Page 1 of 2
Retooling the Artificer class?
Posted: Sun Mar 15, 2009 11:30 pm
by The Whistler
First things first: if any of my presumptive players are reading this...don't!
(On the other hand, if they've discovered this forum, then them reading this one topic is probably the least of my problems.

)
Anyways, I'm starting a campaign in a month-ish, and could use a bit of help designing a major NPC: a Lamordian alchemical child with a bent toward High Technology, who'll end up allied with the PCs over the long term. This brings up two major issues that, being a DM of Very Little Experience, I have no idea how to implement:
-Since I'm iffy on the Scientist PrC (and am starting her at 1st level anyway), I was thinking of casting her as a sort of variant Artificer, with the infusions and magic items she creates swapped out for mechanically identical technological ones. However, if I just scrub the "magic" from the stuff she does, then that creates a few imbalances I can see (and likely a few I can't): the infusions and whatnot couldn't be dispelled by enemies, and noncasters would be able to use some of the "magic" items she created, even if spellcasting ability was normally a prerequisite to use them. Is there any way to work around this, or would I just be better off keeping the arcane slant to the class altogether?
-Thanks to Story Reasons, this alchemical child doesn't actually *know* that she's a construct, initially--and the PCs shouldn't be able to tell for a good chapter or two, either. This means I'd have a bit of a problem just fitting her with the Alchemical Child template from VRA and calling it a day; I'm not sure she'd hold up to well to consistent scrutiny, that way, and it doesn't seem like the template is balanced for PC use (which is effectively what she's gonna be). As a workaround for this, I was planning to make her essentially an "undercover warforged": mechanically identical to the Eberron race (aside from maybe the Composite Plating and the ability mods), but physically identical to a normal human. Would doing this result in a balanced character, or would I have to tweak her in some other way?
Anyways, if any of you folks are familiar with Eberron at all, I'd really appreciate the help. Thanks!
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 1:10 am
by Cronax
To quote Arthur C. Clarke, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." (And as certain anime has led me to believe, vice versa) In my opinion, you don't even really need to 'scrub' the magic off of her artifices. Just re-flavor them into more technological devices. As for Anti-Magic Fields (Which I would highly discourage the use of in general) and Dispel Magic and the like I would recommend something along the lines of the Magic-Psionics transparency rule. Although they are distinct ways of manipulating reality, for the most part they interact with each other as though they were the same. Its not unreasonable that a wizard's dispel magic could temporarily fill a gadget with magical gremlins rendering it inoperable or that a technological dispel projection device could temporarily reassert the laws of physics and turn some magic off (Technocracy FTW).
On the subject of Artificers, I think they could be a pretty good fit with what you want. That being said, there are a few things you should try to avoid. First off, a lot of Eberron's mechanics involve action points. Unless you want to include the action point system for your game as a whole, I would avoid using any feats/PrCs/etc which rely on them (This would include removing the Artificer's built in ability to cast infusions quickly, but you can get by without it). Second, pay close attention to what gear and gadgets she has or can create at any given level. Probably more than any other class, the Artificer's capabilities are dependent on what kind of items she is packing.
I agree that the Alchemical Child is better than a base PC race. I'd peg the Philosophical Child at +1 ECL and the Enlightened Child at +2 ECL. Warforged minus the composite plating ought to work pretty well. The biggest tell that either of these races isn't 'quite right' is going to be when they get injured. Unless someone specifically knows that they are looking for a construct, they're unlikely to figure it out without observing her getting injured. If all else fails, a mechanics-wise human without a belly button works too.
I hope this helps you.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 7:08 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
If you're worried about non-casters using the artificer's creations, you can always say that her devices are complex enough that it takes a skill check -- rolled by you, to "conceal modifiers" -- to figure out how to activate them. Then, when a non-spellcaster tries it, just ignore the die roll and tell the player that their PC failed to activate the device.
