Page 1 of 2
Some musing on the Shadowfell
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 9:31 am
by Jack the Reaper
First I would like to say, that I embrace fulheartedly the concept of RL in the Shadowfell. I know that this topic was thoroughly discussed already, so I won't open it again; but isn't it awesome to discover suddenly that the lands of Ravenloft, which we all love and know so good, are only a part of a full-scale world of darkness and horror? It's like when I purchased the rules book of MERP many years ago, and discovered that the Middle Earth shown on maps in the Lord of the Rings books is just a rather small part from a much greater world. That's what I call a horizons-broadening experience!
For years I had in my mind something I called "The Dark Lands Project". The Dark Lands were supposed to be something like the backyard of the Dark Powers: Dark and harsh lands, without a single Darklord, were you can find all kind of dark creatures, powerful monsters, ancient ruins and evil tyrants, which don't fit the usual domains. Now that it was done officialy for me, how can I not be grateful?
I don't think it would return RL to the status of "Weekend in hell" campaign setting. There is no reason why the core and the other domains won't retain their developed status, when the only difference is that behind the walls of mists, there aren't just more mists, but a whole world rife for explorers and adventurers.
After all this introduction, what I actually wanted to ask is: can anyone give me a full list of products that describe the Shadowfell? I know it's described in the Manual of Planes, and mentioned in Open Grave. Also I knpw that there is the Keep on The Shadowfell adventure, and 3 domains in Dragon magazine.Anytjing else?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 6:31 pm
by Hell_Born
Firstly, allow me to say that it's nice to see someone with a positive attitude towards 4e and its cosmology- it was beginning to feel rather lonely here.
Secondly, to answer your question, as of now, the information you've mentioned (Manual of the Planes, Graefmotte, Sunderheart, Monadhan, Keep on the Shadowfell, Open Grave) is all the official word that there is. However, there are two known Planar Sourcebooks (The Plane Below, doubtlesly the Elemental Chaos, and The Plane Above, doubtlessly the Astral Sea) due out on December 2009 and April 2010 respectively, so it's fair to assume that a Shadowfell sourcebook will come out at some point. Possibly to tie into the PHB4, if that incorporates the Shadow source.
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 7:14 pm
by ewancummins
Does this new '4E-loft' have an Earthlike environment with a normal day/ night cycle? I'm a little fuzzy on this, but isn't the Shadowfell basically just the old Plane of Shadow? Enlighten me, please.
I dislike 4E as a rules-set, but I'm not hatin' on the new cosmology just for hate's sake. My attitude on so-called 'official changes' has always been ''use what you like, lose the rest.''
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 8:04 pm
by Hell_Born
It's hard to describe without bringing the Manual of Planes out, but essentially it's a darker, creepier, more sinister mirror of the materium. There is a day/night cycle, but the sky is often overcast and the light is dimmer- it's not total blackness like the old Plane of Shadow, but it's always gloomy and eerie in the Shadowfell.
I vaguely recall once seeing a postulation that the Shadowfell is like a viewing of the world as it will appear in its dusk, far into the future when the world itself will begin to die, just as the Feywild is a viewing of the world as it appeared in its dawn, far in the past when the world was young... I think that might have been the Manual of Planes, I'm not sure.
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 8:35 pm
by ewancummins
Hell_Born wrote:It's hard to describe without bringing the Manual of Planes out, but essentially it's a darker, creepier, more sinister mirror of the materium. There is a day/night cycle, but the sky is often overcast and the light is dimmer- it's not total blackness like the old Plane of Shadow, but it's always gloomy and eerie in the Shadowfell.
I vaguely recall once seeing a postulation that the Shadowfell is like a viewing of the world as it will appear in its dusk, far into the future when the world itself will begin to die, just as the Feywild is a viewing of the world as it appeared in its dawn, far in the past when the world was young... I think that might have been the Manual of Planes, I'm not sure.
I really dislike the idea of Ravenloft being turned into an all doom and gloom setting, without contrasting sunlit landscapes, blue skies, merry peasant girls dancing in meadows, etc, etc. A world
that's actually covered in shadows seems
very, very Un-Ravenloft to me.
