Notes on 4E monster building.
Posted: Wed Sep 30, 2009 6:48 am
Prompted by jester I did some thinking and some research on monsters, since the DMG's rules proved to be not so solid after all since they were changed quite a bit in DMG2.
A pity... most of these problems as Jester said could have been spotted earlier with a bit of playtesting and a bit more thinking in the development phase.
Elites
From what I have heard, their increased defences were dropped.
They give double the XP and they count as two monsters.
Doubling the hp that the non-elite version would have isn't enough because the monster makes ONE attack instead of two.
For example if we wanted an elite human guard, and we just doubled the hit points, the guard would stay standing for twice as much but wouldn't do the same damage as two guards would do because it has a singe attack.
Doubling the damage the non-elite is doing doesn't solve the problem however. After all, if there were two non-elite guards in a fight one would propably die first so he would stop doing attacks and damage. So, doubling the damage is too much.
However, thinking like the 2= 1 elite, the DMG gives a very nice idea! Bloodied elites do double damage.
This is the reverse of "killing the first of the two monsters, damage drops after the first half of the battle" since it's actually "damage rises after the first half of the battle". It also keeps the battle interesting.
Another way to deal with the "single monster = 1 attack, should do more damage" problem would be to just increase the average damage of the monster by 50%.
Note: By double I mean 2d6+5 = 4d6+10. That's doubling. It may seem awfully much damage, but it's the equivalent of what two monsters would do if they hit. Also if the elite misses is just like both monsters missed.
By +50% I mean 2d6+5 = 12 average damage. +50% = 18 => 2d8+9 damage.
Of course, two attacks per round solve this problem as well.
Important Note: Many elites in the Monstrous Manual already deal a lot more damage than their non-elite counterparts! Even those that don't deal increased damage, have immediates etc to recompensate. Don't go and double the damage of the elites already in the monstrous manual.
Some problems still remain though. For example, a single double hp monster even if it deals 50% more damage would be targeted propably by debilating attacks. Stunning the elite is the equivalent of stunning BOTH the single monsters.
Less monsters in the same battle means less chances for flanking the chars, while they are easier to get flanked themselves.
So, an elite monster with increased damage poses a bit less of threat (tactically now) than 2 single monsters.
In a fight, it's rare that all the PCs hit the same monster till it drops and then move to the next and the next etc. Usually the damage the party does in a round is split in more monsters.
I.e if the fight with the two guards was 10 rounds long, the fight with the elite would also be 10 rounds long.
However, both guards would be around for 6-7 of those 10 rounds, since damage done won't be optimum.
Also if the 1st guard is left with 2 hp and then killed in a single blow, dropped to -10 hp, the second guard doesn't get 10 damage.
In the case of the elite though, after it gets bloodied (equivalent of first soldier killed) this damage carries on. I.e unless the elite drops to exactly bloodied it has some damage remaining.
On the other hand: The elite monster gets an action point. Most of them have more powers than single monsters, that give them more tactical options if not more damage. Some have healing abilities.
So, my conclusion is this:
Make an elite from scratch/from a normal:
- Increase the damage the normal monster deals by 50% or double it after the monster gets bloodied (or another combination like 2d6+5 becomes 3d6+5 and after bloodied 3d6+10). Another solution is simply to allow the elite to make two normal attacks. Like claw, bite etc.
- Give the elite more tactical options by giving it 1-2 more powers that do something besides damage, compared to the non-elite. That offsets the "can't flank" and all the other tactical opportunities lost because it's a single monster.
- Give the elite a power that heals it. This power somewhat offsets the problem of ongoing damage on the elite and the problem that an attack that would drop one of the two non-elites to 0
- Give the elite an attack that affects multiple opponents. This also offsets the problem of conditions affecting it while it's equal to two monsters. How? Proactively. "You affect me while I count for two? I affect two of you"
That should make the non-elite to a very balanced elite worth double the XP and presenting double the challenge of the non-elite.
A pity... most of these problems as Jester said could have been spotted earlier with a bit of playtesting and a bit more thinking in the development phase.
Elites
From what I have heard, their increased defences were dropped.
They give double the XP and they count as two monsters.
Doubling the hp that the non-elite version would have isn't enough because the monster makes ONE attack instead of two.
For example if we wanted an elite human guard, and we just doubled the hit points, the guard would stay standing for twice as much but wouldn't do the same damage as two guards would do because it has a singe attack.
Doubling the damage the non-elite is doing doesn't solve the problem however. After all, if there were two non-elite guards in a fight one would propably die first so he would stop doing attacks and damage. So, doubling the damage is too much.
However, thinking like the 2= 1 elite, the DMG gives a very nice idea! Bloodied elites do double damage.
Another way to deal with the "single monster = 1 attack, should do more damage" problem would be to just increase the average damage of the monster by 50%.
Note: By double I mean 2d6+5 = 4d6+10. That's doubling. It may seem awfully much damage, but it's the equivalent of what two monsters would do if they hit. Also if the elite misses is just like both monsters missed.
By +50% I mean 2d6+5 = 12 average damage. +50% = 18 => 2d8+9 damage.
Of course, two attacks per round solve this problem as well.
Important Note: Many elites in the Monstrous Manual already deal a lot more damage than their non-elite counterparts! Even those that don't deal increased damage, have immediates etc to recompensate. Don't go and double the damage of the elites already in the monstrous manual.
Some problems still remain though. For example, a single double hp monster even if it deals 50% more damage would be targeted propably by debilating attacks. Stunning the elite is the equivalent of stunning BOTH the single monsters.
Less monsters in the same battle means less chances for flanking the chars, while they are easier to get flanked themselves.
So, an elite monster with increased damage poses a bit less of threat (tactically now) than 2 single monsters.
In a fight, it's rare that all the PCs hit the same monster till it drops and then move to the next and the next etc. Usually the damage the party does in a round is split in more monsters.
I.e if the fight with the two guards was 10 rounds long, the fight with the elite would also be 10 rounds long.
However, both guards would be around for 6-7 of those 10 rounds, since damage done won't be optimum.
Also if the 1st guard is left with 2 hp and then killed in a single blow, dropped to -10 hp, the second guard doesn't get 10 damage.
In the case of the elite though, after it gets bloodied (equivalent of first soldier killed) this damage carries on. I.e unless the elite drops to exactly bloodied it has some damage remaining.
On the other hand: The elite monster gets an action point. Most of them have more powers than single monsters, that give them more tactical options if not more damage. Some have healing abilities.
So, my conclusion is this:
Make an elite from scratch/from a normal:
- Increase the damage the normal monster deals by 50% or double it after the monster gets bloodied (or another combination like 2d6+5 becomes 3d6+5 and after bloodied 3d6+10). Another solution is simply to allow the elite to make two normal attacks. Like claw, bite etc.
- Give the elite more tactical options by giving it 1-2 more powers that do something besides damage, compared to the non-elite. That offsets the "can't flank" and all the other tactical opportunities lost because it's a single monster.
- Give the elite a power that heals it. This power somewhat offsets the problem of ongoing damage on the elite and the problem that an attack that would drop one of the two non-elites to 0
- Give the elite an attack that affects multiple opponents. This also offsets the problem of conditions affecting it while it's equal to two monsters. How? Proactively. "You affect me while I count for two? I affect two of you"
That should make the non-elite to a very balanced elite worth double the XP and presenting double the challenge of the non-elite.