Page 1 of 1

Azalin's library - limitations?

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 1:32 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Here's a question for the Azalin Fan Club, as well as DMs who've made use of his memory-recording book collection in their games:

Just how complete and accurate are those biographies in Castle Avernus, which write themselves non-stop, documenting the histories of everyone in Darkon? How much open, veiled, and/or top secret information on a subject do they actually contain?

If people don't know their own histories, whether due to amnesia or non-competence (e.g. a baby) or ignorance, would that information be included in their instant biography? How about if there's something in the person's history which constitutes OOC knowledge (e.g. "This person was born in the Hollow World, inside the planet Mystara...")? What about false information which the DPs have actively promoted belief in, in other contexts: would a G'Hennan's book say he worships "the god Zhakata", or that he follows "a fictitious god"?

How does Azalin's library avoid giving away information that the DPs don't want him to learn? Do the Vistani have biographies, and if so, do theirs contain blank sections whenever DM-only information such as Mist-navigation comes up? Do the books of Ravenloft natives reflect the false histories of their realm of origin? If there's a distinction, would the books refer to a domain by its domain name, or by the name favored by human cartographers (e.g. does a Grabenite's book say she's from "Nebligtode" rather than "Graben Island")? What do the books call the game-setting itself, for that matter?

Does every sentient being in Darkon receive a biography, or are they for humanoids only? Does a dead person's biography start up again, if he or she comes back as an undead? As a sapient undead only? If a person's brain is harvested and installed in a dread golem's head, would their book continue to be written, or would a new book appear for the golem? Would an outlander's familiar have its own biography, or would its life story be covered in its master's book? How about a native's dread familiar, which has its own agenda?

Is the information in the histories objective truth, or subjective truth from the person's point of view? Or are they worded in ways that make it too ambiguous to tell?

Do the Dark Powers ever have the histories lie outright, to manipulate the Big A and/or yank his chain? Does Azalin know for certain that they do this, or does he merely suspect it? (He's Azalin: of course he'll suspect it. :wink: )


So many possibilities, here.... :D

Re: Azalin's library - limitations?

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 6:39 am
by Lord Cyclohexane
While I really ought to check From The Shadows before posting, my opinion is that a person's history should reflect what that person actually knows/knew. It'd be a completely subjective history containing no more secrets than the individual knows about. If (s)he was part of a hidden plot that (s)he knew nothing about, then the history wouldn't contain any information about it.

If the individual was completely and utterly sure that a particular fact was true, and the fact was actually completely false, the history would contain that information as being true. (For example, if the character was sure that his parents were killed by a Juan Garcia, but the parents were actually killed by a Julio Garzon, the history would merely talk about his parents being killed by a Juan Garcia because that's what the character believed. The history would properly contain where the character found a letter signed with a "J.G." and be followed with the misinterpretation that said "J.G." is for "Juan Garcia" because the character sincerely believed that it was Juan Garcia's fault and not Julio Garzon's.)

As for names of places? I think it should be dependent on the character's thinking style. If the character knew that the domain is called Nebligtode, and if the character generally referred to the place as Nebligtode, then the book would similarly denote the island as Nebligtode. If the person always thought of the island as Graben Island, then the book would refer to it as Graben Island. Similarly, if the person knew a secondary individual by a false name, the book would refer to that person by the false name.

Overall, I don't think the Library should have access to some outside, non-local, omniscent database wherein it can crosscheck facts. Instead, the Library should only be able to refer to that individual's memory, correct or incorrect, with as many biases and misconceptions as appropriate for that individual.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 7:02 am
by Drinnik Shoehorn
I've always thought of them as a running interior monologue, so they're intensely personal, but give a biased view to the person's experiences. Take the murderer and the victim.

The murderer's biography may be something like;

"I can feel it in my hand. My mouth is dry. The time is so close, one quick slash and she'll fall. I can see her now, she hurries away from me. I follow, stroking the blade, telling it silently that it'll drink soon.

"She moves faster, poor lamb. She goes quicker and quicker to avoid her fate. Look, the meek creature now hides in an alley. She thinks she has escaped me. I slip down a different alley. I know my grounds. My hands are shaking in anticipation. I am so close, she is so close. I come out of a passage behind her. She turns, she screams. Glorious! The knife moves, almost a dance manuvre. She stops screaming. It is over. An overwhelming feeling of disapointment fills me. It was too quick."

Where as the victim's biography may read;

"He is following me again. Oh, why does he keep following me? This is the third night. I am so scared. Papa says I should tell the guard, but there are none around at this hour. Oh, he gets closer. I resist the urge to run, he must be an animal, he would surely only give chase. I move quicker, the hobnails of my boots clacking loudly on the stones of the pavement.

"An alley! I know it leads to a church of Ezra! Blessed Mists! I am close to salvation. I duck into the alley and pause for breath. My corset seems too tight, I can not breathe. I glance out of the alley, he is gone! Oh, what relief! I turn, relaxed and ready for the church to welcome me.

"No! It is him! I see the knife. I scream and scream and scream. Why me? What did I do to deserve thi..."

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 7:15 am
by cure
The library might be a slightly less useful source of information for general data mining than it might seem since there is so much to read. Azalin would need an army of competent undead plowing through it or some very interesting search magic to use it for the development of leads. Given a lead about an individual, however, it would certainly be useful.

As to the Vistani, maybe the histories are highly partial, since most rarely spend much time in Darkon before moving on. Better, the Vistani, or at least the seers, seem to have the power of sending false visions to those who use the vision spell (from 2e?) so perhaps all Vistani have this option with Azalin, rather like the undead send false thoughts when mind read. Or perhaps, the Dark Powers either prevent this recording entirely or pervert its contents beyond usefulness, endless information about violin playing, dancing, flower gathering, and the pleasures of being free to move as one wishes.

Posted: Fri May 22, 2009 8:09 am
by InVinoVeritas
All I can advise is reading lots of Jorge Luis Borges. The short stories "Tlon, Uqbar, and Orbis Tertius," "The Garden of Forking Paths," "Pierre Menard, Author of Don Quixote," and especially "The Library of Babel" are particularly apropos. Borges expounded at length on the nature of reality, and whether a chronicle of reality is as real as the real thing. Kind of reflecting the Chomskian Chinese Room on itself infinitely.

Posted: Tue Jul 07, 2009 11:09 pm
by HuManBing
The actual entry on Azalin himself in From the Shadows hints strongly at a selectively-omniscient narrator doing the observing. Its tone contains several moral judgments on Azalin's deeds that Azalin himself would be very unlikely to admit and may in fact be completely unaware of.