Page 1 of 2
Epic Ravenloft
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 2:47 pm
by DocBeard
I've heard from several reputable sources that Ravenloft really stops being viable around 15th level; that PCs simply become too powerful to fit into the setting. Then again, a reputable source once insisted to me that a game is not worth playing past level eight. While the former point is far more legitimate than the latter, I happen to believe it is just as wrong; enjoying Ravenloft at epic level is not a matter of system or player problems, but of a shift in the DM's attitude. Ravenloft is a setting where some of the most powerful villains in the D&D universe rule, and epic heroes can certainly challenge them.
My primary idea: Similar to Van Richten, players who make epic tier are something Else. They have the potential to change the whole world just through existing. If Ravenloft is a living world that sets good against evil to see what happens, your epic hero is the counterpart to the Azalins and Strahds who've fully realized their potential as Darklords.
So who else is the world going to turn to for help?
What'd life be like if Ravenloft stopped 'hating' you, and started to LIKE you? You get sucked into the Mists and dropped off with no explanation, and have to find out what reality-shattering threat is amassing in the seemingly quiet little hamlet. The Mists take you somewhere they think would be a 'fun' vacation...like the desert of Torog. Your rivals or friends might be haunted by mist creatures because the Mists are trying to 'help' you-and it's up to you to convince them that it's wrong. Somehow.
That's an epic level problem, and it needs epic level heroes. Preserving Ravenloft keeps the PCs from thinking they can wander around whacking Darklords and breaking up Domains, too-if that keeps being a problem, have the Mists insist the PCs help find a suitable replacement for the fallen Darklord, or even serve an interim term as "Lightlord" until they can find an appropriate villain to be bound within the domain.
Another Thought: What if the shadows of the gods that the people of Ravenloft became independent of the Dark Powers? The Lawgiver is no longer the memory of Bane, but a new god of law and might with his own plans for the universe. Who's going to be responsible for this sudden shift in the divine balance of power?
If you guessed, "The players.", you're darn right.
So, what do you guys think? Any ideas for cool epic-level Ravenloft adventures, threats, or rewards?
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 3:01 pm
by NeoTiamat
While not having personally played in it, I am aware of at least one epic level game (Reckonings, I believe it was) that was epic-level. I know that plans for another one were discussed, but nothing came of it.
Practically speaking, Ravenloft has no shortage of epic-level foes or goals. Off-hand, I can think of a half-dozen Darklords, defeating any of whom would be a perfectly Epic challenge (Azalin, Strahd, Meredoth, Diamabel.... Gwydion seems like a perfect candidate for a 35 Solo, you ask me)
I think that a high level campaign need not necessarily be categorically different from a lower level campaign. It can be, but nothing says you can't have a really high level campaign using the basic principles of a lower level game. Just upgrade the scale.
So instead of having a rank 2 ghost in a haunted house, have a Rank 4 Ghost/Sorcerer trying to recreate the Requiem in Levkarest. Instead of a 100 year old, vampire preying on a town, have a cabal of three Patriarch (1000+) vampires conspiring to overthrow a nation and turn it into their own, personal blood farm. Instead of having to defeat a wandering ghoul, defeat a rogue, mind-bending horror from Bluetspur that transforms everyone who sees it into a mindless slave... and it's path is taking it closer and closer to Kantora.
Just up the ante.
Posted: Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:56 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
It's not that simple. Ravenloft is a world of horror, dread, and mystery. As PCs rise in power, their confidence grows with their abilities and mood is a lot harder to achieve and maintain.
One way around this is to do as NeoTiamat said: up the ante. That doesn't really work well because once the PCs start facing rank five ghosts around every corner then the impact of what could create such a powerful ghost is lost; the same applies to many monsters with magnitudes or age categories. Additional class levels or HD would be better for power increase.
