Page 1 of 1

Syringe weapon type

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:56 am
by cure
In Van Richten's Arsensal p. 20 the syringe is described as delivering on a successful melee attack a dose of contact or injury poison, doing no damage, and shattering harmlessly on a roll insufficiently hight to hit as a melee attack but sufficiently high to deliver a touch attack. All well and good. But should the syringe be considered a simple light weapon, an exotic light weapon, or an improvised weapon?

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 7:37 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Definitely light, and probably improvised. At DM's discretion, you might rule IYC that characters with 5 or more ranks in Profession (physician) get to treat the syringe as a simple weapon. It you opt to treat it as an ordinary simple weapon rather than improvised, I'd suggest adding it to the rogue's list of weapon proficiencies.

I suppose if an inventor comes up with a syringe-throwing crossbow (i.e. prototype tranq gun) for use in capturing animals or asylum escapees, that could qualify as an exotic weapon. But Ravenloft's technology isn't there yet, AFAIK.

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 7:56 am
by A G Thing
I must say I agree with Roti, but I would consider adding perhaps a way to prevent it from shattering. If I am remembering correctly old syringes sometimes had metal coverings with slight openings to view the liquid inside. If it is as I remember then those could perhaps be the masterwork varients that maybe only break on a 1 or such!

Now where do I remember this from?!? :?

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 8:19 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
As I recall, the Exotic Weapon label is used not so much because the weapon is weird, but because it's better in some way than the supposedly balanced martial weapons. Hence the need to balance it with the cost of a feat. The syringe seems so much worse than most weapons that I wouldn't think it worth a feat to learn.

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:13 am
by cure
Rotipher of the FoS wrote: I suppose if an inventor comes up with a syringe-throwing crossbow (i.e. prototype tranq gun) for use in capturing animals or asylum escapees, that could qualify as an exotic weapon. But Ravenloft's technology isn't there yet, AFAIK.
Well the clumsy and more damaging version of that is the viperbite shortspear which is -1 to hit and does 1d6-1 damage. Retaining a metal needle but otherwise enclosing it in a wooden head, which has less penetration power than steel, would give the device a -2 to hit and 1d6-2 damage. I suppose it would not be unreasonable to use a less optimised head and say -4 or -5 to hit and 1d6-4 or 1d6-5 damage. Perhaps there is some obscure exotic weapon missile of at least one-handed (3.5ed)/medium (3ed) size that is less damaging and has more range, and so would be better still.

Of course one can just coat an arrow with poison, but the thinking here is not everything that can be delivered in an injection, for example the primal serum or holy water, is apt to being fashioned into a substance apt to coating a weapon. Equally, I would think that the risk of accidently poisoning oneself, for those without the poison use class ability, would be reduced in some appropriate fashion, without being wholely elminated, when filling and wielding a viberbite weapon.

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:14 pm
by alhoon
I disagree with physicians being proficient with needles as simple weapons...
I have seen many good doctors in my life and none of them had any special training in "syringe-fighting".

I would consider syringes as exotic light weapons. Why not improvised?
Because I believe a broken bottle emulates a dagger far better than a syringe.
With the broken bottle or a pen etc, you perform mainly the same maneuver as with a dagger. With the Syringe, you have to deal with a very thin needle and also to keep contact long enough for pressing the dose in. It's not just stabbing.

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 2:30 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:I suppose if an inventor comes up with a syringe-throwing crossbow (i.e. prototype tranq gun) for use in capturing animals or asylum escapees, that could qualify as an exotic weapon. But Ravenloft's technology isn't there yet, AFAIK.
There's always the blowgun and greater blowgun from Complete Warrior. They don't do much damage but both deliver a compound, and they're so basic that nearly every culture in Ravenloft has them in their false history somewhere. Get a hollow reed or metal pipe, a dart or needle that will fit, and make sure not to inhale the projectile.

Posted: Fri Apr 17, 2009 10:57 pm
by A G Thing
How about Physicians do not suffer no proficiency penalty for using it in a sneak attack. Seems reasonable as they would have to study or be exact to use the Syringe in such a manner...

Posted: Sun Apr 19, 2009 3:31 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I disagree with physicians being proficient with needles as simple weapons...
I have seen many good doctors in my life and none of them had any special training in "syringe-fighting".
Granted ... but then, consider that most physicians in Ravenloft have to deal with mental illnesses as well as physical. (All those botched Horror and Madness saves, y'know? :wink: ) If you were to specifically observe doctors who work in the violent ward of an IRL mental institution, you'd probably find that they know exactly how to safely administer sedatives to uncooperative patients via injection.