Now, perhaps the Ravenloft domains could be fitted in as regions of apparent 'normalcy' within the Shadowfell. The normal daylight would make them very attractive to lost souls from the Prime Material Plane, as well as supporting a more Earthlike ecosystem.
Would you keep the Mists? It seems to me that these are a classic feature of the setting and should be retained. Without the link to the Ethereal, do the Mists still make sense, though?
EDIT-
Have you read
The Night-Land, by William Hope Hodgson?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 8:53 pm
by Hell_Born
Ravenloft, as a world, could also be a materium world where the barrier between the materium and the Shadowfell is unusually thin. The Shadowfell doesn't reflect, it "echoes"- an imperfect duplication. Sunderheart is a empty ruin in the materium and a thriving city in the Shadowfell, at one and the same time. Step into the right place, or make the right actions, and you can slip into the dark version- though escape is harder. In this format, Ravenloft would be a place where the dark world is even easier to access then in core, with gates and doors opening at graveyards, crossroads, wherever there is someplace touched by tragedy and wickedness. The rest of the world is no grimmer then normal, but everyone knows there are some places you just don't go. That dark alley, that old house, that abandoned road...
Why would he not keep the Mists? 4e already does. Nobody knows where they come from, or why, but the Shadowfell sets out its "tendrils" to ensnare and envelop domains and those who dwell within just as the Ethereal did back when Ravenloft was the Demiplane of Dread.
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:04 pm
by ewancummins
I still prefer the Ethereal-with-demiplanes, but the new-fangled Shadowfell does sound interesting.
Thematically, the Mists worked very well with the old cosmology because the Ethereal was itself a misty plane.
What about a small domain that exists within the Prime Material by day, but shifts to the Shadowfell at night?
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:20 pm
by HuManBing
ewancummins wrote:
I really dislike the idea of Ravenloft being turned into an all doom and gloom setting, without contrasting sunlit landscapes, blue skies, merry peasant girls dancing in meadows, etc, etc. A world that's actually covered in shadows seems very, very Un-Ravenloft to me.
This is very important, and it's actually worth pointing out, because in my opinion even the 3rd and 2nd ed Ravenloft settings could have mentioned it more. Gothic worlds in literature are not places of unrelenting doom and gloom. Writers of Gothic fiction describe rustic scenes of rural comfort, and mountains soaring majestically on the horizon. Even the cold arctic described in Frankenstein is a place of frigid beauty and unearthly purity.
The Black Box mentioned it once, as I recall ("seductive orchards" is a phrase that comes to mind). The 3rd Ed books may have, in places, but I didn't read them as obsessively as the Black Box. The point remains that the players need moments by the hearthside just as much as they need moments of tension - because it's this getting to know places and people that gives them an emotional foundation.
As a DM, I've found my best work has come to fruition when the players learn of something that could potentially threaten one of the places or people in-game who are dear to them, and that provides them all the motivation they need to get up and act. Very rewarding!
Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:19 pm
by ewancummins
HuManBing wrote:ewancummins wrote:
This is very important....
It is impossible for me to be in closer agreement with you this count. Ravenloft is not, IMO or IMC, a 'hell-world.' It appears , on the surface, much like many Prime worlds- until one enters the Mists. It's not a realm of unremitting evil and suffering like the Lower Planes.
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 2:33 am
by Jester of the FoS
I'm with most of the posters above. There are gloomy shadowfell-esque places in Ravenloft for sure, but for the most part the individual villages and forests and the like are calm, peaceful, and ordinary. True, sometimes they're more deceptively ordinary than regularly ordinary, but the darkness stands as a contrast.
In a world set entirely in the shadowfell there is no ordinary. It's hard to justify the common people living common lives.
However, it should be pointed out that domains are not typical regions of the shadowfell. They might be best described as pockets of normality, where the standard effects of the shadowfell (gloom, perpetual overcast, emotional leaching, roaming undead) are less present.
This adds an interesting dimension to domains. While many would be happy to live in the real world and not in the shadowfell, living in a domain is preferable to life outside in the bleak, life-sapping shadowfell. It might explain why everyone hasn't emigrated elsewhere.