As for Dispel Magic, there's a die roll involved in that as well, so you can fudge it. ("Sorry, the magic must be stronger than you thought...") Anti-magic effects are so powerful, and so rare in Ravenloft particularly, that it needn't be an issue for such a low-level NPC.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 7:44 am
by DocBeard
I think Cronax has got it down. Arcane is magic-as-science. If anything, I'd penalize Primal-sourced stuff in Lamordia, but ultimately, it's a matter of flavor that doesn't need to be backed up by crunch.
I mean, take Tomas; he's pretty strange as far as people go, but mechanically, he's no different from any other Paladin. That's all flavor-and a sign, I think, of the power of solid flavor text.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:08 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
As I recall, your players aren't rules experts either, so they are unlikely to notice your monkeying behind the scenes.
I'm a big fan of dressing proven balanced rules in a different flavorful cloak.
I did something similar for the gunsmith in my campaign:
http://www.themistway.com/houserules.html
(scroll down to "New Feats").
I basically replaced caster level with related skills. (In place of spellcraft, he use whichever of the three skills Alchemy, Craft(Clockworks) and Craft(appropriate weapon type), he has the least ranks in. And his caster level is 3 less than that number of ranks.) Then I did a "search and replace" on spells -> formulae, spellbook -> blueprints, scrolls -> prototypes.
I didn't worry much about them not being dispel-able. But I like
Cronax's magic gremlins idea. If you're worried about non-spellcasters using stuff, a skill check is a good replacement. A brute fighter's not going to have any easier time getting a mechanical contraption to work than he'd have with an arcane wand.
I don't have my books handy, so I'll have to look up the Alchemical Child stuff later.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:33 am
by Jester of the FoS
The simple thing to do is avoid items with spellcaster pre-reqs and never bring in dispel magic (which might not pop-in until L6+ anyway).
But I agree that any artificer "tech" could possibly be affected by dispel magic (disrupts energy or something).
A reshaped warforge... appearance is the most cosmetic of changes so just having them look human should be fine.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:14 pm
by DocBeard
Generally my rule of thumb is;
Man Trapped As A Beast!: Shifter.
Touched By Fortean Madness: Tiefling or Caliban if you're keeping them.
Shaped By The Chisel Of Science: Warforged.
So a golem or even a "half" golem would use Warforged stats and feats, just like you can change the flavor or appearance of certain powers.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 6:50 pm
by The Whistler
Thanks guys! Yeah, the big tell is probably going to be when she gets healed for the first time--or gets cut and starts bleeding quicksilver.

I actually have an ermordenung following along with the party that has the same sort of amnesia, though in his case the problem's solved by his wearing gloves/being pathologically averse to physical contact. Hooray for hastily engineered narrative workarounds!
Also, ten points to DocBeard for using "Fortean" in a sentence.

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 11:08 pm
by cure
My displeasure with the Scientist class led me to work up a Mad Scientist prestige class that wasn't simply a spellcaster by another name. I am in the middle of a major overhaul of it, part of which includes Lab Effects that can be produced independent of the driving obsession of the mad scientist which, if achieved, would transgress the accepted rules of reality, say building a machine to escape Ravenloft. These lab effects can copy magical effects in domains where magic is a respectable scientific endeavour, but principally take the real world as their guide. Perhaps you might find useful inspiration in it. Note it is more oriented to an immobile NPC than a mobile PC:
Lab Effects (Ex): Beginning at the 3rd level and with each subsequent level mad scientists can produce an effect, with an investment of material and time in the construction of the requisite equipment or machinery, that is technologically achieveable in the real world. Very accomplished mad scientists may be permitted to produce effects that might be achievable in the real world with the refinement of current technology. A 9th level mad scientist working in biology and obsessed by eternal youth might be able to cause a missing limb to regrow and at the 10th level the same mad scientist might be able to grow an entire creature that is physically the clone of its tissue donor and mentally is a tabula rasa. Mad scientists from Darkon, Dementlieu, Dominia, Paridon and Richemulot, where the study of magic may be pursued as a properly scientific endeavour, can also produce effects, again with the aid of appropriate equipment or machinery, that are the equivalent of those that spell casters of any class and spells of any school save Universal may achieve within Ravenloft. A 7th level Darkonean mad scientist working in physics and obsessed with escaping Ravenloft could produce an effect equivalent to the spell plane shift with the qualification that only other domains, not other