The method I used--and still use in the Lost Journals--is to emphasize that the PCs are now very big fish in a very small pond. The tiniest move could cause waves that will attract the attention of the darklords or even the Dark Powers. Suddenly they have to watch themselves; not because they're so weak, but because they're too strong. Darklords would want such powerful agents for themselves, secret societies would be all over them trying to recruit or kill them, and the Dark Powers? Who knows what they would do? This has more impact for RP-heavy games, since most of the consequences can't really be turned into raw numbers or mechanics.
Combining the two is probably the best way to run epic Ravenloft. I never got far into epic play before my last group disbanded so I'm going on assumption and past experience.
I also recommend epic spells be made impossible or at least only possible in areas of high magic (Darkon, the Shadow Rift, etc.). Even then there should be some serious consequences above and beyond what's listed in the ELH.
Posted: Sun Mar 01, 2009 12:27 am
by Archedius
ditto to what High Priest Mikhal has said

Posted: Sun Mar 01, 2009 5:03 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Then again, you could always go off the beaten track and try to apply "Exalted 2e" rules for your high-level Ravenloft campaigns. Works for me.
Posted: Tue Mar 03, 2009 8:54 pm
by Tykus
One of the goals of my Jagged Shoals Log in the fan fiction area was to create a cluster for epic heroes (and I do plan to resume making entries in the near future). If you read even just the first entries, you will notice I had the environment attack them (literally) and deprived the characters of most of their magical gear within hours of their arrival.
I think sometimes the best way to deal with high-level characters is to make sure their dealing with the environment as well as their foes; it seems to work quite well for many action movies of the scifi/fantasy genre (example: the Obi-Wan/Anakin lightsaber battle on Mustafar in Ep. III)
Also, as is the case of my Jagged Shoals cluster, epic heroes require epic foes. The first domain they were in had an elder evil as a domain lord, the current domain (as of the last post I made), while not mention yet, has an epic axani (or zenythri) wizard/monk.
The JS cluster aside, there are plenty of epic/near-epic villians in the Core: Strahd, Azalin, Gwydion, Meredoth, and Van Reise all make power brokers. But don't forget some of the "lesser" darklords. Imagine one of the PCs addicted to Borrowed Time; those border closures have no saving throw unless the PCs have gone out of their way to change their creature type/subtype (epic monk, construct, undead, elemental)
Sorry for the ramble, epic adventures in RL require even more planning than a "typical" RL campaign or non-RL epic campaign.
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 12:49 am
by ewancummins
I consider my follow up to Raf's game to be 'epic Ravenloft' and it has 'only' 8th and 9th level PCs. I wouldn't even bother to try running anything above 12th, I think. At high levels, the threat of death diminishes, saves become
very good, and the PCs are essentially super heroes. While one can run a good dark fantasy sort of game at that level , I think the low to mid levels work best for Gothic Horror or horror/low fantasy/weird tales.
That being said, I do enjoy reading about the epic campaigns and ideas for such here on this thread. Just not my personal prefernce as a Ravenloft DM.
PS- I remember when Strahd has, what, 60 hit points? Maybe 57. He was tough because he used all his vamp powers wisely and had class levels and minions. He's been tunred into a demi-god in the newest stuff, from what I've seen.

Gotta keep pace with power creep!

Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 10:03 am
by DocBeard
So you don't have any opinion on my ideas for making high level Ravenloft more feasible?
Re: Epic Ravenloft
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 11:28 am
by Jester of the FoS
I've kinda ranted about this before, but I'll repeat.
DocBeard wrote:I've heard from several reputable sources that Ravenloft really stops being viable around 15th level; that PCs simply become too powerful to fit into the setting. Then again, a reputable source once insisted to me that a game is not worth playing past level eight.
That might be a 3e-ism, where the game falls apart mechanically after L15 and becomes super-human around L8. At that point the PCs can leap farther, run faster, fall farther, swim longer, and know more than most humans are physically capable.
DocBeard wrote:While the former point is far more legitimate than the latter, I happen to believe it is just as wrong; enjoying Ravenloft at epic level is not a matter of system or player problems, but of a shift in the DM's attitude. Ravenloft is a setting where some of the most powerful villains in the D&D universe rule, and epic heroes can certainly challenge them.
