Page 1 of 2

Darklord Epic Destiny

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 3:13 pm
by Mortavius
So in a recent article released in Dragon on the WotC site, there is an epic destiny tailored for the Shadowfell called "Darklord."

There is some flavor maintained here; as it says that when you reach 30th level and retire your character he or she actually is sucked into the Shadowfell by the "Mists" and then deposited in his own dread realm (domain) to be ruler of it. However, in staying accessible to characters, the Darklord may or may not be evil.

With some tweaking, this could work well in Ravenloft. I would change it to a requirement to be evil, and as such it's probably never going to be seen by players. Or you could go farther, and say that good players who become Darklords can only rule Oubliettes (sp?), as described in VR's Guide to the Mists.

Thoughts?

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 3:46 pm
by cure
Well aside from the fact that Oubliettes are considered a violation of the rules by some well versed folks around here and are not (as far as I recall) ruled by anyone, why not? Then again, do we really need all our Darklords, or even an inflation of Darklords, at the 30th level? Needlessly mechanical for a corner of the universe that prides itself on confinement that is meaningful, indeed poetic, and preferably is unflinching poetic justice. It reminds me of the automatic corruption for just being yourself for fighters and other classes from the 3.5 update.

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 3:58 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Problem with the Darklord epic destiny in Ravenloft is that there's plenty of (far easier) ways to achieve the same effect: simply do evil and let the DP notice.

A more positive-minded epic destiny might be similar to what the mortal Ezra is supposed to have done: become one with the Mists, and in so doing, make the world a tiny bit brighter.

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 4:45 pm
by alhoon
Or better yet, stop playing Ravenloft at paragon levels. :)

Although on the epic destinies I would agree with Igor. Merge with the mists, become a deity or something to make the world a better place.

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 10:45 pm
by Mortavius
I agree; I think that should be a definate epic destiny in Ravenloft. To follow Ezra's example and bring hope. It would be a great thing to aspire to. Not necessarily become a deity, but an exarch of Ezra perhaps?

I don't think that just because there is an epic destiny for the Darklord that it means that all Darklords are now 30th level; I think this is just one path to that outcome. In my mind, it's still perfectly plausible to be 1st level and be a Darklord; the actions are what matters, not the character's level.

Even though 4E D&D seems to shy away from playing evil characters (rightfully so, IMO) it has it's place, especially in Ravenloft. Though I can say from personal experience that it is a rare player who can play a truly evil character and still not have the party turn against him within half a session.

If such a player were inclined and in my games, I would certainly open the Darklord epic destiny for him or her, were my game to run that long. I think it would be a wonderfully fitting end to that character's career.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 10:04 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Meh... I don't know enough about 4e to know what an Epic Destiny is mechanically, but IMHO, Darklordhood or any destiny for that matter should come organically out of the story, not by reaching some kind of "high score".

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 11:06 am
by Jester of the FoS
Epic destinies are paths to immortality. The idea being, characters that reach immortality become immortal and, at level 21, they start down the path to their greater goal.
The destiny offers a couple small benefits (essentially new class powers) and a new utility power.

Personally, I don't think Ravenloft works too well with the epic tier.
The conventions of the tier do not mesh well with the expectations of Ravenloft.
And like the Shadowfell and lower planes are geared to paragon levels while the Astral is epic, Ravenloft domains are really divided into heroic or paragon domains.
That's why I didn't add any epic destinies and only added a few epic monsters (mostly to be available to darklords).

4e wise, domains of dread are places in the shadowfell where a single darklord is bound to the land and, apparently, a L30 good character can become a lord.
One could argue that the destiny is there for unaligned or evil PCs (or that the good PCs slowly become evil). But, realistically, this is one more way the new official Ravenloft is diverging from the canon Ravenloft we all know and love.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 12:23 pm
by Mortavius
I would agree Jester, I am hesitant to play an epic Ravenloft game, but I am not opposed to the idea. I think it has potential. As mentioned, the previous example of a prestige class of joining with the Mists.

