Page 1 of 2

Effects for 4E that will be scary

Posted: Mon Feb 16, 2009 1:58 pm
by alhoon
In 4E nothing published so far to my knowledge weakens a character for long, except diseases. That makes players bold, which is a good thing in a heroic game where you don't want to think again before your hero jumps in the fray.

However, I have thought to bring back some old-favorite effects from previews editions that would make monsters more appropriate for a game when even if you beat the bad guy you may need to sacrifice something.

Energy drain: Losing a healing surge isn't bad. But this is more scary:
Energy drain: (standard, rechargable 5,6) Attack vs Fortitude. Hit: The target gains a negative level.

Negative levels: You lose as many hit points as you normaly gain when you go up a level (i.e 4 for a wizard). You can't heal them until you remove the negative levels. For every 2 negative levels you gain a -1 to defences and skill checks as the flame of your life is diminished.
If you ever have as many Negative levels as your level total you die.

Ability damage: I never understood why 4E got away with ability damage. It's not that difficult to calculate.

Ability damage: (Standard, rechargable 5,6) Attack vs Fortitude.
Hit: low damage (for an at will attack) +2 ability damage (3 paragon or 4 epic).
Ability damage: Your damaged ability score is reduced by 2 (or 3 or 4). For every milestone or for every extended rest you gain back 1.

Posted: Fri Feb 20, 2009 9:56 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Personally, I applaud the disappearance of the "force-me-to-recalculate-all-my-stats-in-the-middle-of-the-game"-type effects. Several unpleasant battles in previous editions made me wary of those many years ago.

Mechanically speaking, the sentiment of horror isn't caused by becoming weaker. Its about losing the assurance of control. Loss of flexibility, comfort, of safety, of backup options. In that sense, losing healing surges is exactly that - not weakening a PC outright, but make him very worried indeed. It doesn't slow down the game, but it does come as a solid kick in the teeth.

I personally like effects that affect the characters like an on/off switch might - here you could move wherever you wanted, now you can't. Here you could heal yourself, now you can't. The character should stay effective despite the effect, but grow slightly less comfortable.

Some possibilities off the top of my head:

Withering of the flesh: Your maximum hp total is reduced by 5 until a cure is found.

Evil Eye: Roll two d20s for every attack and pick the lowest number. Save ends.

Troubled mind: lose one class power of your choice until next quest completion.

Seal of Silence: Characters are rendered mute. Players can no longer discuss tactical options or advise each other out of character. Breaking the rule causes a small hp loss.

Confusion aura: Lose the ability to do opportunity attacks until the end of the encounter.

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 9:16 pm
by alhoon
Igor the Henchman wrote: Mechanically speaking, the sentiment of horror isn't caused by becoming weaker. Its about losing the assurance of control. Loss of flexibility, comfort, of safety, of backup options. In that sense, losing healing surges is exactly that - not weakening a PC outright, but make him very worried indeed. It doesn't slow down the game, but it does come as a solid kick in the teeth.

I personally like effects that affect the characters like an on/off switch might - here you could move wherever you wanted, now you can't. Here you could heal yourself, now you can't. The character should stay effective despite the effect, but grow slightly less comfortable.
Well, interesting opinion. However from what I have seen in my table, PCs are quite afraid of losing something they will need hours of game (or weeks in real time) to get back.
In 2nd edition I have seen players losing interest about their char and dropping the game after losing 3 levels. In 3rd edition, with the negative levels it were better since it was easier to get back your lost levels.
I don't want to go back to the extremity of energy drain or ability drain that was in 2nd edition, that made people drop the game. Still, I like effects that leave lingering damage difficult for the PCs to take out, while not losing too much so that they will still be fun to play.

Your "troubled mind" power for example is fine (although I would say to the next extended rest).

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 1:02 pm
by Mortavius
I have to agree with Igor; I like the lack of options that require your to do extensive recalculating in the middle of a fight in preference for the on/off effects. I absolutely hated level drain in 2E (felt WAY too much like a punishment), and although 3E did a better job of it, it was still clunky.

Healing surges are a good improvement (losing them, that is) but it depends on having the right group make-up. A player on his or her own can usually only use a healing surge once per fight (usually), so when the player has 5-10 of them, taking 1-2 away isn't a big deal. It's when the group has a cleric or warlord that can allow the use of more healing surges that it becomes a problem.