There's also the touches of contradiction and paradox in Ravenloft's placement.
The whole idea of the planar design was consistent and uniform planes from world to world so there would be no confusion as to how certain spells and rituals and powers worked. So you didn't have to re-invent the wheel or explain how Power X worked.
However, in a domain which is a prison and cannot be escaped from and is set in the shadowfell, these are exactly the problems that arise. Can one use the Shadowwalk ritual in a domain, when you're already IN the shadowfell. Can an eladrin use feystep to teleport when you can't leave the domain? Where do the spirits of the dead go when you're already in the world of the dead?
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 6:29 am
by Tobias Blackburn
I have to agree. Ravenloft isn't a gloom and doom, shadows everywhere setting to the average people who live there. Its only those that look under the hood (or those attacked by the thing under the bed) that realize the truth of what lurks below. Having it actually covered with Night and slightly less dark Night would cause it to lose the bright spots that people fight for and go back to the "we can make it absolutely terrible and unlivable" view that sometimes came with the weekend in hell modules of 2e.
As for what would work in the Shadowfell, probably anything. 3e presented the Near Ethereal to cover the issues with it sitting in the Ethereal Plane. Dropping it in the Shadowfell or some other 4e plane would likely cause the Dark Powers to provide some other dimensional conduits to let certain powers and spells work.
Re: Some musing on the Shadowfell
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 7:08 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
Jack the Reaper wrote:First I would like to say, that I embrace fulheartedly the concept of RL in the Shadowfell.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU.

Re: Some musing on the Shadowfell
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 9:06 am
by Jack the Reaper
Dion of the Fraternity wrote:Jack the Reaper wrote:First I would like to say, that I embrace fulheartedly the concept of RL in the Shadowfell.
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU.

You welcome!

As I was used to be myself many times a minority opinion on the RL mailing list (e.g I thought Vecna is an excellent addition!), I know what it feels like, to find allies in dark places...
Like everyone above, I really didn't mean the domains of RL to be dark and gloomy places like the usual Shadowfell. As funny as it sounds, they are pockets of life and hope (aaarrgghh!) in comparison to the Darklands. However, a normal-looking environment can be even more terrifying when its dark aspects are discovered, than an always-dark-and-outright-evil land.
As to the mists, its possible to leave them as they are- surrounding the core, as the Manual of Planes itself states. An alternative is to make the core a part of a greater continent, in the same way that Europe is part of Asia, with some natural barrier between them. I think Vorostokov can be attached to the southern core, so its vast frozen planes and mountains ridges will seclude it- and the rest of the core- from the rest of the Shadowfell. The seas of the core can be parts of larger oceans, through which an easier access may be granted.
Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 1:32 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Tobias Blackburn wrote:As for what would work in the Shadowfell, probably anything. 3e presented the Near Ethereal to cover the issues with it sitting in the Ethereal Plane. Dropping it in the Shadowfell or some other 4e plane would likely cause the Dark Powers to provide some other dimensional conduits to let certain powers and spells work.
It would be no problem to explain away the problems. I just don't want to wait until 2011 for them to bother to put out the Shadowfell book for it to happen. It would take a single, short Dragon article to make it work. I just find it both annoying and insulting that they've put out 3 new domains with explaining how things work.
Posted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 12:52 pm
by ewancummins
Jester of the FoS wrote:Tobias Blackburn wrote:As for what would work in the Shadowfell, probably anything. 3e presented the Near Ethereal to cover the issues with it sitting in the Ethereal Plane. Dropping it in the Shadowfell or some other 4e plane would likely cause the Dark Powers to provide some other dimensional conduits to let certain powers and spells work.
It would be no problem to explain away the problems. I just don't want to wait until 2011 for them to bother to put out the Shadowfell book for it to happen. It would take a single, short Dragon article to make it work. I just find it both annoying and insulting that they've put out 3 new domains with explaining how things work.
Aren't you doing a 4E conversion, Jester? Why not submit your own work as an article for Dragon, if you'd like to see an ''official game content'' version of 4E-loft?
.