Page 1 of 2

"Roleplaying" the Dark Powers

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 11:54 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
OK, I know, I know, the Dark Powers are unknowable entities beyond mortal comprehansion, and PCs should never ever contact them directly. So noted, official disclaimer provided, don't try this at home.

But what if they do?

I've got a situation in my game where it makes sense, and I'm stuck for how to go about it. Specific details in the fine print below. Skip if you don't care:
One of my PCs is a True Innocent, which IMC is not just a pure soul, but a "Chosen One" style figure of prophecy. She is also devoted to knowledge and research and has a particular interest in the Mists. So obviously, the Mists are interested in her as well. When she entered the Misty Border for the first time, the Mists snatched her up and she disappeared (partially because her player was absent). When she returns, I want to account for her time as a prisoner of the Mists/guest of the DPs. Without getting too deep into the "what are the DPs?" question, we know the DPs torment evildoers. Some say they tempt people into evil too. I plan to have three factions within the DPs:

1) Those who can't believe an uncorruptable innocent can exist, hence they want to corrupt her to prove their point
2) Those who believe she is purely good and deserves no punishment, hence they want to send her out of Ravenloft to some celestial realm
3) Those that see her presence as a tool to torment darklords, hence they want to keep her around to push their prisoners' buttons.


Of course, she can't just talk to them directly. I want it to be all symbolic and abstract. The DPs have proven they can create and manipulate matter, so they can show her all sorts of illusionary things to make their points, and to better examine her. I'm picturing something like the "hotel" of 2001, or the "Prophets" of Deep Space 9. Shifting dreamscape-like places, clearly unreal, but with a message to convey.

Where I'm torn is how to present the DPs themselves. One easy way would be to steal from DS9 and Contact and have them appear in the shape of people the PC knows. But that seems too direct to me. I don't want the DPs to be seen as mere dopplegangers or illusionists. DS9 pulled it off with varying degrees of success over the years, but it's tricky, and also, it's been done. I'd like to try something different. But all I'm coming up with are disembodied voices, or indistinct shapes looming in the mists...

How does the utterly inhuman communicate to a human when it wants to do so? Cthulhu-esque monster? Burning bush? Hyperintelligent shade of the color blue?

Has anyone ever done something similar?

Re: "Roleplaying" the Dark Powers

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 12:12 pm
by MadStepDad
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: One easy way would be to steal from DS9 and Contact and have them appear in the shape of people the PC knows.
I used this method. Many years ago when I was closing the books on our homebrewed world, I wanted to bring the PCs over to RAVENLOFT as outlanders. One of the PCs (who was temporarily home from the army) played his old character... but in the end it was revealed he was simply an Avatar for the Dark Powers used to draw the players into the Misty realm. He already came pre-built with a certain level of trust from the players so it was easy to convey, they got the message, and didn't have to "talk" to the DPz to make it so.

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 1:00 pm
by A G Thing
You could have them manifest as faces on objects or parts of the world, perhaps animals and also have them jump from one point to the other...

You could have blended sounds become the speech as perhaps just as an (example: You cannot help but hear a sound, sharp and grating as if claws across stone but they combine into voice and make clear yet disturbing words filled with a context familiar yet unknown to you...) When you change you can have the sound fade into a din of other noises or perhaps it grows deafeningly loud to punish or signal a end of the conversation. This may also signify emotional context.

Beyond that you can describe it as if the character is learning things from madness effects using large amounts of symbolism and leaving certain aspects of it very vague! Horror and Fear can also be effective if every once in awhile the scene changes by a shock or a twist that causes the sudden shift but not every time!

Another aspect once more borrowing from star trek would be to have the character live out parts of her life as if they are normal and have them (DP'S) test or teach through the situation, making it realistic... (Perhaps so realistic that you end up with a time paradox or change to the world when they return!)

You could have them set the scene in frozen slices of life they want to use as an example trying to both persuade confuse and crush her mind...

Threats and even outright temptations could be a great way to test the players innocence by offering the character things that seem perhaps a little out of reach.