After all, you could wrap up a campaign where the PC's travel to and ultimately challenge Gwydion, ending after the final battle with this epic monster.

To me (and mind, I haven't played epic levels yet) epic tier is about ramping up what the PCs and monsters can do. But they still can't detect alignment, or any of that sacrosanct stuff. They basically can cause more damage and don't have to worry about low-level monsters anymore. Well, there's plenty of Ravenloft-appropriate monsters that can challenge PCs of that level, so the fear stays in place.

Besides, fear itself isn't based on level. You can still scare epic PCs with events out of their control, even with epic abilities.

I just think it's worth looking at, and if a designer is creating a 4E conversion (as you have Jester, and kudos to you, I've skimmed it over and I think it's got some very good points), I don't think that designer should not include something, just because they don't think it will work. That would be like original Ravenloft saying that PC's shouldn't reach 20th level, just because then they'll be able to beat most creatures in the setting. Instead, the rules and options are there, and if you as a DM or player choose to use them, and they make your game better, great!

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 3:17 pm
by MadStepDad
Mortavius wrote:Even though 4E D&D seems to shy away from playing evil characters (rightfully so, IMO) it has it's place, especially in Ravenloft. Though I can say from personal experience that it is a rare player who can play a truly evil character and still not have the party turn against him within half a session.
I thought playing evil characters was almost strictly forbidden in RAVENLOFT. Sooner or later the PCs lose control of the character entirely and it becomes part of of the DMs arsenal.

You guys also say RAVENLOFT is not truly combatable with epic-level games, which is true to an extent. But isn't that why (hated-on) domains like the ones once belonging to VECNA and KAS were created? So RAVENLOFT could provide a challenge for anybody regardless of class, alignment or level?

Still stuck in a 3.5 morass here...

peace,

MSD

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 3:36 pm
by Jester of the FoS
From the PHB:
In the epic tier, your character’s capabilities are truly superheroic. Your class still determines most of your abilities, but your most dramatic powers come from your choice of epic destiny, which you select at 21st level. You travel across nations in the blink of an eye, and your whole party might take to the air in combat. The success or failure of your adventures has far-reaching consequences, possibly determining the fate of millions in this world and even planes beyond. You navigate otherworldly realms and explore neverbefore- seen caverns of wonder, where you can expect to battle savage pit fiends, the ferocious tarrasque, sinister sorrowsworn deathlords, bloodthirsty lich archmages, and even demon princes. The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power, whose sleep troubles kingdoms and whose waking threatens the world.
While you can certain play Ravenloft in the epic tier and make monsters and lords to challenge the players look closely at what you're expected to do.

"You travel across nations in the blink of an eye." Nope.
"possibly determining the fate of millions in this world and even planes beyond". Nope, not even a full million in the Core.
" You navigate otherworldly realms" Nope.
"you can expect to battle savage pit fiends (maybe one), the ferocious tarrasque (nope), sinister sorrowsworn deathlords (possibly), bloodthirsty lich archmages (maybe two), and even demon princes (nope)"
"The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power" Nope, only one in the Core.