My argument has always been that true epic-level play has to do more than challenge the PCs. You could ramp-up all the monsters and AC and damage in
Keep on the Shadowfell to L25 but it's still not going to be an epic adventure.
DocBeard wrote:My primary idea: Similar to Van Richten, players who make epic tier are something Else. They have the potential to change the whole world just through existing. If Ravenloft is a living world that sets good against evil to see what happens, your epic hero is the counterpart to the Azalins and Strahds who've fully realized their potential as Darklords.
So who else is the world going to turn to for help?
That's very true. Heck, Van Richten was L10 when we say him, strictly Heroic tier. Even at Paragon levels the PCs should have a larger reputation and change the world more.
At Epic... they're near to gods.
Literally. Gods are L35. Demon lords and princes vary in levels from 28-33 so far. When you hit the high 20s you are equal in game power to the lord of a level of the Abyss. You are equal in power to Vecna when he was a darklord.
DocBeard wrote:What'd life be like if Ravenloft stopped 'hating' you, and started to LIKE you? You get sucked into the Mists and dropped off with no explanation, and have to find out what reality-shattering threat is amassing in the seemingly quiet little hamlet. The Mists take you somewhere they think would be a 'fun' vacation...like the desert of Torog. Your rivals or friends might be haunted by mist creatures because the Mists are trying to 'help' you-and it's up to you to convince them that it's wrong. Somehow.
This might imply a little too much sentience in the Mists. It's interesting but divorces the Mists from the Dark Powers and turns them into strange, literal-interpreting poor henchmen.
DocBeard wrote:That's an epic level problem, and it needs epic level heroes. Preserving Ravenloft keeps the PCs from thinking they can wander around whacking Darklords and breaking up Domains, too-if that keeps being a problem, have the Mists insist the PCs help find a suitable replacement for the fallen Darklord, or even serve an interim term as "Lightlord" until they can find an appropriate villain to be bound within the domain.
The idea of replacing lords with good figures is interesting. Redeem Ravenloft. That might be a neat idea to wrap-up a campaign in epic levels.
(Funny how every epic Ravenloft suggestion I read always involves the entire world becoming unrecognizable at the end and prevents future games in the same timeline. You don't see that as much in Eberron or the Realms.)
DocBeard wrote:Another Thought: What if the shadows of the gods that the people of Ravenloft became independent of the Dark Powers? The Lawgiver is no longer the memory of Bane, but a new god of law and might with his own plans for the universe. Who's going to be responsible for this sudden shift in the divine balance of power?
If you guessed, "The players.", you're darn right.
This itself is the best idea I've heard for Epic Ravenloft. Dealing with newly incarnated gods given flesh. Because, unlike my comment above, it could end and the world could not be a smoking, unrecognizable crater.
It'd be tricky to space out long enough, but it is doable.
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 11:35 am
by Jester of the FoS
NeoTiamat wrote:Practically speaking, Ravenloft has no shortage of epic-level foes or goals. Off-hand, I can think of a half-dozen Darklords, defeating any of whom would be a perfectly Epic challenge (Azalin, Strahd, Meredoth, Diamabel.... Gwydion seems like a perfect candidate for a 35 Solo, you ask me)
Level 20 in 3e does not equal level 30 in 4e.
L20 =/= L30.
Azalin and Strahd in 'Loft would be maybe 23 or 24. 25 at most. Meredoth and Diamabel would be lower. There'd be maybe 2-3 others.
And Gwydion, as much as I love the mook, is NOT equal to Tiamat, a greater god. Maybe a demon or devil prince, but probably not Orcus or Demogorgon. He'd likely be L29, level 30 or 31 at the MOST.
But really, I'd put most at levels that would be usable at high Paragon (L19-21). Especially since they'd likely have minions so they couldn't be solos 2-3 levels above the PCs.
NeoTiamat wrote:I think that a high level campaign need not necessarily be categorically different from a lower level campaign. It can be, but nothing says you can't have a really high level campaign using the basic principles of a lower level game. Just upgrade the scale.
Great!
