Page 1 of 1

To kill a werewolf

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 6:15 pm
by kottakinge
I'm little confused about werewolves listed in the denizen of dread book.
It's said that in human form they lost their dr to all but silver.
So if you want to kill a werewolf kill him in human form?
That's seems a bit easy?

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 8:01 pm
by order99
Well, i'm still a 2nd Edition man, but...

I was always fond of Larry Talbot syndrome myself, so I always had all non-silver, non-fire and non-magical damage inflict Subdual damage in Human form. You could beat or stab a man to death, but when night fell, an angry savage juggernaut would burst forth from its shallow grave for revenge-and normal weapons inflicted no damage in Wereform as it was too enraged to feel pain...

In AD&D 1st and 2nd, a creature of 4+ HD could also strike creatures immune to mundane weapons-I kept that, but unless the cause was Moonsilver, ensorcelled weapon or bonfire that damage was also subdual. So an Ogre could stun a werewolf in wereform but needed to take extra measures to kill it. Two werewolves fighting for dominance could duel in human form or claw in Wereform, but seldom to the Death-certainly not by accident. Wererats are under 4 HD but the same rules applied to them in my games.

Also, Undead special attacks worked normally (and could kill Lycanthropes through Level Drain, Str drain, aging etc but not through mere physical damage. I went with the Universal Studios school of presentation, monsters that took a lickin' but came back for the sequel! :twisted:

All of the above was subject to the Rule of Drama of course. I had one game where Eivon( Lvl 7 Fighter,in the last throes of Lycanthropy and on the way to NPC Monsterdom)decided to go out in a blaze of glory while he still had his Alignment intact. One moment a marauding Vampire was ready to snack on some helpless Peasant lad, the next moment he ate two Javelins of Lightning, and a raving madman fell upon him and transformed into a 400-pound Wereboar...

And when Eivon awoke he was a Lvl 3 Fighter, and cured...the DM had ruled that the Vampire had drained the Beast right out of him! Two Scrolls and much rest later, a very grateful Lvl 5(HUMAN!!) fighter joined the part in a search for the monster's lair.

The Vampire never returned to Hommlet again-but there were rumors of an Undead monster in Furyondy, which could only be Turned by the sight of a Crucifix...and Porkchops...Ham Sandwiches...Sausages...

Heh heh heh.

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2009 10:17 pm
by cure
Well, if you like the Incredible Hulk school of drama, said human, and certainly the beast lurking inside, is probably not going to like being injured and eventually killed and hence a transformation into werebeast form is rather certain.

Alternatively, the Agatha Christie school of drama would make it a mystery as to which human harbours the beast.

And the Ravenloft school of drama would tend towards the party arriving at the relevent door just as the full moon breaks the horizon.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 1:58 am
by Archedius
I've always had damage reduction work in human/hybrid/beast form for true-bred lycanthropes while afflicted only have it in beast/hybrid form.

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 9:25 am
by VAN
cure wrote:Well, if you like the Incredible Hulk school of drama, said human, and certainly the beast lurking inside, is probably not going to like being injured and eventually killed and hence a transformation into werebeast form is rather certain.

Alternatively, the Agatha Christie school of drama would make it a mystery as to which human harbours the beast.

And the Ravenloft school of drama would tend towards the party arriving at the relevent door just as the full moon breaks the horizon.
So correct!!! :D

Re: To kill a werewolf

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 10:15 am
by Joël of the FoS
kottakinge wrote:I'm little confused about werewolves listed in the denizen of dread book.
It's said that in human form they lost their dr to all but silver.
So if you want to kill a werewolf kill him in human form?
That's seems a bit easy?
And I suggest you stick with the book. So if they ever get afflicted, your players won't be undestructible. To have all of this in human form is a dream condition many players would get their PCs afflicted! :)

Joël

Posted: Fri Feb 13, 2009 10:17 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
It's not just Denizens of Dread that says that. It's in the MM, and the SRD. IMHO, the reason for it is to avoid ruining the "guess who's the lycanthrope game" (or "The Werewolf Break," if anyone catches that reference) by cutting everyone's palm with a steel dagger and seeing who heals first.

Posted: Sun Feb 15, 2009 3:55 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
I split the difference IMC: in human form, lycanthropes can be damaged and even "killed" without using silver, but the natural sort will instantly regenerate and revive the next time the "corpse" is subjected to their bloodline's trigger. Only if the body is destroyed by fire, dismemberment, or similar drastic methods will a natural-born lycanthrope stay dead.

Among other things, this can lead to fun confusion as to just what the PCs are up against, when the grave of the werewolf they'd killed last session is found empty -- the casket, torn open from within -- at the next full moon. :twisted:

Re: To kill a werewolf

Posted: Tue Feb 17, 2009 5:16 pm
by kottakinge
Joël of the FoS wrote:
kottakinge wrote:I'm little confused about werewolves listed in the denizen of dread book.
It's said that in human form they lost their dr to all but silver.
So if you want to kill a werewolf kill him in human form?
That's seems a bit easy?
And I suggest you stick with the book. So if they ever get afflicted, your players won't be undestructible. To have all of this in human form is a dream condition many players would get their PCs afflicted! :)

Joël
Indeed my players are infected but they still don't know.
They will have to wait for the next full moon and don't do "the silver dagger on the palm trick" :twisted:
Will definitivly stick with the book.