Page 1 of 1

ghost and ethereal resonance

Posted: Wed Feb 18, 2009 6:49 pm
by kottakinge
Hello,
i see what is ethereal resonance but i was wondering i someone is able to see the ethereal resonance, will he see a ghost?
The spell "see ethereal resonance" in VRA don't mention that.
Ghosts aren't really ethereal resonance (i think they can "fuel" ethereal resonance because they bring with them the emotions that surround their deaths, so that a haunted place won't have its ethereal resonance faded away by the passage of time because a ghost refuled it), right? :D
How will a PC notice a ghost who cannot manifest, execpt with a spell that bring him to the ethereal (seems mid level spell if i remender).
A practical example: a PC is haunted by a corpse candle (a ghost that don't manifest on the material plane) how can his comrade see this ghost that float above his head but that is visible only in the ethereal plane?
Your wise advices are needed fellow DM
:lol:

Posted: Wed Feb 18, 2009 7:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Given that Ghostsight is a separate feat from Ethereal Empathy, it would seem that detecting ethereal resonance doesn't mean you see ethereal creatures.

Ethereal creatures can be detected by non-ethereal creatures using the See Invisibility spell. That would spot your corpse candle, just fine.

The PHB spell description doesn't explicitly say if ethereal presences that aren't creatures or distinct objects also become visible. However, it seems to me that if you want to make use of the atmospheric imagery which goes along with resonance, as described in RLDMG, you ought to make it as easy to discern via spells as possible.

Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 5:56 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Remember that Ethereal Empathy requires a Wisdom check based on the magnitude of the resonance. Even then it's more like picking up a psychic photograph than seeing truly ethereal things. Ghostsight allows you to see ethereal creatures, but you can't tell them from Material creatures unless they're obviously (un)dead.

Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 9:34 am
by kottakinge
Thanks for your reponse.
I reread the entry for see invisibility and it's written that you can see ethereal creature too.
For ethereal resonance there is a special spell in VRA called see ethereal resonance so IMHO see invisibility won't work for that