when needed you're looking at alot more rounds per combat.
Exactly.

Monsters have more hp, chars have more hp damage is slightly more. Also it's one thing to have to check which of 3 Encounter powers you'd use or if you would use your daily power and another one to check from 7-8 of powers+ daily powers + item powers.
NOTE: Damage doesn't go up only 1/2 levels. You add more powers who do more damage, but indeed with monsters having hundreds of hp there are many, many rounds.
Also after 10 or so rounds, the monster powers become ... blant.
"Ahem, the evil wizard shoots his wand at you for the 12th time missing with the well known fiery ray this time. His eyes turn red again which by now tells you that his lighting bolt spell has recharged, since you have seen this 3 times already"
Simplifying monsters that last 5 rounds is cool. A monster with 3 attacks (one of which is a standard, at will attack) that will last 20 rounds or so is blant.
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2009 1:00 am
by Lord Soth
I'm itching to play a Ravenloft game using 4E rules. Unfortunately, I had a hard enough time finding a local Ravenloft game when it was still supported, so...
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2009 5:54 am
by alhoon
I'm itching too. So I wait for that looooooong overdue D&D insider table
Posted: Fri Feb 06, 2009 4:49 pm
by Lord Soth
I've gone and purchased Battlegrounds, which hopefully will make it easy to play online games with my old gaming group. If it works out well, then hopefully I'll be able to get a 4E Ravenloft game going on it. That'd be nice.
Posted: Sat Feb 07, 2009 10:27 am
by alhoon
Igor the Henchman wrote:
I gathered from Alhoon's comment he was saying that the average combat round itself was going slower. Is that the case? Or does the encounter simply last more rounds? Because I wouldn't necessarily mind the latter.
PS. It's alhoon. We're a type, like "golems".

The last 6-7 years or so we're categorized as lich subtype, which I detest.
On topic: Mostly the encounter lasts more rounds. Also each round takes longer because the character has to suffle with 15-20 powers if you add item powers, encounter powers, daily powers.
Idealy, the character decides what to do until his turn is up, but situations change quite fast for this tactic to be reliable. While the player may say "I'll use encounter power 1 (area attack) on the minions surrounding me" when his turn is up again, he may find that he's needing to heal instead (should I use Second Wind, or get in my regeneration stance? Is the battle going to last long enough? Perhaps I should use my armor to get a free heal but what if I need my other item powers in the following battle, before the milestone?)
or that the leader monster is set up nicely for a backstab or something.
On combat rounds: Well, it becomes tiresome after a point. When it's obvious the PCs will win but they still need 5-6 rounds of combat (i.e more than 20 mins) using their at will powers because the situation isn't worth spending dailies.
The point of the monsters in 4E is to do their nice stuff and die. Well, at level 11+ they don't die fast enough. 20 rounds of combat isn't that rare in level 13-14 for example.
Posted: Sat Feb 07, 2009 11:24 am
by alhoon
SOLUTIONS: Here's what I do in order to reduce the rounds in one combat:
1. Reduce HP of monsters. A monster with 1/2 hp is usually worth about 75% of the XP.
I.e a boneshard skeleton (5th level brute) with 38 hp instead of 77 is worth 150 XP instead of 200 XP.
Still it's a 5th level monster! That means that instead of putting 3 boneshard skeletons against a 5th level party of 3 characters, you should place 4 such skeletons.
concept: The damage a monster does in combat is usually rounds it lives x average damage it deals/round.
NOTE: The average damage it deals per round isn't the average damage for at will attacks! Most monsters have at least some trick they use once or twice in a battle which increases their average combat damage.
By lowering the hit points, you reduce the at will attacks, but not the encounter attacks. For example consider a monster that lives 5 rounds instead of 10. It has an encounter attack that it can use and recharges when bloodied and it does double damage. By reducing the time the monster has on the battlefield by 5 rounds, means it will still use the encounter power twice and it's at will power three times instead of eight times.
Considerations:
- Monsters without encounter powers like the mummy guardian (or the ogre), are worth 66% of their XP, because the average damage they do in a combat is = rounds they live x damage of at will attack.
Auras also work that way since they work as long as the monster is alive. Powers that recharge fairly often (say 4-6) also work that way.
So a mummy guardian with 54 hp will be worth 233 XP.
- Encounter powers of monsters play a large part on the average damage they deal in a battle. I.e if a monster has a power it can use once in the battle (i.e not rechargable) that it deals massive damage, while it's at will attacks do little damage, halving it's hp doesn't reduce it's XP to 75% of the original, since most of the challenge the monster presents is still there.
Example: Bodaks. A bodak with 1/2 hp will still live long enough to weaken a foe and then use death gaze to drop him to 0 hp. That's a power he can use once per battle. It's enough.
- Monsters are still of their initial level, they just award less XP. I.e their balanced for characters of their level +/- 2 and usually balanced for characters of their level +/- 5.
Making monsters in a given level more difficult
Increase damage
A monster that deals double damage is worth 50% more XP. For example a mummy guardian that deals 4d8+6 damage with every slam is worth 525XP.
Again, it's an 8th level monster!
concept: Again, usually average combat damage is rounds monster lives x average damage it deals in a round.
Considerations: While this house rule works well with limited use powers it doesn't work very well with other kinds of powers.
Again, the Bodak comes to mind. Sure, doubling the damage it does in a round increases it's difficulty considerably. But the death gaze is still it's main damage dealing attack, and it's not tied to damage.
The Bodak Reaver now does 2d12+12 + 2d8 damage (average 34 damage). While this is some hefty damage, an 18th level fighter has about 130-140 hp and enough healing surges, abilities and trinkets to heal 1/2 of them in the middle of the combat. Yet, the Bodak Reaver can still take him out on round 2. Two Bodak Reavers in the same encounter means that this fighter will probably go down on round 2.
Another example is with monsters that have powerful non-damage abilities (many leaders). The Osyluth for example, gives a -5 to all defences as a minor each round, and also has an aura that gives -2 enemy attack rolls within 25' of it. Also, it teleports.
To such monsters, doubling the damage, doesn't mean they're 50% more powerful. They should be awarded less XP increase since their challenge doesn't come from raw damage alone.
Posted: Sat Feb 07, 2009 6:36 pm
by Isabella
alhoon wrote:
The point of the monsters in 4E is to do their nice stuff and die. Well, at level 11+ they don't die fast enough. 20 rounds of combat isn't that rare in level 13-14 for example.
20 rounds?

