Page 1 of 1
Help with a Darkonese mystery
Posted: Wed Feb 18, 2009 6:41 pm
by Troile
So we're about to start a new game.
All 3 characters are investigators or searchers of knowledge of one type or another (should be a good game).
(Human Swashbuckler investigator, Halfling Wizard/Rogue with ranks in alchemy and Elven Cleric of Ezra out to prove the Lawful Evil sect has it all wrong)
I want to set the stage by having some troublemakers from Lamordia scare/torment a small village near the border. They set up machines and wear costumes to trick the villagers into believing there is some foul magic afoot. Everything works so far and they even blind a bunch of the townsfolk. Their plan is to blame it on magic and demi-humans and then save the day with science.
Unfortunately their memories get rewritten before they can undo the damage they have caused and they become victims to it as well.
So the PCs have to figure out what is going on, avoid blame for it and track it back to the culprits. The culprits will deny doing it and they have no recollection of it.
The solution will be to somehow get them back into Lamordia so they get their memories back and then remember how to undo the damage.
So I've got a few problems.
1) Method of implementation. What sorts of things do they use to mimic magic? Alchemical formulas would be good, I want there to be lots of mist and such. How do they pin it on demi-humans and wizards? They could dress up but I'd like something more elaborate.
2) The clues that lead the PCs back to them. There needs to be a lot of them since they won't be involved anymore.
3) The hint to the solution, getting them back to Lamordia will solve the problem.
This will be an opening adventure and this time we don't have the PCs knowing each other ahead of time. 2 of the 3 are demi-humans (elf and halfling) so I think the distrust of the villagers will draw them together. I think they will distrust each other first but eventually they will see through the clues that none of them are guilty and then they will team up.
I'm pretty much open to anything. There are no bad guys to fight since the bad guys are just peasants so I can go nuts with smoke and mirrors and I don't have to worry about killing the low level PCs.
Posted: Wed Feb 18, 2009 11:08 pm
by Archedius
Chemical gases, bombs etc would work nicely. These things are similar to certain spells. Certain chemical weapons can cause blindness, and there has to be a container of some sort, no matter how well hidden.
As for the container- it could bear the mark of the smithy that made it or be in a style that Lamordians prefer. A hermit(you can make a fun NPC here), hunter or woodsman might've seen strangers about and your PC's could find their abandoned camp.
I would recommend writing out a plot tree with multiple paths/endings. If you do it right, you can nearly wing it and have the PC's feel as though they actually solved the mystery without you having a hand in the events. Any DnD mystery will have the DM determining when there's success, but a good DM will hide this fact. Good luck and have fun!
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 5:13 am
by The Giamarga
When doing mysteries in RPG it is important to approach it from a gamist perspective and not a simulationist one. Don't let the PCs miss a clue. If they miss it when you first present it with NPC A, present the same clue or a very similar in another way. The PCs have to get their clues.
Read
this post on ENWorld (and indeed the whole thread) for more insight.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 9:04 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
While it was written with doppelganger scenarios in mind, you might find some ideas for staging a Whodunit game in the appendix of the VRF:D. IIRC, there are some handy suggestions there for how to run large numbers of paranoid civilians, how to hide a culprit among innocents, and how to deal with players who overlook or misinterpret clues.
As for the issue of how these bad guys would frame demihumans and wizards for the crimes, it'd help if you narrow the scope a bit, and have them lay blame on a specific nonhuman NPC wizard. For one thing, it's a tall order to turn Darkonian humans against demihumans as a whole -- as a nation, they're rather proud of their diversity, and most folk in Darkon know that "demihumans" aren't just one monotypic culture -- and for another, it'd be more personal for the players if their characters can get to know the NPC who's been targeted. If there's some history of enmity between this demihuman and the Lamordians (e.g. an old gnome mage who'd independently patented a device their leader had also been trying to invent), that'll give them a convenient thread to follow as they investigate.
That way, establishing the frame becomes a simple matter of planting evidence which can be traced back to the NPC in question. Easier to set up than dressing up as generic "demihumans", and more in keeping with the traditions of the mystery genre.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:10 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
You also might want to work on the motives of the Lamordians. At least as far as the books go, Lamordians in general have been characterized as stoic, no-nonsense, and unsuperstitious. They aren't, on the whole, intolerant of demihumans, just ignorant of them. Same with magic, they don't hate wizards, they just either don't believe in them or see them as misguidedly meddling with forces they don't understand in a dangerously unscientific way.
So you need to figure out why this particular group of Lamordians has such a vendetta against the demihumans and wizards. Once their motives are clearer, that should lead to some more clues to plant. Also, how were they planning to "save the day" with science. Did they have a medicinal way to cure the blindness they inflicted?
I agree with making them blame a particular demihuman wizard. Easier to prove a single person's innocence than a whole group. Also along the lines of what The Giamarga said, definitely try to plant way more clues, or at least routes to the clues than the PCs will ever find. Because they won't find the ones you think are so obvious.
Check what sort of abilities your PCs have that might help with the investigation and be sure to use them. For example, I'm always sure to have animal witnesses for my ranger to speak with animals with, and lingering spirits or ethereal resonance for my ghostsighted/ethereal empathetic PC to see.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 8:52 pm
by Troile
Chemical gases, bombs etc would work nicely. These things are similar to certain spells. Certain chemical weapons can cause blindness, and there has to be a container of some sort, no matter how well hidden.
That's what I was thinking.
I would recommend writing out a plot tree with multiple paths/endings. If you do it right, you can nearly wing it and have the PC's feel as though they actually solved the mystery without you having a hand in the events.
That's the plan (:
When doing mysteries in RPG it is important to approach it from a gamist perspective and not a simulationist one. Don't let the PCs miss a clue. If they miss it when you first present it with NPC A, present the same clue or a very similar in another way. The PCs have to get their clues.
