Page 1 of 3
Are there any dark lords you feel sorry for?
Posted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 10:36 pm
by brilliantlight
There are a few for me. Adam who really didn't do anything to earn his domain. Sure, he attacked and severely injured Elise but that doesn't earn a domain for me. Also he didn't ask to be created and then rejected by society. That was Victor's doing. Tristen Hiregaard who became a darklord because a curse and not his own doing. For this he is punished by having women he loves killed by Malkin. This must be extremely painful to him as it would be to anyone else. Tristessa is another, evil as she is. It is very sad for a parent to lose their child. For all her evil she did love her child and so I feel sorry for her.
Posted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 10:59 pm
by ewancummins
Strahd- look at how his mommy dresses him, these days:
http://www.wizards.com/dnd/images/dx1006ps_strahd.jpg
All the other widdle vampires make fun of him.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 5:48 am
by Ail
I actually can pity a few of them, and probably that really is the objective of Gothic, isn't it?
I mean, you can understand, though you should not forgive, the pain that led them to the crimes. And although I agree with the OP, I can also pity
Strahd, yes, for how he felt that his life had been squandered in war; Gabrielle Aderre for how true love would be forever kept from her because of something that happened to her mother, and uh....
hard to think of other guys I sympathize to, really...
Azalin? No
Dominic D'Honaire? Not really
Jacqueline Renier? Uh... no.
Von Kharkov? who?
Hazlik? I hate him, ok?
Tristen Ap Blanc? Hmmm, I might, really I might...
Harkon Lukas? no
Godefroy and Soth? both are too much in the backstage for me to really notice.
Drakov? well... no!
erm... no, not the others really. Even though I try to think of something that makes me 'like' them I can't. Alfred Timothy, the Hags, Dominiani, Misroi, Markov and Yagno, none of them catches my sympathy.
Guess I don't feel their histories tragic enough at that. And as for the others, they're too much out of the spotlight for me to remember them.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 9:23 am
by nothri
Some are easier to sympathize with than others....
Strahd I can occasionally feel for, though I feel much more sorrow for the cruel way his love has to constantly be returned to repeat the tragedy and horror of their romance over and over again.
Adam its hard to condemn. He had a fit of rage due to a misunderstanding and hurt, and has been an outcast ever since. Granted, goading his creator again and again doesn't help his case, but his story is certainly more tragic than some.
Gabrielle Aderre is just incredibly tragic. Yes, manipulating people the way she has is cruel, but so was her childhood. She's been used as much as she has used people, and she's been victimized as often as she has been a victimizer. Her whole history feels like a tragic cycle of repitition, so much so that you end up hoping she can find some happiness. Of course, that's not going to happen....
Jaqueline Renier for some reason I've always empathized with. Yes, she's evil...but honestly? Compared to the Renier clan as a whole, she's remarkably well adjusted. We're talking about a family shapechanging, decadent creatures that have been entrenched within their domain for years. jaqueline has struck me as the first one to ever truly rise above the rat heap (so to speak) and show some real humanity....and of course its that spark of humanity the Dark Powers use against her.
Ivana Boritsi I feel sorry for for similar reasons. She would have had a perfectly happy existence if her mother hadn't intervened and ripped her world apart just so little Ivana would be more like mom.
Tritessa. What she does to new born infants is horrific, but the circumstances surrounding her death and the fact that she's an aggrieved and irrational spirit blunt my wrath.
hMM..I seem to be more forgive of the female lords than the males....I don't know if that says something about me or the designers. Certainly, some dark lords I can't feel sorry for at all- Death, Markov, Drakov, Malken (as opposed to Tristen, who's not properly speaking the darklord), Misroi....
Lord Soth I do feel sorry for, even while I think he completely deserves his punishment. Just something tragic about the way he mourns his past with an iron grip.