We've been playing from levels 11-15 in my group and it's
never taken us that long, not even when we fought the level 19 solo monster.
Your mileage may vary, perhaps.
Posted: Sun Feb 08, 2009 10:21 am
by alhoon
Perhaps I was wrong, I wasn't keeping count. I know for sure of one combat that reached and surpassed the 20 rounds. It was 3 Chars vs an advanced beholder fire eye. Admitedly, the party hasn't invested in ranged combat at all, since there was no wizard or warlock and the ranger was 2 weapon fighting type.
The battle was repetitive and increadibly boring. It was like: Ranger: ranged attack. Cleric: throw that radiant (1d6+6-7) at will ranged attack. paladin: scratch head, throw rocks, jump in front of Ranger to shield him.
One of these would heal the ranger (or whoever in need) every 2-3 rounds. Beholder: Bzitt Bzitt attack.
repeat.
After we passed round 20 (the beholder still had about half his hp), I decided on "You win. You all survive -1 more healing surge".
However, it has been common for my table after level 12 to drag in combats. As I said, the monsters do their interesting stuff... and don't die.
That's why I reduced their hp.
Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 9:04 am
by alhoon
Important Update for skill challenges! ! ! !
As many have noticed, it was quite difficult to accomplish skill challenges. WotC noticed too, and they changed the suggested DCs for skill checks and challenges.
No, moderate DC = 10 +2 per 3 lvls above 1st. i.e 1-3, 4-6, 7-9 etc. Hard DCs= moderate+5, easy DCs = moderate -5 to -9.
That means that at 28-30 lvl the moderate DC for a skill challenge is 28. For a simple skill check is 33.
This update fixes the Skill challenges that were very difficult at low levels, but still, it doesn't work very well in high levels.
Why? Because while the level modifier for skills goes up 1/2 levels, there are ability increases, utility powers that allow rerolls, items that boost skill checks etc.
Still, it works better than the old rules.