You can play beyond level 21 but you'll still be playing Paragon tier adventures. You won't really be doing justice to the epic tier. Especially since gods and demon lords start at L30 and greater gods at L35. At level 28 or 29 you should be expecting to fight demi-gods on the decaying bodies of forgotten primordials floating in the astral plane, not defending a small town from a werewolf.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 4:08 pm
by MadStepDad
I respectfully disagree.
Jester of the FoS wrote: "You travel across nations in the blink of an eye." Nope.
Fine stick to a particular domain then. Everything is hampered in RAVENLOFT at the DMs discretion anyways so it doesn't always have to work as perfectly intended.
"possibly determining the fate of millions in this world and even planes beyond". Nope, not even a full million in the Core.
If you operate under the assumption that RAVENLOFT is a literal incarnation of "hell" in D&D world then this is entirely possible. Remember the Grand Conjunction?
" You navigate otherworldly realms" Nope.
I don't know. You could argue that ravenloft IS an otherwordly realm.
"you can expect to battle savage pit fiends (maybe one), the ferocious tarrasque (nope), sinister sorrowsworn deathlords (possibly), bloodthirsty lich archmages (maybe two), and even demon princes (nope)"
Fire-truck it then. Remake MALACCHIO and stat out the GENTLEMAN CALLER.
"The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power" Nope, only one in the Core.
That you know of. An enterprising DM could certainly find a solution to that one.
You can play beyond level 21 but you'll still be playing Paragon tier adventures. You won't really be doing justice to the epic tier. Especially since gods and demon lords start at L30 and greater gods at L35. At level 28 or 29 you should be expecting to fight demi-gods on the decaying bodies of forgotten primordials floating in the astral plane, not defending a small town from a werewolf.
This is all true. I'm just trying to say that in D&D in general - RAVENLOFT in particular - sky is the limit. I seem to recall somebody running a very successful epic-level RAVENLOFT campaign one time that came off remarkably chilling and massive in scope.

peace Jester,

MSD

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 8:23 pm
by Amicus
Jester of the FoS wrote:"The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power" Nope, only one in the Core.
I thought there were two?




I think an epic-level character would just start waking up each morning coated with progressively thicker layers of mother-of-pearl.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 10:13 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Jester of the FoS wrote:From the PHB:
In the epic tier, your character’s capabilities are truly superheroic. Your class still determines most of your abilities, but your most dramatic powers come from your choice of epic destiny, which you select at 21st level. You travel across nations in the blink of an eye, and your whole party might take to the air in combat. The success or failure of your adventures has far-reaching consequences, possibly determining the fate of millions in this world and even planes beyond. You navigate otherworldly realms and explore neverbefore- seen caverns of wonder, where you can expect to battle savage pit fiends, the ferocious tarrasque, sinister sorrowsworn deathlords, bloodthirsty lich archmages, and even demon princes. The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power, whose sleep troubles kingdoms and whose waking threatens the world.
While you can certain play Ravenloft in the epic tier and make monsters and lords to challenge the players look closely at what you're expected to do.

"You travel across nations in the blink of an eye." Nope.
"possibly determining the fate of millions in this world and even planes beyond". Nope, not even a full million in the Core.
" You navigate otherworldly realms" Nope.
"you can expect to battle savage pit fiends (maybe one), the ferocious tarrasque (nope), sinister sorrowsworn deathlords (possibly), bloodthirsty lich archmages (maybe two), and even demon princes (nope)"
"The dragons you encounter are ancient wyrms of truly earthshaking power" Nope, only one in the Core.

You can play beyond level 21 but you'll still be playing Paragon tier adventures. You won't really be doing justice to the epic tier. Especially since gods and demon lords start at L30 and greater gods at L35. At level 28 or 29 you should be expecting to fight demi-gods on the decaying bodies of forgotten primordials floating in the astral plane, not defending a small town from a werewolf.
Jester, you know my views well enough to guess what I might object to all that. Short version: the RAVENLOFT setting is not in the books. Its at your game table, controlled by you. Absolute "Nopes" are inexistant in this game.

Possible Epic-level adventure hooks for Ravenloft:
  • - A dark god chooses to violate the Unspoken Pact and take control of Ravenloft under the pretense of "saving" it from evil.

    - The Hour of Ascension comes to pass, as the real manifestation of Death itself sends epic-level undead minions all across the world, with orders to eliminate all life.

    - A piece of information the PCs desperately need can only be found within Vecna's personal library in citadel Cavitius.

    - Different churches all across the world receive the visit of angel-like creatures who claim to speak for the local deity, ordering the collection of vast amounts of tribute, supposedly to fight the Time of Unparalleled Darkness. Church officials who question the "angels" true nature all meet a gruesome death.