As a note, the troubled mind idea has been done. In the second module (Thunderspire Labyrinth) there is a creature called an Enigma of Vecna that steals memories and such. This is represented by it stealing the powers the players can use.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 1:15 pm
by DocBeard
I've gotta agree. The intention is solid, Al, but ultimately these things were dropped for a reason.

Why not use the disease mechanic if you want a lingering effect? You can make 'disease' into a curse or similar malady easily enough.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 1:29 pm
by Igor the Henchman
alhoon wrote:
Well, interesting opinion. However from what I have seen in my table, PCs are quite afraid of losing something they will need hours of game (or weeks in real time) to get back.
In 2nd edition I have seen players losing interest about their char and dropping the game after losing 3 levels. In 3rd edition, with the negative levels it were better since it was easier to get back your lost levels.
I don't want to go back to the extremity of energy drain or ability drain that was in 2nd edition, that made people drop the game. Still, I like effects that leave lingering damage difficult for the PCs to take out, while not losing too much so that they will still be fun to play.
Well, OK. You're right. It really depends on the table. If a mechanic adds thrill to your group, by all means, use it. Your ideas sound like they've been tested by time.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 1:58 pm
by alhoon
Mortavius wrote:I have to agree with Igor; I like the lack of options that require your to do extensive recalculating in the middle of a fight in preference for the on/off effects. I absolutely hated level drain in 2E (felt WAY too much like a punishment), and although 3E did a better job of it, it was still clunky.
Actually you agree with me too. :) As I said, I had a friend that dropped a campaign after losing 3 levels. I can't say I blame him. It was really, really not enjoying session for him when he lost the levels. He felt... cheated. Like "I played for hours, growing stronger etc and within a fight I'm dropped to power? Better to kill the char than have him weaker than the rest."


DocBeard wrote:I've gotta agree. The intention is solid, Al, but ultimately these things were dropped for a reason.


I never went for permanent weaking effects. :) Neither in 2nd edition when diseases were permanently dropping your stats and restoration could restore just ONE lost level.
Neither I ever played with the "risen chars lose a level" rule in 3rd edition. It was too harsh for my table.

I know very, very well the reasons these were dropped. :wink:
Weakening for a few hours seems OK IMO.
Mortavius wrote:
As a note, the troubled mind idea has been done. In the second module (Thunderspire Labyrinth) there is a creature called an Enigma of Vecna that steals memories and such. This is represented by it stealing the powers the players can use.
Stealing them for how long? More than one encounter and it is dangerously close to "too harsh" for me (unless it steals daily powers). Let's face it, the PCs are playing the game for the story but also for the C00l powerz! Stealing these powers for long is stealing the fun.

Oh, and actually I find the constant draining of Healing surges quite harsh. Stealing a couple in a fight it's OK. But stealing 4-5 is essentially a session closer as the PCs don't have the resoursces to go on.

Clarification: I think I have been misunderstood here. I never said that I want to permanently weaken the players. Such decissions steal the fun.
What I said is that I don't find arduous adding a -1 to rolls in the middle of a combat. :) Also I don't feel that telling them "the -2 persists until you do the remove affliction ritual" is too harsh... unless it takes more than 1-2 days to find the means to do the ritual.

Igor the Henchman wrote: Well, OK. You're right. It really depends on the table. If a mechanic adds thrill to your group, by all means, use it. Your ideas sound like they've been tested by time.
:wink: Well, the energy drain doesn't work very well, because it may add up to great penalties making the character mostly worthless.
If anyone uses my rules for energy drain, I would advise to never use more than 2-3 monsters that can use energy drain between uses of remove affliction ritual.
I mean, if your party's cleric has enough reagents to make enough such rituals, it's OK to have 3 energy drainers spread out in the day before he does the necessary rituals.
Each energy draining monster drains (at paragon tier) about 2-3 levels in a fight. Now if 3 chars gain a -1 to attack rolls and defences and -10 hp until the next extended rest it's OK.
But if a character loses 6 levels ... well he's someone that is severely weakened. For example a cleric would be at -30 hp and -3 to all attacks and defences.