Posted: Wed Sep 09, 2009 4:18 pm
by Rock of the Fraternity
Another possibility is to not have the DPs do any direct communication at all.

Say, your true innocent finds herself in the Mists, and she hears whispers in the distance, getting closer, then receding, then drawing closer again. At no time should she feel a clear presence, at no time should she have even an inkling of what is being whispered. The Mists cling to her, draw into her with every breaths she takes. She can feel the cold creeping through her veins, through her internal organs, through her brains. It is an unclean feeling, as if the Mists are sampling even the tiniest hidden part of her, looking for hidden flaws and sparking memories of past regrets.

When the time for something more direct comes, the true innocent could feel as if she is 'being taken into' memories that the Mists are touching; warped images of what she remembers. Or the Mists can briefly open and show her snatches of events transpiring throughout the time of the dread realms, past, present and future.
Once the experience is over, the true innocent could feel soiled because something utterly alien has invaded every part of her, touched her not just physically, but her very mind and soul, and dabbled its fingers in her memories and forced her to see what it wanted her to see.
Depending on how bright this true innocent is, she can then start to try and interpret what she's seen on her own, or try and make sense of it with the help of others.

How she responds to this test will then allow the DPs to decide which of their factions was right about this individual, and they can then act in concert again.

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 3:35 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
A G Thing wrote:You could have blended sounds become the speech.
Hmm... I like this...
Rock wrote:The Mists cling to her, draw into her with every breaths she takes. She can feel the cold creeping through her veins, through her internal organs, through her brains. It is an unclean feeling, as if the Mists are sampling even the tiniest hidden part of her, looking for hidden flaws and sparking memories of past regrets.

When the time for something more direct comes, the true innocent could feel as if she is 'being taken into' memories that the Mists are touching; warped images of what she remembers. Or the Mists can briefly open and show her snatches of events transpiring throughout the time of the dread realms, past, present and future.
Ooh... I really like this too...

Sadly, these would be way cooler in a movie than trying to relate it in words, but still, I'm going to try to combine these ideas somehow.

Once the experience is over, the true innocent could feel soiled.
And that's the other conundrum. That's how this should all end, if it were a book. But I feel unfair taking her Innocence through no fault of her own, even though it clearly should be lost by such close contact with something so evil. (standard disclaimer that the DPs aren't necessarily evil here. for me, in this campaign at least, they are.)

In fact, she already lost her innocence once just by participating in a ritual that focused her powers to cleanse the Mist-taint from a cursed dagger. She got better.... ;) by an involuntary memory-wipe of the events.

Perhaps the DPs learned from that and hence avoid that direct contact for fear of "ruining her" again. Hence, the symbolism and images... hmm...

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 4:53 pm
by DocBeard
I think "purity" is a better term than "innocence". Any adventurer loses their innocence pretty darn quick; but someone who is good and true shouldn't lose their sacred connection just because they mature and grow as a person.

As far as the DPs go, I have a sort of preference for Jungian archetypes; shadowy, misty beings who seem to be inhabiting a vague skeletal costume as a way to be comprehensible to the mortal mind. All of the DPs are a take on the traditional scientist/knowledge seeker character, from the little boy who tears the wings off of flies to see how they work to the idealistic young turk hoping to prove himself right to the cold figure who justifies horrific methods with vague assurances of it all being "for the best".

I feel like this is consistent with the characterization of the Dark Powers as has been hinted at in official products, while not defining them so absolutely that they lose their mystique. You aren't even saying outright that there's more than one Dark Power; all of the masks and costumes could be the schizophrenic turmoil of a single over-mind that is trying to decide what to do with all the questionable people in its power.

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 6:02 pm
by Kaitou Kage
There was an intriguing claymation show a long while ago that had something to do with Mark Twain adventures. I forget the details exactly.

Anyway, in one of these episodes, the main characters had a rather creepy encounter with an interpretation of Satan. You can find the clip on Youtube and I'll link it here if I remember when I get home. However, I think it might give you some useful ways to portray something like the Dark Powers.

