Page 1 of 1
VRA barbed & viperbite weapon issue
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 3:00 pm
by cure
In Van Richten's Arsenal p. 14 barbed weapons and viperbite weapons are described in relation to Tiny (arrows and bolts), Small, Medium and Large weapons. Is this terminology a holdover from 3e? If not, where in 3.5e are these categories described. If a holdover, how should these rules be rewritten for 3.5e?
Equally, should the rules for barbed weapons be toned down or altered in light of the barbed dagger presented in the Complete Adventurer p.115?
Incidently, conceptually does a viperbite rapier, as opposed to a viperbite dagger or viperbite short short sword, make sense? That is to say, is such a thin and flexible blade adaptable to this function?
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 3:17 pm
by Mangrum
VRA isn't a 3.0 holdover -- it is 3.0. It was one of the first books in the line.
Re: VRA barbed & viperbite weapon issue
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 4:22 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
cure wrote:In Van Richten's Arsenal p. 14 barbed weapons and viperbite weapons are described in relation to Tiny (arrows and bolts), Small, Medium and Large weapons. Is this terminology a holdover from 3e? If not, where in 3.5e are these categories described. If a holdover, how should these rules be rewritten for 3.5e?
In 3E, weapon size didn't scale with creature size, so terms like Small and Medium were available for descriptions of the physical bulk of a weapon. In 3.5 terms, 3E's "Small" becomes "light", "Medium" becomes "one-handed", and "Large" becomes "two-handed". Ammunition (3E's "Tiny") would have to be given its own category, or else lumped together with the light weapons.
The additional barb damage from
VRA would be for weapons scaled to a Medium wielder. Barbs' damage would scale up or down from there according to the wielder's size, as per the usual 3.5 rules.
IDHTBIFOM, so I can't check how that compares to the barbed dagger in
Complete Adventurer. My advice would be to use whichever rule is more useful for your game, based on how often the PCs or their foes use barbs on weapons other than daggers.
Re: VRA barbed & viperbite weapon issue
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 4:29 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
cure wrote:Incidently, conceptually does a viperbite rapier, as opposed to a viperbite dagger or viperbite short short sword, make sense? That is to say, is such a thin and flexible blade adaptable to this function?
If a dagger has room for a fluid reservoir, so should a rapier. Rapiers in D&D are thin, but they're not epees or foils; at most, think 17th century smallswords. A viperbite rapier would probably be built like the heaviest examples of the Spanish
espada ropera.
Posted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 7:22 pm
by cure
Ok, cancel the viperbite dagger and viperbite short sword, or the viperbite dart for that matter. They are all small weapons in 3ed which is to say light weapons in 3.5ed, whereas viperbite weapons have to be medium sized or larger which is to say one-handed or two-handed. And indeed the rapier would be the only appropriate sword, at once of medium size in 3ed which is to say one-handed in 3.5ed and dealing piercing damage.