Page 1 of 7
Vistani in 4E.
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 10:37 am
by Mortavius
For those who are interested in the continuing releases of 4E Ravenloft material on the WotC website, there are three articles planned this month entitled "Playing Vistani."
Just thought I'd throw out a heads-up there for those who don't know.
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 10:39 am
by DocBeard
Oh really? Cool.
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 12:48 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
Latest News: "Playing Vistani" articles coming this week in Dragon Online. No word yet if this will finally confirm that the Hag and Halflings in Expedition to Castle Ravenloft were just "Playing Vistani."
Thanks, Gonzo!

Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 7:57 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rafael wrote:Thanks, Gonzo!

You mean people actually read that thing?
First brought to our attention by Hell_Born:
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=6612
But thanks for the reminder, Mortavius.
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 8:25 pm
by DocBeard
Well, halflings do have a semi-nomadic, semi-shifty culture. It musti've seemed like a logical fit. As for hags, well, depends on hags develop. They could've been human at one point.
Okay so it was kind of silly. I still liked Madame Eva's sisters' names, if not their whole overcomplicated sub-plot.
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 9:31 pm
by ewancummins
DocBeard wrote:Well, halflings do have a semi-nomadic, semi-shifty culture. It musti've seemed like a logical fit. As for hags, well, depends on hags develop. They could've been human at one point.
Okay so it was kind of silly. I still liked Madame Eva's sisters' names, if not their whole overcomplicated sub-plot.
Those sound like kender.
Real halflings have beer guts, hairy feet, and smoke pipeweed.
'The weed of the halfings has addled your wits.'
Posted: Sun Oct 04, 2009 10:29 pm
by DocBeard
Can't they just have both?
I mean I know fantasy has a bad habit of taking 'an ethnicity' or 'a different philosophy' and making it 'a different species' instead, but, man, Bilbo Baggins was a burglar. It didn't come outta nowhere.
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2009 12:32 am
by ewancummins
DocBeard wrote:Can't they just have both?
I mean I know fantasy has a bad habit of taking 'an ethnicity' or 'a different philosophy' and making it 'a different species' instead, but, man, Bilbo Baggins was a burglar. It didn't come outta nowhere.
BB wasn't really a professional burglar, though. His only 'thief skill' was the natural ability of the hobbit to make himself quiet and unobtrusive when trouble is about. He wasn't one for picking locks, disarming traps, climbing up sheer surfaces,etc. Once he had the ring, then he could become invisible, which obviously helped him out in his 'burgling' quite a bit.
I think that halfings being larcenous gypsy types is more a matter of copying the kender, who were themslves an exaggeration of the way not a few gamers liked their halflings: short but not fat, sassy and full of spunk, and will steal anything that isn't nailed down.
Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2009 6:43 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Fitting or not, I think the major complaint there was the violation of established Ravenloft canon, not cultural meshing issues. A Hag could easily lead a band of human and halfling gypsies... but that wouldn't be Madame Eva and the Vistani. (What bothered me most was that as a D&D hag, it cemented Madame Eva as evil, but I prefer the vistani to be ambiguous on the good/evil front.) Of course EtCR made no pretense of holding to the Ravenloft setting canon, so it may be unfair to harp on it. But maybe the larger fact that it made no pretense of holding to the canon is what we were really harping on anyway, using the "vistani" as a scapegoat.
Anyway, we're off on a tangent brought about by my little joke on the front page. We now return you to your regularly scheduled rampant and ill-informed speculation....

Posted: Mon Oct 05, 2009 7:48 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
DocBeard wrote:Well, halflings do have a semi-nomadic, semi-shifty culture. It musti've seemed like a logical fit. As for hags, well, depends on hags develop. They could've been human at one point.
FWIW, making some of them halflings might also have been an attempt to further divorce the Vistani from
IRL Romani culture. Even if it's really old horror movies and books that created the "spooky mystical nomad" image, feeding those stereotypes is something that the Kargat writers always had reservations about ... hence, calling them "Vistani" in the first place rather than "gypsies".
Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2009 1:13 am
by Mortavius
I dunno...I guess I'm insensitive, but I can't feel for anyone who takes offense where no offense is meant. And yes, the Vistani are modeled after real world Romani culture, but there has never been an insult in that modeling intended against the real-world culture.
That's like the french getting mad because the society of Dementlieu is modeled after them...
Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2009 3:22 am
by Le Noir Faineant
Barovia is actually BAVARIA, where I come from!
And has anyone of you EVER apologized to me? Anyone???
Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2009 8:06 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rafael wrote:And has anyone of you EVER apologized to me? Anyone???
To you, no.
For you, yes.

Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2009 2:33 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
FWIW, I suspect it's the much darker (i.e. Neutral Evil) way that Madame Eva's tribe were portrayed in I6, along with the thieving and kidnapping practiced by the Corvara, which IRL Romani would find offensive. Let's face it: when the greatest hero in the game-setting got that way because his child was abducted by gypsies, it's not unreasonable for genuine Romani to find that offensive, or for WotC to try to dodge the issue in its own revival of I6. :-/
Posted: Tue Oct 06, 2009 2:37 pm
by ewancummins
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:FWIW, I suspect it's the much darker (i.e. Neutral Evil) way that Madame Eva's tribe were portrayed in I6, along with the thieving and kidnapping practiced by the Corvara, which IRL Romani would find offensive. Let's face it: when the greatest hero in the game-setting got that way because his child was abducted by gypsies, it's not unreasonable for genuine Romani to find that offensive, or for WotC to try to dodge the issue in its own revival of I6. :-/
I think it's silly political correctness, personally.
Next they'll be removing demons and devils from the books to avoid offending certain sectarian groups...oh wait, been there, done that.