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 6:11 pm
by ScS of the Fraternity
Kaitou Kage wrote:There was an intriguing claymation show a long while ago that had something to do with Mark Twain adventures. I forget the details exactly.

NOOOOOOOOOO!
Dear God no!

That video will scar you for life!
Stay away, stay away!

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 7:21 pm
by cure
Have bone runes tumble from the mouth of the innocent, whenever she tries to speak, until such time that she takes them to the Vistani to be interpreted.

Depending upon your vision of the Dark Power's in relation to the Vistani, the rauni in question could be anything between wholely unphased to utterly terrified.

In anycase, what the innocent gets is mediated through the Vistani, begging the question of whether the individual is getting the whole story, a manipulated version, or pure bunk.

And oh, yes, the Vistani insist that the runes be burnt to ashes and the ashes be scattered/dumped in the sea.

Re: "Roleplaying" the Dark Powers

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 9:09 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:One easy way would be to steal from DS9 and Contact and have them appear in the shape of people the PC knows. But that seems too direct to me. I don't want the DPs to be seen as mere dopplegangers or illusionists.
FWIW, an audio-only version of this is precisely how the novels depicted Strahd's and Azalin's respective "encounters" with the DPs: as the voices of people they know, taunting them for their flaws and their reluctance to do whatever's necessary to get what they want.

For a precedented visible avatar of the DPs, the flock of taunting ravens from When Black Roses Bloom was stated outright to be a manifestation of the Dark Powers. A similar manifestation occurred when Vecna tore his way out of Ravenloft, ranting at the DPs all the way.

Posted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 9:49 pm
by Deewun
I second (third?) the DS9 approach. The Pilot did it so amazingly well, though in no sinister way, which of course would be closer to the DP's style, showing the worst memories or the happiest and just talking to her about despicable things during them, ruining those memories, or at least tainting them.

I also really like the "needing-to-get-it-deciphered" idea.

When I had characters in my pirate campaign deal with the DPs, I gave them a single face in a senate of a thousand shadowed faces, who they dubbed Crowley, but the dark senate never offered names. The players didn't know it was the DPs until very late in the campaign, and it worked very well. I think that kind of mystery could be a good way to go about it. Perhaps have something non-sinister start, and the dread of what is happen actually dawn on your True Innocent, and right when it dawns on her, everything reverts back to mist.

Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 2:29 pm
by Drinnik Shoehorn
I'm going to have the DPs contact my PCs in my 4th Ed Planescape game by having them be forced into a dreamscape by the Nightmare Man and having the DPs appear as charcters the PCs have either met and killed or met in previous campaigns. I've given the option to my players to play PCs from old campaigns, dead or alive with 2 provisions;

1) They have to start at level 1.
2) They can not have ended their last play inside Ravenloft.

Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 2:42 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
:shock:

Last Drin sighting reported on: Tue Oct 27, 2009 7:29 pm!

:o

All the best, man! Nice to see you're still around!

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:58 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Kaitou Kage wrote:There was an intriguing claymation show a long while ago that had something to do with Mark Twain adventures.
That is some seriously messed up #@$@. It's amazing any of us kids of the 80's made it to adulthood sane, with that kind of stuff haunting our dreams.

Thanks for the nightmares. :)

Posted: Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:32 am
by Ail
If it's still of any use, here's another approach, I think.
What if there's no talk at all, no conversation of any kind?
Your PC simply wakes one morning realizing she knows something she didn't before. And each new morning a new piece of information comes to her, naturally, as if it had ever existed.

The way this manifests could be varied: she could begin writing automatically, without really realizing, and then read over her diary; or she could go for a walk and act differently, as if she 'thought' differently on certain aspects. All of us wonder when we walk alone: well, so would she, but the results of her wonderings would take her to conclusions she never had before, and she would understand that change.

She could even perceive the world around (well, ok, she's in the mists, but there must be something there, even if she experiences this new reality only through dreams) differently, notice details she never saw before, noticing behaviours of animals, for example, that ellicit things the DPs want her to know, which she can later transport to the real world.

In this way, there is no real manifestation of the DPs, there is just a 'planting of conscience' of sorts.