My next camapign will be set at L25 and feature the characters cleaning-out epicly powerful kobolds and goblins from a series of caves around a keep on the borderlands.

Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 12:55 pm
by DocBeard
Thanks for the detailed feedback, Jester. I really appreciate it. As for the Mists, perhaps I saw too much sentience in how they worked-there was a deliberate cruelty there, and thus, I reasoned, there could be deliberate kindness.
As far as leaving Ravenloft a smoking crater, half of that is because the bad guys are universally in charge. To confront them is to confront the hierarchy of a whole Domain, even in the case of shadowy Darklords like Inza.
Personally, I would probably lighten the planar travel rules a little too, while I am at it, because you've got a point, at some level 4E expects epic heroes to challenge the heavens and hells of the setting.
As far as the type of challenges faced, Herc wasn't too good to have to clean a stable for a whole adventure. I mean, you make an excellent point, but I think you, perhaps, underestimate how involved PCs can get with any challenge if presented in the proper manner. If those goblins ate one of the PC's kids alive, well, suddenly they don't care that the goblins are scrub monsters.
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 1:06 pm
by Isabella
DocBeard wrote:
Personally, I would probably lighten the planar travel rules a little too, while I am at it, because you've got a point, at some level 4E expects epic heroes to challenge the heavens and hells of the setting.
That's generally how I imagined playing Epic 4e Ravenloft: Go somewhere else.
You have the Shadow Rift. You have the Nightmare Lands. You have Bluetspur. You have the bottoms of the oceans, and whatever secrets lurk down there. You have wonky pocket domains and mirror universes. You have the Mists themselves, with all the secrets that lurk within, possibly even the Dark Powers. It lets your players be, well, Epic, without upping the fantasy and power level of the mundane world.
Otherwise, well, Ravenloft is a fluid realm, ruled by the whims of unknown and unfathomable entities, so Epic Level challenges showing up and knocking on the PCs door isn't that radical an idea. The PCs could wake up to find their entire home domain is missing one day, and no one even remembers it was there; that should keep even an Epic level party busy for a bit.
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 1:31 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Jester of the FoS wrote:Azalin and Strahd in 'Loft would be maybe 23 or 24. 25 at most. Meredoth and Diamabel would be lower. There'd be maybe 2-3 others.
Just to be contrary: if you're going with the backstory for Meredoth that
DoD introduced and I'd incorporated into the NS Gaz, a 4E Meredoth would need to be upgraded to
30th level. Wizards who manage to make a name for themselves in the Alphatian ruling class tend to be of the maximum level allowed by the core game system, no matter which edition of the game you're playing (36th level in OD&D, 20th in 2E or 3E, 30th in 4E).
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 1:40 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
DocBeard wrote:As far as leaving Ravenloft a smoking crater, half of that is because the bad guys are universally in charge. To confront them is to confront the hierarchy of a whole Domain, even in the case of shadowy Darklords like Inza.
Of course, depending on how powerful you like your campaign's Dark Powers to be, Ravenloft's unique metaphysics
does allow you the rare opportunity to let your PCs turn the game-setting into a smoking crater ... and then
put it back again, either just as it was or with whatever adjustments you like. If the DPs can weave entire nations out of whole cloth, there's no reason they can't drag out the patterns they'd used before and whip up another batch.
How many times did the writers nuke the world on
The Twilight Zone? Didn't stop them from rebooting reality with each new episode, and trying out a different twist ending. Darklords stay dead and domains vanish forever when the DPs are tired of them, and not one moment sooner.
Posted: Thu Mar 05, 2009 3:35 pm
by WolfKook
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Of course, depending on how powerful you like your campaign's Dark Powers to be, Ravenloft's unique metaphysics
does allow you the rare opportunity to let your PCs turn the game-setting into a smoking crater ... and then
put it back again, either just as it was or with whatever adjustments you like. If the DPs can weave entire nations out of whole cloth, there's no reason they can't drag out the patterns they'd used before and whip up another batch.

WOW!!! That sounds like
Matrix Revolutions... And a lot of ideas spring to mind
