Page 1 of 1

Who is the Bloody Cobbler

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 2:49 pm
by Hell_Born
I was just reading through the Book of Sacrifices when I saw this character mentioned in the article on 2e Bogeymen. Can anyone give me the details for him?

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 3:20 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
The Bloody Cobbler appeared in "Spectre of the Black Rose", IIRC. He's not a boogeyman, but a unique entity somehow related to Lord Soth's comeuppance in that novel.

Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 4:04 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Its creator, James Lowder, wrote his 2e stats and background in Dragon # 258 (april 99), as a masked Supernatural Agent, able to Shadow Walk at any place in Sithicus. He is said to punish those betraying their calling.

He is also feared because of his sinister habit to remove the sole of one's feet...

Joël

Posted: Thu May 28, 2009 1:25 am
by The Giamarga
So if he's not a bogeyman, what is he, what is his base creature? Fey, demon, misted human ?

EDIT: I found some 2E stats for the Bloody Cobbler and the Whispering Beast on this site. Are they the ones from the Dragon article?

Posted: Thu May 28, 2009 6:45 am
by Catman Jim
The Giamarga wrote:Are they the ones from the Dragon article?
Yes, word-for-word, other than a few typos, and minus the illustration that makes him look somewhat like the title character from "V for Vendetta".

Posted: Thu May 28, 2009 7:29 am
by The Giamarga
Ooh, there's an illiustration. Nice. I loved the descriptions. I somehow think it is based on an old illustration, esp with the strange plague mask. I had hoped to find a pic on the web, fanart or anything, but found nothing. (Well not exactly nothing, i did find the complete novel as a pdf... :shock: )
(Edit, found it, just google plague doctor mask!)

Ryan Naylor's article in the Book of Sacrifices implies that they are not bogeymen, but I must then ask how he came to this conclusion? Jim Lowder did handily handwave the classification away, calling them supernatural agents. Both of them are not undead, and are tied to Sithicus, even having thematically fitting shadowwalk powers, which iirc Lord Soth used to have too. Unique entitiy indeed. They seem to me very much similar to Salizzar the Meazel from VRGttM. So perhaps they are Fugued beings? Ooooh we need to stat them up in 3.5....

There's some material in HoL, about the giant Nabon i believe. What's his involvement with the Cobbler again.

PS: James Lowder explains much about the Cobbler in this interview.
Jim Lowder: [...] By the by, I had plotted and started a short story set pre-Spectre, specifically dealing with the Sithican elves: "All the Colors of Sorrow." It was going to run in Dragon, but when WotC dropped the Ravenloft line, the story was no longer of interest to Dragon and I stopped working on it. I'm hoping that one will eventually get finished, when I find the time. The Bloody Cobbler shows up in it, and I really enjoy writing him.

The Curator: The Bloody Cobbler was an absolutely amazing character. Can you tell us a little about the creation of that character, and is there a certain direction you would have liked to take that character?

Jim Lowder: The Cobbler did everything I had originally intended him to do. He, like the Whispering Beast, was intended to be manifestations of Soth's failings as a Rose Knight. Soth knew his path, his destiny, and purposefully walked away from it; he swore these grand intellectual and philosophical oaths and broke them, in part, because of his gross nature as a physical being. On a bare bones plot level, because Soth wouldn't own up to these failings, the sins manifested and forced him to confront them--and dared him to accept them, to take responsibility for them. I don't want to "give away" the book's ending here, but that's why the Cobbler and the Beast tie into the story of Soth's child with the elfmaid.

As to how the Cobbler came about--that's always hard to pin down precisely, especially from a vantage of several years after the writing of a work. I knew he was going to be a manifestation of Soth's failing to fulfill his destiny, because I came up with the Beast first and knew what he was going to represent. But before I knew he was a cobbler, I saw what he was going to look like. Because of the plague in Sithicus, he was going to have that grotesque mask with the flowers in the beak (that's derived from historical accounts of medieval cities hit with plague). I then came up with the whole "soles of the feet" thing and walking the paths of your destiny, and suddenly he was a cobbler. I had done something similar with a tradesman in The Screaming Tower, where there's a supernatural character called the Grim Tailor, who is involved with closing the eyes of the dead. The Tailor came first, but the Cobbler saw print first, so when Screaming Tower finally does see print, there might be some who mistake him as a variation on the Cobbler. It's really the other way around, as far as coming up with a supernatural use for a mundane tradesman.

Anyway, once I knew what the Cobbler looked like and what he was supposed to do as a force in the book, the scenes where he appeared were quite easy to plot and, eventually, write. He was so fully formed in my mind by that I never really had a question about what he was going to do and why. In every book, there's usually a character or two who "talks" to me, whose voice and motivation is so clear in my mind that I don't have to struggle with dialogue or actions. They sort of take creating themselves upon the page. Cyric was always like that for me in the Realms books, and the wombats in The Ring of Winter. The Cobbler was that character in Spectre--how much so came clear to me when he moves to take his mask off for the very first time. My original intention was to simply describe his face, but as I got to that paragraph, the Cobbler's voice noted in the back of my mind "I don't really have a face, you know." That's why the character sees the Cobbler's face as a blank at first, gets that slight glimpse of the void.

This part of the writing process might sound stranger than it really is. I was already thinking in the Cobbler's voice--just as a matter of technical storytelling, you need to do that to do a good job with dialogue. But it's those moments of less linear creation that make the difference in a book being predictable or not, and make writing fun for me (usually it's hard work). In those moments the story or the characters go in a direction you had not thought, at least consciously. If they work, you'll find later that you had already laid the foundation for that inspired action with all your much less glamorous technical work of plotting and making character notes. But it's always startling in that moment of composition when things don't go quite as you had planned.
So... manifestation of failings... no face.. tormenting mortals ...tied to the domain. Sounds kind of fey to me.

Posted: Tue Jun 09, 2009 10:38 pm
by Pale
Aw.

So, has nothing to do with pie?

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 4:17 am
by Hell_Born
The Giamarga wrote:Ooh, there's an illiustration. Nice. I loved the descriptions. I somehow think it is based on an old illustration, esp with the strange plague mask. I had hoped to find a pic on the web, fanart or anything, but found nothing. (Well not exactly nothing, i did find the complete novel as a pdf... :shock: )
...You found Spectre of the Black Rose as a .pdf? I don't suppose you could tell me where to find it, could you? Getting D&D novels of any sort isn't very easy down here in Australia... oh, is it a free download, or a paid purchase?

Posted: Wed Jun 10, 2009 4:40 am
by The Giamarga
It's an illegal russian transcript. So i won't post it here explicitly.

Don't you have amazon in australia, or half.com or a local half price books? When i was still able to i found ordering from half.com real cheap even from germany. Or buy ravenloft lots from ebay.com to save on postage...