planes, may be reached. Whether an effect is inspired by what is achievable in the real world or with magic, effects must be related directly to the mad scientist's field of science and none may realise at a stroke, or bring within reach, the ultimate goal of the mad scientist. Either an effect is conceived in consultation with the DM to have a potency equivalent to spells of the same level or an effect reproduces that of a given spell of the same level. Effects have levels of 1 through 8. At the 3rd level mad scientists master the production of a 1st level effect and with each additional class level an effect with an additional effect level is added until at the 10th level they have mastered the production of 8 effects of the 1st through 8th levels. Mad scientist have an effect wielder level equal to their class level minus 2. When an effect is the equivalent of that of a spell and the spell level differs by class, the effect level equals the lowest of the possible spell levels. The DM should not hesitate to exclude or limit any effects inappropriate to the particular mad scientist, his or her goal, his or her field of science and science generally or equally to the particular domain or the setting itself. For example, perhaps only a mad scientist who is an arcanist can produce effects that are the equivalent to those of Abjuration spells. The DM should also not hesitate to prune the scope of effects. For example, perhaps a 10th level Richemuluese mad scientist working in biology can only produce a living tabula rasa rather than a true clone; the subsequent and successful transplantation of the still living brain, if available, from the original into the clone would be required to achieve a result on par with the clone spell.
To prepare an effect a mad scientist must have a Madness score at least equal to the level of the effect, must invest both 500 gp and 1 week for each level of the effect, and must make a DC 15 + effect level craft skill check. A single assistant can with a successful Aid Another check add a +2 bonus to the mad scientist’s craft skill check and halve the crafting time. Should either the mad scientist or the assistant fail his or her check, the equipment or machinery is fatally flawed and the process must begin again. However the recycling of equipment or machinery allows the cost in material and time for attempting to re-prepare the same effect to be halved, with the qualification that equipment or machinery ruined by a failed craft check reduces these costs by only a quarter. Successful theft allows material costs to be halved again. All reductions stack. Mad scientists engaged in, or at least believed to be engaged in, research approved by their university, research institute or patron, if any, may be absolved of some or all of the material costs. For example, a 5th level mad scientist employed as a biology professor in Port-a-Lucine, recycling parts, stealing from the supply room, and blessed with a competent assistant could rebuild a one shot blood filtration system that neutralises poison at a cost to his research budget of 325 gp and in a little over 5 days. The production of effects equivalent to those of spells with material components that have a stated cost adds the same cost to the expense of producing the necessary equipment or machinery except when material components are described as being laboratory supplies or equipment. When a body or a body part is an indespensible component in the production of an effect, it always constitutes an additional cost in terms of the difficulty of finding and acquiring it. A mad scientist producing an effect equivalent to that of the continual flame spell would have the added cost of 50 gp in special materials whereas a mad scientist producing an effect equivalent to that of the clone spell would not have an additional 1500 gp in laboratory expenses but would have to somehow acquire the necessary pound of flesh. The production of effects equivalent to spell effects that burst into existence at the completion of a spell may be spread out in time. A mad scientist working in biology and producing an effect equivalent to a growth plant spell spends 3 weeks crafting his equipment or machinery and growing the plants. The production of effects equivalent to spell effects that are realised very slowly are compressed in time. A mad scientist working in biology and producing an effect equivalent to that of a clone spell spends only 8 weeks crafting his equipment or machinery and growing the duplicate.
A mad scientist may prepare or be preparing only one effect for each class level between 3rd and 10th. A mad scientist may save substantial money and time by preparing at the same time multiple instances of the same effect. The cost in material and time for the second instance is halved, the third instance is quartered, and so forth. A 8th level mad scientist working in psychology could prepare one instance of an effect equivalent to the confusion spell at a cost of 1500 gp and 3 weeks or could prepare up to 4 instances using her 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th level slots at a cost of a little less than 2500 gp and a little more than 5.5 weeks. Recycling remains applicable but only reduces costs by a quarter unless the old equipment or machinery was crafted with at least as many instances of the same effect.