I prefer to give an abundant amount of clues...unless there has to be important ones then I agree with you.
While it was written with doppelganger scenarios in mind, you might find some ideas for staging a Whodunit game in the appendix of the VRF:D. IIRC, there are some handy suggestions there for how to run large numbers of paranoid civilians, how to hide a culprit among innocents, and how to deal with players who overlook or misinterpret clues.
I'll check it out, thanks.
As for the issue of how these bad guys would frame demihumans and wizards for the crimes, it'd help if you narrow the scope a bit, and have them lay blame on a specific nonhuman NPC wizard.
I was thinking of having them carve elven runes into cattle and basically specifically blame elves.
I do have to work on their motives. I know that it will involve them thinking what people perceive as magic is a blight on the world and that demi-humans are inferior and are just animals but yet they're still treated like humans in Darkon so they want to put a stop to it.
Also along the lines of what The Giamarga said, definitely try to plant way more clues, or at least routes to the clues than the PCs will ever find. Because they won't find the ones you think are so obvious.
Agreed...I just have to come up with the clues first, that's the hard part.
Thanks for all the help.
My game is on Sunday, I've been panicking a bit b/c I've had so much work all week. I'm sure on Saturday though when I can devote a full day to it I'll be able to flesh it out some more.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 9:20 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Troile wrote:I do have to work on their motives. I know that it will involve them thinking what people perceive as magic is a blight on the world and that demi-humans are inferior and are just animals but yet they're still treated like humans in Darkon so they want to put a stop to it.
Sounds more like a Falkovnian attitude than Lamordian. Have you considered making the culprits Falkovnian? You'd then have to deal with their forehead Hawk brands, but perhaps that could just be a big clue. Given the nature of Darkon, they probably wouldn't be the only "Darkonians" around sporting such brands. (maybe their altered memories include a brief capture by the Falkovnians and then an escape "home" to Darkon.)
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 9:43 pm
by Troile
Sounds more like a Falkovnian attitude than Lamordian. Have you considered making the culprits Falkovnian? You'd then have to deal with their forehead Hawk brands, but perhaps that could just be a big clue. Given the nature of Darkon, they probably wouldn't be the only "Darkonians" around sporting such brands. (maybe their altered memories include a brief capture by the Falkovnians and then an escape "home" to Darkon.)
It doesn't mean all Lamordians aren't like that.
There is even a secret society of Lamordians that are specifically racist and hate magic.
Falkovnia doesn't fit the theme at all.
Even if .005% of Lamordians were racist it would still be enough.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 11:41 pm
by Archedius
I think I remember seeing a society in the Gaz that has Lamordia in it- their goal was the snuffing out of arcane magic. I think I'm not making that up, but it's worth checking out.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 11:50 pm
by Mangrum
The Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens.
Posted: Fri Feb 20, 2009 12:03 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Troile wrote:It doesn't mean all Lamordians aren't like that.
Indeed, but that makes it all the more important to explain what made these particular Lamordians different.
There is even a secret society of Lamordians that are specifically racist and hate magic.
Yup, I'd forgotten about the Syndicate. If you stick with Lamordians, I'd definately link this group to them. It might help as a source of clues, and provide hooks for the future.
Falkovnia doesn't fit the theme at all.
The science theme, no, but the racism theme, yes. When you mentioned them equating demihumans with animals, it sounded like a very Falkovnian point of view. That's what I was referring to. (The Syndicate sidebar in Gaz II even mentions them using racist Falkovnia military officers to further their schemes.)
Even if .005% of Lamordians were racist it would still be enough.
Sure. No culture should be monolithic, even in Ravenloft. I'm just saying, give them a reason for their hate, and you can use that to plant more clues. Maybe an traveling elvish wizard saved their town from some threat when they were trying to do the same with science, and the shame drove them to it. Or an evil elf kidnapped one of their kids for some magic experiment. Or one of their number was turned into a changeling by the shadow-fey, and they don't know the distinction between Arak and Elf. Maybe one of them had a crush on some lady who was swept of her feet by an elven bard. That sort of thing.
I like the idea of elven runes carved into cattle. One clue there might be that the runes don't make sense to anyone who reads elven. Or they might make sense, but be stilted and grammatically incorrect.
Posted: Fri Feb 20, 2009 7:16 am
by Troile
I'm just saying, give them a reason for their hate, and you can use that to plant more clues. Maybe an traveling elvish wizard saved their town from some threat when they were trying to do the same with science, and the shame drove them to it. Or an evil elf kidnapped one of their kids for some magic experiment. Or one of their number was turned into a changeling by the shadow-fey, and they don't know the distinction between Arak and Elf. Maybe one of them had a crush on some lady who was swept of her feet by an elven bard. That sort of thing.
Good ideas.
I like the idea of elven runes carved into cattle. One clue there might be that the runes don't make sense to anyone who reads elven. Or they might make sense, but be stilted and grammatically incorrect.
That was my idea exactly.
Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 10:52 pm
by Troile
Thanks for the help.
I ended up taking some of the advice offered here.
The culprits kidnap a local recluse wizard and make it look like he's doing it. Of course when they lose their memory they forget that he is locked in a cellar and he is currently starving.
I've got 3 main points of interest, the wizard's house, the mysterious events in the forest and an imitation dark ritual in a farmer's field.
The culprits are now a husband and wife farmer, an apothecary and a tailor.
When the PCs check out the apothecary and the tailor they will see obvious things, like alchemist equipment taken from the wizard and such. Then they can link those to the farmers who have the wizard.
We had our first session and it went pretty well. We didn't get much time to play but the PCs visited the wizard's house first and found some clues though they'll have to go back to find some more.