Page 1 of 2

A Ravenloft Wikia?

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 7:20 pm
by Nerit
What would you all think of a Ravenloft wiki? I have recently been introduced to the setting and researching was a scattered process of sifting through numerous PDFs of out of print books and various gazettes. It occurred to me that there simply isn't an easy, centralized access to this game. I would like to rectify that. The setting deserves more than Diaspora, even if there is no official 4.0 version, etc. A wiki is also customizable in the sense that there can be non-canon aspects that are marked as such, allowing a full breadth of information for Ravenloft.

If I set up a wikia, would you all attack it and fill it with wonderful things (basics first)?

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 8:48 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
There has been talk of such a thing before, and if you want to run one, good luck to you, I'm sure there will be plenty of interest.

However, in the meantime, I'd like to direct you to a few resources we have here that you might not be aware of:

Firstly, Joel's List of Canon and Fanmade Material

And secondly, The Ravenloft Catalogue

The catalogue is currently incomplete and we're always looking for new editors to help with the task. If you're interested in doing that instead of or in addition to your wiki, let me know via email or pm.

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 9:27 pm
by NeoTiamat
I can also direct you to the following website:

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Ravenloft

WARNING: TVTROPES IS HIGHLY ADDICTIVE :wink:

But it's a nice site, and the Ravenloft page there needs some love.

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 9:48 pm
by Joël of the FoS
I understand the wiki is the best way to do a catalogue, but it's quite a job to do. One good way to start it would be to convert my list and the catalogue to wiki, then start writing stuff about each entry.

But there are so many entries, I do not see how to tackle the beast!

If there are wiz kids in the area, let us know :)

Joël

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 9:49 pm
by Kaitou Kage
I don't think the TVTropes site is quite what Nerit's looking for ;-)

Personally I'd like to see something like the Forgotten Realms Wiki or Planewalker's (currently offline) Encyclopedia, which are what I think Nerit's suggesting. It'd be a very convenient way to look up specific information without the hassle of having to cross-reference numerous books and sources.

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 9:57 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Another sorry issue is controling what is written in it. On fan boards, I see so many personal opinion given as fact, or unchecked "facts" or plain mistakes (even on regular wiki by the way), it makes my head spin thinking what this project could become...

Of course you'll say it would be censored by other users, but that would require an immense job of doublechecking everything... Are there enough people willing to do this and make sure it's accurate?

Joël

Posted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 10:02 pm
by Nerit
Ohhhh, no, I'm not editing TvTropes with a radio controlled keyboard. I get sucked in way too long. Anyway, I will look into the other sites but the point of a wiki is that the community can grow and more people can add to it than a few editors. The links you gave me are lists, but there's no guarantee of where to find everything. Why can't it all be freely available? I realize the trouble of copyright, but putting up the gist of the material could greatly assist some folks.

I would even suggest campaign info hosting in a different space like Campaigns/Shattered_City, and it could have all manner of subpages if desired. Wikis are marvelous things. This project would happen over the course of a few years, and I won't/can't write or control all of it; realistically I'd control little but safety.

EDIT: Yes, there is always the problem of biased editing. Of course. However, as a broad function, I think an open-source encyclopedic format would work quite well. Also, those lists WILL be immensely helpful in compiling resources ;).

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 7:19 am
by The Giamarga
Kaitou Kage wrote:Personally I'd like to see something like the Forgotten Realms Wiki or Planewalker's (currently offline) Encyclopedia, which are what I think Nerit's suggesting. It'd be a very convenient way to look up specific information without the hassle of having to cross-reference numerous books and sources.
Seconded. Another example could be the GreyhawkWiki (which iirc was started to preserve wikipedia entries about to be deleted).

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:22 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Nerit wrote:Why can't it all be freely available? I realize the trouble of copyright, but putting up the gist of the material could greatly assist some folks.
I think that was the original point behind the Kargatane doing the Catalogue the way they did. It's an index to the published info, not a replacement for it. Things are of course a bit murkier now that the setting's not officially in print. I don't know how the Greyhawk and FR wikis handle that issue, or if they're just hoping not to get a cease and desist from WotC's lawyers, but there's certainly a fine line between "the gist" and copyright infringement.

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:27 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I don't mean to be down on the idea, by the way. If such a thing existed, I know I'd find it useful, but:

a) a lot of the groundwork has already been done in Joel's list and the cataloge

and

b) I wouldn't want to be the one responsible for it legally.

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:48 am
by Joël of the FoS
That is, unless WotC gives us permission, but considering the success we had in previous dealings with them, I doubt it.

Joël

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 10:26 am
by Jester of the FoS
Well, the above linked FR wiki shows it can be done without lawsuit.

The alternative is to do it ON the new WotC community boards, so they can't complain.

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 11:12 am
by NeoTiamat
If one were really interested, perhaps sending some emails to the various Wiki-runners asking for advice? How do Planewalker's Encyclopedia, The Greyhawk Wiki, the FR Wiki, etc. handle this?

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 2:21 pm
by Nerit
A summary of information is not copyright infringement, as far as I know. Copying all the text from the books would most likely cause a C&D letter, yes.

Posted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 10:31 pm
by Kaitou Kage
NeoTiamat wrote:If one were really interested, perhaps sending some emails to the various Wiki-runners asking for advice? How do Planewalker's Encyclopedia, The Greyhawk Wiki, the FR Wiki, etc. handle this?
Planewalker's Encyclopedia is very cut and dry. It's also community edited/editable. It lists some basic facts about each point, but doesn't delve too deep.

An example: If you looked in the Planewalker Encyclopedia for the town "Death of Innocence," you'd get a couple paragraphs on where it is, maybe a very short description, and possibly the blood in charge. If you want anything more in-depth about the town, you have to go to the sourcebook -- which is also listed.

Forgotten Realms Wiki is much, much more in-depth

The Greyhawk wiki, when I looked at it, was woefully unpopulated.

This kind of thing would be very useful because a lot of the source material is out of print. With the removal of PDF sales, there is simply no other way to get a simple overview of information on settings and games like Ravenloft unless you go through illicit means.

All told, I seriously doubt copyright is an issue here. Just glancing around, there are wikis and similar setups for the following:

- Forgotten Realms (very comprehensive comparatively -- the article on Waterdeep is pretty big)
- Eberron
- Greyhawk
- Planescape
- Warcraft (very, very in-depth for both the games and the setting lore)
- Dragonlance (pretty well-done)

That just names a few. The information presented in any of the D&D wikis is not as thorough as what you'd get from a sourcebook. It is, however, more than enough to serve as a quick-reference for old bloods and a good introduction for new folks that don't have easy access to old settings. Warcraft, I believe, is much, much more thorough. Anyway, if you really want to know the setting, you still need the source material. I think they are able to avoid copyright issues by just providing some basics. If copyright were an issue, I think they'd have been shut down by now. It's not like they're hidden or anything.