Page 1 of 2

3.5 statistics for the common scalpel?

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 7:20 am
by cure
I seem to recall seeing statistics for a scalpel in one of the Ravenloft 3.0 or 3.5 books, but I cannot recall where.

Can anyone help with a Ravenloft source or any other official 3.0 or 3.5 source?

Thanx.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 7:22 am
by Sorti
Masterwork knife, if I recall correctly..

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 8:53 am
by The Giamarga
Are there actually stats for a knife in 3E ? I think there's only the dagger. Now you could use the stats for a small dagger to represent a knife. RL has the razor which could also be used for a scalpel. (either in the Core book or VRA) I would probably use the stats for a masterwork small razor.


Edit: Found more:

Scalpel Goods and Services Book of Vile Darkness (3.0) p39
Straight Razor Weapon Ravenloft Campaign Setting (3.0) p56

from this useful thread: http://forums.gleemax.com/wotc_archive/ ... p/t-627236

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 9:44 am
by cure
The Giamarga wrote:Are there actually stats for a knife in 3E ? I think there's only the dagger. Now you could use the stats for a small dagger to represent a knife. RL has the razor which could also be used for a scalpel. (either in the Core book or VRA) I would probably use the stats for a masterwork small razor.


Edit: Found more:

Scalpel Goods and Services Book of Vile Darkness (3.0) p39
Straight Razor Weapon Ravenloft Campaign Setting (3.0) p56

from this useful thread: http://forums.gleemax.com/wotc_archive/ ... p/t-627236
I think you are right, no knives in 3E.

The Book of Vile Darkness, sadly, just classifies the scapel as a torture instrument that does 1d6 damage, but no detail beyond, as to critical hits, threat range, etc.

I have used the Straight Razor as a substitute in the past, but I am wondering about the legitimacy of doing so. Any experts on straight razors verus scalpels?

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 10:24 am
by BigBadQDaddy
I would think the two would do a similar amount of damage and the differences Game mechanics-wise would be close to non-existent.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 10:30 am
by Mortavius
I would say that the thing only does 1d2 damage at most. It's such a tiny blade; sure it's sharp, but it's also not meant to be used in combat. I would follow the rules for improvised weapons on this one. I mean really, how well would a scalpel do if you attacked someone in armor?

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:04 am
by Nathan of the FoS
I would give a scalpel 1d2 damage with a 4x critical, myself.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:20 am
by BigBadQDaddy
Not to render it completely useless, but I think a x4 would be a bit too high. Granted a scalpel is sharp, it is also ridiculously small.
If the scalpel could crit at x4, that means it crits for a range of 4-8 damage, doing as much damage as a sword. That means theoretically you could chop an arm off with a scalpel in on strike if you rolled high enough (50% chance if crit threat is made).
Regardless of how sharp a scalpel is, it would be incapable of effective use in combat unless of course it was being used in a backstab attack.
...IMHO of course.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:27 am
by cure
For reference/comparison purposes, these are the stats on a razor:

Straight razor - 1d4 damage, x3 critical, 1/2 lb., Slashing

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:30 am
by BigBadQDaddy
Man, That is a B.A. scalpel, lol. Max of 12 dmg with a crit!

I can see it now...

Player: Sweet, I got a 17 CON for my first level fighter, this is gonna be great!

(later)

DM: Out of the shadows, you see the face of a maniac slowly appear...(Rolls some dice)

Player: Don't worry, I can take it. The reports we received from the constable indicated he was killing his victims with a scalpel. How mach can a scalpal do, am I right.

DM: Coming out of the darkness, a wide arcing flash of silver reflect in the moonlight. For a moment you feel nothing, then all goes black. You took 12 points of damage.
The rest of you see the fighter get struck by the maniac. He is cut in half by what appears to be a small surgical scalpel in the maniacs right hand. The fighters upper torso falls to the ground with a meaty thunk!
You are going to have to roll up a new character.

Player: ...Sob

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:33 am
by Nathan of the FoS
BigBadQDaddy wrote:Not to render it completely useless, but I think a x4 would be a bit too high. Granted a scalpel is sharp, it is also ridiculously small.
If the scalpel could crit at x4, that means it crits for a range of 4-8 damage, doing as much damage as a sword.
Sure. What I'm thinking is, if you hit at just the right place--say, the eye, or the neck--(slim odds--a 1 in 20 chance, plus you have to confirm) the scalpel is just as dangerous as a sword. Anywhere else and it is a very minor wound.
That means theoretically you could chop an arm off with a scalpel in on strike if you rolled high enough (50% chance if crit threat is made).
Well, hit point damage doesn't really equate to "could this chop a guy's arm off". :? And if you can hurt a guy wearing plate mail with shuriken, why not a scalpel? That is my reasoning, anyway; YMMV.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 11:46 am
by BigBadQDaddy
I suppose, but in all seriousness, if someone where to get hit in the eye with a scalpel, I highly doubt it would be enough to kill them.
Anyone could make the same argument for a pointy stick, or a piece of paper inflicting a paper cut.
Personally, the only time I would allow a scalpel to inflict such lethal damage would be with a captive victim who is strapped to a medical table or something. In combat, it is just simply unreasonable. Another problem with using a scalpel in combat, the handle is not designed for combat. The chance that it would fall free from your grip due to having such a slim handle, especially if covered in fresh slick blood, would be high.
Sure, scalpel are used in horror movies and such is one thing, especially since they are used in stealth-like sneak attacks. But to have someone with a scalpel go against someone with a long sword is laughable.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 12:15 pm
by The Giamarga
cure wrote:For reference/comparison purposes, these are the stats on a razor:

Straight razor - 1d4 damage, x3 critical, 1/2 lb., Slashing
A straight razor has a considerably longer blade than a scalpel, probably about 10 cms or 4 inches.

Comparing that to a dagger (which has a blade up to a foot long!)...

Dagger - d4 damage, 19-20/×2 critical , range 10 ft., 1 lb. Piercing or slashing

...and checking the Table: Larger and Smaller Weapon Damage in the SRD I would say use the stats for a masterwork tiny razor for a scalpel:

tiny razor - 1d2 damage, x3 critical, slashing (probably better piercing)

Masterwork of course adds +1 to attack.

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 6:41 pm
by Archedius
...people kill people in prison with blades smaller than a scalpel- and those aren't even as sharp!

BTW- if you do take out an eye- there's only a small layer of bone left b4 you hit the brain.

The real danger is getting cut on the torso- it is sharp enough and just big enough to make intestines become exposed. Someone in armor is probably not going to be worried about a scalpel however.

I'd go with 1d2 critx19-20/X2. It doesn't deserve to be 1d4 because that'd be saying that a dagger is as damaging as a scalpel (which is madness).

Posted: Wed Mar 11, 2009 7:34 pm
by BigBadQDaddy
People do get killed in prison by items as small as scalpels, but the method of attack is what does it. Usually the "Shank" is thrust into the victim repeatedly in a relatively short amount of time (think a dozen or so attacks in a single melee round), and not to mention done in quite an underhanded and sneaky fashion (ie; Sneak Attack) such as from behind, or concealing the "shank" until the moment to attack presents itself.