Page 1 of 1

Better write up for Inza

Posted: Mon Aug 03, 2009 2:53 pm
by brilliantlight
Magda was seduced by a sith named Malcantis who wanted to bring death to the world even more than he himself could. Before he seduced Magda he polymorphed to appear to be a man called Mancy he also cast a spell to make sure the baby would look entirely human. As an apparently human baby the baby would be in a better position to set people against each other and cause havoc. In the ensuing fighting he would gain a greater understanding of death. Shortly afterwards he had Gundark kill Mancy by shouting insults about Gundark outside his castle and disappearing when men came for him. Eventually they found the real Mancy and executed him for treason. He did this hoping that Madga would become bitter and thus make her child bitter and more anxious to wreck havoc. The rest of the story proceeds as it does in Ravenloft Gazzete 4.

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2009 8:23 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Interesting, but not necessarily that much better. I think the trouble with Inza isn't just that her evil tendencies come out of nowhere, but that her behavior is so unconnected to Magda's previous history. There's nothing in Knight of the Black Rose -- the novel which Magda comes from -- to link her to creepy shadow-beings, let alone to a sith. And even if her father was a sith, that wouldn't account for Inza's evil: half-fey have free will, after all, and Magda just isn't the type to mistreat her child for the father's mistakes.

Perhaps the reason why Inza seems so incongruous is that she isn't really Inza at all? If Magda's daughter really did discover those shadow-spirits in childhood, maybe one of them possessed her, a la the witch from the Tin Man miniseries on SciFi. Depending on what crimes that spirit may have committed in life, and where the spirits came from in the first place, such a being could: A) be a far more plausible culprit for Inza's otherwise motiveless crimes, and B) link Inza to Sithicus's origins in Lord Soth's own story.

What if the shadow-spirit in question had once been a Krynnish elf, and the same one whose bigoted whispers spurred other elves to tell Soth his bride was unfaithful to him? She didn't care to accuse Soth's elven wife directly, but spreading secondhand rumors gave her an avenue to voice her own disgust at a mixed-race marriage to a failed knight. That kind of duplicity would be in keeping with Inza's behavior in Spectre of the Black Rose. The elves who accused Soth's wife to her husband's face became banshees, forever openly speaking their lies; the one who'd goaded them to do so, by contrast, was left to lurk in, and as part of, the shadows ... until a defenseless little girl stumbled into them.

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2009 9:07 am
by High Priest Mikhal
Or Inza could be a mirror image of her mother, darkness to Magda's light. Magda was devoted to her tribe, to their well-being and survival. Inza is a sociopath who couldn't care less about others. Thus her gift--and curse--is to become that which she is and always will be. She escaped her mother's shadow only to become one herself.

And as for motive, I always thought Inza's crimes stemmed from resentment. "Why can't you be more like your mother?" and all that. That sort of thing has spurred horrid crimes before. Look at the Menendez case.

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2009 9:18 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Except that, apart from restraining their future actions, there's no point to punishing a sociopath. They don't understand that whatever offense they've committed is wrong, and no amount of punishment will convince them of it, because "wrong" means nothing to them. So what's the DPs motive for making Inza a darklord, if that's what she is? Darklords are condemned to be tormented by their own misdeeds, but a sociopath can't regret crimes, only mistakes.

Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2009 10:33 am
by High Priest Mikhal
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:a sociopath can't regret crimes, only mistakes.
Which is what Inza seems to be regretting in the canon write-up. Plus her "curse" seems to be an abstract conscience. And yeah, I think the use of "sociopath" isn't quite the meaning I had in mind before.

Instead of a sociopath, maybe it would have been better to say Inza is a hateful sadist who enjoyed tempting others and then reveling in their pain--be it the pain of guilt or something more tangible. She knows it's wrong and that's the whole point; she's utterly perverse in that regard. Corruption and the pain of others as her vices would make for a more interesting character. Especially if she loathes pain of her own and fears it more than anything, which could make her curse more of a curse than it is.

Regardless of how you slice it, Inza's character just doesn't come across as the type to feel regret no matter what. That's the core of the problem if you want a sympathetic darklord. But for a darklord that just plain deserves what they get (does Alfred Timothy regret anything?) then Inza is perfect.

Posted: Thu Aug 06, 2009 11:26 am
by Mortavius
I always thought Inza was just bad. I mean in an "bad seed" sort of way, not a bad character. I mean she's just an evil hateful person. She wasn't mistreated as a child, and she still turned out this way. The real world is full of people like this. It doesn't ALWAYS have to be that they were abused, or there was some defining moment of their change.

I realize that this gets away from the whole "there but for the grace of God go I" theme, but I think it's okay to have some Darklords who don't perfectly fit the mold. Besides, even if a PC can't immediately see themselves in the Darklord's situation, perhaps with some changes on the mindset, they might be able to.

Besides, regret isn't a key component in Darklords. Many Darklords have no regret. Adam certainly doesn't. Godefrey is another example. They might fear their curses (in the latter case), but I've never seen evidence that their characters would change what they did if they could go back. I think that's part of being a Darklord; they can see what they did wrong, but they still wouldn't change a thing if given the chance. Simply put, they're damned.

Posted: Thu Aug 06, 2009 3:28 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Regret their actions, no: like most villains, darklords have convinced themselves that their misdeeds were necessary. But even a callous jerk like Godefroy at least aknowledges that killing his family was immoral, for all that he might tell himself that they asked for it.

Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2009 10:16 am
by brilliantlight
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Interesting, but not necessarily that much better. I think the trouble with Inza isn't just that her evil tendencies come out of nowhere, but that her behavior is so unconnected to Magda's previous history. There's nothing in Knight of the Black Rose -- the novel which Magda comes from -- to link her to creepy shadow-beings, let alone to a sith. And even if her father was a sith, that wouldn't account for Inza's evil: half-fey have free will, after all, and Magda just isn't the type to mistreat her child for the father's mistakes.

Perhaps the reason why Inza seems so incongruous is that she isn't really Inza at all? If Magda's daughter really did discover those shadow-spirits in childhood, maybe one of them possessed her, a la the witch from the Tin Man miniseries on SciFi. Depending on what crimes that spirit may have committed in life, and where the spirits came from in the first place, such a being could: A) be a far more plausible culprit for Inza's otherwise motiveless crimes, and B) link Inza to Sithicus's origins in Lord Soth's own story.

What if the shadow-spirit in question had once been a Krynnish elf, and the same one whose bigoted whispers spurred other elves to tell Soth his bride was unfaithful to him? She didn't care to accuse Soth's elven wife directly, but spreading secondhand rumors gave her an avenue to voice her own disgust at a mixed-race marriage to a failed knight. That kind of duplicity would be in keeping with Inza's behavior in Spectre of the Black Rose. The elves who accused Soth's wife to her husband's face became banshees, forever openly speaking their lies; the one who'd goaded them to do so, by contrast, was left to lurk in, and as part of, the shadows ... until a defenseless little girl stumbled into them.
That certainly could work. Being pocessed by a shadow spirit could do it.