However, ability damage works fine if you don't mind doing a minor recalculation.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 9:30 pm
by Kaitou Kage
alhoon wrote:As I said, I had a friend that dropped a campaign after losing 3 levels. I can't say I blame him. It was really, really not enjoying session for him when he lost the levels. He felt... cheated. Like "I played for hours, growing stronger etc and within a fight I'm dropped to power? Better to kill the char than have him weaker than the rest."


Well, the energy drain doesn't work very well, because it may add up to great penalties making the character mostly worthless.
If anyone uses my rules for energy drain, I would advise to never use more than 2-3 monsters that can use energy drain between uses of remove affliction ritual.
I mean, if your party's cleric has enough reagents to make enough such rituals, it's OK to have 3 energy drainers spread out in the day before he does the necessary rituals.
Each energy draining monster drains (at paragon tier) about 2-3 levels in a fight. Now if 3 chars gain a -1 to attack rolls and defences and -10 hp until the next extended rest it's OK.
But if a character loses 6 levels ... well he's someone that is severely weakened. For example a cleric would be at -30 hp and -3 to all attacks and defences.


However, ability damage works fine if you don't mind doing a minor recalculation.
I get the impression most folks here, like myself now, are agreeing with you about ditching the permanence, and that nobody has been arguing that :) I think the sticking point that most of us are having is with the recalculation, not any long-term effects. 4e combat and battle effects are far more streamlined overall than they ever have been. Ability damage and to a lesser extent, level loss, permanent or not, was just too overly complicated. I know a good portion of hardcore gamers can pull the adjusted stats out at the drop of a hat, but not all of us are so inclined, and the gamers that can do that probably represent a small minority.

Think about it. Taking a negative level in general is more than just -1 to all rolls. You have to recalculate hp and in an environment like 4e where level is a much more intimate part of your character's power, you have to remember to dock an additional -1 for the 1/2 level thing, and so on. If you take ability damage, you have to recalculate almost your entire character sheet, especially if it's one of your main attack stats. These things take an awful lot of time to work out. And since they almost never occur on the player's turn, the player has to scramble to get them worked out. Not everyone can do that easily, so it seems like it's a little too much.

So I think you are misinterpreting the arguments against you here :) Everyone agrees that permanent level/ability loss is too much. The argument is that the mechanics for ability/level damage are too clunky, especially for the 4e environment.

Now, I don't think long-term effects are needed to make characters scared. And it kind of runs counter to the way 4e seems to work (most effects last for the encounter only). Moreover, my experience has been that most fights in the upper end of "standard" and lower end of "hard" for a party's level will be a pretty good challenge -- enough to make the players sweat, but not so much that they can't win as long as they avoid doing stupid things. In my humble opinion, that's what you should really go for in combat, not something permanent. If the characters need to sacrifice something, it seems to me that it should be a story item, not a mechanical thing. Plus, as I said, it seems we're all agreed that long-term sacrifices like level and ability drain are generally a bad thing :)

The other thing that I think is important to consider is 4e was deliberately designed without effects like level and ability drain. Introducing these to the environment could create risks that really are unnecessarily powerful since there's relatively nothing to balance them against. That and effects like ability damage mean something entirely different in 4e. Dexterity damage to a wizard in 3e might mean his ranged touch spells are harder to land. In 4e, Dexterity damage means practically nothing to the same wizard. You could drain a rogue's Strength, but his Fort defense will only go as low as his Constitution allows. So the mechanic is wildly skewed.

All that being said, if it works for you, then more power to you :) I personally don't think there's a place for ability/level damage in 4e at all because it's needlessly complicated (and I think that's what others above were saying, but they are welcome to correct me if I'm wrong). However, if you like it and your players like it, there's no reason for you not to do it!

Re: Effects for 4E that will be scary

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 9:48 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:Negative levels: You lose as many hit points as you normaly gain when you go up a level (i.e 4 for a wizard). You can't heal them until you remove the negative levels. For every 2 negative levels you gain a -1 to defences and skill checks as the flame of your life is diminished.
If you ever have as many Negative levels as your level total you die.
It seems like a good idea, but isn't it just easier to do 5 damage and grant a -1 penalty on attacks, defence, and skill checks until after your next extended rest?
alhoon wrote:Ability damage: I never understood why 4E got away with ability damage. It's not that difficult to calculate.
By itself it isn't, but it can get complicated.