Some darklords I'm indifferent towards but kind of like as personalities. Azalin....I don't feel the least bit sorry for the old lich (oh gee, you can't go up in level and must be content as a 'mere' 18th level mage with dozens of spells including a wish at your finger tips....yeah, somehow I'm able to hold back the torrent of tears that just want to pour out of my heart....) but his approach to his rulership and general personality are kind of fun. Ditto Harkon Lukas and Anton Misroi, who aren't very tragic but who are fun to interact with. Its nice to have a Dark Lord you can see sharing a drink with the party as or more often embroiling them in some horribly cruel scheme.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 9:30 am
by Joël of the FoS
I've always tried to do that in my game when my players met darklords (Ivana, Gabrielle, Godefroy) - yes, they are evil, but somewhat tragic/pathetic too...
- Gabrielle's pathetic inability to find true love and keep it because of her lies / manipulations;
- Godefroy's curse (especially after the insubstancial halo adventure;
- Ivana - well, they don't know for now!
Joël
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:14 am
by alhoon
nothri wrote:
Jaqueline Renier for some reason I've always empathized with. Yes, she's evil...but honestly? Compared to the Renier clan as a whole, she's remarkably well adjusted. We're talking about a family shapechanging, decadent creatures that have been entrenched within their domain for years. jaqueline has struck me as the first one to ever truly rise above the rat heap (so to speak) and show some real humanity....and of course its that spark of humanity the Dark Powers use against her.
Remember, she's trying to create a breed of rats that would spread
her lycanthropy so she can in one fell strike she can turn most of Richemulot's human population to wererats under
her personal influence. That is she's researching a biological weapon that would kill many of the victims in pain and turn others to monsters she can control. And then she will order those monsters to infect others.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 7:19 pm
by ewancummins
I actually do feel sympathy for Drakov. I've been unduly influenced by HumanBeing's fanfic, of course!
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 9:07 pm
by brilliantlight
nothri wrote:Some are easier to sympathize with than others....
Strahd I can occasionally feel for, though I feel much more sorrow for the cruel way his love has to constantly be returned to repeat the tragedy and horror of their romance over and over again.
Adam its hard to condemn. He had a fit of rage due to a misunderstanding and hurt, and has been an outcast ever since. Granted, goading his creator again and again doesn't help his case, but his story is certainly more tragic than some.
Gabrielle Aderre is just incredibly tragic. Yes, manipulating people the way she has is cruel, but so was her childhood. She's been used as much as she has used people, and she's been victimized as often as she has been a victimizer. Her whole history feels like a tragic cycle of repitition, so much so that you end up hoping she can find some happiness. Of course, that's not going to happen....
Jaqueline Renier for some reason I've always empathized with. Yes, she's evil...but honestly? Compared to the Renier clan as a whole, she's remarkably well adjusted. We're talking about a family shapechanging, decadent creatures that have been entrenched within their domain for years. jaqueline has struck me as the first one to ever truly rise above the rat heap (so to speak) and show some real humanity....and of course its that spark of humanity the Dark Powers use against her.
Ivana Boritsi I feel sorry for for similar reasons. She would have had a perfectly happy existence if her mother hadn't intervened and ripped her world apart just so little Ivana would be more like mom.
Tritessa. What she does to new born infants is horrific, but the circumstances surrounding her death and the fact that she's an aggrieved and irrational spirit blunt my wrath.
hMM..I seem to be more forgive of the female lords than the males....I don't know if that says something about me or the designers. Certainly, some dark lords I can't feel sorry for at all- Death, Markov, Drakov, Malken (as opposed to Tristen, who's not properly speaking the darklord), Misroi....
Lord Soth I do feel sorry for, even while I think he completely deserves his punishment. Just something tragic about the way he mourns his past with an iron grip.
Some darklords I'm indifferent towards but kind of like as personalities. Azalin....I don't feel the least bit sorry for the old lich (oh gee, you can't go up in level and must be content as a 'mere' 18th level mage with dozens of spells including a wish at your finger tips....yeah, somehow I'm able to hold back the torrent of tears that just want to pour out of my heart....) but his approach to his rulership and general personality are kind of fun. Ditto Harkon Lukas and Anton Misroi, who aren't very tragic but who are fun to interact with. Its nice to have a Dark Lord you can see sharing a drink with the party as or more often embroiling them in some horribly cruel scheme.