Once the crafting is complete, the triggering of an effect may be delayed indefinitely so long as the equipment or machinery that contains it remains intact and largely undamaged. An effect is triggered as a standard action. To trigger an effect, the mad scientist must have a Madness score at least equal to the level of the effect and he or she must succeed a skill check of DC 20 + effect level, using the skill most appropriate to the desired effect. For example, if the effect is neutralise poison, the skill would be heal for a mad scientist who is a biologist and be profession (herbalism) for one who is a botanist. An assistant who succeeds an Aid Another check with the same skill affords the mad scientist a +2 bonus. Should either the mad scientist or the assistant fail the skill check by 5 or less, the effect is not triggered and further attempts may be made to trigger it. Should the failure be by more than 5 the effect is lost.
An individual other than the creator of the equipment or machinery may also attempt to trigger it. A lay person would need to be trained in the use magic device skill, would have to succeed twice with this skill to emulate class features, would have to succeed once with this skill to activate a device blindly, and would have to make the relevant triggering skill check. A mad scientist not in the service of the creator would need to be trained in the use magic device skill, might have to succeed twice with this skill to emulate class features if his or her Madness score and his or her level was insufficient, would have to use this skill again to activate a device blindly, and would have to make the relevant triggering skill check. A mad scientist who is the assistant of the creator might need to be trained in the use magic device skill and use it twice to emulate class features should his or her Madness score and his or her level be insufficient and would have to make the relevant triggering skill check.
Equipment or machinery is large, heavy, unwieldy and fragile. Ideally it resides in a spacious laboratory, affording many mad scientists a further reason to linger on at the university. At twice the cost of material and time a mad scientist can craft equipment or machinery for an effect two levels below his maximum effect level that can be disassembled and packed onto a wagon. The initial cost of such equipment cannot be reduced by recycling. For example, a 5th level mad scientist can craft slightly portable equipment or machinery with one instance of the equivalent effect of the colour spray spell at the cost of 1000 gp and 2 weeks. The cost could be halved subsequently by recycling. Disassembling or reassembling this equipment or machinery takes 6 hours. At quintuple the cost of material and time a mad scientist can craft, within reason, equipment or machinery for an effect four levels below his maximum effect level that can be carried in a functional state in a heavy back pack. For example, a 10th level mad scientist working in biology could craft portable equipment or machinery charged with the equivalent effect of the cure critical wounds or locate creature spells at the cost of 8000 gp and 16 weeks or a 7th level mad scientist working in chemistry could craft portable equipment or machinery charged 7 times with the equivalent effect of the hideous laughter spell a the cost of nearly 4000 gp and 8 weeks. The cost could be halved subsequently by recycling. Equipment or machinery should have a hardness of 2 to 10, hit points of 10 to 90, and a break DC of 5 to 10. Broken equipment or machinery can be recycled but not repaired. Equipment or machinery remains functional until it has lost a quarter of its hit points at which point it is broken. Recycling equipment or machinery that has lost half to three-quarters of its hit points reduces cost in material and time by only a quarter and equipment or machinery more damaged than that is useless. A mad scientist can repair 1 hp of damage to still functioning equipment or machinery in 1d6 hours with access to relevant supplies and a successful DC 20 + effect level craft check.
Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2009 1:53 am
by DasSoviet
In my current campaign, one of my players is playing a human artificer, and it's working out extremely well. I've allowed him to take the technology feats from the World of Warcraft Campaign Book, so he runs a bit more on the technological/steampunk side of things, which fits the character pretty well... as well, thanks to the all-powerful wand of cure light wounds, he's taken up the role of primary healer in the cleric-less and druid-less party. We've flavoured it more as an alchemical injector which creates a healing factor, rather than a magical wand... though it still requires specialized skill to use, in this case Use Technological Device. We've similarly reflavoured his infusions to be technological, such as Repair Light Damage involving the application of clockwork repair bots, or Identity being an alchemical treatment that causes a reaction based on the spells involved. Of course, some spells haven't quiet worked out yet, such as Sheild of Faith, but we'll work it out in time.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2009 8:15 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
The Whistler wrote:Thanks guys! Yeah, the big tell is probably going to be when she gets healed for the first time--or gets cut and starts bleeding quicksilver.