But you take a hit to dex. Which affects your AC, Reflex save, dex checks, initiative, and multiple skills. Not to mention any ranged combat. It can be alot of adjustment on the fly.
Then there are feats with pre-reqs which you lose. And someone might compensate with a cat's grace which might change things again for a fight.

It's just easier to add a -1 penalty to attack and defence(s).

I had a game stopping situation last Saturday related to ability damage. My wizard was being blood drained by a crimson mist, loising 1d4 Con each round, and losing related hp as the con dropped (as bonus hp were removed).
I was at 3hp (down to 7 Con from 14 IIRC) and there was debate if I could reach 0hp from just blood loss. I thought that if I was dropped to 5 Con I'd lose another 3hp (3rd level wizard) but the counter argument was you always have 1hp gained each level regardless of Con penalty so you could never drop lower than your level in hp.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 11:20 pm
by alhoon
Kaitu Kage and Jester:

Yeap, you're right. I have forgot that -2 to dex means more than a -1 to AC, dex skills and checks and ranged combat.
It may mean that you have to check your powers, since some say "You deal extra damage = dex modifier" or "you shift dex mod squares".

While I stand firm that it's possible, it's immensely easier for me and the player to adjust just the affected attributes. Say a -2 to melee hit and damage rolls, -2 to all strength checks and skills instead of a -4 strength (which means recalculation of how many squares someone is pushed back etc).

Sometimes I'll have effects that temporarily reduce an attribute and force recalculation, but that's personal taste and as Igor said, it fits my table.

Remember that in one of my tables, I have people that found the 3rd edition combat "too simplified". One of them, as a DM had made a complex system about which weapon penetrates how much of which armor type, how much power attack gives with which weapon type etc etc.A combat usually took 3-4 hours at 4th level. While the system was realistic we dropped it later.

Still, the system we use in my 3rd edition game is more complicated than usual 3rd.
Jester of the FoS wrote: I had a game stopping situation last Saturday related to ability damage. My wizard was being blood drained by a crimson mist, loising 1d4 Con each round, and losing related hp as the con dropped (as bonus hp were removed).
I was at 3hp (down to 7 Con from 14 IIRC) and there was debate if I could reach 0hp from just blood loss. I thought that if I was dropped to 5 Con I'd lose another 3hp (3rd level wizard) but the counter argument was you always have 1hp gained each level regardless of Con penalty so you could never drop lower than your level in hp.
Happens a lot. The counter argument is right. You never have less than your level in hp.
bellow 10 con, you don't lose 1hp/lvl.

Here's the average for various con mods at d4.
12: 3.5hp /lvl
10: 2.5hp /lvl
8: 1.75hp/lvl (1+1+2+3)/4
6: 1.25 hp/lvl
4: 1 hp/lvl

So for 3rd lvl wizard it is:
Drops to 10 con from 14: loses 2 hpx3lvls = 6 hp.

drops to 8 con from 10: loses 0.75x3 hp= 2.25hp=2 hp.
drops to 6 con from 10: loses 1.25X3 hp= 3.75 hp =3 hp.
drops to 4 con from 10: loses 1.5 X 3 hp= 4.5 hp =4 hp.

So in total at con 5 from 14 you should have lost 15 hp.

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 11:42 pm
by Igor the Henchman
If you really want to get the PCs running for their lives:

Life drain aura: characters within area of effect cannot regain lost hit points.

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 7:55 am
by alhoon
Interesting. :)

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 8:43 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
If you're really looking to avoid paperwork, why not just have players keep a separate character sheet for each level, filling in a new one when their PCs advance? No need to track penalties or spells or ability-boosts or whatever, just pull out the old sheet if they suffer a negative level. At worst, they might have to add a bonus for an upgraded magic weapon to their old stats. Plus, retaining the old sheets allows them to look back at how far their PCs have come.

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:43 am
by Igor the Henchman
Because your more important stats aren't just on your sheet, anymore. You got class powers by the bucketload too. I play a 3rd level dragonborn paladin with four magic items, and once battle starts, I shuffle through my powers as though through a deck. My power cards have all my attack bonuses and variable effects pre-calculated in advance. Change my level or ability scores, and I have to recalculate everything.

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 12:48 pm
by DocBeard
Igor, I like that one. Mind if I borrow it for when my PCs get trapped in a dimension dominated by Anti-Life?