I tend to agree with you but I have a hard time sympathizing with Gabrielle since she abadoned her mother to werewolves. I agree with you about Ivana, she might have turned out decent if her mother wasn't a jelous witch. I think part of the reason I have sympathy for Tritessa is that my mother died of cancer 5 years ago and I can say without a doubt that was the most depressing time of my life. It must be even worse with children. You expect to outlive your parents you don't expect to outlive your children.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 10:48 pm
by Mortavius
I'm capable of feeling sorry for some of them, but I believe they all deserve what they have gotten.
Adam is a favorite of mine, what with him coinciding with my fascination with the Frankenstein story. Adam I think deserves his curse though, because as many of the Darklords, although Adam had a hard beginning (like so many DLs) they have not risen above that but instead lashed out with rage and revenge. This is one of the components that damned them, IMO. (Remember, Adam sabotages Mordenheim's work to revive Elise, even though he knows that she is beinging tormented by being kept alive.)
It's easy to feel sorry for Gabby, or Ivana and say that they had a hard youth, but what have they done since? They've used that hard upbringing as an excuse to perpetrate evil, to cause suffering and death, to further their own selfish desires.
Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 11:11 pm
by HuManBing
ewancummins wrote:Strahd- look at how his mommy dresses him, these days:
I think he's acquired the fey template. Apparently he's prancing around the background of the domain having all sorts of interesting "low level encounters" but I'm not inclined to pry further.
Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 12:13 am
by Yaoi Huntress Earth
For some reason I always had the sneaking suspicion that Ivana mgiht've had a bit of a history of maybe using and throwing away boyfriends. Not totally in a cruel way but more like a popular girl in high school with the "so many boys so little time" mentality and has a tendoncy to be rather vindictive if she doesn't get her way. She wasn't evil but could be quite cruel and treat people like lackies (like Nostilia) if she had the chance. With Pieter (sp) actually warming her heart. Cause I just have a bit of a hard time believing that total innocent\nice girl could be tossed with Darlord-dom for two bad acts (one that she was forced into).
Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 4:33 pm
by Lucius
Easan.
Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 4:49 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
alhoon wrote:nothri wrote:
Jaqueline Renier for some reason I've always empathized with. Yes, she's evil...but honestly? Compared to the Renier clan as a whole, she's remarkably well adjusted. We're talking about a family shapechanging, decadent creatures that have been entrenched within their domain for years. jaqueline has struck me as the first one to ever truly rise above the rat heap (so to speak) and show some real humanity....and of course its that spark of humanity the Dark Powers use against her.
Remember, she's trying to create a breed of rats that would spread
her lycanthropy so she can in one fell strike she can turn most of Richemulot's human population to wererats under
her personal influence. That is she's researching a biological weapon that would kill many of the victims in pain and turn others to monsters she can control. And then she will order those monsters to infect others.
Ah, but the reason... She is doing it because she is terrified of being alone. But this has placed her in a position where she actually prefers the company of backstabbers to being alone.
So of course she's planning to turn people into monsters. To her she's giving them a great gift. She's making sure they will follow her for power, but also so that she knows she isn't creating a nation of enemies. She is making sure that people will follow her and protect her. She will never be alone again.
But most importantly, by placing everyone in the same boat she will never again suffer the humiliating and painful rejection that she did that night she found true love.
I can't agree with the methods, they're horrible, but her underlying reasons are sympathetic.
Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 4:59 pm
by ewancummins
HuManBing wrote:ewancummins wrote:Strahd- look at how his mommy dresses him, these days:
I think he's acquired the fey template. Apparently he's prancing around the background of the domain having all sorts of interesting "low level encounters" but I'm not inclined to pry further.
So, he's finally gotten over Tatyana, then?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 6:31 pm
by brilliantlight
Lucius wrote:Easan.
True enough, he was a decent guy until the warlord messed with him.