You could still postpone revealing the truth for a while, if you present the players with a false clue: imply that the construct (or her ancestors) had been cursed by the Vistani, so that healing magics don't affect her. You could say that her faux "blood" is colored red for verisimilitude (but looks weird under a microscope), or that its appearance is another aspect of this "curse". Likewise, for other biological discrepancies she might also display, e.g. not having to eat, breathe, or visit the chamber pot.
I'm assuming this character has false memories of a human life, since you say she's unaware of her own nature. Including a "curse" in those phony recollections would be a plausible rationale for her creator (?) to offer, so she wouldn't figure it out for herself.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2009 9:41 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
another good red herring would be to plant clues that's she's some sort of divine/celestial creature. sliver blood and a lack of the needs Roti pointed out could lead in that direction too. Make it seem that she's something more than human, rather than less.
Posted: Wed Mar 18, 2009 11:43 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Cronax wrote:I agree that the Alchemical Child is better than a base PC race. I'd peg the Philosophical Child at +1 ECL and the Enlightened Child at +2 ECL.
Upon reviewing the template, I'd agree. Philosophical child just gets 2 +2 abilities, +2 nat armor, and acid resistance 20 as benefits. (I'm calling the construct type a wash, since it has pros and cons). That's not much better than an aasimar, which is LA+1.
Posted: Thu Mar 19, 2009 4:27 pm
by Cronax
Artificers are on the squishier side anyway, so she ought to try to avoid injury by staying out of the middle of fights. If you do make her a Warforged, disguising the 50% healing is pretty easy as the PCs never need see the damage rolls made against her or her HP maximum. Digging around, I came across the Reforged PrC (Races of Eberron, pg 161) which mitigates some of her 'tells', though may not work as your need to disguise her decreases the higher level she becomes.
Of course, some spells haven't quiet worked out yet, such as Shield of Faith, but we'll work it out in time.
A mesh armor overlay consisting of electromagnets connected to a limited duration capacitor.

Posted: Fri Mar 20, 2009 9:43 pm
by The Whistler
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:I'm assuming this character has false memories of a human life, since you say she's unaware of her own nature. Including a "curse" in those phony recollections would be a plausible rationale for her creator (?) to offer, so she wouldn't figure it out for herself.
Actually, the deal is that she (and all the PCs) are modern real-world folks who've been consciousness-transferred into the bodies of native Ravenloftians, through Magic Gone Awry--so she *has* a perfectly good set of memories already, they just don't tell her anything about the construct whose mind she's occupying. She and everyone else will be getting periodic flashbacks about the natives' former lives, though, so it'd definitely be easy enough for me to tailor the few memories she *does* receive so that she gets a misleading idea about the construct's prior personal history.
gonzoron wrote:another good red herring would be to plant clues that's she's some sort of divine/celestial creature. sliver blood and a lack of the needs Roti pointed out could lead in that direction too. Make it seem that she's something more than human, rather than less.
One of the other NPCs in the same predicament actually *is* inhabiting the body of a celestial creature, so I don't want to overlap.

That said, I'm with you and Roti on the "lack of physical needs pointing to something screwy" angle. She's going to eat and sleep out of habit--but the modern lady was a smoker, and one of the first tells is going to be how *difficult* it is to get her new self back on the cigs...
Cronax wrote:Artificers are on the squishier side anyway, so she ought to try to avoid injury by staying out of the middle of fights.
Exactly! Great thing about her being an NPC is I can just *not have anyone attack her* for a while.
Cronax wrote:A mesh armor overlay consisting of electromagnets connected to a limited duration capacitor.
YES. If she ever casts a weapon augmentation infusion without it involving a backpack-mounted modular steam engine or something powered by electric eels,
then I'm doing something wrong.