    - An eccentric sage theorizes that the Shadow Rift conceals beneath it a second, even more mysterious domain.

    - Why are all dead bodies everywhere suddenly dissapearing?

    - The Shadow Rift is expanding, devouring the surrounding domains. Already Keening is no more, while Falkovnia, Darkon and Barovia have lost sizeable chunks.

    - The El Koth have awakened - their numbers a legion. Within two weeks, the creatures control most of the southern Core.

Posted: Sat Feb 14, 2009 2:35 am
by Jester of the FoS
But at some point you just end up playing a generic fantasy game or even a Forgotten Realms game that just happens to be set in Ravenloft. The setting is being shoe-horned into the adventure.
Just like you can have a low-magic gothic horror adventure in Castle Ravenloft in the Realms. But it ends up costing you the soul of the world.

I find it hard to reconcile the gothic humanist horror with the tropes of truly epic play that isn't just paragon with higher numbers. Especially when you can "die" and come-back on a daily basis.

And it's really deflating to have the Big Bads of the world (Strahd, Azalin) be so weak compared to the heroes and having the new evil be that much more impressive. Yes, demigod Vecna should be powerful and Gwydion is a great example of a L30 solo something, but you only have so many monsters.
Even if you pimp and sex up Strahd and Azalin to L25 you still have 50 encounters between 25 and 30 to fill with creature who are more powerful than those two.

Yes, it is possible to play Ravenloft as an epic game: you just might have to give-up what makes it Ravenloft to do so...

Posted: Sat Feb 14, 2009 1:07 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Jester of the FoS wrote:But at some point you just end up playing a generic fantasy game or even a Forgotten Realms game that just happens to be set in Ravenloft. The setting is being shoe-horned into the adventure.
Absolutely true. No argument from me. And that's OK. The purpose of any game setting is to be shoehorned into the adventure. The setting is no more than decor for your game.

It is no more than my current opinion of course, but I suspect there exists a "trying too hard" syndrome among some Ravenloft DMs: an irrational distaste to run adventures that don't seem "gothic" enough. Which leads to restricting creative possibilities, generating more workload during game-preparation and limiting the potential player pool to the rare roleplaying nuts (which, I should point out, do exist and are a blast to DM for, but you don't find a lot of them).
Jester of the FoS wrote: Just like you can have a low-magic gothic horror adventure in Castle Ravenloft in the Realms. But it ends up costing you the soul of the world.
I see nothing wrong with an occasional gothic horror adventure in the Realms, do you? Why should an occasional break from gothic atmosphere in Ravenloft be any different?
Jester of the FoS wrote: I find it hard to reconcile the gothic humanist horror with the tropes of truly epic play that isn't just paragon with higher numbers. Especially when you can "die" and come-back on a daily basis.
I see why a "Folklore-Realism"-type DM (like yourself and plenty other DMs around these boards I'm sure) might not enjoy a game like that. And that's all right. There are, however, other Ravenloft DMs who don't have as big a problem with that - me among them.
Jester of the FoS wrote: And it's really deflating to have the Big Bads of the world (Strahd, Azalin) be so weak compared to the heroes and having the new evil be that much more impressive. Yes, demigod Vecna should be powerful and Gwydion is a great example of a L30 solo something, but you only have so many monsters.
Even if you pimp and sex up Strahd and Azalin to L25 you still have 50 encounters between 25 and 30 to fill with creature who are more powerful than those two.
Depends on what you find deflating. Strahd was a 10th level necromancer originally. Azalin was a single "See-it ->Kill it" encounter. I have no problem with either of them being vanquished in my games.
Jester of the FoS wrote: Yes, it is possible to play Ravenloft as an epic game: you just might have to give-up what makes it Ravenloft to do so...
Looks like we have found a very reasonable middle-ground to our opinions then. I personally don't look at an evolution in campaign atmosphere in terms of substraction, but, all argumentation aside, I do see and understand where you're coming from.